Replies to '06/12 On the Outs With In-Laws'

 

Message Emote
blank
February 28, 2006, 4:11 pm PST

there's the problem

Quote From: seecheyle

Before a couple gets married, sometimes before they are even engaged, the in-law jokes start.  More times than not on television, in books, movies, etc..., the in-law relationships are often depicted as dysfunctional, and most often the relationship that is dysfunctional is the mother-in-law/daughter-in-law relationship.   

As a mother of 2 young children, I'd like to think that when they marry, I will not be the stereotypical mother-in-law.  But, being realistic, mother/son relationships are close.  For years and years we will have been the ones to feed him, hug him, hold him, and love him in a way that only a mother could.  When someone else starts to "take care" of him, making his meals, washing his clothes, wiping off his milk mustaches :-), it is a completely human feeling to miss having that place in his life. I am getting choked up thinking about it and my son is only two!   

  

That being said, that does not mean that the relationship between the mother-in-law and daughter-in-law has to be a strained contest to "take care" of son/husband the best.   I think that maybe the stereotypes about this relationship may put us on guard before we even bother to establish a relationship beyond (daughter-in-law) "my boyfriend's mother", or (mother-in-law) "the girl he's seeing."  I believe that stereotypes can often damage a relationship before it even starts. 

  

It's so easy for me to see that it would be best to realize that both myself and his future wife ::gulp:: love my son very much.  That is probably the most important thing we'll have in common to build a relationship on and then hopefully build a friendship even beyond that.  BUT, that is so much easier said than done and I can only hope I remember this when it's time. :-) 

I think what you said about "taking care" of the son/husband is the crux of the problem.  The mother is done mothering and must establish a new kind of relationship with her son and she sees the wife as the new mother.  Whereas wives do not want to "mother" their husbands.  Wives want a grown man that is able to operate a stove, operate a washing machine, and knows how to drink milk without getting a mustache.  A mother takes care of child care needs, a wife takes care of adult relationship needs.  It's very different and problems between the two women arise when either one or both forget there are differences.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 1, 2006, 10:28 am PST

02/28 On the Outs With In-Laws

Quote From: seecheyle

Before a couple gets married, sometimes before they are even engaged, the in-law jokes start.  More times than not on television, in books, movies, etc..., the in-law relationships are often depicted as dysfunctional, and most often the relationship that is dysfunctional is the mother-in-law/daughter-in-law relationship.   

As a mother of 2 young children, I'd like to think that when they marry, I will not be the stereotypical mother-in-law.  But, being realistic, mother/son relationships are close.  For years and years we will have been the ones to feed him, hug him, hold him, and love him in a way that only a mother could.  When someone else starts to "take care" of him, making his meals, washing his clothes, wiping off his milk mustaches :-), it is a completely human feeling to miss having that place in his life. I am getting choked up thinking about it and my son is only two!   

  

That being said, that does not mean that the relationship between the mother-in-law and daughter-in-law has to be a strained contest to "take care" of son/husband the best.   I think that maybe the stereotypes about this relationship may put us on guard before we even bother to establish a relationship beyond (daughter-in-law) "my boyfriend's mother", or (mother-in-law) "the girl he's seeing."  I believe that stereotypes can often damage a relationship before it even starts. 

  

It's so easy for me to see that it would be best to realize that both myself and his future wife ::gulp:: love my son very much.  That is probably the most important thing we'll have in common to build a relationship on and then hopefully build a friendship even beyond that.  BUT, that is so much easier said than done and I can only hope I remember this when it's time. :-) 

I think that you hit it on the nailhead.  It's often a stereotype.  Not always - there are some bad MILs out there but not the majority.  MOST MILs WANT to be friendly with the DIL's and don't have time to meddle.  But  think about this - - why is it that it is usually  that it is the husband's mother that is the MIL from Hell and not the wife's???  Hmmmmm.  Sounds to me like most DIL's think that you are not supposed to like your husband's mother.  It seems like the wife's mother is ALWAY'S perfect!  Most MIL's that I've talked to actually liked their DIL's until they decided to use their baby as a wedge to get them out of their lives totally.  Some have succeeded, some have not.  It depends if the husband has any sense or IS a wuss!  The mother has always been there from him and always will - even after she has been hurt very deeply because of a vindictive DIL.   

  

Sons are the best but I do feel sorry for you when they get married.  It's usually not pretty. . .  They want you to give them money when they need it - - - and believe me, I'm sure that they will LOVE me again when I have "1 foot in the grave and the other on a banana peel!"  They will not want to miss out on a hefty inheritance - I KNOW!  They might be real surprised someday - after all why would I want my DIL from Hell (that keeps me from my son and grandchildren)  to share any of it with my son?  I tried - - she didn't - - so beit. 

 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page