Message Boards

Topic : 07/25 Plastic People

Number of Replies: 780
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, March 31, 2006, 12:53:50 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 04/06/06) Dr. Phil speaks to people who are searching for the perfect body. Gina admits to an obsession with plastic surgery and has a long wish list of procedures she'd like to have done in her quest for perfection. Her fiancé, Jason, finds her the picture of perfection and says she needs to stop. With their wedding on the horizon, second thoughts are creeping into Jason's mind. Then, Michael's wife, Christy, repulses him and he can't even kiss her. Christy is trying to lose weight so she can look attractive for her husband, but his repulsion makes her feel unworthy. Should Christy lose weight and try to look more like a model, or should Michael accept her just the way she is? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More July 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
July 28, 2006, 1:39 pm PDT

i relly think he was being very hurtful to her with his words!!!!!

Quote From: donotbefat

   

   

   

Why has Christy's husband been portrayed as the bad guy?  The one that is responsible for Christy putting on 90 extra pounds since their marriage and her consequently having low self-esteem?  

   

This poor guy really bought into Dr. Phil's and Christy's combined portrayal of him as causing her emotional and obesity problems.  Come on guy, you DO need counseling to help you realize it is not YOU that is the cause of your wife's obesity and her feeling "repulsive."  She's done it to herself, and it's OK for you to admit this, no matter what Phil says.  

   

And now you doubly need counseling to undo the trauma you experienced of being ganged up on by Phil and Christy on national television and portrayed as the villain and cause of  her food addiction and her own self-loathing.  

   

And Dr. Phil tells the poor guy he needs to really examine his "superficial appearance aspects of yourself."  

   

I beg to differ with you, Phil.  We have eyes and they are for seeing.  And we have hands, and they are for touching and feeling.  Do these senses not count?  What this guy sees and touches and feels is not a turn on to him.  So why is he being scolded for his reality?  Come on Phil, are you so 'unsuperficial' that you'd be willing to trade your wife's shape and size for Christy's?    

   

So I say to Christy's husband, yes you are in a no-win situation, and before you accidentally make any more kiids with her, get out now, because she will never take responsibility for her own reality and you're always going to be the bad guy in this relationship.  

   

Good luck to you!  

   

   

    

   

   

are you aware of just how much a persons words can hurt someones heart? and how those words can affect how you feel about yourself? and even how those words can make you see your self? christys hubby was being a heartless ass h#&e, you just do not say things like he said to her !!!! not when your suppose to love her, hell man that isnt love, and you do not tell your wife she stinks, if that were me that ass h#&e said that to i would have knocked his damn teeth doun his throaght, and then told him wow hunny you got no teeth, so please dont sit thear and condoan this kind of behavior from a suppose to be spouse!!! he married her for better or for worse didnt he? he needs to stop looking for just the worse in her and start being a loving carring husband to her as he stood before god and promiced to be!!!! so shes a bit over weight, that just makes for more to love
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
July 28, 2006, 5:12 pm PDT

Doctor Phil Show.

Doctor Phil. Plastic People.  Are you kidding me?  What are you thinking? Plastic People are just as good as it can get. See you tomorrow Afternoon. Well I had better close now. Sincerley Your. Russe 

ll

 

Message Emote
blank
July 29, 2006, 1:13 am PDT

07/25 Plastic People

Quote From: donotbefat

  

I've been reading many of the posts pertaining to Christy's obesity.  The majority of the respondents seem sympathetic toward her and scornful of her husband. 

  

I can only assume the reason for the above, is that probably most of the respondents are overweight or obese themselves. 

  

Nevertheless, let's talk real here.   

  

When someone becomes fat or obese, lots of things about their physical as well as emotional self change.  

  

1.  When someone becomes fat or obese, so does their tongue.   

So when they go to bed and lie down on their back, all the extra fat within the neck area and the increased size of the tongue all falls back into the throat, often causing breathing problems as the throat area becomes blocked by fat.  One of the results of this is snoring, loud snoring.  Another result is sleep apnia, and the fat person consequently needing to sleep with a contraption over their face making them sound and look like Darth Vader.  This noisy device helps them to breathe through the night as they sleep. 

  

Now I ask you, does this sound like a sexy sight?  Is this what you envisioned for yourself and your mate when you hooked up with them?  

  

2.  When someone becomes fat or obese, they are in constant pain. 

ALL obese (and most fat) people live in chronic pain.  People who are in pain are not in the mood to be fun or sexy.  And they usually don't even feel like any unnecessary movement at all.  The pain is screaming loud and clear from the extra stress on their joints and bones.  The extra pounds they drag around cause them to be slow and lumbering in their movements. 

  

Does this sound like someone who would be creative and  inventive during romantic moments?  Does it sound like someone who would even be interested in romantic moments at all?  Orteven a jog around the block?  Probably not! 

  

3.  For the fat or obese person, there is a strong emotional component to living with chronic pain, causing the fat or obese person to  be depressed, short-tempered, sleep-deprived, irritable, angry, and sorry for themselves. 

  

Does this sond like someone who will be an upbeat, energetic and interesting person to be around?  Does this sound like the person you would intentionally choose as the parent of your child?    I think not.  

  

  

So, for all you people out there who continue to feel sorry for Christy who has packed on an extra 90 pounds, and for those of you who continue to blame her husband for not being supportive enough, try getting fit yourselves.  Fill up your plate, then cut the portion in half and scrape it off for the dog. Eat less and exercise more and reduce your weight until you are proud of the way you look and feel.  Then, if you can actually do this, let's see if you still want to baby Christy for her over-eating choices. 

  

  

I agree with you to an extent. I am obese and I know that the things you say are true about the discomfort that goes along with fatness.

But you need to change your attitude about it just a little. A lot of people have over eating disorders, they are more deadly and more prevalent than anorexia or bulimia. Anorexia and bulimia are probably looked at by you with compassion, and that is good because it's a disease that a person is INFLICTED with. So you should try to have compassion...any empathetic human being would.

Most people who are fat like me KNOW they are fat, KNOW how to lose the fat, but they are stuck inside the dark world of eating disorders, food rules them, it's all they think about, it brings them joy, it fills a hole...on and on...ALL the same things that other ED's contain. I KNOW how to lose weight, but I also have depression, so I am stuck between a rock and a hard place. I AM losing weight, but it's hard....it's going to be a long road because I am in a downward spiral and many other women are too.

The other thing you missed about this show is that this man, Christy's husband isn't just concerned with weight. He is concerned with a lot of other stupid superficial things, shaving toes and haircuts and what not. This isn't about Christy's weight in this case...this is about a controlling and unhappy man.

No one wants to baby Christy...they just might have an iota of empathy, something you are greatly lacking, something that humans MUST have in order for society to work correctly. Imagine yourself in her shoes..really do it. Really...do it. She's aware that people like you dislike her simply because of her weight, I'm aware of it too...it hurts and it doesn't make giving up "food as a friend" easier when people like you are rude.

Think about it.
 

Message Emote
blank
July 29, 2006, 1:14 am PDT

07/25 Plastic People

Quote From: msjambo

Why is everyone focusing only on weight issues.  In Christy's case, her husband ragged on her for her weight, her hair, the way she smells, and her toes.  Come on.... 

  

I think that Christy's weight could be a health issue at some point, but her hair style wont, or her hairy toes.  Is he concerned about her or himself?  There is no excuse for cruelty and that is all he is about. 

  

For Michael to act the way that he has, there has to be another reason.   

Exactly...her weight isn't the issue...her husband would find just about anything to be disgusted with...this is a very unhappy controlling man and he needs therapy because no matter who he is ever with in this life he will NOT be happy.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
July 29, 2006, 6:29 am PDT

07/25 Plastic People

Quote From: purplepain

I agree with you to an extent. I am obese and I know that the things you say are true about the discomfort that goes along with fatness.

But you need to change your attitude about it just a little. A lot of people have over eating disorders, they are more deadly and more prevalent than anorexia or bulimia. Anorexia and bulimia are probably looked at by you with compassion, and that is good because it's a disease that a person is INFLICTED with. So you should try to have compassion...any empathetic human being would.

Most people who are fat like me KNOW they are fat, KNOW how to lose the fat, but they are stuck inside the dark world of eating disorders, food rules them, it's all they think about, it brings them joy, it fills a hole...on and on...ALL the same things that other ED's contain. I KNOW how to lose weight, but I also have depression, so I am stuck between a rock and a hard place. I AM losing weight, but it's hard....it's going to be a long road because I am in a downward spiral and many other women are too.

The other thing you missed about this show is that this man, Christy's husband isn't just concerned with weight. He is concerned with a lot of other stupid superficial things, shaving toes and haircuts and what not. This isn't about Christy's weight in this case...this is about a controlling and unhappy man.

No one wants to baby Christy...they just might have an iota of empathy, something you are greatly lacking, something that humans MUST have in order for society to work correctly. Imagine yourself in her shoes..really do it. Really...do it. She's aware that people like you dislike her simply because of her weight, I'm aware of it too...it hurts and it doesn't make giving up "food as a friend" easier when people like you are rude.

Think about it.

The over eating disorder is one that a lot of people do not or will not empathize with. They see over weight people as lazy and unwilling to do anything about their condition. Obese people have been and still are the butt of the joke. The thing that makes no sense to me is that with this the majority of America is either overweight or obese. You know it is no longer acceptable to poke fun at people of a different race or ethnicity. It is no longer acceptable to poke fun at someone with a mental disorder, but if you want to take pot shots at overweight people oh go right a head. I knew a girl who was about the nicest person you could ever wish to meet. She was a very kind hearted generous person the only thing was she was morbidly obese. She wouldn't go out of her house very much because people would stare at her and make unkind remarks about her. One day she went out to eat with her family the staff of the restaurant put them in the back of the restaurant that made it very hard on her to get to the buffet line and when she did get up to get her food some mean spirited people made comments about what she had put on her plate. Needless to say that was the last time she went out to eat.  

Food addiction is the only addiction where you can't quit cold turkey. No pun intended here. I have known quite a few over weight people in my lifetime and none of them could I have called lazy. They were hard working caring individuals who loved their family's and their family's loved them. It doesn't help the person dealing with the food addiction to call them names and belittle them. It just makes them want to eat more. People need to be more considerate of peoples feelings maybe with a little empathy we might make some head way with the overweight individual. Lift them up and try to help them along the way. Be the light in their day instead of the food then they might have incentive to lose the weight. But if they don't then love them anyway.  

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
July 29, 2006, 12:55 pm PDT

Daahhhh

Quote From: barbie75

I was replying to a negative message.  Pay attention!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 30, 2006, 11:03 am PDT

Weight Loss Buddy

Christy, I would like to be your weight loss buddy.  I too am over weight and your story really touched me.  If you are looking for someone to loose the weight with you, let me know.......
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 31, 2006, 7:35 am PDT

07/25 Plastic People

Quote From: purplepain

Exactly...her weight isn't the issue...her husband would find just about anything to be disgusted with...this is a very unhappy controlling man and he needs therapy because no matter who he is ever with in this life he will NOT be happy.

I just hope Christy takes care of herself for her, and not for him.  Anybody that treats you that way doesnt deserve to be in a relantioship, let alone with someone like Christy.  He should find someone as shallow as himself...maybe like that lady that was on that said she never goes out without makeup on.....Theres a match made in heaven~! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 31, 2006, 7:40 am PDT

Buddy

Quote From: swmbo0531

Christy, I would like to be your weight loss buddy.  I too am over weight and your story really touched me.  If you are looking for someone to loose the weight with you, let me know.......

That is a nice offer to make to someone....I'd like to be in to.  Im a member at Curves, and it has helped me lose many many inches, and it makes you feel good about your self.  I think Curves would be a good thing for Christy considering the fact that you can work out at your own pace and nobody is judging you or pushing you.   

  

Let us know Christy! 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
frustrated
July 31, 2006, 10:42 am PDT

GET A LIFE!

GINA, FOR HEAVEN'S SAKES GIRL - GET A LIFE!

IT IS A VERY SHALLOW PERSON WHO THINKS OF NOTHING OTHER THAN WHAT SHE LOOKS LIKE.  YOU SHOULD BE LIKE ME - THREE YEARS ON PREDNISONE FOR A LUNG DISEASE

AND NUMEROUS OTHER TIMES SINCE.  I DON'T LIKE THE WEIGHT GAIN AND THE CHANGE IN MY APPEARANCE (FACIAL CHANGES) BUT THE ALTERNATIVE IS STAYING VERY SICK AND BEING ON OXYGEN 24/7.  YOU NEED TO GET SOME SERIOUS HELP - YOU HAVE A REAL PROBLEM.

 
First | Prev | 72 | 73 | 74 | 75 | 76 | 77 | Next | Last