You are not a failure. It's hard to not feel guilty about what has happened to our children. I know I carry around a trunk-sized baggage of guilt myself. I have reason to feel guilty, however....my husband decided 12 years into our marriage (when my son was 4yo) that he was going to become an intravenous drug addict. I spent 8 years trying to get him clean and sober...and for him to STAY that way. It took me that long to realize there wasn't a single thing that *I* was going to do that would count for anything at all towards his sobriety. By then the damage to the family had been done. I think it affected my son the most. My older two children (both girls ages 23 and 21, respectively) have had a few issues...one has OCD and the other suffered from bulimia. But nothing like this. Don't get me wrong...I don't BLAME the situation for my son's problems...but I'll carry to my grave the belief that it contributed...HEAVILY. You know how misery loves company...well, I know a lot of people that are dealing with issues with sons like you and I are. There's one common denominator......*weak*, *ineffective* fathers. I'm not saying ALL disturbed and troubled boys have bad or ineffective fathers...there are always exceptions to every rule...but I've seen it too many times to not notice the pattern. Even when other behaviors aren't present (as in my husband's drug abuse)...fathers who just aren't there for their boys...or are neglectful or ineffective....it's just a recipe for disaster. BOYS NEED GOOD FATHERS. Period.
My son's best friend has been in a juvenile detention center for 3 years now. He's only 16. I know the nightmare of those centers you've described. And the juvenile case workers don't appear to be working in the best interest of the child, imho. I'm sure there are some out there that do...I just haven't seen any in our own local juvenile office. And always...they want to point the finger to the parent and blame. Sure...I share some of the blame...but when my son first started acting out, where was the help? There wasn't any. There are no in-patient drug rehabilitation centers for adolescents in the state I live in. (Oklahoma) NOT ONE. There are plenty of behavioral centers that are located in hospitals, but there comes the insurance trouble. All my son ever got was two months...tops. Though he qualified to stay for AT LEAST a year....he got two months. I'm afraid there are going to be too many stories like ours unless/until something is done to facilitate a change in how we handle at-risk juveniles in this country. Of both sexes. Of all ages. Like you, I've written letters...made countless phone calls...to no avail. It's a national disgrace if you ask me. Housing these kids isn't doing a thing. It's not FIXING whatever is eating these kids alive.
I have a smaller son at home..a child I had at 42, the last of our children with my husband..who's now deceased. (I left him and had no contact for 3 years before he died, btw)This child's life has been the polar opposite of how my son grew up. I live with a man who's ten years younger than myself...no children of his own...and has taken my own children into his life and heart as though they were biologically his. He's stood beside MY SON every step of the way. Never judged him. Always just been there for him with an extended hand of friendship. My son NOW knows how valuable that relationship is, and they've forged a bond and a love between them. I know there are tons of people who would judge me for not marrying..but I am just not able to do it at this current point in time, though I AM committed to this man for the rest of my life. That's neither here nor there...but he IS the father to my almost 7yo. I look at the difference between the two kids. That's not to say that my 6yo won't grow up to give us trouble...but I don't think it's going to be of this magnitude, if any at all. Barring the minor "growing pains" all teenagers go through, of course. He has a father that's very active in his life...spends time with him...and my son knows that there are boundaries and consequences when those boundaries are pushed. No hitting...just swift consequences. I don't know if anyone knows what I'm talking about when I say that it's different when it (the consequences) comes from a man. Very, very different. My SO has shed as many tears and laid awake at night as often as I have over my 17yo.
My son has never had a clinical diagnosis of more than depression. I believe he suffers from PTSD myself...how could he not? 8 years of his life that he remembers before I left his father for good were practically a battlezone. But we weren't allowed to get to the root of all of that, the insurance said "enough".
My email addy is in my profile, if you want to contact me. I believe as you do...that parents who are dealing with troubled kids need all the support they can get. Too often there is just judgment...no support. I have no room in my life for anyone to judge me, since that isn't their place. There's someone else that's going to do that for them. No one could judge me as harshly as I've judged myself anyway. I'd welcome hearing from you!!!