Message Boards

Topic : 07/17 Mommy Dearest

Number of Replies: 327
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, March 31, 2006, 12:44:40 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 04/03/06) Marri and Jessica both want to confront their mothers, who they say were neglectful and abusive during their childhoods. Marri has put up with her mother, Marilyn's, addiction to crack cocaine for 18 years, and she's ready to shut her mom out of her life for good if she doesn't admit she has a problem and seek help for it. Marilyn says her drug use is the solution, not the problem, and she can be a good mother and still smoke crack. Then, Jessica says she had to care for herself when she was a little girl. Her mother, Deana, was never around, and when she was, she was bringing strange men home for sex. In a ploy for attention, Deana committed her daughter to a mental institution -- three times! Tired of holding in her anger, Jessica demands her mother take responsibility for what she's done. Will these daughters get some emotional closure on their painful childhoods? Share your thoughts here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More July 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
April 3, 2006, 5:12 pm PDT

Difficult to move forward, but possible

I remember all too well my days as a child.  My mother was a pill addict in the 60's.  The valium housewife.  Valium, demerol, morphine etc...  My mom was a hypochondriac,she had 12 abdominal surgeries, and more drugs.  She hit, screamed, cursed, lied, and was very selfish.  It was always about MOM.  She called me a "worthless bitch" most of my childhood.  We had the ambulance at our house maybe 3-4 times yearly for drug overdoses.  Life was miserable.  My grandfather molested me from age 9-11, and my mother was not available to save me.  At age seventeen I left home.  What I learned from my childhood was, adults were mean and hated children, or more personally, me.  Something was obviously wrong with ME.  I learned that if you take pills you feel better and if you take too many you get alot of attention.  So at age 10  I started taking my mom's pills, at age 11 I had my first suicide attempt.  By age 12 I was drinking and taking pills.  By fifteen I was a heroin addict.  My life was awful.  No one to talk to, no one to support me, I felt so alone.  My parents thought I was using heroin for attention, that I wasn't an addict.  Anyway, years of bad blood between me and mom.  Talking to her as an adult made me crazy.  She never had anything good to say.  A very negative spirit.   She never told me who my real father was, said he was killed in an accident when she was pregnant with me.  I finally got a name out of her last year and had someone look for his name, birth, death, anything.  NO such person. 

      Well she's seventy four, and I'm 53.  The war is over.  I started drinking heavily in my  mid 40's and ended up in treatment.  In treatment they asked me why can't I accept that this is the way my mother is.  Why do I keep expecting her to be different, expecting her to be concerned, if after 40 years of dissapointment.  I wanted my mom to love me.  Now we are mending our relationship.  We know we can't go back, but we are trying to salvage what time we have left.  She comes to my home in Montana for 10 days at a time.  We are going on our third year, and believe it or not we actually had a good time together this last visit.  It's a miracle.  We can gab on the phone, I can finally say I love you, sometimes she'll say "love you too", not very often but it's starting.  It started when I quit expecting something that she was not able to give.  I thought it was too late, but it wasn't.  The important part is to move forward.  Just because they admit guilt and apoligize, trust me the wounds were still there.  Put on a different pair of glasses and you may find something you didn't see before.  Good Luck  (start with boundaries, boundaries, boundaries) 

   

Janet 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
angry
April 3, 2006, 5:24 pm PDT

Heart broken

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 3, 2006, 5:37 pm PDT

my mean mother

Quote From: momissue28

 I can't believe there are so many people living the same life I lived and am still living.  My biggest problem at this point with my mother and I are the same thing I was getting with Jessica and her mom.  Deanna it is your fault!!!!!!!!  When are you going to get it that your the mother not the daughter in the relationship.  Stop being so winy like a crying baby.  Stand up for your daughter!!!!  If you love her really love her you will do anything she asks without question and withoput needing anything back.  I am so glad that Dr. Phil recognized Deana's buts and preaching attitude.  This is exactly how my mom is when all the issues are brought to her attention.  My mother minimizes it or lies as well and acts as if it never happened.  At this point I have no relationship with my mom because of her self rightous attitude, but at the same time I wait ,wait for the REAL apology.  Deanna wasn't giving the real apology either I just don't think she gets it.  Jessica if you read this please don't feel guilty, because I know you do.  It isn't your fault and it's up to your mom to fix herself and not you.

     I started therapy a couple of months ago because I was still so traumatized by the abuse my mother did to me as a child. I am in my early 30's and have confronted my mother several times since I was a teen; she either denied the abuse ever happened or claimed she couldn't help it because she was so depressed and felt trapped in her life as a mother and wife.  A few years ago I confronted her again; again she denied the abuse, but this time she wrote me a letter after our fight and mailed it to me.  Her letter did not contain an apology or acknowledgement of her behavior but I read it and kept it as evidence of her state of mind and her attitude towards me.  

      When I started therapy and started talking about my mothers denial I remembered my mothers letter.  My next session I took that letter in for my therapist to read.  In combination with what I have told him about her abusive behaviors and his sense of her state of mind from that letter my therapist thinks she may have Borderline Personality Disorder.  This is not a diagnosis of her but it is a point of reference for me as I find out more and more about this disorder.  BPD makes mothers do some of the most horrible things to their children as the mother reenacts the abuse she suffered from when she was a child.   

     I do not believe this is an excuse for what she has done to me but it does help me to connect the different aspects of her abusive behavior and understand it better so that I can heal myself.  I have just finished reading a book titled "Understanding The Borderline Mother".  Even if my mother does not have BPD this book has helped me understand how her abuse has effected me and I would reccomend reading it as a way to understand the true effects of the abuse by your mother and begin to heal yourself.  Do not wait on an apology to begin the process of forgiveness and healing; you may be waiting forever.   

     Good luck to all of us that have been through the trauma of feeling our mothers rage. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 3, 2006, 5:42 pm PDT

move out and on...

Quote From: rhineland

You are describing the life I had as a child. We would have been much better off if my mother had removed us from the situation. You have to get you and your children away from the situation to save yourselves. You need to go to Al-Anon and other groups to understand what this is doing to you and how you can recover. Alcoholics like your significant other are like a poison that will eat and destroy the family and the sooner you leave the better chance your children will have to be "normal". Love does not mean that you should stay. The fact that this is a disease does not mean that you should stay or have to put up with the environment. You can love your significant other and help him without exposing yourself and your children to the abuse.  

  

The sad thing is realizing that there is nothing you can do to save him -- he can only decide to save himself. And the ironic thing is leaving or kicking him out may be the only thing that can get him to save himself.  In my father's case, it didn't matter that my mother stayed with him and some of the children still put up with his awful behavior. Drinking still killed him.   

I was, also, married to an alchoholic - an abusive one at that.  My breaking point was when my daughter started seeing and hearing the abuse.  That in itself, is abuse for the child.  I made the decision that I did not want my daughter growing up thinking that the behavior was normal - that fighting is what it is about between a husband and wife.  I wanted better for my child.  I moved out, divorced and never looked back.  It was very difficult surviving on my income but, the peace of mind was worth all the sacrifices we had to make.  Even though we left when my daughter was only 5, she has not forgotten and at 29, still has yet to marry. 

  

Get your children out of that life style and into a stable, optimistic household.  It may even be just what he needs to get help. 

 
User Mood
Touched

Message Emote
hopeful
April 3, 2006, 5:49 pm PDT

i was a mommy dearest

it was painful for me to watch today's show as I was reminded of what I put my own daughter through. I've been in recovery from drugs/alcohol for over 2 years now and am trying to make ammends for the damage I've done. It took losing custody of my daughter to DCFS to finally wake me up. It is abuse and neglect when a parent is under the influence, period. You just may not realize it at the time.  I was disgusted with Marri's mom, but I also realize that she is sick and I hope and pray that she gets into treatment before it is too late. I could also relate to Jessica's story since my daughter was admitted to a psychiatric hospital on more than one occassion due to her being sexually abused (at her father's home) and due to behavioral problems. It was not for my benefit for her to be hospitalized although I can plainly see now that if I had been clean and sober at the time, there may have been other options. 

Recovery is hard work and trying to repair the damage done can be overwhelming, but it is worth it. 

I had a horrible childhood myself, but you can only play the victim for so long and then it's time to hold yourself accountable.  My thoughts and prayers are with both families. 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
April 3, 2006, 5:59 pm PDT

Alanon

I would suggest Marri find an Alanon group or other groups who support the friends & families of addicts.   It has been very helpful to me in my life.   I'm surprised Dr. Phil didn't suggest this.
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
April 3, 2006, 6:01 pm PDT

Struggling to make peace with my mother

Dr. Phil, thank you for having this show.  I have been waiting for a show like this to come up and I hope that my mom watches it.

   

 

  

I grew up with my mom, dad and my little sister. My dad worked away from home, and only came home on the weekends - I think he liked it that way because he wanted to get away from my mother and us kids. He probably knew how my mother was but chose to ignore it instead of protect us. Which I think is selfish.

  

 

  

 My mother had an abusive alcoholic father who I never knew but heard terrible stories about - like him hanging my uncle in the garage when he was 12 and how my grandma found him and saved him - but she stayed with him nevertheless and I resent her for it. Now because of this cycle of abuse all of my cousins including my sister and I had to endure a lifetime of passed on abuse - in which I intend to break.  I know that because my mother was abused by her father, that is one of the reasons why she abused my sister and me. She was emotionally and physically abusive my whole life - from threatening to drive us off a bridge and kill us, to pointing knives in our backs when we wouldn't finish our supper, choking us, chasing us around the house, hitting, slapping, kicking, punching, dragging us to our rooms by our hair, calling us names and you name it she did it, including threatening to commit suicide right in front of us when we were very young just because we were being bad. (Again, my father was never around. And she acted slightly different when he was and more out of control when he wasn't - so I don't think he ever really knew what she was like. Plus she is a master manipulator and would have convinced him of whatever she wanted anyways.) For a long time, I felt like this 'life' was normal, until I became old enough and realized that it wasn't. I am emotionally and socially scarred because of this. I don't know how I am ever going to be normal. And I sure as hell don't know how I am ever going to make peace with my mother. Anytime, I have tried to make peace or get some kind of closure all we do is argue and she blames me for everything. She either hangs up the phone or she tells me that I have mental problems and that I need to grow up, she makes me feel like everything is my fault and that she never did anything wrong. My dad is the same way. He says that we were bad kids and that anybody would have done the same thing. It feels like they don't care and are at peace with their lonely miserable lives. My mother manipulated my dad into thinking his family were awful people when they got married (and I know that they are very good people, thank god I got to know them on my own even though my sister didn't, so I know different). Therefore my dad did whatever she said, and that included isolating themselves and cutting themselves off from his family and everyone at that, because my mother always thought that everyone was out to get her, so my parents don't have friends and never have. Because of all of this, my sister and I never got to know our family and were very socially awkward and inept all throughout school and now as adults. It seems my sister has moved on with her life maybe that is because she is more passive than me, or she didn't get the abuse as bad as me or maybe that is because she chooses to ignore what happened I don't know. But I know this - I see my mother in me and I don't want to be that kind of person or mother to my own kids when I have kids. I told my husband that if we have kids and you start seeing these things I want you to put me away because I never want to have another person go through what I did. 

 

 

Dear Dr. Phil, it has been a long and tough journey and I feel like I have learned alot. I also feel like I have made alot of mistakes. Sometimes I wonder if I am on the right track. And I wonder how I can make things normal. I want to be able to have a relationship with my parents but I feel as though they just don't care. How can anyone be so selfish their whole life and never admit when they are wrong I just don't understand. 

  

'Struggling to make peace' - Amanda 

 

Message Emote
blank
April 3, 2006, 6:05 pm PDT

04/03 Mommy Dearest

Quote From: peanut27

I've struggled desperately with my mother's and I relationship.  I completely empathize with the daughters on the show, and feel so heartbroken over their situations yet am glad to see I am not alone.  My mother was physically and emotionally abusive, beating me weekly and calling me a whore at age 10 (long before I was sexually active), and to this day denies it all.  I've become such a disappointment to her, she even denies me as a daughter and never tells me she loves me.  I believe personally that I am successful for the most part, having earned advanced degrees and being financially independent and socially well accepted.  Most of my girlfriends have healthy relationships with their mother, so it is isolating and difficult to heal from the pain of having such a traumatic childhood.  Our relationship in my late 20's has completely degenerated.  She refuses to speak to me whatsoever, and we haven't spoken for over a year.  Even worse, I am expecting my first child soon.  I am reaching out in this blog for some advice.  How do you heal such deep childhood scars when the other party will never participate in the process?  Thanks for responding. 

Hi Peanut, 

  

It would be nice if your mother would participate sweetie but if she's not acknowledged her toxic part in your life thus far it's not likely she will be doing so any time soon and you shouldn't hold up your happiness for a moment because of her.  It's not up to you to heal her side of the relationship which means the only person you are responsible for taking care of is yourself.  I can't say that it doesn't matter that she owns up to her role as your mother but the reality is even if she does somewhere down the line you can't put your life on hold waiting for it to happen.  What if it never does?  Some people just should never be parents and simply don't have what others of us feel to be the natural instinct to love, protect and nurture our children.  It takes so much more to be a parent, to nurture and love a child, than some have the capacity to give.  Some behave as if they are no more than vessels in which offspring are formed and they have no tangible connection.  In any case you have to take care of your own heart and spirit.  How sad that your mother has missed out on having a relationship with such a wonderful woman like you!  Her life is less for not having shared it as she could have knowing you.  Surround yourself with love, acceptance and positivity.  It won't change your mother but it will help you put enough emotional distance between yourself and her to be able to find the goodness in your life in spite of her.  Mourn the relationship you wish you might have had with a mother had she been able to fill that role then give your own child and yourself all the love you missed.  What an incredible gift that will be to your child and to you!  Don't allow a poisonous legacy to continue to mar your life or color what you will have with your own child.  Know that at least from here I send you hugs, heart, and wishes for the brightest future there is to have!   

  

(((Hugs))) 

Vicki 

 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
April 3, 2006, 6:18 pm PDT

Missed the approach

Quote From: loopdlu212

During the first segment, I kept waiting for Dr. Phil to do his thing ie:  "TELL IT LIKE IT IS"  to the crack-addicted mother who sat there with her head held high, her chest puffed out, and her righteous attitude exuding - but he never did. 

It seemed to me as though he walked on eggshells with her. 

I was especially disappointed when his advice to the daughter was "perhaps she could visit with the children for an hour a day if she sounded rational"... 

Are you kidding?!!!  She shouldn't be anywhere near those children!!! 

The mother sat there argumentitively, justifying her behavior, while I felt as though Dr. Phil really let her daughter down terribly by not "doing his thing". 

Unfortunately, he probably knew, like others who have dealt with addicts, it wouldn't have done much good at all, her mind was tooooo fried, though I did NOT agree with her seeing the children for even an hour.  The problem is, addicts are great actors, it is a skill they learn to develope early on, manipulators would be a better name I suppose. 

Also, with the way she was acting, he might've been avoiding a violent outburst (violence is NOT what put the Dr. Phil show on television ) she looked like she could've gone off at any moment, yes I would've liked to see his no nonsense approach, but I think like the viewers, he realized there was nothing he could say or do to make that woman see what she was doing to her family. 

I'm sorry, I sound blunt, I don't mean to, but that is my two cents 

 

Message Emote
blank
April 3, 2006, 6:18 pm PDT

04/03 Mommy Dearest

Quote From: vicksin1

Hi Peanut, 

  

It would be nice if your mother would participate sweetie but if she's not acknowledged her toxic part in your life thus far it's not likely she will be doing so any time soon and you shouldn't hold up your happiness for a moment because of her.  It's not up to you to heal her side of the relationship which means the only person you are responsible for taking care of is yourself.  I can't say that it doesn't matter that she owns up to her role as your mother but the reality is even if she does somewhere down the line you can't put your life on hold waiting for it to happen.  What if it never does?  Some people just should never be parents and simply don't have what others of us feel to be the natural instinct to love, protect and nurture our children.  It takes so much more to be a parent, to nurture and love a child, than some have the capacity to give.  Some behave as if they are no more than vessels in which offspring are formed and they have no tangible connection.  In any case you have to take care of your own heart and spirit.  How sad that your mother has missed out on having a relationship with such a wonderful woman like you!  Her life is less for not having shared it as she could have knowing you.  Surround yourself with love, acceptance and positivity.  It won't change your mother but it will help you put enough emotional distance between yourself and her to be able to find the goodness in your life in spite of her.  Mourn the relationship you wish you might have had with a mother had she been able to fill that role then give your own child and yourself all the love you missed.  What an incredible gift that will be to your child and to you!  Don't allow a poisonous legacy to continue to mar your life or color what you will have with your own child.  Know that at least from here I send you hugs, heart, and wishes for the brightest future there is to have!   

  

(((Hugs))) 

Vicki 

This goes to Mari, Jessica and all of us who have lived this sad experience with the one person in our life who was supposed to have loved us most...  (((HUGS))) 

  

Vicki 

 
First | Prev | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | Next | Last