Message Boards

Replies to '12/06 Desperate to Be a Mom'

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 6, 2007, 1:34 pm PST

12/06 Desperate to Be a Mom

Quote From: pocket523

I realize you think you are being helpful when you tell someone who is struggling with infertility that they should consider adoption; however, having struggled with infertility for 5 years, I can tell you from personal experience how insensative, inconsiderate and uneducated such a comment really is.  Until you experience the hell of struggling to concieve, you have absolutely no business dispensing solutions!  Adoption is a wonderful experience for some parents; however, it is NOT a "next best thing" to having your own biological child (and it NEVER should be!)  It is a completely different experience, one that should not be considered "the next best thing" when trying to become a parent.  I don't know whether to be outraged by the insensativity of this message or sad that this person is so clearly uncompassionate.  How dare you tell infertile couples to "just accept their life where they're at."  The pain of infertility is so deep and so personal, it is appalling to read such an insensative comment.  I'll admit, in the 5 years we struggled, I was faced with many comments like this.  Thank you Dr. Phil for bringing this subject into the spotlight.  It's so rare that anyone tries to tackle this issue, and it's very clear by this mindless, obtuse message, that it's a topic that needs to be discussed.  I hope you'll continue to do more features on infertility so those facing the unimaginable pain of infertility don't have to continue to be bruised by these simple-minded, hurtful remarks.

My Father was adopted so maybe you will understand that it angers me to here you say its not the next best thing. Had their been more people in the world that dont think that just because they were not the one who physically pushed him out that he wasnt worth taking care of  and loving, he  would along with his 3 sisters and brothers wouldnt hve sat in that God awful placeas long as they did.

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 6, 2007, 3:16 pm PST

12/06 Desperate to Be a Mom

Quote From: pocket523

I realize you think you are being helpful when you tell someone who is struggling with infertility that they should consider adoption; however, having struggled with infertility for 5 years, I can tell you from personal experience how insensative, inconsiderate and uneducated such a comment really is.  Until you experience the hell of struggling to concieve, you have absolutely no business dispensing solutions!  Adoption is a wonderful experience for some parents; however, it is NOT a "next best thing" to having your own biological child (and it NEVER should be!)  It is a completely different experience, one that should not be considered "the next best thing" when trying to become a parent.  I don't know whether to be outraged by the insensativity of this message or sad that this person is so clearly uncompassionate.  How dare you tell infertile couples to "just accept their life where they're at."  The pain of infertility is so deep and so personal, it is appalling to read such an insensative comment.  I'll admit, in the 5 years we struggled, I was faced with many comments like this.  Thank you Dr. Phil for bringing this subject into the spotlight.  It's so rare that anyone tries to tackle this issue, and it's very clear by this mindless, obtuse message, that it's a topic that needs to be discussed.  I hope you'll continue to do more features on infertility so those facing the unimaginable pain of infertility don't have to continue to be bruised by these simple-minded, hurtful remarks.
i so don't agree with you that it is insensative or inconsiderate to offer the option of adoption -- i struggled with infertility for 6 years before i concluded that it wasn't going to happen for me "naturally", - i admit that it was a hard end to come to, but i feel God had a different plan for me and my life --  and i did end up adopting a beautiful 2 year-old girl, and a year and a half later a baby boy -- i definitely think adoption can be an option for anyone, even infertile couples!!! -- please don't try to say they can't have a wonderful life in a different way!!   i would ask Dr Phil to show how incredible adoption can be to not only the adoptive parents life, but how it brings the ultimate joy into the childs life!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 7, 2007, 1:06 pm PST

12/06 Desperate to Be a Mom

Quote From: pocket523

I realize you think you are being helpful when you tell someone who is struggling with infertility that they should consider adoption; however, having struggled with infertility for 5 years, I can tell you from personal experience how insensative, inconsiderate and uneducated such a comment really is.  Until you experience the hell of struggling to concieve, you have absolutely no business dispensing solutions!  Adoption is a wonderful experience for some parents; however, it is NOT a "next best thing" to having your own biological child (and it NEVER should be!)  It is a completely different experience, one that should not be considered "the next best thing" when trying to become a parent.  I don't know whether to be outraged by the insensativity of this message or sad that this person is so clearly uncompassionate.  How dare you tell infertile couples to "just accept their life where they're at."  The pain of infertility is so deep and so personal, it is appalling to read such an insensative comment.  I'll admit, in the 5 years we struggled, I was faced with many comments like this.  Thank you Dr. Phil for bringing this subject into the spotlight.  It's so rare that anyone tries to tackle this issue, and it's very clear by this mindless, obtuse message, that it's a topic that needs to be discussed.  I hope you'll continue to do more features on infertility so those facing the unimaginable pain of infertility don't have to continue to be bruised by these simple-minded, hurtful remarks.
a comment from a very grateful adopted child:  no, its not comparable..its not the 'next best thing'. Your message is very insensitive towards adoption. I am appalled by your 'simple' remarks. Adoption is a selfless act. Every time I see or think about my parents I feel so joyful that they were generous enough to adopt me. If I made the suggestion of adoption it would be in the form of compliment as not every person is able to make such a huge commitment.
 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page