Quote From: wildwood Abuse and it's victims (target persons) is very complex. Learned helplessness can be very prevelant in both the target person (victim) and in the abuser (abuse of substance or of power). It is sometimes referred to as a dance where neither party can escape, so they continually dance in a dysfunctional way often trading places in the power and man down postitions.
My husband fluxuates daily from tyrant, (daddy figure or how he sees them) to child (Mr. Magoo clueless and therefore not responsible). These are the ways he copes with his "non meshed" personality.
He has disordered black or white thinking, and if his being here all the time has taught me one thing.........it is that he has ALWAYS been at war with extremes, not able to be crossed, with out immediate shift to the "victim or helpless and clueless" only to rise up the tyrant within days.
. He is therefore(seen as and behaving) passive aggressive, oppositional defiant and obessive compulsive (my diag.) and many other things that CLEARLY illustrate to me that his SELVES are not at peace with each other. All, manipulations, however are in fact a symptom of the deeper personality disorders, though they may be situational. POWER OVER is however the goal he strives for. If he can't have THAT he melts before your eyes into a total helpless child. Of no use to anyone. This is manipulation to the tenth degree.
I, having lived with him for many years, and in hopelessly trying to mesh a reality that is constant, believe they have ALWAYS been there. As are his "multiple personalities" (my arm chair diag) and his Mr. Moodies ( or "actors" that come out as I refer to them to myself) and his need to manipulate others into their "roles". dependant on HIS moods. I also think he is clearly narcississtic (sp?). This may be his MAIN disorder and the others support that role. All of this is "my conclusions" based on much readings, consultations, and otherwise futile attempts to understand it, counteract it or cope with it in a less "put your own neck in the noose way".
However, upon numerous attempts to get it to stop, or uncovered through counseling alone or together, NOT ONE COUNSELOR did much to do anything but HURT the situation. One even told him (based on a self test of himself) that he was not an alcoholic (as they did my father at one time), nor did they apparently do any other testing of any kind on EITHER of us to determine what WAS at the bottom of any of this.
More often I was addressed and given assignments, or seen as the "more pitifull" even when I was groomed, in control, non emotional and very articulate. They were intimadated and impressed by my husband profession, (police military,and his polish and manipulations of truth, relaxed demeanor, non challence (good gracious he has been TRAINED to decieve and be "in control" people!!!!!).
I was told don't interupt, forget the past, be a supportive and appreciative wife, stop spending money, ( his by the way, stop living!) my nest was empty, (NOT by a long stretch) my surgery (hysterictomy) was the cause, get a hobby (duh I have hundereds) get a job, which I had had several during the marriage, to include self employed (while he blackballs me to the kids? transfers his abandonment issues?) and a multitude of "it is your fault, shut up and take it or look the other way" consider yourself lucky he DOESN"T beat you! babblespeak, that only "abused further" and clearly showed our counselors "didn't have a clue" as to the dynamics or hidden aspects of emotional abuse, financial blackmail or any of the realities I dealt with.
These were the "professionals" I spent good money on to help us. I should have saved it for my escape instead, but wanted my marriage to WORK under different dynamics. One, did identify me as the family "scapegoat" but proceeded to crab walk away from that when my husband was in the room. COUNSELING doesnt' help. Many men just use "going to counseling to stall and abuse further" making me VERY sorry for all the years spent getting him to go and attempting to go. The only thing I got from counseling is it can't help you, ONLY YOU CAN help yourself. Get them out or get you out.
Perhaps it is his catholic upbringing, his war experiences, or because he is a twin, a male, hurt, angry or really IS confused, or maybe just because he can. None of course, are excuses, nor reasons to stay with someone at war with themselves. I only offer this for the "debate" purposes of our unrelenting desire to "understand" how and why we here have had an "encounter with a person at war with themselves".
I can certainly relate to all the things you describe here. Like many abusers they all sound the same; same MO and all. My first counselor years ago would ask me why I thought my H (ex now) was controlling. I didnt really have a good enough answer so the therapist chucked it off and relized I didnt have enough info. to support the control issue. What I was trying to express was that if I didnt live up to my ex's expectations he would find a way to punish me; not physically but mentally and I didnt get it yet!! It was such a slow process that I never felt it coming down the pike. I remember I was out of work for awhile and I had some savings. Ex knew that I was living off my savings and had no job. Instead of helping me with that for awhile (by no means am I a spendthrift either) he never said a word nor did we discuss the issue. Instead he would tell me that the only money he had was to pay the bills and there was nothing left over. I never pushed the issue and would shop at bargain basements when I needed to and suffered financially all the while he was making a huge salary. After I went through my savings I had to go back to work.
There was also a time when ex had raises and money coming in from all sorts of places. I never saw a penny of it. While he spent I struggled and struggled with the finances. Sure: I had credit but it was all too control my spending and see what I spent. My second therapist told me to stop feeling sorry for myself and get a life also!! She told me you have everything you want and need so what is the problem. More ways of not being able to explain the control and mental abuse. Dont forget the respect and the love they also get from the community. Mine was involved in community things and knew high officials. They thought as they still do that he was the most caring loving and nice individual. Even if I tried to explain to them what he really was would they listen nor care? Boy do I know about the Jekyll and Hyde too!! This was a guy who choked me and smashed windows and doors one minute and then the next go out and meet with coworkers and people who adored him in the community. I always felt something wasnt quite right. What I think the hardest thing in the world to do is see through the manipulations while you live the nightmare with an abuser and major manipulator. For me as a lay person and all around regular gal I never saw it coming. The power plays and the manipulations; but I knew something was wrong. i couldnt understand why I couldnt voice my own opinion around ex. Arent we entitled to our opinions? Arent we entitled to say what we want? I never could; wait I did but when I did there was another price to pay. If I said it was black he said it was white. If I didnt agree a major battle was in place and I never won any of them. He beat me mentally again and again until years later I was a vegetable cowering in the corner. i had no life, no self esteem and I felt like a shell of a human being. The only thing that kept me going was the spirit that God gives us. For some reason our spirits are the most powerful weapon against the enemy. Even when I left home after I couldnt take the abuse anymore I was labeled from the ex as the one who left him because I wanted to find out what was out in the world and to seek out other relationships because I was bored. I cringe at to what he really told people. I could go on and on but enough for now. I like that saying you have up there in your post. Live in the Truth. The day I decided to really get out was when I was watching Dr.Robin Smith onOprah and she said,"Live in the Truth" otherwise life is not worth living. That day I filed for divorce.