Message Boards

Replies to '02/01 A Difficult Reunion – Part 1'

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
frustrated
February 1, 2007, 7:24 am PST

YOU MISSED THE POINT OF THE SHOW

Quote From: lynnie59

Our family watched this show, and CANNOT understand the need to meet, talk, give the time of day to this person who murdered their mother!!  Forget it! He's not worth it and there's no good to come from this "reunion".... it's unhealthy, sick and cruel. I do think it is disrespectful to the mother to have any desire to meet the man who killed her in cold blood! no way.

 

I have personal experience with a father who molested me, gave up his parental rights in exchange for never having to pay the child support he owed my mother and any future child support....

 

Not every man is a father or a person who deserves to be given a second chance, this is definitely one of those situations.. there are other people this woman can get love and support from in her life. This guy is sick and why he was not executed for the murder he committed is another question, let alone he is now out and FREE???? and we call this justice for the victims??? I don't think so....

 

this show irritated me and my family, we thought Dr. Phil should've counseled this woman to move on, this man took her mother away and he has issues.

 

We think he missed the boat on this show for sure...

EVERYONE WHO HAS TRAGEDY IN THEIR LIVES AND IF IT HELP THEM TO MOVE FORWARD INLIFE FOR THE BETTER. THAN WHY NOT FACE THE PERSON WHO DID THIS CRIME TO HER MOTHER. I GIVE HER CREDIT FOR HAVING THE GUTS TO DO THE SHOW WITH DR. PHIL. SHE WANTED ANSWER FROM THE ONLY PERSON WHO COULD ANSWER THEM!!!!!!!

YOU KNOW THEIR ARE CHILDREN OUT THERE IN THE WORLD WHO HAVE HAD TRAGIC THINGS HAPPEN IN THEIR LIVES THAT CAN'T HANDLE THE PROBLEMS THAT CA ARISE FROM SUCH ISSUES. THIS IS WHERE SOME OF THESE KIDS GO WRONG, THEY TURN OUT TO BE THE SAME WAY, JUST WITH DIFFERENT KINDS OF EMOTIONAL PROBLEMS.

ALL DR. PHIL WAS DOING, NOW KEEP IN MIND THIS IS JUST MU OWN PERSONAL OPINION, IN WHICH EVRYONE IS ENTITLED TO.

I ADMIRE FOR HAVING THE COURAGE TO DO THIS SHOW ON NATIONAL TV. YOU GO GIRL AND I HOPE THIS WILL GIVE YOU SOME PEACE.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 1, 2007, 8:15 am PST

Why can't you understand???

Quote From: lynnie59

Our family watched this show, and CANNOT understand the need to meet, talk, give the time of day to this person who murdered their mother!!  Forget it! He's not worth it and there's no good to come from this "reunion".... it's unhealthy, sick and cruel. I do think it is disrespectful to the mother to have any desire to meet the man who killed her in cold blood! no way.

 

I have personal experience with a father who molested me, gave up his parental rights in exchange for never having to pay the child support he owed my mother and any future child support....

 

Not every man is a father or a person who deserves to be given a second chance, this is definitely one of those situations.. there are other people this woman can get love and support from in her life. This guy is sick and why he was not executed for the murder he committed is another question, let alone he is now out and FREE???? and we call this justice for the victims??? I don't think so....

 

this show irritated me and my family, we thought Dr. Phil should've counseled this woman to move on, this man took her mother away and he has issues.

 

We think he missed the boat on this show for sure...

Just because YOU didn't need this type of closure doesn't mean others don't. We are all individuals with different wants and needs.

.

I carried brick (of hatred and resentment) on my shoulders and into all my relationships until I decided to FORGIVE my father. For me, it's what changed my life for the better. He no longer controls me, I finally appreciate all the good that was in him (he made horrible mistakes, but his love for me was always evident...he just didn't know how to parent!) and I wake up with a clean slate (of happiess) every single morning. I also have a great relationship w/ a dying man who now has a daughter that has forgiven him and moved forward. I LOVE my father. I hate what he did to me, my sister and my mother, but I still love him. Forgiving does not mean forgetting.

.

See, we are all different. Dr. Phil didn't miss any boat. You apparently have missed out on the part about people being individuals with different needs (different needs to be ABLE to move on). Please don't look down on others for needing something different than you do.  The daughter deserves credit for being strong enough to face the man who killed her mother.

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
sad
February 1, 2007, 4:13 pm PST

This is exactly what I was talking about..

Quote From: lynnie59

Our family watched this show, and CANNOT understand the need to meet, talk, give the time of day to this person who murdered their mother!!  Forget it! He's not worth it and there's no good to come from this "reunion".... it's unhealthy, sick and cruel. I do think it is disrespectful to the mother to have any desire to meet the man who killed her in cold blood! no way.

 

I have personal experience with a father who molested me, gave up his parental rights in exchange for never having to pay the child support he owed my mother and any future child support....

 

Not every man is a father or a person who deserves to be given a second chance, this is definitely one of those situations.. there are other people this woman can get love and support from in her life. This guy is sick and why he was not executed for the murder he committed is another question, let alone he is now out and FREE???? and we call this justice for the victims??? I don't think so....

 

this show irritated me and my family, we thought Dr. Phil should've counseled this woman to move on, this man took her mother away and he has issues.

 

We think he missed the boat on this show for sure...

the anger, the hurt that this show has dredged up for so many.  My ex was an abuser, and when I found out he had taken my daughter to a place where drugs were....I left him and I was only 19.  Do I have any hate for him now? No, I have NO feelings for him either way.  I had to let go of all the power he had over me to be able to grow as a person.  My dad was ex-military; very strict - he was the reason I left home at 15......there is a fine line between fear and respect, I had to establish that line.  When my dad was diagnosed at the age of 82 with terminal brain cancer, I quit my job and took care of him until the day he died.  I have two brothers that could not find it in them to do it and my mom was too fragile after 52 years of putting up with his rampages.  We found that line of mutual respect/fear - but only after I decided I was in control of my life.  Many occasion, I was the one thrown in between the fights between my mom and dad, I had found the courage to control my destiny, my mom couldn't so she always called me to deal with my dad.  I have no regrets on that front.

 

Let go of the hate, no not everyone that has a child is a parent, the ability to reproduce doesn't make you a parent - and all hatred begets is hatred.

 

I wasn't happy when, after my daughter had grown up, she took up with a married man, even lived in the same house with both of them before the wife granted a divorce - it was all wrong from many moral fronts.....they are now happily married and choose to live in another state - I let hatred and control almost cost me my daughter.  I learned the lesson hatred begets hatred, I couldn't push my own daughter into hating me and realized that in time enough to stop it.

 

Let it go.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 1, 2007, 4:28 pm PST

02/01 A Difficult Reunion – Part 1

Quote From: lynnie59

Our family watched this show, and CANNOT understand the need to meet, talk, give the time of day to this person who murdered their mother!!  Forget it! He's not worth it and there's no good to come from this "reunion".... it's unhealthy, sick and cruel. I do think it is disrespectful to the mother to have any desire to meet the man who killed her in cold blood! no way.

 

I have personal experience with a father who molested me, gave up his parental rights in exchange for never having to pay the child support he owed my mother and any future child support....

 

Not every man is a father or a person who deserves to be given a second chance, this is definitely one of those situations.. there are other people this woman can get love and support from in her life. This guy is sick and why he was not executed for the murder he committed is another question, let alone he is now out and FREE???? and we call this justice for the victims??? I don't think so....

 

this show irritated me and my family, we thought Dr. Phil should've counseled this woman to move on, this man took her mother away and he has issues.

 

We think he missed the boat on this show for sure...

dont think this will help you understand but in all honesty the need the girls had wasnt for your family to try to understand, but you should thank god the same demon that struck this family hasnt struck yours,as for your experance with a child molester for a father goes im very sad to hear things like that, but as far as him giving up his parental; wrights goes you should look upon that as a blessing as a molested child, you didnt have to ever be put in harms way again by him but one thing about this show so many people need to think about is the fact that mark is these girls father, trashing him on this topic board isnt going to help these girls heal in any way.
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
February 1, 2007, 5:15 pm PST

Healing is Different for different people

Quote From: lynnie59

Our family watched this show, and CANNOT understand the need to meet, talk, give the time of day to this person who murdered their mother!!  Forget it! He's not worth it and there's no good to come from this "reunion".... it's unhealthy, sick and cruel. I do think it is disrespectful to the mother to have any desire to meet the man who killed her in cold blood! no way.

 

I have personal experience with a father who molested me, gave up his parental rights in exchange for never having to pay the child support he owed my mother and any future child support....

 

Not every man is a father or a person who deserves to be given a second chance, this is definitely one of those situations.. there are other people this woman can get love and support from in her life. This guy is sick and why he was not executed for the murder he committed is another question, let alone he is now out and FREE???? and we call this justice for the victims??? I don't think so....

 

this show irritated me and my family, we thought Dr. Phil should've counseled this woman to move on, this man took her mother away and he has issues.

 

We think he missed the boat on this show for sure...

Healing is different for different people. This type of meeting is happening all over the world in victim and offender reconciliation groups. This is where victims confront thier offenders or other offenders not associated with their crime in order to get answers they need to find a space to work toward healing or some sort of closure. What you have gone through is horrible and you should never have had to go through it. What you may do will be different for you but this is a program that works for some. I think it holds him accountable in the most extreme way. I hope you find peace and I commend you for your bravery for being able to share your trauma.


Christine

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
upset
February 1, 2007, 5:44 pm PST

I disagree with you SO very much....

Quote From: lynnie59

Our family watched this show, and CANNOT understand the need to meet, talk, give the time of day to this person who murdered their mother!!  Forget it! He's not worth it and there's no good to come from this "reunion".... it's unhealthy, sick and cruel. I do think it is disrespectful to the mother to have any desire to meet the man who killed her in cold blood! no way.

 

I have personal experience with a father who molested me, gave up his parental rights in exchange for never having to pay the child support he owed my mother and any future child support....

 

Not every man is a father or a person who deserves to be given a second chance, this is definitely one of those situations.. there are other people this woman can get love and support from in her life. This guy is sick and why he was not executed for the murder he committed is another question, let alone he is now out and FREE???? and we call this justice for the victims??? I don't think so....

 

this show irritated me and my family, we thought Dr. Phil should've counseled this woman to move on, this man took her mother away and he has issues.

 

We think he missed the boat on this show for sure...

The reason you can not understand the NEED is because you have never had something  this horrible happen to you!!! That is a good thing, because I would not wish something like this on my worst enemy. Her father may not be worth it.... but who are you to tell her that?? This young lady needs some form of closer. She will not get that closer until she asks what she needs to from her father, and she can draw her own conclusions. She was very young when this took place she needs to have this off her shoulder, in order to go on with her life. I think she has every right to confront her father on this, and I commend Dr Phil for taking the time and effort to help these young ladies to move on with their lives!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page