Message Boards

Replies to '10/07 The Latest Debates'

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 5, 2005, 4:09 pm PDT

10/07 The Latest Debates

Quote From: missjane2

OK OK OK.  Let's BACK, BACK, BACK, BACK, BACK UP!  All right I don't even want to go there... BUT Let's retrack and clarify.  1st My first comment was that Mother's who breastfeed older children meaning close to Kindergarden might make an interesting discussion which it has.  AND YOU ALL HAVE ENLIGHTENED ME and I WOULD GO AS FAR AS TO SAY SHOCKED ME that you include BREASTFEEDING THE ELDERLY in your pursuit.  Now I don't have a problem at all with breastfeeding babies and I am ok with comforting toddlers.  I don't think it is sexual at all.  NOW I DO HAVE A PROBLEM WITH BREASTFEEDING THE ELDERLY and it is kind of Sexual.  And I still believe it belongs on the Jerry Springer show with the adults who wear diapers in public.  And if it is not sexual to breastfeed the elderly.  It is at least WEIRD.  At least in my opinion. 

I don't think people would really nurse an elderly person, though expressed breast milk would be ok. It offers a lot of health benefits. It could be fed in a tube if the person was on a feeding tube, it could be fed in a cup or incorporated into a tea when someone is sick. It tastes better than regular cow's milk and is easier to digest, so I can see where it might be of great benefit to an elderly person.  

As for nursing kindergarteners, I can't say that I want to do that personally out in public but I don't think it's wrong to do it. I don't have a problem with it but I imagine by the time my son is 3 or 4 he will have weaned already. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 5, 2005, 6:12 pm PDT

10/07 The Latest Debates

Quote From: missjane2

OK OK OK.  Let's BACK, BACK, BACK, BACK, BACK UP!  All right I don't even want to go there... BUT Let's retrack and clarify.  1st My first comment was that Mother's who breastfeed older children meaning close to Kindergarden might make an interesting discussion which it has.  AND YOU ALL HAVE ENLIGHTENED ME and I WOULD GO AS FAR AS TO SAY SHOCKED ME that you include BREASTFEEDING THE ELDERLY in your pursuit.  Now I don't have a problem at all with breastfeeding babies and I am ok with comforting toddlers.  I don't think it is sexual at all.  NOW I DO HAVE A PROBLEM WITH BREASTFEEDING THE ELDERLY and it is kind of Sexual.  And I still believe it belongs on the Jerry Springer show with the adults who wear diapers in public.  And if it is not sexual to breastfeed the elderly.  It is at least WEIRD.  At least in my opinion. 
If you go back and read what the OP was referring to, it was a long time ago and it helped heal the sick. She didn't say that they held their grandparents to the breast and had them suckle. Quite frankly though, if we lived back then, it might not have seemed odd. Society has done a good job (including people like yourself) to sexualize breastfeeding. I don't remember ANYONE saying we wanted to add bfing older people in our pursuit. I think you're trying to take one thing someone said out of complete context to make your statements seem justified. It's just not going to happen. And unless you've PERSONALLY breastfed a 5 year old, I don't think it's fair to comment on them being weird. In most cultures (not only human but animal cultures) you'd be the oddball.
 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page