Message Boards

Replies to '11/23 Schizophrenia'

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 6, 2005, 5:33 pm PST

11/23 Schizophrenia

Quote From: stryker_m

I have to disagree.  I can say from personal experience that the meds DO help.  Without them (and yes, i've tried going off them before and it was a disaster), I am unable to perform my job duties, function as a wife and mother, and live a fear free life.  Meds HELP ME.  I do not believe that I "stressed and worried" myself "into" schizophrenia.  I do not believe that paranoia 'grows into' schizophrenia.  It is a biological and possibly genetic disease that IS helped with medication.  To say otherwise to someone with this illness is irresponsible and asking for disaster.  My psychiatrist isn't the boogyman.  She's a physician with experience that shows that meds help relieve the symptoms of schizophrenia.  Yes, reducing stress helps minimize episodes but that is not the whole picture.  I, for one, will continue taking my meds because I know what my life is like when I am not on them.  I choose to take control over my life and my illness and not succumb to paranoia of the medical system that is there to try to help me.  If you think modern mental institutions are bad, try going back in time a little... maybe 100 years when the mentally ill were caged away in asylums and forgotten.  The advent of meds for schizophrenia has evolved along with the attitudes and treatment of patients in hospitals.  I for one, would not like to go back to the dark days before there was any treatment for this disease.   For those of you who think i've 'worried and stressed' myself into schizophrenia, I say walk one day in my shoes.  Know the things I know and see the things I have seen.  and then tell me meds (in conjunction with medical evaluation and therapy) are not the answer.  JUST ONE DAY. 
I agree with you I Have an uncle that my parents are taking care of who has had schizophrenia sence he was a teen in the early seventys. He is almost fifty now and has never been able to work or get married or funtion in everyday life. I have seen him without his meds and he is very dangerous without them. Unfortunately they are not a cure but they do help him stay under control. That is about all you can do for right now.  I know that someday my parents will no longer be able to take care of him and the job will someday come to me. I will do anything to keep him from having to go back to a home. He is really a very sweet man and I hope to someday bet a chance to get to know him without the illness.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
December 7, 2005, 9:35 am PST

Hi Mary!

Quote From: stryker_m

I have to disagree.  I can say from personal experience that the meds DO help.  Without them (and yes, i've tried going off them before and it was a disaster), I am unable to perform my job duties, function as a wife and mother, and live a fear free life.  Meds HELP ME.  I do not believe that I "stressed and worried" myself "into" schizophrenia.  I do not believe that paranoia 'grows into' schizophrenia.  It is a biological and possibly genetic disease that IS helped with medication.  To say otherwise to someone with this illness is irresponsible and asking for disaster.  My psychiatrist isn't the boogyman.  She's a physician with experience that shows that meds help relieve the symptoms of schizophrenia.  Yes, reducing stress helps minimize episodes but that is not the whole picture.  I, for one, will continue taking my meds because I know what my life is like when I am not on them.  I choose to take control over my life and my illness and not succumb to paranoia of the medical system that is there to try to help me.  If you think modern mental institutions are bad, try going back in time a little... maybe 100 years when the mentally ill were caged away in asylums and forgotten.  The advent of meds for schizophrenia has evolved along with the attitudes and treatment of patients in hospitals.  I for one, would not like to go back to the dark days before there was any treatment for this disease.   For those of you who think i've 'worried and stressed' myself into schizophrenia, I say walk one day in my shoes.  Know the things I know and see the things I have seen.  and then tell me meds (in conjunction with medical evaluation and therapy) are not the answer.  JUST ONE DAY. 

After I read those posts, I felt very angry and insulted that people who have had no experience with this particular disease could write such things. I'm sure they're well-intentioned, but their comments come off as very ignorant. Your reply totally hits the nail on the head. You have developed some amazing coping skills. Thank you so much for your appearence on the show! I think it really helped educate a lot of people on the daily struggles with the disease. 

  

My brother was diagnosed with schizophrenia when he was 22 (and I was 18 - I'm now 30). The years that preceded his diagnosis were extremely difficult for me and my family. My brother was very kind, smart (honor student), and very musically talented (playing the piano from a very early age). Within a period of a few years, everything in his world changed. He suffered from hallucinations and thought birds talked to him (among other things). He was very paranoided about everything. Part of his paranoia was that the entire medical community was after him, and he refused to seek any treatment. He even stopped bathing, brushing his teeth and washing his clothes. I think he was paranoid about the "chemicals". Conversations with him were almost impossible, because he couldn't focus on anything that was being said and continually made outrageous claims about stuff. He became extremely violent and had a feeling that he was "all-powerful". Everyone feared that he would kill someone in the family. On one occasion, he came after our dad with a fire-poker and ended up breaking some windows with it. My aunt ended up having to call the police on him after he broke into her house.  

Having him arrested was the only way we could have him committed long enough to get a diagnosis and treatment. He went into an institution for a period of about five months. It was very difficult for everyone to see him on the different medications as the doctors were trying to find the right ones.  

He was finally permitted to come home for a two week visit. He seemed very happy, peaceful, and clearer in his thoughts during that time. I actually was able to have somewhat normal conversations with him, although I could still tell that he had problems with his focus. Everyone thought he was finally on the road to being able manage his disease, but at the end of those two weeks, while alone at my dad's house, he took his own life. My family has struggled with his death ever since. 

  

I really hope more research is done on this disease. I also think something should be done with the institutions where people seek help. Funding for either of these, unfortunately, seems to be extremely anemic. If you know of any political action groups to raise awareness on this disease, please let me know. I feel I should get involved in something like that to help cope with my brother's loss. You're proof that people can, with the right medical help and support system, successfully managed this disease. God bless you and your family! 

 

Message Emote
blank
December 9, 2005, 3:36 pm PST

Thank-you, Mary

Quote From: stryker_m

I have to disagree.  I can say from personal experience that the meds DO help.  Without them (and yes, i've tried going off them before and it was a disaster), I am unable to perform my job duties, function as a wife and mother, and live a fear free life.  Meds HELP ME.  I do not believe that I "stressed and worried" myself "into" schizophrenia.  I do not believe that paranoia 'grows into' schizophrenia.  It is a biological and possibly genetic disease that IS helped with medication.  To say otherwise to someone with this illness is irresponsible and asking for disaster.  My psychiatrist isn't the boogyman.  She's a physician with experience that shows that meds help relieve the symptoms of schizophrenia.  Yes, reducing stress helps minimize episodes but that is not the whole picture.  I, for one, will continue taking my meds because I know what my life is like when I am not on them.  I choose to take control over my life and my illness and not succumb to paranoia of the medical system that is there to try to help me.  If you think modern mental institutions are bad, try going back in time a little... maybe 100 years when the mentally ill were caged away in asylums and forgotten.  The advent of meds for schizophrenia has evolved along with the attitudes and treatment of patients in hospitals.  I for one, would not like to go back to the dark days before there was any treatment for this disease.   For those of you who think i've 'worried and stressed' myself into schizophrenia, I say walk one day in my shoes.  Know the things I know and see the things I have seen.  and then tell me meds (in conjunction with medical evaluation and therapy) are not the answer.  JUST ONE DAY. 
 You are so very, very brave to speak so openly about your experiences with this devastating condition.  You are, in my opinion, a shining example of how to survive this horrible disease.  You are an inspiration, and not just to people with psychiatric disorders!!

Thank-you, also, for standing up to the anti-med crowd.  Medical advances in psychiatry have been so badly delayed for so long by fear and superstition.  It is really sad to me to think that someone reading this board might actually take some of this hare-brained advice and go to their priest, shaman, or whatever instead of their doctor.

Thank-you, again.
 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page