Message Boards

Replies to '12/27 Extreme Parenting'

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 24, 2005, 9:09 am PDT

Disagree

Quote From: irishmom

 I think the key is compromise.  My husband wants our daughters to take piano lessons because he believes it's a good skill to have and you can use it in church.  My oldest daughter doesn't want to play piano, she wants to learn the guitar.  I said "what about a compromise?"  You can take a year of piano and learn some basic skills, and after that year, if you still want to play guitar instead, then you can.  That seemed to be something everyone was happy with.  Of course we can't afford ANY music lessons right now, but next year when we can, at least we have game plan.  I don't think a child should be pushed to fulfill their parent's dreams.  Our children have their own dreams and we should be encouraging them to follow them.  If you missed out on your dream as a child, then you need to rectify that yourself.  Don't try to live the life you wished you had through your children. 

  

I am not by any means trying to start a fight about this, however, I believe that the children should have their own dreams like you said.  I do not think that any child should have to do any type of sport or lessons just because their parents think it's a good idea.  I do not want to push my child away from me because I think it is "best" for them.  They need to try new things on their own and see what they like best.  This is just my opinion so don't take it personally.  We all have our own values.  I totally agree with you when you said, "Don't try to live the life you wished you had through your children."  Many parents have this problem and I appreciate it that you put it out there. 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
giddy
October 27, 2005, 9:05 am PDT

10/27 Extreme Parenting

Quote From: irishmom

 I think the key is compromise.  My husband wants our daughters to take piano lessons because he believes it's a good skill to have and you can use it in church.  My oldest daughter doesn't want to play piano, she wants to learn the guitar.  I said "what about a compromise?"  You can take a year of piano and learn some basic skills, and after that year, if you still want to play guitar instead, then you can.  That seemed to be something everyone was happy with.  Of course we can't afford ANY music lessons right now, but next year when we can, at least we have game plan.  I don't think a child should be pushed to fulfill their parent's dreams.  Our children have their own dreams and we should be encouraging them to follow them.  If you missed out on your dream as a child, then you need to rectify that yourself.  Don't try to live the life you wished you had through your children. 

If you missed out on your dream as a child, then you need to rectify that yourself. 

  

 

Well put.  It's interesting how parents will try to push their child to do something that they wish they did when they were a kid.  Like music lessons for example.  At a nearby music shop in my town there is an instructor there that teaches the fiddle and most of his students are adults.  If these parents regret not doing something when they were a kid then they should give it a go now.  They just might like it! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 26, 2005, 7:21 pm PST

12/27 Extreme Parenting

Quote From: irishmom

 I think the key is compromise.  My husband wants our daughters to take piano lessons because he believes it's a good skill to have and you can use it in church.  My oldest daughter doesn't want to play piano, she wants to learn the guitar.  I said "what about a compromise?"  You can take a year of piano and learn some basic skills, and after that year, if you still want to play guitar instead, then you can.  That seemed to be something everyone was happy with.  Of course we can't afford ANY music lessons right now, but next year when we can, at least we have game plan.  I don't think a child should be pushed to fulfill their parent's dreams.  Our children have their own dreams and we should be encouraging them to follow them.  If you missed out on your dream as a child, then you need to rectify that yourself.  Don't try to live the life you wished you had through your children. 

Learning to read music for piano can also help with playing guitar because the top bar of the music is the same.  And as bonus learning to play a second instrument is good because learning music has been proven to help with other subjects especially math.  

 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page