Message Boards

Topic : 06/12 On the Outs With In-Laws

Number of Replies: 603
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, February 24, 2006, 11:23:38 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 02/28/06) Manipulative, violent and diabolical. These are just some of the words Anna-Laura uses to describe her mother-in-law, Janice, who she says is destroying her marriage. Anna-Laura says Janice hates her so much, she’s taken a swing at her and even threatened to hire someone to kill her. Janice denies the accusations and says they’re all lies. Where does Morgan, Anna-Laura’s husband, stand on the issue? After not speaking for almost a year, Anna-Laura and Morgan face off with Janice in front of Dr. Phil. With their relationship on the rocks, can Anna-Laura and Morgan find a way to end this war with his mother and save their marriage? If your extended family is spiraling out of control, find out how to get your relationship to take a turn in the other direction. Join the discussion.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
ecstatic
June 12, 2006, 7:30 am PDT

well i think i now know what i would do!!!!!!!!

get on out of thear!!!!!! i would pack my family up and move across country,period., and not ever move back, morgan may have waited too late time will tell, but it seems nether his wife or mother ever welcomed each other with open arms!!!!  just with boxing gloves on!!!!    lol     ,very pitifull, and with grandma makin problems with morgans wife and family and children services well i just know ots a terrible thing for any person to put a child have to go through, i dont give a damn what grandma morgin or his wife think or do!!!!!!!!! thear all a bunch of noobs fighting over a bunch of bull crap in the first place ( and dr phil you just said the same thing im typing at this very moment, thank you, ) morgan needs to grow himself some cuhunness!!!!!  think about what all of this is doing to thear poor child, why in the hell do people always have to make the children suffer beacouse the adults dont know how to act as adults are suppose to act!!!!!  this makes my blood boil!!!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
ecstatic
June 12, 2006, 7:38 am PDT

poor dr phil for all the money in the world i would not walk 10 feet in your shoes

poor guy my heart goes out to you truley,
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
June 12, 2006, 7:47 am PDT

give grandmother visitation

just move 3000 miles away let her vist any time she is willing to come and visit!!!!!!! it wont be very often i bet
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
June 12, 2006, 8:30 am PDT

thank you thank you thank you dr phil

as it seems to apear, your the only one on the show that relly cares about the children in this type of situation, you truley are one of gods guardian angeles for the children, with out you god only knows what would become fo them,( you relly need to take a do wright stick to the grandmother morgan and his wife!!!!!!!  if any of them relly thought  about what all of thear fighting among thear selves as they have been doing was doing to those children well all i can say is thear all adults and as adults with children we always need to think about what our actions as adults will have on our children before we act not as were acting or after we acted, the children do not under stand in the first place all they know is mommy and daddy and grandma are fighting, it relly breacks a childs heart to have to live a life in such a enviorement, and foster care my god people thats your children!!!!!! a preasious gift to you from god, do you dare give them to people they dont even know!!!!!!!!!!! not a very nice way to tell god thank you for this special gift!!!!!!! im sure he isnt smileing about all of this!!!!!!!!!! but i see all involved have made 1 wright desision sofar!!!!!  they came to you dr phil for help and as i have seen and heard you tell every one your first concern and most piroity is the childrens well being and health mental and phisical, god bless you dr phil for giving the children a chance, apparently you were the only person on the stage that even cared honestly about the childrens feelings, and as for the grandmother- mother in law--- morgan---- and his wife learn to put your feelings and needs last put the children first !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  damit grow up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! you are all acting in a very low way,   if any of you guys lived in my neaibor hood hell i would move 3000 miles away in hopes you wouldnt end up in my neaibor hood again!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and thats the gods honest truth)  ill swear that on a holy bible!!!!!!!!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 12, 2006, 11:32 am PDT

I totally agree

Quote From: laram_34

  

I was truly amazed at the immaturity demonstrated by the two women on today’s show. I was saddened to see both women were blinded to the reason as why they were on the show, which was to try to create some sort of ‘peace; and all I saw were lies and accusations flying back and forth. I don’t believe Anna-Laura really wants to save her marriage; it seems she is using her marriage as a pawn to fight her mother-in-law, and prove she is ‘right’. Interesting body language demonstrated by her arm around her husband, she reminded me of a dog with a bone. If you really love him so much, why again are you divorcing him?  And to the mother-in-law, stop telling lies, if you really care about your grandchildren, in the end it really doesn’t matter who is right or wrong does (I’m sure your grandchildren don’t or won't remember in the future unless you continue your behaviour). Both women need to step back, refocus to what are the important issues; family and being good role models for their children. Both are being poor role models for their children… it is time for them both to wise up and grow up. 

 

Kudos to Dr. Phil to be able to sit and look so calm the whole show, I think I would have run off screaming in frustration... 

My son has always come to us when he and his wife are having serious marritial issues. Seems in order to get what she wants, she threatens divorce. Even while planning her their wedding she was threatening to leave him. While I DO like her as a person I do not agree with a lot her ways. But I don't have to, my son is the one that has to live with her.    

On mothers day this year my son called to tell me he was pampering his wife and that was really all there was to the conversation.  It hurt me and I told him so. He went on the defensive and the next thing I know we are fighting about his wife. She found some of the emails, called me up screaming at me. She has decided the best to handle the issue is to be mad, forever I guess. I think we could work through it.  

Anyway, now i have lost my son.  

From my vantage point, I think there is a lot more going on than meets the eye. I agree that both women are blinded.  I have personally experience how quickly one loss control of a disagreement and how easily words can be misunderstand or manipulated. 

 

Message Emote
blank
June 12, 2006, 12:24 pm PDT

06/12 On the Outs With In-Laws

Quote From: dreammom4

I need some advice, my situation is similar to some of the other people, but my MIL did not raise my husband his whole childhood. Her husband was VERY abusive to my husband, his brother, and only one sister. His brother has absolutely nothing to do with anyone in the family because of this, to watch his sister is sad because its like she is begging for love from her mother and just to be acknowledged, my MIL ignores her, and constantly talks about how perfect the "other" sister is. My husband didn't have hardly any relationship with his mother at all when we got married. She was very nice to me and we got along great when we were together. My husband shared all the horrible terrifying stories about his childhood, it is so bad I won't go into it. The abuse came from his step-father, but MIL knew and didn't do anything to stop it. After we were married about 4 years MIL and husband were divorced. That's when she decided to be the mother she should of been. I had reservations. We have 4 children and my husband has always said she is never to be alone with them no matter what, so that's how its been. She has never babysat, and my kids don't even like her I think they sense things, and she never shows them any attention, she only shows attention to the other sisters 3 kids. She shows favoritism towards her and her kids. My other SIL has a beautiful baby girl who has SP. She needs so much more attention then the rest of the grandchildren, but my MIL will walk right past her and not say a word to her. Its really sad. Then my MIL started treating me horrible, rude nasty and just plain mean.  She would decide to have a dinner and tell me it was gonna be at my house, so I would have it then not one of them would help clean up, my house would be a disaster. I told my husband no more I had EVERY holiday for the first 5 years of our marriage, then she really started to hate me. My husband won't stand up to her or defend me, we went to a counselor and she said that wasn't right for her to do that. Its sickening to watch her around him now. She treats him like he is 5 years old. We have now been married 8 years. It has gotten so bad that my husband and I split up a while back, she then told him she didn't like me. She told him that I thought she was too fat and ugly to be around, and I wanted her to be my mother and she just can't do that. She said a bunch of other horrible things about me. My husband never defended me one time. I asked him if he thought those things were true and he said no, but nothing to her. Now we are back together and trying to work things out. She has not come to our house or called here  nothing. But my husband has a business and she goes there and calls him at least once a week. He never talks about her or this problem, its just pushed under a rug for right now but I know its gonna come back and I don't know what to do. She hasn't seen my kids in 4 months and hasn't even asked about them. Sometimes I feel like my husband is living two lives, one with her and one with us. Am I wrong to feel this way? There are so many more things to say but it would take all day. Thank you for listening and letting me get it off my chest. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

A wonderful book I happened across at my local library helped me & my husband immensely with our in-law problems. "Toxic Parents" by Dr. Susan Forward. It confirmed, for me, so much of what I felt about my in-laws & their toxic behavior not only with my husband, me & our children but also what I witnessed with my brother-in-law's family and my sister-in-law and her family.

  

 

 

  

 

We have chosen to no longer be in contact with FIL & MIL, as BIL & his family has also chosen. BIL & MIL had what seems to be a similar relationship as your husband & MIL. She raised all of her children (for the most part) though.

  

 

 

  

 

I hope the book is a help to you. As kooky as it may sound, I think I was meant to find it. I happened across it purely by accident. It was in an area where books are given away for free & it couldn't have come at a better time. It gave us the tools to try again with the in-laws on sure footing & helped us deal with what all came afterwards.

  

 

 

  

 

I wish you all the best.

  

 

H 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 12, 2006, 12:34 pm PDT

MIL from hell is High functioning autistic

 This woman is high functioning autistic. I don't believe even Dr. Phil knows what he's dealing with. Hats off to the wife.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 12, 2006, 12:41 pm PDT

06/12 On the Outs With In-Laws

I think both of these women are wrong.  How can they say such nasty things about each other?  Morgan should [i]never[/i] be taking his marital problems to his mother.  When he and Anna-Laura have problems they should talk it out together.  On the other hand Janice should allow Morgan time, including Mother's Day, to spend with the woman who raised him. 

  

What selfish people they all are. Neither woman will be the bigger person and stop the accusations. None of the three adults will put the children first.  

  

 I'm so sick of the over-use of restraining orders.  In this town all the trashy women brag about the restraining orders they have on their boyfirends the same way trashy women used to brag about how their boyfriends got in fights over them.  Restraining orders should be reserved for serious cases, not used to make points in petty quarrels. Ugh.  As soon as Janice started mentioning the restraining order she had on Janice and going back and forth between, "I ain't going nowhere" and "I'm divorcing him" it was clear she was just out for the drama.  

  

 I was sorry to hear the audience applaud when Anna-Laura interrupted Morgan at the very moment he was standing up to his mother.  Morgan is just  bouncing from one hateful, controlling drama queen to another. 

  

  

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
June 12, 2006, 12:51 pm PDT

Whoa!

Quote From: txkatie54

I think you are wrong, my daughter-in-law has moved through our family like a mac truck, mowing down everyone who gets in her way, but to hurt her as much or more than she has hurt us would only be bringing the rest of us down to her level. It started before my sons wedding when my daughter could not afford a hundred dollar tux for my four year old grandson to wear as ring bearer, she was told by my daughter_in_law that he would be replaced. My grandson thought his uncle hung the moon and was really excited to be in the wedding and would have been crushed, so my daughter managed to borrow the money and get the tux. At the reception, my daughter_in_law got angry at the groomsmen and made them all leave the reception. My son no longer speaks to his former friends.After returning from their honeymoon, they were living with my daughter. One evening while having drinks with my son and his new wife and five other friends, my daughter-in-law said that she hated my four year old grandson so much that she wished someone would smack him so hard that he would fly up against the wall and die. I did not tell my daughter what she said, but my sister did and my daughter made them move out. My son asked me to lie to my daughter and say his wife didn't say it. That ended the relationship between my son and daughter and between my son and his nephew. I could go on and on about how she has hurt us, as I write this "they" have decided that I am dead to them and want no contact with me.  I really have no idea what I did this time.  All I do know for certain is that to say nothing is the better way. To tell either of them that I don't want them in my life anymore would just bring me down to their level and trying to hurt or manipulate her like she has done our family would just give her more power. Anyway my choice was to just walk away and not say anything anymore. My son is my son and I love him very much and this situation hurts me to the core, but what else can I do? He is sticking by his wife, as he should and I am after all just his mother. Any contact I would try to make with either one of them she would consider harassment. So I keep silent. I have not seen or heard from either of them since October 2005 and don't expect I ever will again.   

Hang in there TxKatie.  Any woman who would say something that evil about a four year old child is bad to the bone.  The marriage won't last and your son will return.  Let's just hope he gets custody of any children involved.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
June 12, 2006, 1:09 pm PDT

i think the wife IS nuts

 dr phil...im sitting here 45 minutes into the show and im very upset about this situation...his mother isnt destryoying the marriage the wife is...they are out of their minds...i feel that the mother has done maybe 5% of the stuff that was said  but laurily? claims that all these things are going on and her husband is being told that  it happened  and i dont think that it has...she is steamrolling him... and its sad...she has filed for divorce until he stops talking to his mother...but doesnt kick him out of the house...she is NOT normal at all...the children are in foster care...grandma is trying to get visitation and dr phil your asking  her to stop litigation??   NOOOOOOOOOO!1! she wants to see her grandchildren and has every right to see them...laurily? is making her children  upset and sad all the time...she is a brute and she uses that against her children...grandma didnt get a fair shot at anything in this show and i am very disturbed by that...laurily took over the entire show!  the one who was played in this show was you...she played YOU like a marionette GO GRANDMA!   LAURILY YOU ARE A PSYCHOPATH AND A BRUTE!!!  AND THE SON IS WHIPPED AND YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN...HE COULDNT EVEN LOOK IN HIS MOMS EYES...HE ONLY LOOKED UP AT HER WHEN HE WAS SAYING ABOUT THE CAR ACCIDENT THAT SHE PASSED BY...ITS HER SON SHE WANTS TO SEE IF HE IS OK???POSSIBLE??I THINK HE WANTED HER TO KNOW THAT HE LOVES HER AND APPRECIATES THAT SHE PASSED BY...OTHER THAN THAT HE KEPT HIS HEAD HUNG AND THATS RIGHT  SHAME ON YOU!!!1 THATS YOUR MOTHER!!!...ID PASS TOO,  MY SON IS MY SON....PERIOD!! I WOULD WANT TO SEE HIM NO MATTER WHAT..HE NEEDS COUNSELING IN THE WORST WAY TO SEE THAT HIS WIFE IS MANIPULATIVE BITCH....PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE..HAVE HER ALONE ON THE SHOW WITH HER SON NO WIFE...SHE IS A MANIACLE MANIPULATIVE PSYCHO!!      IM ALL OVER YOU LIKE A BAD RASH DR PHIL....I HATED THIS SHOW AND IVE SEEN SOME REAL BAD SHOWS!        WELL I HOPE THAT YOU SEE THIS!   
 
First | Prev | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | 53 | 54 | 55 | 56 | Next | Last