Message Boards

Replies to '11/24 Great School Debate'

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
December 1, 2006, 11:40 am PST

11/24 Great School Debate

Quote From: tinkerbell123

 

 

Ok!  first, in regards to the government serving the people.....the emphasis was on the word "YOU" , as far as, "the government serving the people....  meaning, it serves the people, as a WHOLE, not "YOU" or ME, as an individual. 

 

Second,  the reason I do not think Hitler should be used as an example for this topic in banning homeschooling, is because MORE importantly Hitler killed over 6,000,000 Jews - something Im far more concerned about!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Third, I love this country, I have served in the military, for this country, and I take great PRIDE in the freedoms, the men and women before us, who lost their lives have given us. WE DO NOT live in a dictatorship, maybe you should visit Germany yourself, to understand the difference.

 

Lastly, the intent of the Facts I told from the CBS news report, was in responding to a post from my message, someone asked for me to put in some info about what was on the report.  this was some of the info!

 

FYI: There was a law established many years before Hitler was born, 126 yrs to be excact.

 It was King Friedrich Wilhelm I of Prussia who established the general regional school regulation. 

 

http://www.homeedmag.com/blogs/newscomm/?p=590

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 1, 2006, 11:40 am PST

Child's rights

Quote From: tinkerbell123

 

 

Ok!  first, in regards to the government serving the people.....the emphasis was on the word "YOU" , as far as, "the government serving the people....  meaning, it serves the people, as a WHOLE, not "YOU" or ME, as an individual. 

 

Second,  the reason I do not think Hitler should be used as an example for this topic in banning homeschooling, is because MORE importantly Hitler killed over 6,000,000 Jews - something Im far more concerned about!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Third, I love this country, I have served in the military, for this country, and I take great PRIDE in the freedoms, the men and women before us, who lost their lives have given us. WE DO NOT live in a dictatorship, maybe you should visit Germany yourself, to understand the difference.

 

Lastly, the intent of the Facts I told from the CBS news report, was in responding to a post from my message, someone asked for me to put in some info about what was on the report.  this was some of the info!

 

Tinkerbell -

How would you feel if your child was mistakely  or even rightly accused of an offense at school and the police questioned your child without your knowledge or consent?

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
December 1, 2006, 12:16 pm PST

11/24 Great School Debate

Quote From: tinkerbell123

 

 

Ok!  first, in regards to the government serving the people.....the emphasis was on the word "YOU" , as far as, "the government serving the people....  meaning, it serves the people, as a WHOLE, not "YOU" or ME, as an individual. 

 

Second,  the reason I do not think Hitler should be used as an example for this topic in banning homeschooling, is because MORE importantly Hitler killed over 6,000,000 Jews - something Im far more concerned about!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Third, I love this country, I have served in the military, for this country, and I take great PRIDE in the freedoms, the men and women before us, who lost their lives have given us. WE DO NOT live in a dictatorship, maybe you should visit Germany yourself, to understand the difference.

 

Lastly, the intent of the Facts I told from the CBS news report, was in responding to a post from my message, someone asked for me to put in some info about what was on the report.  this was some of the info!

 

Okay, I think there must be some communication break down.

 

Ok!  first, in regards to the government serving the people.....the emphasis was on the word "YOU" , as far as, "the government serving the people....  meaning, it serves the people, as a WHOLE, not "YOU" or ME, as an individual. 

 

I never said anything about "you" or "me".

 

Second,  the reason I do not think Hitler should be used as an example for this topic in banning homeschooling, is because MORE importantly Hitler killed over 6,000,000 Jews - something I’m far more concerned about!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Or course Hitler did many evil things including the Holocaust. It was a terrible event that will always be mourned worldwide.

But I don't understand your point. Why should the Holocaust be the only thing we are allowed to discuss when the topic turns to Hitler.

 

It's a very valid point.

He banned homeschooling.

You want to ban homeschooling.

 

Third, I love this country, I have served in the military, for this country,

I am very glad you love our great country and I thank you for your military service. 

 

 and I take great PRIDE in the freedoms, the men and women before us, who lost their lives have given us.

As do I. By the way, my husband is active duty Army with 15 years of service under his belt. He could retire in 5 years but he will not. He chooses to max out in the Army and push to 30 years of service. He does this because he believes in our country. He believes in protecting our freedoms and the freedom of those who cannot protect themselves. He has left our family twice for one year deployments. The first was Korea and the second was Iraq. Since his return from Iraq, one and a half years ago,  he has trained privates who will be fighting in the war immediately upon their graduation from basic training.

You do not need to lecture me on cherishing our freedom. My husband is willing to die for freedom and we support his decision to serve our country and President.

 

maybe you should visit Germany yourself, to understand the difference.

 

I never suggested anyone move to Germany. Why do you? I may at some point move to Germany however as our Army has military installations there.

 

Lastly, the intent of the Facts I told from the CBS news report, was in responding to a post from my message, someone asked for me to put in some info about what was on the report.  this was some of the info!

 

Yes I understand that.

It was you that originally brought the article to the message board though, was it not?

What was your intent in posting the article?

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
December 1, 2006, 12:28 pm PST

11/24 Great School Debate

Quote From: tinkerbell123

 

 

Ok!  first, in regards to the government serving the people.....the emphasis was on the word "YOU" , as far as, "the government serving the people....  meaning, it serves the people, as a WHOLE, not "YOU" or ME, as an individual. 

 

Second,  the reason I do not think Hitler should be used as an example for this topic in banning homeschooling, is because MORE importantly Hitler killed over 6,000,000 Jews - something Im far more concerned about!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Third, I love this country, I have served in the military, for this country, and I take great PRIDE in the freedoms, the men and women before us, who lost their lives have given us. WE DO NOT live in a dictatorship, maybe you should visit Germany yourself, to understand the difference.

 

Lastly, the intent of the Facts I told from the CBS news report, was in responding to a post from my message, someone asked for me to put in some info about what was on the report.  this was some of the info!

 

Whoops! I missed one.

 

WE DO NOT live in a dictatorship

 

I never said we did.

 

If you would please read my posts. I'm sorry if I'm not clear enough in my posts but I thought I was. Here is what I said, " The court has declared you have no right to override the public school. What's worse is there are people, such as yourself, who believe all children should attend public school. Reminds me a bit of dictatorship." 

 

If the government forces  it's citizens to a building and has complete authority over what is taught there it is like a dictatorship.

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
December 2, 2006, 5:31 am PST

11/24 Great School Debate

Quote From: tinkerbell123

 

 

Ok!  first, in regards to the government serving the people.....the emphasis was on the word "YOU" , as far as, "the government serving the people....  meaning, it serves the people, as a WHOLE, not "YOU" or ME, as an individual. 

 

Second,  the reason I do not think Hitler should be used as an example for this topic in banning homeschooling, is because MORE importantly Hitler killed over 6,000,000 Jews - something Im far more concerned about!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Third, I love this country, I have served in the military, for this country, and I take great PRIDE in the freedoms, the men and women before us, who lost their lives have given us. WE DO NOT live in a dictatorship, maybe you should visit Germany yourself, to understand the difference.

 

Lastly, the intent of the Facts I told from the CBS news report, was in responding to a post from my message, someone asked for me to put in some info about what was on the report.  this was some of the info!

 

I also want to add, here is what was ruled this year in Germany:

 

The ECHR stated in its Konrad and Others v. German Decision opinion that the German FCC had attempted to balance individual rights with "the state's obligation to provide for education of responsible citizens who participate in a democratic and pluralistic society."

 

Basically the courts ruled "it was in the children's best interest to be indoctrinated in the prevailing social order."

 

This is a prime example of forced socialism folks. For all those who argue "What about socialization?" is that argument really worth losing all educational choice freedom?

 

 

 

 

 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page