Message Boards

Topic : 08/02 "I Love Myself!"

Number of Replies: 1934
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, April 13, 2006, 01:18:17 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 04/20/06) Do you know someone who craves attention so badly that he or she will do anything to get it? One family believes their loved one is a master manipulator and her ways are causing a major conflict in the household. Hilary claims she wouldn’t shed a tear if her stepdaughter, Shannon, died tomorrow. She calls Shannon a narcissist and says she will lie, fight and cuss just to be noticed. Shannon feels like a scapegoat, and thinks her stepmother is simply out to get her. When Shannon was younger, her biological mom died, and now she believes Hilary has turned her father and sister against her. Is Shannon’s behavior all an act, or do her father and stepmother need to change how they deal with her? Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More August 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
surprised
April 20, 2006, 1:22 pm PDT

disappointed

 Just finished watching today's show with my sister and we couldn't believe that you ended the show without saying how bad shannon's father and step-mother were to her. It felt that you also let shannon down which you could see in her eyes and when over and over the bad things that you said were her contribute to the situation and not her father's. As the show ended i thought that you're turning out to be the same as the rest of the 21st century doctors have turned out just not to say it like it really is. I think you're the best and have helped millions of people but in the last season and seems to be this season you're not the same.
 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
April 20, 2006, 1:23 pm PDT

04/20 "I Love Myself!"

Quote From: debjanhan

PLEASE DR. PHIL ... I would be DELIGHTED to have Shannon come and live with me ... in our home ... away ... FARRRR AWAY TO THOSE PEOPLE SHE WAS BORN TO! ... SHAME ON THAT ENTIRE FAMILY! ... SHAME ON THEM! ... 

It would not matter what Shannon's problems are ... how big or small ... I would love her unconditioinally ... as a human being, for Goodness sake! ... I would do everything in my power to show her love and consideration and understanding ... I would NOT label her ever! ... except to say that she is a beautiful young woman who deserves to know what it feels like to be loved! 

SHAME ON THAT AWFUL STEP MOTHER!!!!! ... SHAME ON THAT WOMAN! ... SHAME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

AND THE FATHER! ... Shame on them both! ... I am so horribly sickened by the lack of love or any feeling whatsoever from them to "his" daughter! ... Shame on them ... for so many things! 

I would love to give Shannon a chance at life ... FARRRRRRR AWAY FROM THEM ... IN A LOVING HOME! ... If those people ever regret what they've done to her up to this point, I would hope that if Shannon could be surrounded by the love she so deserves, that she would one day be able to forgive them ... and love them, in spite of themselves! ... 

And by the way, I have not been manipulated by Shannon ... I see her behavior ... I see she needs and wants help ... REAL HELP ... I also see a bright, loving, kind, caring, young lady who would like for one minute to feel that she fits in ... 

Shannon would "fit in" and be loved by me and almost anyone I know ... anyone with a heart! 

I love Shannon, and I will pray for peace for her ...  

and for a change of heart on her biological father and stepmother's part ... 

I WANT TO HELP SHANNON! ... I HOPE SHE CAN FEEL THE LOVE WHEN I PRAY FOR HER! 

AMEN ME TOO!  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 20, 2006, 1:24 pm PDT

04/20 "I Love Myself!"

  

I must say that after watching that show I hope that I will never be like that father and step-mother. I feel really bad for Shannon and for the father and sister. The poor dad just wants someone to share his life with and he is trying to help out Shannon, but he's doing it all wrong all because of Hilary. I do understand that Shannon should not act the way she does, but it is true that no one helped her grieve for her mother. I am 18 years old and I was just thinking to myself 'what if my mother died and my father met someone and remarried so soon and that person decided that she didn't like to way the house looked and all the things my mother loved and she took them down, I started balling right then and there! I cannot even imagine how hard it must have been for both Shannon and her sister. I am really outraged on what both the father and step mother said about not sheding a tear if she died, that would make me feel just HORRIBLE and I cannot believe they said that! You call that good parenting? It is completely obvious that the household environment that Shannon is in, is not good at all. Just look at how she was with that other couple, with people who didn't spoil her but actually treated her with kindness and respect. Anyway, I would LOVE to see a follow up on this story, definitely and I really hope the parents and Shannon realize that they all need help and they get and become a good family. If not, then Shannon you need to just move out of there maybe and get on with your life.  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 20, 2006, 1:24 pm PDT

04/20 "I Love Myself!"

Quote From: nasale

 And saying things like this is adding to the problem.Are YOU perfect? Obviously, not! Start with your OWN share of this!
I am only assuming that this message was coming from the  family, because no one else really knows the girl. I have 2 things 1 obviously someone else had her live with her and had no problems besides regular teenage things, which I agree if you think fighting and acting crazy with a sibling is not normal you have something wrong.

Second thing that I would like to say is that clearly no one agrees with the parents and the way they have approached this whole thing....it kinda reminds me of  "It takes two" when the mom wants to ship the kid off to boarding school because she is in the way.

Oh but wait maybe I should re-think this all because maybe I have been maniulated by this master mind Shannon!! Wow shes sooo good she has manipulated everyone on this board and Dr. Phill so maybe she will make millions with her master manipulations!! LOL
 

Message Emote
blank
April 20, 2006, 1:25 pm PDT

Can you explain this?????

Dr. Phil was adamant about a person behaving totally different in two situations, and that since Shannon was wonderful with Jennifer and in other situations away from her family, it must be the fault of the family.    

   

My father was an abuser, physically, mentally etc.  BUT out in public with either friends or the rest of his own family who he worshipped, he was the epitome of what a kind and loving father should be.  Of course, he was neither.    So I guess it was my mother's fault and also mine.  After all I'm sure a 3 year old deserves to be beaten.  After my father and mother passed away, I told people about our life.  To salvage what little I had left of my self-esteem, I refused to listen any longer to the false image he perpetuated to everyone.  Many of them still don't believe it and think I am lying because he was so conniving and cunning.  I'm surprised Dr. Phil that you couldn't see through Shannon more than you did.  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 20, 2006, 1:26 pm PDT

Power Play

My reaction to this show was horror.  The father seemed to me to be a passive fellow who rushed into another relationship.  The step mother seemed like a controlling cold-hearted witch.  It is clear who is in charge in that house.  The step mother seemd to be more like the narcissistic person she tried to paint Shannon as.  Hillary was one of the most unappealing people I've ever seen.  Run for your lives!
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
April 20, 2006, 1:26 pm PDT

I don't get it

Perhaps I missed something, but I really didn't hear anything so terrible that Shannon has done. Everything they said seemed to fall under the normal category of children growing up. Children do wrong things and parents teach them to do better. Some children are more challenging than others. She has not been arrested, there is no drug problem, she is not promiscuous. Shannon and her sister argue, but it seems that only Shannon only bares the responsibilty for that.  If she has done worse, why didn't the parents bring it up?  

She is working. She is going to college. Okay, she is not doing well in college, but hardly the first one to have a bad start in college.  

I just don't get it. What has this child done that is so wrong that her family would turn agaisnt her?  

  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 20, 2006, 1:26 pm PDT

School In Mexico

I would just like to share with anyone who is interested that I have been to a school in mexico that was based on the same principles. I do not know if it is the same one. I too did not get a phone call with my parents for one year. I was there for a total of two years and three months. I just graduated in February. I did transfer to a school in Iowa which is based on the same principles. The school I was at in Mexico was Casa By The Sea. The school I was at in Iowa was Midwest Academy. And I would like to let everybody know that I would not change a single thing about those two years. It worked for me. Ofcourse I did not like being there at first. But the end result was genuine love for my family and my self. It takes completion of all of the levels and a want to change in order to make it work. But the rules are there for a reason. I just want you to know that Dr. Phil was speaking from  a lack of knowledge in this case. The boarding schools are great things if the parents believe in them and the kids actually want to change. I think their problem really came when they pulled their daughter from the program. This showed the young woman that her parents were weak. Or at least that's how I think she interpreted it. Then she was able to do whatever she wanted because she used this weakness against her parents. For anyone who is affiliated with the programs I am talking about, please for your sake and for your kids sake, don't take what Dr.Phil said about the programs seriously. He does not know about the methods that they use. I do. I have been through all six levels and am successfully sober now at home. It has made changes in my life that I cannot even begin to explain. I hope whoever reads this will feel the truth in it.  

   

   Much Love,  

     Funone  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 20, 2006, 1:27 pm PDT

What...?

     This is my first post on the Dr. Phil site. I have been watching the show for alittle over a year now, and i must say that he is the only person I have seen on tv who actually seems to care about the people he works with, and not just because it's his job. And thats just wonderful.
The only thing i don't know how he can hold himself back and not just punch some people out...

   For example. I am only 18, I have no kids, but, one thing that really struck me as odd was how a parent could just disown their child in any matter, or under any circumtance.
  I don't think that Shannon has any type of disorder...
I think that she has some anger, i didn't catch her age, but doesn't every teenager go through an annoying i'm so wonderful, it's all about me stage? and if you think not, i think you're wrong. I am just getting out of stage.. the "badass" stage so to speak. If my mother were to die, i would be completely ticked off if some women came into MY house and decided, 'oh hell, i'm just going to take down everything and anything that reminds you of your mother'  THEN go and tell me we're going on a vacation and drop me in mexico? haha whats that? i'm sure that move is definatly going to help her attitude, i know it would help mine *rolls eyes*
And through all of this how could the father of such a beautiful young lady just sit there and let his new wife do that to his daughter? If you ask me that takes all his manly-ness away.

Don't get me wrong, i'm sure that Shannon could be a real brat when she wanted to be... but wouldn't you? and to try and make her feel as though she has some type of disorder is just completely uncalled for.

when will people learn...
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
April 20, 2006, 1:28 pm PDT

How did those adults become so stupid and blind?

From the beginning of this poor girl's life, people have been choosing OTHER people over her.  She's felt 'disgarded' and abandoned over and over.  There's no wonder she fights for attention and love.  She was replaced by the 'baby' sister, then Dad chose the step-mom over her, and then they abandoned her to some kind of gestappo type of behavioral school and left her there for a YEAR!  If that isn't child abuse, what would you call it?  Her behaviour IS unacceptable.  She has not learned how to 'blend' into the family unit, but then, they haven't exactly made her welcome into that family, have they?  The step-mom IS a huge problem.  She has obviously seen Shannon as a threat of some kind and she goes out of her way to make everyone else see her as 'evil'.   Wait until they begin therapy where the step-mom isn't involved.  She's going sabotage this whole plan because she isn't the one in 'charge' now.  Poor Shannon.  While her behaviour is terrible, she is the victim here.  Did anyone think to get her help when her mother died?  Did Dad think 6 months might be a little early to bring a new woman into this girl's life, or was he much more concerned with himself, his needs and the fact that he wanted help to bring up his daughters?  SHAME on HIM!
 
First | Prev | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | Next | Last