Message Boards

Topic : 07/03 "I Want My Ex Back"

Number of Replies: 261
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, March 31, 2006, 12:46:27 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 04/04/06) Have you ever called it quits and then decided you wanted your ex back? Amber's divorce from her husband of 10 years, Duane, is almost final, but she wonders if she's making the right choice. Is Duane willing to change and meet some of Amber's demands? Should Amber tear up the papers and let Duane move back in? Then, Scott and Erin have been married, divorced, reconciled, engaged and are now separated again. He wants her to come home and raise their children together, but she says she doesn't know how she could ever love him again. What's behind the conflict in this marriage, and can they resolve it and reignite their romance? Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More July 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
April 4, 2006, 3:12 pm PDT

Young and Confused.

 I've read the message boards and theirs know one my age replying. I know you older women have experienced more, I am 26 and I feel like I been through hell! My troubles started mack in 02" and they haven't been the same since. I met Damon when I was 20 years old, I had one child that was three at the time. Everything started off great Damon and I started out as friends we worked together, I would hang out with his aunt we were the same age, I never thought about getting with him, but it happened. A year after dating him I had his son, I never thought about having anything serious with him because of the company he kept. A serious relationship did happen, and he gave up hanging out with the fellas to show me how serious he was. Then on Mother's Day 02" he asked me to marry him, I was surprised and so not expecting it. He went out and brought the ring and everything! Three months after that he was telling me he wanted to be alone, at this time I now have a five year old and a two year old. Not only that I had found out that I was pregnant again! Well you know all the changes a woman goes through in pregnancy, and on top of everything the man that wanted to marry me is leaving me. He called me up at my place of employment to tell me this! I begged and pleaded him and he stayed, but it didn't feel right. So I prayed and asked God to show me, and he did. One day I was calling Damon's phone and it kept ringing, so I checked the charger to see if he left it and he did. So I went into the phone to erase my call and I seen another call at 1 am in the morning. I called the number and it was a female she denied everything, so when he came home I confronted him and lied and told him that the girl told me everything so he confessed. I found out that he left me for a 19 year old girl who had one child, the same as I was when i met him. My pregnancy was hard and we even tried to get an abortion, it didn't happen. He had the nerve to tell his girlfriend this! He came back to me when our baby was born in June 03." But it wasn't right and he still refused to erase all doubt that I had, so I made him leave and he went right back. This has been going on for four years, I have damaged new relationships I've had because I fell in love with a man who is not even worthy of my love, but I love him. Currently I am with someone else, who I've been with the last two years. I have dragged him into my saga too! My children's father had asked me in front of this man did I still love him and I told him yes! I have put my boyfriend out to prove to my children's father my devotion to him. He wants alot from me and he's giving a little, he takes me out, pays bills at the house with me and his children, he spends time but only when he can sneak. My boyfriend I love him but he can't support me financially, he loves me unconditionally, even after all the drama he's still with whereas any other man would have left already. Don't get me wrong I work and go to school part time. Is it possible to love two people. I love Damon but I know being with him will be an uphill battle of proving to me that I can trust him again! Antwan I love him too! He makes me happy, and I can't stand to be away from either one of them. I need advice!   

Sincerely, Young and confused. 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
April 4, 2006, 3:14 pm PDT

04/04 "I Want My Ex Back"

Amber are you crazy? Let him go. He is not worth it. He was with someone else, he wants his cake and eat it too. You can do it on your own.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
April 4, 2006, 3:19 pm PDT

ive learned alot from the show

 

my boyfriend and i have a 7month old son together, and have been together for 3yrs. he acts the same way as Duana's ex. he wants his cake and eat it too. he doesnt keep his promises and never is ontime . he bought a new 2006 honda dirt bike after telling me that he is saving up money for us to get our own place. he goes to his friends houses every day after work and shows up to see his son at 10pm every nite. i trying telling him how i feel and want him to change and that i am not waiting on him anymore but i just cant seem to call it quits with him. im not afraid for my son, or living without my boyfriend but every time i intend to break up with him i cave in .     

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 4, 2006, 3:32 pm PDT

save yourself

Quote From: bellusklm

I met my now ex, who is also the father of my 10wk old son, just over a year ago through mutual friends.  We started dating, and a month later, found out I was pregnant.  We decided to go through with the pregnancy, and discussed our relationship and our future, which I thought would be together because at the time, he told me he wanted it to work as much as I did.  I knew I had fallen in love with him after about three months, when I was about 10wks pregnant.  I loved everything about him, and we had a great freindship.  I knew he had been divorced from his ex-wife for about a year and a half, and that he still talked to her on ocassion.  She filed for divorce behind his back after cheating on him multiple times, and after going through marriage counseling, where he says, she blamed everything on him that went wrong with their relationship.  Even after she moved the new boyfriend and his daughter into the house they used to share, he continued sleeping with her for almost a year after their divorce.  He told me at one point after a heated discussion about her, because I didn't and still don't understand why he talks to her, that he was still in love with her.  Like an idiot in love, I stayed with him because he said he wanted to work on things with us and make our relationship work.  When I was seven months pregnant, he broke up with me, all for reasons that had to do with him, and the issues he has with his ex.  Whenever she calls, he answers, and has now begun spending time with her (she is now single, has been since November).  He said that nothing that had to do with her influenced our relationship, and that he didn't want to get back together with her, this was when he broke up with me.  The reasons he gave for not being able to be with me were that I was jealous, insecure, and posessive - well, of course, look at the relationship he's had with her, why wouldn't I be all those things, especially seing as how I love this man, and he's the father of my son.  He has stopped coming to see his son, has bought anything for him, and won't answer my calls, although I have not tried to contact him in over a week, and it all started when I found out about him and his ex, through a mutual friend.  I don't understand how he could walk away from me and his son, when all I ever wanted was to be with him, and be a family.  I am truly devestated, and brokenhearted.  I do the best I can each day to not think about him, and how much it hurts, but I just wonder, will he ever realize that she doesn't care about him the way that I do, and that even after two years of being divorced, she still has the ability to keep him at her beck and call.  Why does he still care for her, and why does she do it to him?  It hurts so much to know that he walked out on me for no good reason, and now has walked out on his son, for her.
It's sad to say, and I'm very sorry to hear your story. You unwittingly got caught up in a situation with a man who was not free, not emotionally. I'm glad you have a son, as the years go by, you will be so amazed as you learn from him what love truly is.  I'v been a single mom for 18 years, and you will never know anything as brilliant as the love and bond you two will share.  Right now I imagine the pain you are going through must feel almost unbearable, I'm sure you think of him, and her, constantly, please don't let the pain immobilize you.  I know it's easy for someone to say, but I can tell you that I have lived through pain like yours, and there is a definite light at the end of the tunell. I promise you that in time, it will hurt alot less, and though I'm sure your self-esteem and self-worth is in the toilet righr now, it won't remain there. Do not be a victim.  You had no control over the choices he has made, but you do have control over the choices you make for yourself and your son. A few tips that seem to make difficult times easier for me... act like the lady i'm sure you are. Even though your heart is broken now, behave in a way that will leave you with no regrets.  Try to remind yourself that you will not always feel this pain, and try your best not to carry the baggage you are sure to have from this experience into your next relationship, as I can tell you as well from my own experiences, that is a huge mistake.  When my girlfriends are going through a breakup, or myself, I always have a few comments to put things into perspective.  First, I know it sounds like I could be trivializing things, but I'm not... really think about what I'm going to say... You made a mistake.  You picked the wrong guy. Oh well.  You simply made a mistake.  Another thing... What is the worst thing that could possibly happen in this situation,...on one hand, the worst thing has already happened, on the other hand, you don't strike me as a woman who could spend her life with a man without common sense, without good decision making skills. We are all so much stronger than we give ourselves credit for, and there are in fact some wounds that time does heal, and you will find that this is one of them.  You will go on, you will hold your head high, I hope you will remind yourself that his actions have nothing to do with you.  He had no business starting a relationship with you, and if I were you I'd probebly be angry about this, but unfortunatly, it is what it is, and now you need to forgive, probebly mostly yourself, as we all tend to be hardest on ourselves, and live, and breathe, and love your self, and your son. 
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
confused
April 4, 2006, 3:45 pm PDT

what is a girl to do!!!!!

I too am in a similar situation as everybody else I am 32  been married for 13 years.  I left my husband about 6 months ago because of all the lies and all the cheating that was never ending.  In the whole 13 years he has cheated on me phycically not including the internet chats with multiple women and looking at porn.  He has cheated on me with at least 9 different women.  Over 13 years I have left 10 times always to come back it feels hopeless.  I leave and he comes to me and he tells me just what I want to hear and I go back even though deep inside I know that nothing will ever change.  Why do we do this to our selves?  I know he won't change Steve will be telling me how much he misses me and loves me and get in the car and call his girlfriend and tell her the same thing I know this but I feel like I have no control over my feelings.  I know before i even pack up my kids and myself and head back into this relationship that nothing has changed.  Now yeah at first it's wonderful he's attentive and warm he says he loves me he holds me at night and makes love to me all the time. Then 3 weeks into it it starts to fall back into the same patteren.  This time I am praying that it is different that I wll have the will power to stay away and make a new life for my self.  I am sick of being a victim of his sick games.  I am better than what he makes me feel that I am.  Over the 13 years I have gained so much weight I went from a very good looking 130 lb young woman to a 311 old feeling woman at the age of 32.  I know that this has a lot to do with it my self image and self esteem so if anyone knows how to rebuild all that please share.  I am currently in school and it's going good I think I have finally decided that I would rather just be alone than to be with him.  It's hard cause I know he doesn't want to be with me how could he when all he ever does is search for somthing better than me or at least that is the way it feels.  It is very hard because I am trying to stick to my guns and to stay single and to work on getting my life back together but it's like he won't let me leave.  Like that guy on the show he uses the kids to keep me on a leash, he says that if he can't have me then lets me friends I don't want to be his friend.  But he makes me feel that I am being so mean to him when I know deep inside that I am not.  I really don't know what to do or where to turn.  How do I move on when he's there all the time being charming and all that. How do I turn my back on my childrens father when do still love him very much?  These are questions that I ask myself everyday.  I don't want to feel like this anymore.  Sometimes I feel like getting in my car and just driving until I get far away so that he will never be in my life ever again.
 

Message Emote
blank
April 4, 2006, 3:49 pm PDT

I am going through the same thing

Hi! 

I am 50 years old, and last month my husband and I had our 32nd. wedding anniversary. Thing is, is that our Divorce is still pending.  My Divorce from my Husband has been filed since Dec. 2005. and because I am trying to get Disability, my Attorney has asked me to remain living with my husband, because I do not have any money coming in, and she cannot see me getting Divorced, and getting out of our Marriage without any money.  Now, I have been informed that time is running out on our Divorce case, and the end of this month we have to go back into Court for an update and probably to decide if we still want to get a Divorce.  My Husband says he does not want the Divorce, even though he was the one to file for Divorce 2 times before I filed.  He wants to stay married because he knows what it is going to cost him.  He is a controller, like in today's show.  He has admitted that we will never have the love for each other that we should have, and right now we are just co-existing and living in the same house together.  He loves Porn, and continuously looks at Women and downloads movies on the internet.  He does not care what I think, and goes ahead and does it anyways.  He is verbally abusive, and so are his Sisters, who verbally attack me and make me feel like I am always at fault... I know we are both at fault. I do not deny that.   I am just tired, and am tired of living with a man who does not love me, or show affection for me, or even shows that he likes being with me.   

My biggest problem is that I am also Morbidly Obese, I have gone through Cancer, and have other Health problems and cannot do things with my husband that he wants. 

Now the end of this month I have to decide whether to end our Marriage.  There are other issues with my Husband that I have not even mentioned.  Even though, he says he does not want the Divorce, he does not love me, and I will have to live with that for more years, under the same house with him, and continue to co-exist with one another.  I am just waiting now for my Court hearing for my Disability, and that may not take place for a long time yet.  I would sure like to know what to do, or how I should handle this...  Please help! 

Thanks for listening ... 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 4, 2006, 3:57 pm PDT

Going back can turn out good!

  

 Back in 2000, my husband of just about 5 years( 1 month short). Got a divorce. We had 2 GREAT boy's 3 and 1. 

 We grew apart it was like we where roomates, no sex life what so ever. So why stay togeather?  He did not want to split up.We lived in different towns, he got the boys every other weekend and 1 night durning the week.  

 After time had gone by we both started to date, i right away got into a relationship with another man. He just dated. I grew to love this other man, but in the back of my mind i always woundered if i had did the right thing. 

  Well my ex and i talked alot, even got togeather from time to time and hung out. This went on for 2 years, me being with another man and him dating. But while this was going on we where getting to know each other again. After you are married with kids, bills, work etc, its like you get in a rut and can't get out.  I decided to end it with the other man and see where my ex and I would go from there. 

 Well i can tell you we got back togeather, i moved into his home, and things have been GREAT!!!!!!!! 

 It's like we fell in love all over again. I understand him so much better now. I had to change alot and so did he but after being apart for 2 1/2 years we both learned alot.
 So sometimes going back is not always a bad thing, you both have to want it, and you both have to change what was wrong to start with. Yes we still have little spats ( he does make me mad), but i know now it's gonna be ok. Hope everyone the best of luck!!!!!!!! 

 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
upset
April 4, 2006, 4:06 pm PDT

I want my Ex back

Hi Dr. Phil and all reading. 

  

I am a 39 year old that is separated from my husband of 11 years.  This makes the 3rd time that have been thru this.  This time being the longest one yet.  I am desperate to get my ex back.  I have been in counseling for almost a year now.   I am in search of a good councilor that can help me find myself and figure out what it s that I want to be when I grow up.  I feel like I am fighting a loosing battle.  My husband is very hard headed and set in his ways(as am I).  He goes back and forth in his head as to weather or not he wants to reconcile our marriage.  Some days I do too, but the bottom line with me is I love him and can not imagine my life without him in it.  He has his faults, but despite them, I love him.  I accept him with or without fault.  He does not understand that.  We have been talking (sorta) since November of last year about reconciling.  about a month ago things with him changed.  He stopped calling me as much(he usually called everyday) and then on Friday (the past on) he called and was "him hauwing" around and not sure he thinks we should reconcile.  He says he is confused.  I moved out of our home that we own together and moved to the town in another state where my mother lives.  WE are about 5 hours apart.  The lease on my apartment is up at the end of April, and I had been emailing and asking him what it was that we were going to do.  He could not give me an answer.  So I sent him an email telling him I was setting him free.  That I could not fight for our marriage all alone and I could not allow him to play with my heart anymore.  I have not heard from him since.  What do I do?  I love my husband and want to make my marriage work.  Please let me know what y'all think and if you have any good advice 

 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
sad
April 4, 2006, 4:10 pm PDT

Help me....

Hello all, 

     I'm going through something similar. I want my ex back too. Only I was nevered married to him, but we have a beautiful daughter together. We were together for 1 year and half. He says he is done trying and I want us to try one last time. I want us to get counseling and try. We have never tried that, he said he would but never got to it, cause he moved on to another female. I hate the fact he has a new girlfriend. He says it's not his girlfriend and he only sees her ocassionally but after a week of being apart he had already found someone. And now has been seeing her for 4 months. He raley sees his daughter. He only saw her 3 times last month. He plays these games with me....a couple of weeks ago we got together intamtley then the next day wanted nothing to do with me. we fight all the time....now i won't let him see the baby unless its around me in a public place. what do i do? 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 4, 2006, 4:15 pm PDT

with friends like you

Quote From: mykidzmum2

Well said!!  Dr. Phil gave Duane the opportunity to speak up and defend himself and he couldn't!  He couldn't because there is no defending himself.  Dr. Phil always is fair and he was fair in their discussion.  It is obvious to me that Dr. Phil knows what Amber needs to do and I know Amber knows what she needs to do and I know she will do it! 

I'm so happy to read your response and know that Amber has a friend like you.  I felt her pain when she spoke, and I know it sounds corny, but when she had her epiphany, I saw it and I related to her, and I know in that moment she confronted the truth, I just hope she hangs on to that moment, because if she does, and with friends like you to remind her, she will walk to the other side. Also I have to say, I do not know what show some of these people watched, how could anyone think her husband's behaviour is justified??!!  Please Amber, I heard you say you would prefer to raise your children under the same roof as their father, that you think it would be better for them.  I promise you, it will not.  I would hate to see your son grow up to think this behaviour is o.k., or your daughter to be at risk for an abusive relationship. ( I'm not sure if you have boys, girls, or both )  Amber, hang on to your truth, and to the friend I'm responding to, every girl in the world would be so lucky to have a friend like you.
 
First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | Next | Last