Message Boards

Replies to '10/19 Teacher Caught in the Act'

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 18, 2006, 8:27 pm PDT

10/19 Teacher Caught in the Act

Quote From: tbrooks1124

I will defend Janelle to the day I die. She IS my friend. Janelle and I taught Reading together last year in the public school system . You may not agree with what I have to say,  but that is purely your ignorance to the situation. Yes, Janelle committed a crime. But, to attack her personally and say things like she is a rapist, is wrong. That is not the case. Janelle made a mistake, but does that mean she is a bad person? I know her. I have spent time with her. She is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. To see her in this position  breaks my heart. I can tell you, she is a better person than many of you. You can sit there and judge her for her mistake, but what about you? Her mistake is a big mistake, but why is she the only one to blame? What about that 15 year old boy..who, by the way, turned 16 during this fiasco. So, this 16 year boy is totally innocent? I think not. 

 

Janelle IS a good person who made a mistake. It doesn't mean she is a sexual predator, a rapist, or just a sick human being. SHE MADE A MISTAKE. A mistake that gives the public the right to throw obscene and rude comments in her face. Well, may your lifetime of mistakes one day be thrown in your face or put on display for the public to defame you.

 

Janelle WILL rise above this. I know that the time she spends paying for this crime will make her a stronger person.

but she does need to pay for her criome and to say that she is too pretty to go to jail is way off the wall, So who get sto decide who is pretty and not pretty? She may be a sweet person and yes, I agree she made a mistake and it was a mistake that was against the law and she needs the same consequence as any one else who has done the same thing, having sex with a child. She was the adult here and she should have been able to say NO. I pesonally do not think this boy was all that innocent but yet at the same time, she did committ a crime. And I agree, she  can/will arise above this, but she is no differnet then anyone else who committs a crime and her looks shouldn't have anything to do with the outcome.

And sorrry to say, but when some one in a postotion such as hers, tehy are gonna be publicized, we all know that, therefore those people need to be a little extra careful, believe me, I know. I have held high positions in my churhc denomination and one thing that can land some one in thepostion of losing their job such as I had was to committ adukltery or sex before marriage, When I met and fell in love with my now husband, I wanted to be with him in more ways then one but knew that if I messed up, the whole district would know eventually cause stuff like that doesn't stay secret for very long, i knew if I fail into that temptation, I could have lost my job but thankfully, I knew what my priorities and beliefs were and nothing would get int eh ay of that. I know it is easy to fall at times, but we have to use our brains and run the other way at times and she didn't do that. I ma sure, in the back of her mind, she knew she was wrong and could lose her job but she let her emotions, whatever get the best of her, sad but she committed a crime. Hopefully she has learned from this and will come out on top but she isn't aboce the law just because of her looks and the type of person she is..............
 
User Mood
Nervous

Message Emote
upset
October 19, 2006, 8:28 am PDT

blah blah blah

Quote From: tbrooks1124

I will defend Janelle to the day I die. She IS my friend. Janelle and I taught Reading together last year in the public school system . You may not agree with what I have to say,  but that is purely your ignorance to the situation. Yes, Janelle committed a crime. But, to attack her personally and say things like she is a rapist, is wrong. That is not the case. Janelle made a mistake, but does that mean she is a bad person? I know her. I have spent time with her. She is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. To see her in this position  breaks my heart. I can tell you, she is a better person than many of you. You can sit there and judge her for her mistake, but what about you? Her mistake is a big mistake, but why is she the only one to blame? What about that 15 year old boy..who, by the way, turned 16 during this fiasco. So, this 16 year boy is totally innocent? I think not. 

 

Janelle IS a good person who made a mistake. It doesn't mean she is a sexual predator, a rapist, or just a sick human being. SHE MADE A MISTAKE. A mistake that gives the public the right to throw obscene and rude comments in her face. Well, may your lifetime of mistakes one day be thrown in your face or put on display for the public to defame you.

 

Janelle WILL rise above this. I know that the time she spends paying for this crime will make her a stronger person.

Janelle may be a nice, good person that yes did make a mistake but she broke the law and needs to go to prison. She was suppose to GUIDE children not have sex with them. I really dont care if she loved him, I love some of my sons friends but would never mess with them that  WILL mentally screw with this young mans head. Stop trying to make light of the situation and accept she needs prison.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2006, 12:00 pm PDT

10/19 Teacher Caught in the Act

Quote From: tbrooks1124

I will defend Janelle to the day I die. She IS my friend. Janelle and I taught Reading together last year in the public school system . You may not agree with what I have to say,  but that is purely your ignorance to the situation. Yes, Janelle committed a crime. But, to attack her personally and say things like she is a rapist, is wrong. That is not the case. Janelle made a mistake, but does that mean she is a bad person? I know her. I have spent time with her. She is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. To see her in this position  breaks my heart. I can tell you, she is a better person than many of you. You can sit there and judge her for her mistake, but what about you? Her mistake is a big mistake, but why is she the only one to blame? What about that 15 year old boy..who, by the way, turned 16 during this fiasco. So, this 16 year boy is totally innocent? I think not. 

 

Janelle IS a good person who made a mistake. It doesn't mean she is a sexual predator, a rapist, or just a sick human being. SHE MADE A MISTAKE. A mistake that gives the public the right to throw obscene and rude comments in her face. Well, may your lifetime of mistakes one day be thrown in your face or put on display for the public to defame you.

 

Janelle WILL rise above this. I know that the time she spends paying for this crime will make her a stronger person.

I applaud your defense of your friend;  you stand by her no matter what.  Not all of us have many people in our lives that would do that or would be willing to be that faithful.

 

I have no idea how the mind of a person operates unless they have the same opinions that I do.   I do not understand why she thought that sex with a minor was appropriate.  Maybe her starvation for feeling loved at the time clouded her judgement.  I'm sure that , at the time, she did not think that she was doing anything wrong.  Somehow she was able to justify it to herself  that maybe she was not wrong because it was, to her, love and not just sex. 

 

As a person who is bi-polar and was molested many times as a child and teenager, I do not believe that this can be classified as a "mistake".  She acted impulsively but she did not just fall on top of him.    Bi-polar people sometimes do act impulsively and I've done some things myself that I'm not proud of.  I've put myself in some very questionable sexual situations (some considered dangerous) but never with a minor.  She did something wrong and there are consequences.  I will not attack her as a person because I do not know her but I do believe that she should be accountable for her actions.

 

When I was 19 I went with a guy (off-duty cop) to a closed VFW to play pool.  He raped me.  My accountability with this is that I willing went with him to a place that I knew we would be alone.    I put myself in the situation but HE was the one responsible for the rape.  The young man may have put himself in the situation but it was her responsibility to not take action.

 

My heart really goes out to her family and friends who I'm sure are devastated by this.  Keep doing what you're doing and be supportive of her.  It does not mean that you approve of what she did, but believe in her as a person.

 

 

 

 

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2006, 12:12 pm PDT

10/19 Teacher Caught in the Act

Quote From: tbrooks1124

I will defend Janelle to the day I die. She IS my friend. Janelle and I taught Reading together last year in the public school system . You may not agree with what I have to say,  but that is purely your ignorance to the situation. Yes, Janelle committed a crime. But, to attack her personally and say things like she is a rapist, is wrong. That is not the case. Janelle made a mistake, but does that mean she is a bad person? I know her. I have spent time with her. She is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. To see her in this position  breaks my heart. I can tell you, she is a better person than many of you. You can sit there and judge her for her mistake, but what about you? Her mistake is a big mistake, but why is she the only one to blame? What about that 15 year old boy..who, by the way, turned 16 during this fiasco. So, this 16 year boy is totally innocent? I think not. 

 

Janelle IS a good person who made a mistake. It doesn't mean she is a sexual predator, a rapist, or just a sick human being. SHE MADE A MISTAKE. A mistake that gives the public the right to throw obscene and rude comments in her face. Well, may your lifetime of mistakes one day be thrown in your face or put on display for the public to defame you.

 

Janelle WILL rise above this. I know that the time she spends paying for this crime will make her a stronger person.

So let's see what we have here:

-We have her friend defending her, that's no surprise, so I have no doubt you aren't bias about the situation.

-You say she's better than some people on this board, yet you don't know anyone here...so I don't know how you could possibly say that.

-You are blaming the VICTIM in this case. (Did you see the boy at the end of the show whose life was messed up by a similar situation?) That's disturbing that you think you can blame a kid for his being abused and taken advantage of.

-You minimize her crime by repeatedly calling it a "mistake".

-You don't seem to understand the fact that she's a sex offender and that makes it necessary for the public to know about her.

-I hope she does learn from this, but I also hope she isn't in charge of kids anymore. Ever again.  It's not her fault that sex offenders repeat their crimes...that is the way it is. So forgive me for not being naive and trusting of someone simply because they SAY they've "learned"...
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
October 19, 2006, 12:24 pm PDT

she needs friends

Quote From: tbrooks1124

I will defend Janelle to the day I die. She IS my friend. Janelle and I taught Reading together last year in the public school system . You may not agree with what I have to say,  but that is purely your ignorance to the situation. Yes, Janelle committed a crime. But, to attack her personally and say things like she is a rapist, is wrong. That is not the case. Janelle made a mistake, but does that mean she is a bad person? I know her. I have spent time with her. She is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. To see her in this position  breaks my heart. I can tell you, she is a better person than many of you. You can sit there and judge her for her mistake, but what about you? Her mistake is a big mistake, but why is she the only one to blame? What about that 15 year old boy..who, by the way, turned 16 during this fiasco. So, this 16 year boy is totally innocent? I think not. 

 

Janelle IS a good person who made a mistake. It doesn't mean she is a sexual predator, a rapist, or just a sick human being. SHE MADE A MISTAKE. A mistake that gives the public the right to throw obscene and rude comments in her face. Well, may your lifetime of mistakes one day be thrown in your face or put on display for the public to defame you.

 

Janelle WILL rise above this. I know that the time she spends paying for this crime will make her a stronger person.

I am glad you stand by yr friend.   I am sure she needs all the friends she can get right now.

But please understand she is a sexual predator and she over stepped her boundaries as a teacher in a position of authority.    The boy was a minor and it is a criminal offense what she did and she did make a mistake and is paying for it now.    Like I said I am glad she has you for a friend and I feel bad for the boy.   He is just a boy and he needs our prayers as well.

I am looking forward to seeing this show and maybe I need the whole story and I hope Janelle gets some good counseling.    I am sure it was not easy to go on the show and expose herself in such a negative way.  

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2006, 9:02 am PDT

Question

Quote From: tbrooks1124

I will defend Janelle to the day I die. She IS my friend. Janelle and I taught Reading together last year in the public school system . You may not agree with what I have to say,  but that is purely your ignorance to the situation. Yes, Janelle committed a crime. But, to attack her personally and say things like she is a rapist, is wrong. That is not the case. Janelle made a mistake, but does that mean she is a bad person? I know her. I have spent time with her. She is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. To see her in this position  breaks my heart. I can tell you, she is a better person than many of you. You can sit there and judge her for her mistake, but what about you? Her mistake is a big mistake, but why is she the only one to blame? What about that 15 year old boy..who, by the way, turned 16 during this fiasco. So, this 16 year boy is totally innocent? I think not. 

 

Janelle IS a good person who made a mistake. It doesn't mean she is a sexual predator, a rapist, or just a sick human being. SHE MADE A MISTAKE. A mistake that gives the public the right to throw obscene and rude comments in her face. Well, may your lifetime of mistakes one day be thrown in your face or put on display for the public to defame you.

 

Janelle WILL rise above this. I know that the time she spends paying for this crime will make her a stronger person.

What was her "mistake"? 

 

And yes, the child whose trust she abused while sexually assaulting him over an extended period of time, who also happened to turn 16 during the media coverage of Janelle's "mistake" , is completely innocent.   

 

To your question of "why is she the only one to blame in this", Janelle was the adult in the position of authority over the child whose trust she abused when she sexual assaulted him.

 

Shawn ferrie-Beulman

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2006, 9:29 am PDT

Just ask yourself

Quote From: tbrooks1124

I will defend Janelle to the day I die. She IS my friend. Janelle and I taught Reading together last year in the public school system . You may not agree with what I have to say,  but that is purely your ignorance to the situation. Yes, Janelle committed a crime. But, to attack her personally and say things like she is a rapist, is wrong. That is not the case. Janelle made a mistake, but does that mean she is a bad person? I know her. I have spent time with her. She is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. To see her in this position  breaks my heart. I can tell you, she is a better person than many of you. You can sit there and judge her for her mistake, but what about you? Her mistake is a big mistake, but why is she the only one to blame? What about that 15 year old boy..who, by the way, turned 16 during this fiasco. So, this 16 year boy is totally innocent? I think not. 

 

Janelle IS a good person who made a mistake. It doesn't mean she is a sexual predator, a rapist, or just a sick human being. SHE MADE A MISTAKE. A mistake that gives the public the right to throw obscene and rude comments in her face. Well, may your lifetime of mistakes one day be thrown in your face or put on display for the public to defame you.

 

Janelle WILL rise above this. I know that the time she spends paying for this crime will make her a stronger person.

What if this was your son she had molested.? Would you still be so ready to defend her? Would you think that it was his fault? Somehow I think not. You are trivializing this situation by trying to blame the boy. And as so many others have previously stated had she been a male, she would now be in prison. Would you still be his friend and defend him to your dying day? You know, you don't have to even answer because I already know. You would write him off as a pervert. And rightly so. So how does being female make her any less? Sorry, but you can keep her as your friend, I don't want or need friends like that.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2006, 6:23 pm PDT

I totally agree

Quote From: tbrooks1124

I will defend Janelle to the day I die. She IS my friend. Janelle and I taught Reading together last year in the public school system . You may not agree with what I have to say,  but that is purely your ignorance to the situation. Yes, Janelle committed a crime. But, to attack her personally and say things like she is a rapist, is wrong. That is not the case. Janelle made a mistake, but does that mean she is a bad person? I know her. I have spent time with her. She is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. To see her in this position  breaks my heart. I can tell you, she is a better person than many of you. You can sit there and judge her for her mistake, but what about you? Her mistake is a big mistake, but why is she the only one to blame? What about that 15 year old boy..who, by the way, turned 16 during this fiasco. So, this 16 year boy is totally innocent? I think not. 

 

Janelle IS a good person who made a mistake. It doesn't mean she is a sexual predator, a rapist, or just a sick human being. SHE MADE A MISTAKE. A mistake that gives the public the right to throw obscene and rude comments in her face. Well, may your lifetime of mistakes one day be thrown in your face or put on display for the public to defame you.

 

Janelle WILL rise above this. I know that the time she spends paying for this crime will make her a stronger person.

I watched this show with my 16y/o son who by the way is a 3.17 student in high school and very bright.  I do not feel this lady is in any way a sexual predator I think she made a big mistake in judgment however.  I don't think anybody will benefit by her getting any jail time. I think she was a bit naive perhaps.  I really think she thought this was love and that she truly did not think about the legality of what she was doing. NO I would not want a teacher to pray upon my son in school but my son and I talked about this incident and he agrees that Janelle seemed very naive and that she should not go to jail .  There are a lot of 15y/o" kids "out there that are far advanced beyond their years and while that is certainly no excuse I do think we have to consider that.  If this was an issue of the 15y/o Kid committing some type of violent crime might the judicial system be considering trying him as an adult if they felt he was aware of what he was doing was wrong? I am sorry I just feel this woman made a mistake and that she truly is not a some evil person. I think she has learned a lot from this experience and that she deserves forgiveness's she certainly has my compassion is this situation.  I truly got no feelling while watching the show that Janelle intended to victimize anybody . I wish her all the best
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2006, 7:05 pm PDT

10/19 Teacher Caught in the Act

Quote From: tbrooks1124

I will defend Janelle to the day I die. She IS my friend. Janelle and I taught Reading together last year in the public school system . You may not agree with what I have to say,  but that is purely your ignorance to the situation. Yes, Janelle committed a crime. But, to attack her personally and say things like she is a rapist, is wrong. That is not the case. Janelle made a mistake, but does that mean she is a bad person? I know her. I have spent time with her. She is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. To see her in this position  breaks my heart. I can tell you, she is a better person than many of you. You can sit there and judge her for her mistake, but what about you? Her mistake is a big mistake, but why is she the only one to blame? What about that 15 year old boy..who, by the way, turned 16 during this fiasco. So, this 16 year boy is totally innocent? I think not. 

 

Janelle IS a good person who made a mistake. It doesn't mean she is a sexual predator, a rapist, or just a sick human being. SHE MADE A MISTAKE. A mistake that gives the public the right to throw obscene and rude comments in her face. Well, may your lifetime of mistakes one day be thrown in your face or put on display for the public to defame you.

 

Janelle WILL rise above this. I know that the time she spends paying for this crime will make her a stronger person.

I don't think most people are saying that she isn't, they just want her to take FULL responsibility for her actions.  She can in no way blame the boy, argue that she was in love with him, or play the innocent young lady in this scenario.  Just own up to what you did Janelle and pay the consequences.  Recognize that according to the letter of the law you are a pedophile and you have committed a crime, I think that is all anyone is expecting of you. 

 

Okay maybe you don't want to think of yourself as a pedophile, but maybe you should have thought about that before you got involved with this young man whom you had authority over. 

 

She made a mistake that has now labeled her a pedophile, stop living in denial.  It's a terrible thing to have to live with that label, who would want that, no one, but that is what she is according to the laws in this country. 

 

If you are truly her friend then you will help her to accept the real truth of the situation, maybe then she can get the real help that she needs to help her understand why she would choose this path in the first place, then the real healing can begin in her life. 

 

This is not just a mistake, like oops I forgot to set the alarm on my house and it was burglarized.  This was something that she knew was wrong, but did it anyway.  She committed a crime, not a mistake.  There is a difference. 

 

I am glad that you are her friend and are sticking by her, but please don't help her to stay in denial about the truth about this situation, help her to see it how God views it. 

 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page