Message Boards

Replies to '07/07 Adult Sibling Rivalry'

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
July 7, 2008, 4:50 pm PDT

Enmeshed

Quote From: just_me_07

 I disagree with the premise that they have to grow up - I think it takes a strong adult to say "I don't like this person - family or not - and I CHOOSE not to have them in my life." If the hurt goes deep enough, and the damage is dangerous enough to be this harmful, it is an adult decision to make. Siblings who are told "she's your sister, how can you shut her out this way?" are being guilted into "family comes first" - and that's something I disagree with, as a tactic and a fact. Family isn't chosen - but we CAN choose how we deal with them and whom we choose to have in our lives.

I'm better off for not being enmeshed in my sister's web. I feel more like a grown-up than I ever did, BECAUSE I made an adult decision to cut the negative out of my life.

Unfortunately, I think you looked at this story as a personal one instead of objectively (according to your last paragraph).  It is not always the other person's "web", but the other person who makes the choice to eliminate family members.

 

People give up on family way too often, and if people give up on family, they probably have less ties with the general public and give up them even quicker.  Yes, family does come first, and always should.

 

And unfortunately, often therapists are the most damaging to family, but not getting two sides to events and building the client into believing they have options, which in fact are often not the most healty or best options, and can be permanent due to causing more pain.

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 7, 2008, 5:08 pm PDT

Adult Sibling Rivalry

Quote From: just_me_07

 I disagree with the premise that they have to grow up - I think it takes a strong adult to say "I don't like this person - family or not - and I CHOOSE not to have them in my life." If the hurt goes deep enough, and the damage is dangerous enough to be this harmful, it is an adult decision to make. Siblings who are told "she's your sister, how can you shut her out this way?" are being guilted into "family comes first" - and that's something I disagree with, as a tactic and a fact. Family isn't chosen - but we CAN choose how we deal with them and whom we choose to have in our lives.

I'm better off for not being enmeshed in my sister's web. I feel more like a grown-up than I ever did, BECAUSE I made an adult decision to cut the negative out of my life.

I have to truly agree with the above response, especially the following:

 

Family isn't chosen - but we CAN choose how we deal with them and whom we choose to have in our lives.

 

My Mom comes from a very large family, and would/is always have nice conversations with siblings on a regular basis. As a child, I had  envied that sort of relationship; being that I am an "only" and longed for a sibling.  However as I got older, I have seen some of the BS that occurs between siblings by listening to laments from my buddies (as well as from husband and watching shows like this one).  As the years passed  (46yo), I have gradually become glad that I am an "only child".

 

Although being an only child  *does*  have its advantages and disadvantages (a whole new topic altogether); it nevertheless  eliminates another element of complexity from my life. I know that I can be a "right-fighter" at times; and can easily envision myself in some nasty sort of row with a hypothetical sibling (LOL!).  Speaking *only*  for myself, I'm glad that the old adage, "be careful what you wish for" did not come to pass (LOL!)

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
July 7, 2008, 5:16 pm PDT

07/07 Adult Sibling Rivalry

Quote From: just_me_07

 I disagree with the premise that they have to grow up - I think it takes a strong adult to say "I don't like this person - family or not - and I CHOOSE not to have them in my life." If the hurt goes deep enough, and the damage is dangerous enough to be this harmful, it is an adult decision to make. Siblings who are told "she's your sister, how can you shut her out this way?" are being guilted into "family comes first" - and that's something I disagree with, as a tactic and a fact. Family isn't chosen - but we CAN choose how we deal with them and whom we choose to have in our lives.

I'm better off for not being enmeshed in my sister's web. I feel more like a grown-up than I ever did, BECAUSE I made an adult decision to cut the negative out of my life.
I did not see one single thing that warranted the behavior of any of these sisters!! There wasn't any "dangerous damage"; and the so-called "hurt" was superficial nonsense that was allowed to get out of control.......so, in these cases, they do need to GROW UP!!! All of the crap they were fighting over was juvenile tantrum-throwing garbage perpetuated by these girls who evidently have nothing better to do with their time! 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 7, 2008, 8:29 pm PDT

About Adult Behavior and Siblings

Quote From: just_me_07

 I disagree with the premise that they have to grow up - I think it takes a strong adult to say "I don't like this person - family or not - and I CHOOSE not to have them in my life." If the hurt goes deep enough, and the damage is dangerous enough to be this harmful, it is an adult decision to make. Siblings who are told "she's your sister, how can you shut her out this way?" are being guilted into "family comes first" - and that's something I disagree with, as a tactic and a fact. Family isn't chosen - but we CAN choose how we deal with them and whom we choose to have in our lives.

I'm better off for not being enmeshed in my sister's web. I feel more like a grown-up than I ever did, BECAUSE I made an adult decision to cut the negative out of my life.
 Well, I think it's worth it to try to mend family rifts -- up to a point. But if it doesn't work out or your siblings won't cooperate in this, then I agree that one needs to cut one's losses and move on iwth one's own life. Siblings don't have to be "best buddies"just b/c they happen to be born to the same parents, etc.
 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page