Message Boards

Topic : 04/12 Dangerous Love

Number of Replies: 595
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, April 07, 2006, 10:09:03 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
If two people are truly in love, does anyone have the right to judge them? What if their relationship crosses moral boundaries? Jeremy, 16, is disturbed that his 45-year-old father, Chuck, is engaged to a 17-year-old girl who used to be his classmate. Chuck says he wants to spend the rest of his life with Michelle. The constant fighting in the house led to Jeremy moving out. Why did Michelle's mom allow her daughter to move in with Chuck? Did Chuck mislead her? See what Dr. Phil tells these parents they must do. Then, Angela is repulsed that her brother, Anthony, wants to marry their second cousin, Tosha. Anthony says he loves Tosha and nothing's going to stop their relationship from moving forward. Does Angela have a legitimate reason to be concerned? Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More April 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 13, 2006, 7:17 am PDT

Dangerous Love

Quote From: juliebgg

Obviously he plays everything to his advantage.  I agree he is just keeping her on the hook by saying they are engaged. This way he can have his cake and eat it too (not be tied down by marriage but sleep with her) He obviously does not have her best interests at heart, just his own selfish gratification
Why buy the cow, when you can get the milk free.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 13, 2006, 7:17 am PDT

Dangerous Love

Quote From: juliebgg

Obviously he plays everything to his advantage.  I agree he is just keeping her on the hook by saying they are engaged. This way he can have his cake and eat it too (not be tied down by marriage but sleep with her) He obviously does not have her best interests at heart, just his own selfish gratification
Why buy the cow, when you can get the milk free.
 

Message Emote
blank
April 13, 2006, 7:24 am PDT

04/12 Dangerous Love

Quote From: redlocks

Michelle, I just want you to know that I have your back.  You and Chuck look very happy together despite how bad Dr. Phil tried to make your relationship look.  I met my husband when I was 17 and he was 37.  We have been married for 25 years and I have not been sorry for even one minute.  Please don't listen to all the judgmental voices on this board....they have not walked in your shoes so they do not know what they are talking about......but I have.  We have 5 children together who have grown into very successful adults.  I went back to school and got my degree which you will too when the time is right for you.  My husband has two daughters...one a year older than me and the other a year younger than me.  The younger daughter was my best friend for the first 15 years until she died in a car accident.  My husband and I then took in her two children and raised them too.  However, the older daughter has never accepted me completely but we do get along for the most part.  She has accepted the fact that I am here to stay.  Eventually everyone will move on to a different topic to whine about and people will just see you two for who you are....just two people who love eachother.  Most people don't even notice the age difference between us anymore.  If this is what you really want then stick to your guns....the naysayers will fade away.  As far as having children is concerned I would not wait until you are 28.  We started having children when I was 21......my husband (now 62) says they keep him young.  Last weekend he took our 7 year old snowboarding for the 11 time (he snowboards with the grown children too.)  The only concern that I have is that I will have a lot of life left to live when he does pass away but then  again anyone can be a widow at any age. Life makes no promises so grab what you can, ignore the naysayers, live your life and be happy!

You met your husband when you were 17 but your situation is nothing like Michelle's.  Michelle met Chuck when she was 16.  Chuck used her sexually for the first time 5 days later. She was in a live in spousal relationship within one month of meeting this "man".  All of that happened before she was 17. 

  

Then, he has helped her completely drop out of her life for a year and a half so far.  She doesn't attend school or work; she just wastes time in his basement until he is there to use her sexually again. Worse, he says he won't marry her for 8 years. That means that she is completely dependent on him and becoming less and less employable but she has no legal rights to support when this train wreck hits. 

  

I suspect that her situation isn't a mirror of your own. 

  

 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
April 13, 2006, 7:58 am PDT

Canadian Law

Quote From: dunnie06

If he is so in love with you,why couldn't he marry you before impregnating you?Love means COMMITMENT!!

Just to clarify, for the American public who may or may not be familiar with the laws in Canada, and for obviously the Teens in Canada who like to twist the law to suit their own ends and to justify their behavior. 

The Age of Consent in Canada is indeed ( as horrible as it sounds ) fourteen years of age, meaning a girl or boy of this age group can consent to sexual intercourse, BUT....... 

If anyone older than two years older ( Which means over the age of sixteen in this case, Sorry but some of these kids are having trouble with the math here ) has sex with a fourteen year old, it Statutory Rape, obviously there are parents out there that should be looking into this as well. 

Canadian Parents, if you are concerned, your fourteen year old brings home a twenty four year old, Daddy and Jounior should have a talk, and the local police should be called, you HAVE options 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 13, 2006, 8:40 am PDT

People

Quote From: groovy

This isn't about true love, it's about pedophilia.  If by some miracle they're still together by the time the girl's in her mid 20s, Chuck will probably dump her for another teen. 

  

Re. the girl, at 17 her brain's not even fully developed.  She's in no position to make such an important decision such as marriage.   Chuck will probably make sure she gets pregnant to lock her into a dependency with him.  And say by some anamoly they stay together until she's Chuck's age.  She'll be with a 73 year-old guy.  Bet Chuck would never go near a 73 year-old woman, much less someone his own age or even a few years younger.     

  

Judging by the pic, Chuck's an old looking 45.  God forbid he would want to date women his own age. 

  

Emote = Disgusted. 

     A few things in the above quote bother me. One being that if they make it till she is 20 Chuck will leave her for another teen. Now I know that is not true in all cases. And this may be a case where that may not happen. And for that matter a boy this girl's own age could do the very same thing to her. So age does not even really play apart in that.

Second that her brain is not fully developed yet. I bring this up because a few people have said if she was 18 it wouldn't be so bad. So I have to ask is it the law that is getting everyone upset or is it the age difference? Would be upet if she was 18 and him 45. Would you be upset if she was 20 and him 45.  Would you be upset if she was 25 and him 45?

I meet my hubby when I was barely 18. We have now been together for around 7-8 yrs. We got married 4 yrs ago. He will be 42 this yr. We have 3 beautiful kids together. And I know he would never leave me for someone younger. Never.

Michelle I wish you and Chuck all the best in the world. If both of you really love each other than I hope you make it. I hope you get to live a long happy life with the guy you love.

 

Message Emote
blank
April 13, 2006, 8:59 am PDT

What a mess

I watched the entire show last night and I was appalled by both groups of people. 

 Angela,  you said straight out that you intended to make your brother's life and Tosha's a living hell.  Quite the loving sister you are (note the dripping sarcasm).  Your brother is in love with a person who, while in the same EXTENDED family, is far enough removed that the relationship shouldn't be an issue.  Even the Catholic church wouldn't have a problem with it and the church is not exactly noted for its liberal views.   You don't have to accept your brother's choice, but your disapproval doesn't justify your outrageous behavior.  Anthony is a fully grown adult and can make his own decisions - your approval is not required and your childish notes and tricks do you no credit - in fact your actions make.you seem to be an extremely vicious and mean-spirited person.   Anthony, I know you have an interest in the house, but if you are ready to get married, get out on your own and get some space of your own.   

 As for Chuckie, he was obviously scrambling to justify his egregious behavior.  He thinks Michelle's enough of an adult to make an adult choice about sleeping with him, but he thinks they should wait 8 years to get married because she won't be adult enough to make the decision to get married until then.  Does he really buy that logic?  Does anyone?  That magic wedding day that's scheduled to happen after she graduates from college in 2014 is never going to arrive if she never gets to college - she's certainly not doing anything to get there.   Chuckie obviously just likes to poke little girls and has created this fantasy of a someday marriage to justify the sexual exploitation of a child.  

 Michelle, here's a clue:  if you were anywhere close to mature you would be taking steps to secure your future (getting your GED, getting a job, getting into college), instead of loafing in the basement by day and sleeping with a surrogate daddy by night.  I'm sure you're having fun playing house, but part of being a mature adult is doing the things we need to do, not just what we want to. 

 To the sons, Jeremy and Shotzi - you seem like very intelligent, articulate, and well-grounded kids, with good senses of humor and a startling level of maturity for your age.  How that happened with the father you have . . .  I don't know but your mom must be a heck of a lady.  Stay strong, and if you can, stay with your mother.   You shouldn't have to share your home with your father's little sex toy. 

 And for those who think I'm being judgemental, you're damn right I am.   I don't care what adults do in private, but when it comes to those who take advantage of children I am absolutely judgemental.  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 13, 2006, 9:07 am PDT

26 & 50 in INdiana

Quote From: juliebgg

Whatever their darling children want they let them have.  Or let them do.  That is NOT what parents are for.  Children do not have good judgemnt and they need guidance from their parents so that they can learn to make good judgements.  No wonder there are so many spoiled rude children around who run all over the place in restaurants, have no manners whatsoever, and show no respect for other people or their property.  It is because of irresponsbile parents who want to be friends with their children instead of role models and authority figures.  You would let 2 and 6 year old do whatever they want?  Hey I have kids like yours in my preschool class who have "pals" for parents.  They are obnoxious and out of control.  The ones with responsible parents have good manners and behave well.  Can't wait to see the pal parents trying to reign them back in when they are teens.  Good luck.  With that parenting philosophy  you will need it down the road.
your 26,she's 17,Big Difference!If your 15 year old daughter told you she met a 43 year old man and one week later they are sleeping together,1&1/2 year later engaged?dropped out of school?lays around the house,does nothing,that would be okay with you?it goes beyond that.....and if all you can say is stand by your kids....no matter what ,then you have alot to learn....just because your married to a geezer doesn't mean you have the wisdom of one!
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
April 13, 2006, 9:13 am PDT

You demonstrated patience

Quote From: susanshell

  

I am 36.  I have only been married once to a very abusive man.  We have a 13 year old daughter, she is the light of my life.  I have been in therapy for four years and trust me, it has worked wonders.  No longer do I feel the need to be with someone-I am my own person.  I think you should find a good therapist..you sound so sweet and caring.  I can understand the bad choices in men, I made few myself.. 

  

I have finally found someone who is a great guy, full of understanding.  Still, I am not rushing into anything.  Perhaps you rushed?  Stay single for a year or so.  Pay attention to your needs!!!  Your child will love having its mother being healthy and happy.  I decided to listen to my needs and I am also finished with college-and my daughter is pround of me.  I am a better mother than I ever was.   

  

Do not sell yourself short-and do not think you are doing anything wrong.  Just remember you are human and want to be loved.  Right now, do not worry about having love from a man-get love from friends and family.  If you want to chat, just reply to this message and I will give you my email address. 

It's nice to hear of the patience that you endured, because it seems like you are a mother before anything else. 

  

The funny thing is that all my husbands wanted me back after all they did to me.  I just couldn't accept it.  They hurt me so much and then it's like, honey let's put ********** behind us.  Well, with the first two I had no children, so there was no way I was going to be patient. 

With my third husband, God blessed me with a girl.  I stayed in that marriage for 5 years (the longest), for the sake of my daughter.  3 of those years he was not even with us.  I just thought the fact that we were married would at least be good for my girl. 

We then got divorced and I was reading so much about the negativity of girls not developing a strong relationship with their fathers and that will affect them in adulthood. 

So, I said,well it seems the right thing to do to get remarried to provide my girl with a dad. 

My neighbours introduced me to this man, a professor, well established, mature, respectful family, etc.   

But all that, I found out, you can throw out the window and the one thing I asked for was to be patient with my daughter and give her time to adjust and he showed me otherwise. 

I told him a few months ago that I no longer wish to continue this marriage and will be leaving this summer. 

I wanted to leave then, but he asked me to give him some time to change.  I still feel I can't do this, and I will never be able to raise my daughter the way I want to.   

So, like I said, I want to be single to raise my daughter. And as you said love doesn't have to come from a man. 

  

The thing is that I don't have a man in my family that I can put my head on his shoulders.  I so much wish that my dad was alive today, so I can cry on his shoulders and ask him, why men are like that. 

I don't know if you know what I mean by that.  It's like when you need a man in your life like a brother or a father who you can get advice from, and who will support you emotionally. 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
sad
April 13, 2006, 9:19 am PDT

Not Dangerous, just Disgusting

 I don't believe that we as Americans can afford to sit back  and allow people like Chuck to continue abuse our youth. The problem has been growing and is completely out of control. Look at Mary Kay Letourneau, and others in the news recently. They too argue that it is love, when clearly it is sexual abuse. Chuck is a pedophile, point blank and Michelle is incapable of making an ubiased assessment of her situation because she has already been placed under the abuser's spell. Of course he'll tire of her eventually, after a few (unwanted) children are brought into this situation, then he'll move on to younger and greener pastures. As for the "wedding date" EIGHT YEARS from now in 2014, (he'll be 53, and she'll be 25) I think that is just a bunch of garbage. He has no intention of marrying her. If he did have plans to marry her and it was truly love, he would not have slept with her! He would have done the decent thing and waited until she was "adult" enough to objectively assess the relationship and make a rational decision.  Apparently she is old enough to decide  to sleep with him, just not marry him?!? Again I say garbage!  How young is too young? 15? 14? Where is our outrage? Where is our sense of decency?
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 13, 2006, 9:26 am PDT

Age differences can work, but its hard

I went to college when I was 16, dropped out a year later and was working.  When i met my husband, our first date was my 18th birthday; he was 42.  We were married 6 months later; that was 31 years ago.  Now, let me preface by saying, I love my husband, I adore him, and I do not regret marrying him. 

  

However.... 

  

Can a marriage with this age gap work? Clearly, it can.  However, I can assure it, if marriage is difficult, having this large of an age difference increases the problems significantly.   There are a 1000 little issues that can cause friction that are directly attributed to the difference in our ages.   

Fortunately, there are no childen involved, or I believe it would have been even more difficult.   

  

In addition to the differences that simply occur because the two of you grow up with completely different life experiences, there is also the hard cold fact that the bodies are aging at different rates.  My husband is in good shape for a 73 year old man, but he is _73_; he simply does not have the strength, energy, or desire to do things we once did, and the memory begins to slip as well.  I understand that.  But its not easy, I'm 49, and there are things I would like to do, things I would like him to do, and the reality of it is, he's simply not physically up to it.  I love being with him at home more than I would enjoy going antiquing or to an event on the weekends.   

  

Are you strong enough to stand up to be different?  We also think its hilarious when someone looks at us and then mention, your father or your daughter, and we correct them, to 'my spouse'.  People are shocked and embarassed, others will feel its perfectly okay to tell you what you are doing is wrong.  if you want to blend in, being with a significantly older person is not the way to do it. 

  

Can you separate the spouse from an authority figure?  We are taught to respect our elders, etc.  Now you are married to one.  Just because he's older, doesn't make him right.  Are you strong enough to be able to see this individual as a man who is a partner, not someone who is a father?  And you will most likely have to teach him not to treat you like a child. 

  

Are you prepared to give up your youth for an older man?  Life is not a rehearsal, this is your one shot.  Are you willing to stay with this person, and not date other people, party, go to college spring break, etc. while your friends do?  its very hard in a college environment not to want to hang with people your own age, if you do, you risk destroying your relationship. 

  

Are you prepared for the possibility that you may have to nurse your husband in his final days?  True, spouses get sick at any age, but with someone that much older, you must be prepared for this eventuality.   

  

Are you prepared to be alone and independent?  My husband insisted I complete my education,  The day I graduated with my masters,  I gave HIM a gold watch, he could retire from all the hard work he labored to get me thru school.  He wanted me to be able to fend for myself when he is gone. 

  

Are you prepared to make financial and purchasing decisions on your own?  When my car died, my husband drove me to the dealership and said, okay, buy yourself a car.  I told him, I couldn't do it,, and he said to me, you will have to do it sooner or later, best to do it sooner.  And so I did.  I have managed the money, major purchases, investments, etc. for the past 31 years, again, in preparation of the day that I will be alone. 

  

Are you both prepared for the day you no longer need him?  Its a terrifying turn of events, the day you no longer need the person you leaned on for so many years.  It requires a great deal of trust and commitment on both sides: first, that the investment and trust the spouse makes will not betrayed, and secondly, that the newly independent spouse isn't going to simply go wild with this new way of life. 

  

Both parties need to really consider what the future brings... first you fall in lust, then you fall out of lust and into love, that's when the hard work starts. 

  

 
First | Prev | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | Next | Last