Message Boards

Replies to '06/12 On the Outs With In-Laws'

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 28, 2006, 10:08 am PST

So off the mark

Quote From: steff313

I don't think it's fair to imply that her family is not happy with the situation the way it is, or that she is controling.  We don't know how hard they have tried to mend fences with her MIL or that her husband even wants to have a relationship with her.     

  

As far as the grandchildren go, I can say from personal experience that my parents' marriage and my childhood would have been better had my mother kept her mother from us.  She was a terribly mean woman, who contributed nothing but drama, chaos, and hatred to our lives.  My father was always cordial to her, but her hatred for him was palpable.  I have never felt anything but contempt for her.      

 I beg to differ with you, Gradmabear.

When there is no resolution to the problem with the family, one does break away from them.  Anna Laura's sister-in-law is exactly right when she tells Anna Laura that if this continues, it will kill her.

Family does not give anyone the privilege of abusing others.  We expect strangers on the street to abuse us, not members of our own families.  I speak from experience when I say I broke away from my mother and I had NO choice.  It was me or her, and my survival instinct was still too strong.  That, and I had an obligation to my own child.  It's not easy, to do or to live with, but you have to weigh the costs and it was too expensive a proposition to contribute to the next generation's being made miserable because of one abusive member of the family -- mother or not, grandmother or not.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 28, 2006, 10:10 am PST

There you go

Quote From: steff313

I don't think it's fair to imply that her family is not happy with the situation the way it is, or that she is controling.  We don't know how hard they have tried to mend fences with her MIL or that her husband even wants to have a relationship with her.     

  

As far as the grandchildren go, I can say from personal experience that my parents' marriage and my childhood would have been better had my mother kept her mother from us.  She was a terribly mean woman, who contributed nothing but drama, chaos, and hatred to our lives.  My father was always cordial to her, but her hatred for him was palpable.  I have never felt anything but contempt for her.      

 From the mouths of babes, Gradmabear.
 

Message Emote
blank
February 28, 2006, 10:11 am PST

02/28 On the Outs With In-Laws

Quote From: steff313

I don't think it's fair to imply that her family is not happy with the situation the way it is, or that she is controling.  We don't know how hard they have tried to mend fences with her MIL or that her husband even wants to have a relationship with her.     

  

As far as the grandchildren go, I can say from personal experience that my parents' marriage and my childhood would have been better had my mother kept her mother from us.  She was a terribly mean woman, who contributed nothing but drama, chaos, and hatred to our lives.  My father was always cordial to her, but her hatred for him was palpable.  I have never felt anything but contempt for her.      

One of my Grandfathers hated my mother.  She wasn't Catholic (but she converted) or Italian (how do you fix that?).  We didn't see him often-about 2 times a year so he didn't really contribute much to our family beside the poison of his prejudices-he really just ended up a standing joke because my mom was a gem about it.  Cutting him off would have done my father good. 

 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page