Topic : An Open Consideration of Reality and Religious Beliefs

Number of Replies: 1046
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, March 03, 2006, 09:33:47 am
Author : trtlelove

For the record, this topic has been posted to accomodate many threads that tend to end up discussing religion and our beliefs about God, etc.   We would like to maintain an open and peaceful tone for all to participate and simply share their points of view and experience, exchanging ideas, asking and answering each other's questions, etc.

 

From my own personal experience, I have been writing mostly on the original "Twisted Love" thread so if anyone wants to get more background they can look me (or anyone else) up there by using  "Search Boards" above (next to "Boards Archive" and "Profile", etc.) and type in any of our user names in the "blank box".  This will bring up everything we have posted and the responses we have given to each other's posts.

 

Peace and Love All-Ways,

 

Turtle Love (user name "trtlelove")



User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
March 10, 2006, 4:56 am PST

An Open Consideration of Reality and Religious Beliefs

Quote From: judyblue22

I don't believe that nor do I think most catholics believe that the pope has the power to change the principles and demands of Christ.  Where did you get that idea?

I agree with Judy on this one. 

  

Peace, 

  

Fredi 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 10, 2006, 9:18 am PST

Answers Forthcoming

Blksheepy and JoeyJohn, 

  

I am swamped with work, school and home - life right now, but I will be answering your questions about Adi Da in full as soon as I get a break. 

  

Peace, 

  

Turtle Love 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
March 10, 2006, 10:20 am PST

To turtlelove

Quote From: trtlelove

Blksheepy and JoeyJohn, 

  

I am swamped with work, school and home - life right now, but I will be answering your questions about Adi Da in full as soon as I get a break. 

  

Peace, 

  

Turtle Love 

I wondered where you had got to.   
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
March 10, 2006, 10:38 am PST

Do the means justify the end?

Quote From: judyblue22

The reason I have prayed for guidance is that very thought-that so many people agree that it is wrong :). Not only do people tell me it is a sin, you can see on these very boards that some people can get very angry about the very idea that we lived like that-even when it is something that is no longer part of my life and long past.   

  

I see a similar reaction to homosexuality (very topical in Canada this past few years because we allow gay marriage) and I have prayed about both. I believe the guidance I have received is from God. The things that I have done in love without deceit are lawful but that I have to be careful not to place myself in the way of temptation to act out of lust.  I felt clearly told that if I am not homosexual it isn't my business to pray for guidance about it. That last bit was pretty sharp and clear. I felt an absolute prohibition. 

  

Now, I am the first to admit that I am not perfect and I have responded just to lust a time or two but I recognise that I sinned I repented.  The other things I have done were not sinful but they were risky.  I think my current life is fairly free of risk but I still have that pesky pride thing going on :) I always need something to humble me. 

I guess what you are saying is that first of all you don't believe sex outside of marriage is a sin, but you're not 100% sure (neither am I by the way).    If it is/was a sin, then the fact that it was done for a good reason (you could marry someone who was not matched sexually)  then it is/was acceptable?  Acceptable because the result has been a long, happy marriage.   

  

Please know that when I say the word  "acceptable", I am thinking acceptable to god,  not acceptable to people.    I am certainly not in a position to judge anyone and I get that the people on this board feel the same way. 

  

Here's an example that just leapt to my mind.   If a person has hungry children, and is in a position where they can't feed them.   Would it be a sin to go out and steal the food because the end result would be fed children?   Nobody wants to see hungry children, OR unhappy marriages.   I would personally steal the food, but ask for forgiveness.      Do the means justify the end?   

 

Message Emote
blank
March 10, 2006, 11:08 am PST

An Open Consideration of Reality and Religious Beliefs

Quote From: blcksheepy

I have an acquaintance who is "Seventh Day Adventist", and this sabbath thing seems to be a very big issue to her.   She says the rest of the christian church is going to church on the "wrong" day.    From what I have been taught by this board, god is about love and forgiveness, not timetables and nitpicking.     If people who have accepted Jesus as their saviour are going to hell for going to church mistakenly on the "wrong" day, then the horrible death of Jesus was pretty much wasted don't you think?    I am just now beginning to realize what they did to him.    They tortured and murdered him.    

I actually think it is sinful for people to use the concept of sin to justify a difference of opinion-even a difference of opinion of a theological issue  It is misleading and trivializes the whole concept of sin.  A true understanding of sin is an important part of having a relationship with God. 

  

My own view is that God wants us to have one day a week where everyone rests where families can all be together. I doubt if he is hanging on whether it is Saturday or Sunday. 

 

Message Emote
blank
March 10, 2006, 11:16 am PST

An Open Consideration of Reality and Religious Beliefs

Quote From: blcksheepy

I guess what you are saying is that first of all you don't believe sex outside of marriage is a sin, but you're not 100% sure (neither am I by the way).    If it is/was a sin, then the fact that it was done for a good reason (you could marry someone who was not matched sexually)  then it is/was acceptable?  Acceptable because the result has been a long, happy marriage.   

  

Please know that when I say the word  "acceptable", I am thinking acceptable to god,  not acceptable to people.    I am certainly not in a position to judge anyone and I get that the people on this board feel the same way. 

  

Here's an example that just leapt to my mind.   If a person has hungry children, and is in a position where they can't feed them.   Would it be a sin to go out and steal the food because the end result would be fed children?   Nobody wants to see hungry children, OR unhappy marriages.   I would personally steal the food, but ask for forgiveness.      Do the means justify the end?   

I would personally beg for the food and trust God to soften up the hearts of those I approached.  

  

I do understand what you meant but deciding that the ends justify the means is a bit slippery, no? And you were also failing to have faith in God and that was a problem for Abraham even when Abraham only gave up waiting for his promised baby when Sarah was 80!! 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
March 10, 2006, 11:36 am PST

Have faith in god?

Quote From: judyblue22

I would personally beg for the food and trust God to soften up the hearts of those I approached.  

  

I do understand what you meant but deciding that the ends justify the means is a bit slippery, no? And you were also failing to have faith in God and that was a problem for Abraham even when Abraham only gave up waiting for his promised baby when Sarah was 80!! 

I am a new christian so I guess I have to learn that "have faith in god" concept.  

  

Do you feel the ends justified the means in your case? 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
March 10, 2006, 11:39 am PST

Was it love or lust.

Quote From: judyblue22

I agree with you that if what my husband and I did was done out of lust then it was sinful.  I guess only we know what is in our hearts -if it was love or lust .  That is where the issue has to rest because you really can't see into my heart and I can only respond to accusations like yours with anger.  Kinda pointless, no?
I guess I am coming in at the end of the conversation, but may I ask if it was love or lust?   A lot seems to be riding on that difference.    The reason I ask is that you explained you were finding sexual satisfaction that your husband couldn't supply.
 

Message Emote
blank
March 10, 2006, 11:46 am PST

An Open Consideration of Reality and Religious Beliefs

Quote From: blcksheepy

I am a new christian so I guess I have to learn that "have faith in god" concept.  

  

Do you feel the ends justified the means in your case? 

It is hard to grasp that concept but the failure to trust in God is a sin.  It is called the sin of dispair (again a catholic concept).   It is probably the hardest thing to do when your life is painful or difficult, but resting your trouble on your faith in God can really be a relief...and I honestly have never had Him fail me.  He has helped me in ways I might not have anticipated but I've never been abandoned. 

 

Message Emote
blank
March 10, 2006, 12:00 pm PST

An Open Consideration of Reality and Religious Beliefs

Quote From: blcksheepy

I guess I am coming in at the end of the conversation, but may I ask if it was love or lust?   A lot seems to be riding on that difference.    The reason I ask is that you explained you were finding sexual satisfaction that your husband couldn't supply.

Let's clear something up. My husband is GREAT in bed.  No question about that-he is generous and giving and skillful.  He gives massages and pampers me too and I am pretty great, too even if I do say it myself.  We didn't need other partners because we were failing to get each other off. 

  

I can't really explain about our other needs without getting too personal and I'm sure it would just sound weird to people who don't have those needs.  It wasn't lust that caused us to need to include others and we were not just playing around with other people's bodies.  There was love and commitment in those relationships that still last to today.  We were bound together in a more mental way than you are thinking. 

  

However, having explored relationships of dominance with others and having been able to come to a better understanding of our own dominant charactoristics, we have been able to engage with each other in that way now.  It certainly isn't the same, but it is satisfying and it is even more satisfying to be able give that to each other. 

 

First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | Next | Last