Message Boards

Topic : 07/06 Baby Wars

Number of Replies: 7225
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, April 13, 2006, 01:22:17 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 04/21/06) Being a parent is hard enough, but what happens when Mom and Dad can't agree on how many kids to have, how to raise 'em and how to get ‘em to sleep?  Sometimes, it can lead to an all-out baby war! Matt's baby battle ended up in front of a judge and made headlines. He was ordered to pay child support for the baby he had with his ex-girlfriend, but he says he shouldn't have to cough up the money because she told him she wasn't able to get pregnant, and he told her he didn't want to be a father. He, his attorney, and the director of the National Center for Men discuss the lawsuit they filed, known as “Roe v. Wade for Men,” arguing that men should have a constitutional right to avoid fatherhood. Next, Dan says even though he and his wife, Lisa, already have four children, he wants just one more. Lisa has been pregnant on and off for 11 years and says she's closed for baby business. Will Dr. Phil help Dan see Lisa's point that four is enough? Then, a frustrated husband is camping out on the roof of his house and living in a tent. He refuses to go back to his bedroom until his wife moves their kids out of their bed and starts paying more attention to him. Can Dr. Phil get him to come down the ladder? Plus, a sleep expert has a simple method for getting your child to sleep through the night. See the plan in action! Share advice and talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More July 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
April 21, 2006, 9:54 am PDT

Little Elizabeth

Dr Phil brings out and excellent point - WHAT ABOUT ELIZABETH?  IS ANY ONE THINKING ABOUT HER?  

  

Sadly I must say, NOT THE FATHER!  The mother in this case was not on the show and I think that she made a wise choice.  If she had come on the show she may have felt attacked or less of a mother for being the only one in the situation thinking about the baby and what it takes to rear one in todays society.  She is not asking for the money because she made an independent choice. She did not lay down and become spontaneously pregnant alone.  She is asking the man that provided the DNA to also give her help and assistance in raising this beautiful girl.   

If we took away the money aspect all together what are we left with in this case as we know the facts to be???  A mother who wants a FATHER AND DAD to her child.  There is nothing more pure and wholesome in this life than the love a child brings to the family.  He always had a choice but it is unfortunate that he gets to throw a tantrum, like a 2 year old, and we are forced to see this on a national stage.   

He made his choice period.  Now, the end result is that he fathered a child.  Do you think it is OK to let someone go free who chose to kill his neighbor or friend?  This is no different.  He made his choice and now he is trying to run from the inevitable consequences of that choice.  He is a coward.  Real men stand up after they lie down. SEX=Parenthood period.  If everyone thought of it in this way, maybe things like this would not be happening and the cycle would not be perpetuated. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
April 21, 2006, 9:54 am PDT

Correction...

Quote From: mtnesbound

I'm just wondering why Mr. "That Dog Won't Hunt" didn't advise his guest (Matt) to keep his pants up!  He (Matt) should thank his lucky stars that he's not facing bankrolling another 'life [or death sentence' like HIV, Aides, or any number of other STD's.  Incidentally, both Matt and his paramour should be tested for STD's as soon as possible if they haven't been already.   

   

Entrappment is deplorable (if that's even what happened).  It does not, however, negate the fact that Matt should step up to his responsibilities...  His "baby's momma" apparently has.  He will never actually 'see' his daughter, however, until he finds the wheretowithall to take the focus off himself.   

   

This just underlines that fact that there is no such thing as "casual sex." Sex was intended to be enjoyed within the confounds of a happy and healthy marriage... That's MARRIAGE, not "relationship."     

   

For those of you who are as anal-retentiive about syntax, spelling, etc as I am... Despite evidence to the contrary, I am aware that Auto Immune Deficiency Syndrome is AIDS.  "Aides" pick up your dry cleaning, and screen your calls.
 

Message Emote
blank
April 21, 2006, 9:55 am PDT

04/21 Baby Wars

Quote From: poodlepink

 But why would she say she was on birth control and couldn't get pregnant? That's very odd behavior and can't be overlooked. It's not okay to do that. It just like saying if your boyfriend says he's had a vasectomy, you shouldn't trust him. In truth, he shouldn't be lying.  

Why do you assume she was lying? 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 21, 2006, 9:56 am PDT

04/21 Baby Wars

As a women who also couldn't get pregnant, my fiancee and i got pregnant last feburary. We know have a 5 month old baby boy.So I know how it feels when you do get pregnant and you thought you couldn't. If you didn't want to be a dad or even the chance DONT HAVE SEX!!!!! OR PERTECT YOURSELF!!!!! Now that you have a child be a man, you don't know how much you are hurting your child, especially when she grows up she will hate you!! You are not punishing your ex you are hurting your child. For the single mom's out their you keep your chin up, your child is the best thing in the world and you will be rewarded in the end   

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
April 21, 2006, 9:56 am PDT

Let's talk reality

First, let me say that all children born into this world are apart of God's creation. Concerning the discussion of Mark and his not wanting to be a father, I'm not on either side. In a relationship, one component of the relationship is trust. He believed his girlfriend could not and would not concieve, neverthelss she did  become pregnant. If she altered her birth control in some way, I do feel that Matt was mislead. And if that is the case, she should not force him against his will to be a father. I understand that he chose to have unprotected sex with her, but in some relationships, if a contraceptive is being used, who does use condoms? Truthfully? That's what's happening in a lot of societies; women know that their significant other absolutely does not want children, and she does her best to become pregnant anyway and then wants to cry and complain when the father doesn't want any thing to do with her or the child. If she knows the man doesn't want children before she has sex with him, just don't do it because in the end the mother would be the carrier of most the responsibility. That's where single parent homes and poverty, and sometimes juvenile delinquency begins. Contrary to this, God has a plan for every life, and when He decides to bring life into the world, it's an amazing thing, and whosoever does not choose to be apart of the creation, doesn't understand the meaning of life. This is why it's so important to SAVE SEX FOR MARRIAGE!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 21, 2006, 9:57 am PDT

04/21 Baby Wars

Quote From: kimike

The only thing I have to say on this is when 2 ppl get together they know the risks involved and should a woman become pregnant and choose not to keep the child then she should've been more responsible. I don't agree with abortion unless it's rape related or family related.  

 As I said in many of my replies to avoid these situations just choose 1 partner for life.........God didn't want us to sleep with many different ppl he wants marriage and children.......thats the way it should be PERIOD  

 I would like to bring up a matter of a diffrent shade of this green topic of male rights. As a woman who could never have children of my own, but dearly loves her step children as much as their father does, I take every means to relate and communicate with the mother of these dear children. I would like to know how anyone could not want to support a child monitarily, mentaly, or otherwise. BUT.... (And here it goes!!!!) If a couple decide to have children TOGETHER then it is a TOGETHER journey. Let's say the mother decides to bail from this jorney. She meets another man and wants to be with him and devorce her spouse. Does she have a right to make the ex-husband pay for her mistakes? After all SHE made the dicision to break up the family and cleave to another. Is this fair and just to all??? He is all for suporting his children, never late and never behind with his support, ALWAYS spends every moment possible with them and yet broke while she has 3 incomes. His, her Boyfriends and her own. There is no tax breaks or even any kind of fairness in child support matters, not even the slightest bit of a break for the men who are not dead beats. Again I ask... Is this fair and just for all????? 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
angry
April 21, 2006, 9:58 am PDT

great points!

Quote From: powers009

Why is it we want to assume he was lied to by the girl. What if she was telling the truth as related by the doctor who told her and he/she (the doctor) was wrong as sometimes they are. Then maybe Matt and the girl should sue the doctor for child support. But I don't see that case making it very far in court either. Maybe they could sue the birth control pill maker for child support but the court will probably tell them you knew that birth control pills are not 100% effective so you must take responsibility for your actions. HEY WHAT A NOVEL IDEA TAKING RESPONSIBILITY FOR YOUR ACTIONS NEVER THOUGHT OF THAT ONE.
all very great points. i don't know either of these people but i think it's ridiculous to assume that the woman lied to him. there is NO 100% effective method of birth control, not even sterilization (I personally have a close friend who had her tubes tied and STILL got preggers!) and doctors are not infallible beings. if Matt was serious about not wanting to be a father then he shouldn't have had sex, period. he made his decision at that point as a child can always be the result of sex, regardless of whatever precautions are being taken or level of "safety" assumed there is still that possibility. he's not even taking responsibility for his decision to have sex by blaming her and saying, oh she told me she couldn't get pregnant! give me a break. what a small, sniveling, irresponsible little boy he came off as. grow up and take some responsibility for your decision to have sex!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 21, 2006, 9:58 am PDT

Wrong

Quote From: scriptr

It seems to me that Matt opened his mouth and lost his case.  Matt said to Dr. Phil that a condom also isn't always reliable.  True.  Since he knew when he had sex with his girlfriend that a condom wasn't 100% effective and he absolutely did not want to be a father at that time, perhaps he shouldn't have had sex with his girlfriend.  Her claim that she was on birth control and also could not get pregnant has little relevance if you believe him when he says that he was clear about not wanting to have a child.  They both assumed the risk of pregnancy when they had consentual sex.

Except... that SHE had a bunch of escape hatches, means by which to VOID her parental responsibilities... Its sexist to give such, especially when several are NON biological, and NON 

medical, to women ONLY... 

Saying that " both assumed the risk... " requires one to be BLIND to all the women ONLY POST-coital choices that let HER out of that risk. 

Risks for men, rights for women... thats what WomenFirsters call " equal right ". Ptui. 

" Her body, her choice... HER *responsibility* ! ". 

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 21, 2006, 10:00 am PDT

I could hug your neck

Quote From: sandra1955

Matt has a right to not be lied too. She told him she could not get pregnant. He took her at her word. She knew that he did not want to be a father at that time. So she also had a responsibility that if there was a minute possibility that she could get pregnant that she should had insisted that he wear a condom.   

   

My husband lived with that same lie. She said she couldn't get pregnant. She did and he married her to do the right thing......three children were born. He loves his kids and supports them. The youngest will be 17 in Aug.    

She left him for another man after 10 years of marriage...and left all three kids with him for 3 years. Then she took the youngest one. Never paid any child support for the two oldest. My husband pay child support for the youngest. This has gone on for the last 9 years.   

He was taken to the cleaners..........she is on easy street.   

   

I have never had children because I did have a medical condition that prevented me fom it. It has resulted in a Hysteroctomy.   

   

I believe a lot of women get pregnent to "hook" the man. She has all the power!   

   

I hope Matt wins his case.....but I fear he will not. That will be a sad day for men.  

My husband's first wife did the same thing.  They had been dating a while and she was on the pill she quit taking the pill without telling anyone because she wanted a baby to play with and show off.  She didn't plan on my husband offering to marry her.  They were married less than two years.  This beautiful little girl has no memory of her parent's ever being married. 

The ex wife admits getting pregnant on purpose.  But she says "I was young" as if that explains everything.   

It was VERY selfish of this woman to keep this baby when she KNEW the father didn't want anything to do her.  If she didn't believe in abortion, then how about adoption.  Everyone is jumping on Matt's head at least HE was honest, kids aren't for everyone.  My husband didn't want a baby and he didn't have to "do the right thing" but he did.  Matt has a right to feel the way he does. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 21, 2006, 10:01 am PDT

Should Father's be able to opt out of fatherhood?

NO!  why should men have the pleasure of sex and then when the woman gets pregnant they bail out!  Not fair at all.  If they do not want children then don't have sex!!!!  The poor child, how fair is that to them.  How selfish can you be to deny your own child!  Growup and take on the responsibility!  Also, many woman have gotten pregnant when they have been told they couldn't.  Has the father led such a shelter life that he didn't know that it is sometimes possible to get pregnant when you are told you can't !  They usually call these miracle babies!  The child looses in the end.  Think of the child...what if his father did this to him and he grew up without a dad, how would he have felt!?  

 
First | Prev | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | 53 | 54 | 55 | 56 | 57 | Next | Last