Replies to '08/16 The Hunt for Amanda'

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
February 7, 2006, 8:13 am PST

02/07 The Hunt for Amanda

Quote From: liatsunami

 I'm kind of curious if the boy's family are REALLY gypsies or if they just live like them.   I think that a lot of people know very little about ethnic gypsy culture so they pass judgements based on improper understanding.  But that isn't the point here.

This girl's parents have a legal right to tell her how she will behave in their home until either a) she turns 18, b) the state for some reason emancipates her early,  or c) the state removes her from the home .  She can be as mad about it as she wants but that's the reality of it.  Sure she can run away again, but the police will just be able to go get her again.

On the flip side the young girl seemed to be doing just fine with her boyfriend's family.  She had her own money to do with as she pleased.  She seemed well taken care of as far as clothing, hygiene, shelter, and food was concerned. She actaully kept in contact with her mother,letting her know that she was alive and well,  rather than just disappear off the face of the earth.  While I don't condone her lying to her boyfriend's family I think the fact that she still wanted to be in contact with her family is a relatively responsible choice.

I just hope the boyfriend and the family don't get into too much trouble.   I mean legally they did so something wrong in transporting a minor over state lines without parental consent, but on the other hand what if they thought they were taking her out of a bad home situation?

Even though she's agreed to go to this boarding school I don't think it'll stop her from trying to run away again.  Time shall tell I suppose.

I hope the boys parents DO get into trouble and lots of it.  They knew.  They had to have known.  There were confrontations before they left town for Petes sake.  Even if you think you are rescueing a child from trouble you don't just take them out of the state. 

  

I don't like the idea of boarding school though.  Those parents need to learn how to parent just as much as that girl needs to grow up.   

  

As for the girl "doing just fine with her boyfriends family".  Oh please! What is she learning there? That her family is not worth any consideration?  That premarital sex is ok starting at such an early age? Hey everyone is doing it younger and younger...nothing WRONG with that.  Lets see the traits the girl displayed on the show...Deviance, deception, cursing, rebellion - lets guess which family she had learned all that with. 

  

And the boyfriend on the phone saying something to the effect of 'she never told us' - HELLO - If I'm gonna take your kid - for months at a time - AND keep her out of school AND take her out of state - Then you and I are going to talk at some point.  So lets just call that what it is - a load of crap. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 7, 2006, 11:52 am PST

02/07 The Hunt for Amanda

Quote From: liatsunami

 I'm kind of curious if the boy's family are REALLY gypsies or if they just live like them.   I think that a lot of people know very little about ethnic gypsy culture so they pass judgements based on improper understanding.  But that isn't the point here.

This girl's parents have a legal right to tell her how she will behave in their home until either a) she turns 18, b) the state for some reason emancipates her early,  or c) the state removes her from the home .  She can be as mad about it as she wants but that's the reality of it.  Sure she can run away again, but the police will just be able to go get her again.

On the flip side the young girl seemed to be doing just fine with her boyfriend's family.  She had her own money to do with as she pleased.  She seemed well taken care of as far as clothing, hygiene, shelter, and food was concerned. She actaully kept in contact with her mother,letting her know that she was alive and well,  rather than just disappear off the face of the earth.  While I don't condone her lying to her boyfriend's family I think the fact that she still wanted to be in contact with her family is a relatively responsible choice.

I just hope the boyfriend and the family don't get into too much trouble.   I mean legally they did so something wrong in transporting a minor over state lines without parental consent, but on the other hand what if they thought they were taking her out of a bad home situation?

Even though she's agreed to go to this boarding school I don't think it'll stop her from trying to run away again.  Time shall tell I suppose.

I think George's parents should not get of the hook...come one a 16 year says oh my mom says its okay for me to live with you....please....common sense people...they should of know better.   

 

Message Emote
blank
February 7, 2006, 3:47 pm PST

Food, clothing & shelter for NOW.

Quote From: liatsunami

 I'm kind of curious if the boy's family are REALLY gypsies or if they just live like them.   I think that a lot of people know very little about ethnic gypsy culture so they pass judgements based on improper understanding.  But that isn't the point here.

This girl's parents have a legal right to tell her how she will behave in their home until either a) she turns 18, b) the state for some reason emancipates her early,  or c) the state removes her from the home .  She can be as mad about it as she wants but that's the reality of it.  Sure she can run away again, but the police will just be able to go get her again.

On the flip side the young girl seemed to be doing just fine with her boyfriend's family.  She had her own money to do with as she pleased.  She seemed well taken care of as far as clothing, hygiene, shelter, and food was concerned. She actaully kept in contact with her mother,letting her know that she was alive and well,  rather than just disappear off the face of the earth.  While I don't condone her lying to her boyfriend's family I think the fact that she still wanted to be in contact with her family is a relatively responsible choice.

I just hope the boyfriend and the family don't get into too much trouble.   I mean legally they did so something wrong in transporting a minor over state lines without parental consent, but on the other hand what if they thought they were taking her out of a bad home situation?

Even though she's agreed to go to this boarding school I don't think it'll stop her from trying to run away again.  Time shall tell I suppose.

Amanda is not acquiring the education & job skills to financially prepare her for the future.  It shows very poor judgement on Amanda & the boyfriend's family to allow her to drop out of school. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
ecstatic
February 7, 2006, 10:36 pm PST

Let her go with George to visit his parents in Federal Prison

Quote From: liatsunami

 I'm kind of curious if the boy's family are REALLY gypsies or if they just live like them.   I think that a lot of people know very little about ethnic gypsy culture so they pass judgements based on improper understanding.  But that isn't the point here.

This girl's parents have a legal right to tell her how she will behave in their home until either a) she turns 18, b) the state for some reason emancipates her early,  or c) the state removes her from the home .  She can be as mad about it as she wants but that's the reality of it.  Sure she can run away again, but the police will just be able to go get her again.

On the flip side the young girl seemed to be doing just fine with her boyfriend's family.  She had her own money to do with as she pleased.  She seemed well taken care of as far as clothing, hygiene, shelter, and food was concerned. She actaully kept in contact with her mother,letting her know that she was alive and well,  rather than just disappear off the face of the earth.  While I don't condone her lying to her boyfriend's family I think the fact that she still wanted to be in contact with her family is a relatively responsible choice.

I just hope the boyfriend and the family don't get into too much trouble.   I mean legally they did so something wrong in transporting a minor over state lines without parental consent, but on the other hand what if they thought they were taking her out of a bad home situation?

Even though she's agreed to go to this boarding school I don't think it'll stop her from trying to run away again.  Time shall tell I suppose.

I would be willing to bet they are already arrested.  Imagine her life with George now.  He will be angry because his parents are in prison and he won't blame himself because people like him, blame everyone else for their problems.  He couldn't even answer Dr. Phil in a complete sentence.  This whole situation is too involved not to have George's parents arrested and charged.  The fact that there is no accountability from George's parents prove that the fruit doesn't fall far from the tree.  No, I don't believe for a moment that the FBI isn't all over this one.  Now if the parents get to move around, it will only be in the back of a Constable's vehicle  and they are in shackles.  It will be up to the judicial system what the fate of the parent's involvement is.  I would be willing to bet on at least 5-15 years in Federal Prison.   

  

Another note is....you said that "what if they thought they were taking her out of a bad home situation?"  What the parents did was illegal and who cares what they thought.  Ignorance of the law does not excuse you from the consequences.  All I can say is that George had better start saving his money to send to his parents in Prison.  They will be looking to him to provide him with money for cigarettes.   

 

If by chance the FBI is reading this post, I applaud you if you are going to or already have arrested George's parents.  They need to feel the consequences of their actions.  I would hope that we still have the laws in place so we can make people accountable for their actions.   

 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page