Message Boards

Topic : 08/07 Big Burden

Number of Replies: 366
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, April 21, 2006, 10:21:06 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 04/27/06) Morbid obesity changes the dynamic of two entire families … and tears them apart. DeeDee weighs over 700 pounds and hasn't left her house in more than a year. She has become a burden to her friends and family by constantly demanding their help and company. Is DeeDee ready to get real and make a change, or will she continue to blame her weight gain on other circumstances? Also, her children explain why they resent their mother and feel hostage to her demands. Then, MaLynn is only 14 years old, but she already weighs 419 pounds, and her obesity is causing problems in school. Her mother, Shari, admits she can't say no to her daughter when it comes to food. Dr. Phil shows MaLynn how she can easily lose 86 pounds, and he gets this mother-daughter team to work together to save their relationship and their lives. Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More August 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.


Message Emote
blank
April 27, 2006, 10:09 pm PDT

04/27 Big Burden

Quote From: mswing10

I don't think DD's son should be her "Drill Sergent" with this deal.  If he does, and she fails, he'll become her next spider to blame.   

I grew up with a fat, lazy, manipulative mother too.  She got the bipass surgury and is now thin, lazy, and manipulative.  Not once did this mother apologize to her kids for the abuse she made them suffer.  I hope she has a wake up call about that too. 

I'm only going by what I saw but I didn't see this woman as bad or evil. I saw her as someone who was in deeeeeeeeeeeep denial and that denial justified a lot of bad things.

This woman seemed loving though. Like I said, I don't know her.  But I think that this family has a really good chance of staying bonded and they can turn that bond around into good.

She may appolgize someday when she's ready. And her kids might too. This family is going through a very very horrible nightmare, we only saw a split second of their world.

She did not abuse her kids...she has a lot of emotional problems. Parent are NOT perfect, even when you have off spring you continue to be a human being with faults.

I liked Dee Dee...I can't put my finger on it but she seem to have an inner light. I don't normally say that about people either. I hope she pulls through because I think she has more to offer the world then this.
 

Message Emote
hopeful
April 27, 2006, 10:16 pm PDT

Topic : 04/27 Big Burden

Quote From: mgilman

Hello my name is MaLynn and i was the fourteen year old that was on the show and i love the fact that i can get on here and see so many supporter!!!!!  i hope that all of you enjoyed the show and are having a good day!!!  

   

MaLynn  

MaLynn,           I didn't get to see the show, but I did read your story.   I hope you overcome your obstacles and got yourself started to a heathier life  :).  Good luck with everything!
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
frustrated
April 27, 2006, 10:44 pm PDT

I know how DeeDee feels.

  I was surprised to hear DeeDee say her Dr. just would'nt hear what she was saying. The same thing is happening to me. I've fought my weight every day of my 58 yrs. and did manage to keep it down to 150 until I became diabetic 20yrs ago. I quickly ballooned to 238. Then I had a heart attack I was unaware of and went up another 50lbs. I can't get much exercise so I can't loose weight even though I believe I am eating very healthy and all other indicators say the same. I have begged 3 different Drs. to help me put together a plan that would work for me. I get answers like, " It's just almost impossible with diabetes", " It's awful hard to loose weight." It's no wonder we have a little self pity going. We can't get help! I wish DeeDee and her family good things in the future, now that Dr. Phil has heard you, put all you have into it. This is your chance to take control of your futures. To the kids: Your Mother knows you love her, and she will know it even if you say no to her! Get going on your new lives.
 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
April 27, 2006, 10:45 pm PDT

MaLynn you are beautiful

Quote From: mgilman

Hello my name is MaLynn and i was the fourteen year old that was on the show and i love the fact that i can get on here and see so many supporter!!!!!  i hope that all of you enjoyed the show and are having a good day!!!  

   

MaLynn  

MaLynn...you were so courageous to go on Dr. Phil and tell it all.  I am 42 but I was very heavy all my life up until I was 37 when I had surgery.  I was 415 lbs that day and had been for many years.  I wish I'd had the help at your age so I could have done it sooner and not wasted so many years focused on my size.  I applaude your energy and spirit! I wanted you to know that I and I'm sure others would say the same are here if you have a hard day and need extra encouragement or someone to vent to. We're here and totally plugged into helping you succeed!  Just remember you're not alone...I for one know exactly how you are feeling and if I can ever help you all you need to do is say so!  Congrats on your success so far!  You're beautiful and I think you will achieve whatever you set out to do! 

  

Aj 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
April 27, 2006, 10:47 pm PDT

People are kinder than you think

Quote From: lgizmo1400

I understand what both of you are saying. You don't just gain 300lbs over night. It happens from being inactive. In 2000 I found out I was pregnant and quite my job because the environment was not healthy for me to be in during my prenancy. I ended up staying home and I am still a stay at home mom. Since then I have gained at least 100lbs since then, most was with my pregancy and I have not been able to loose it. I am a very active person I think. I just have a very crappy metablosim. I have thought about the gastric by pass surgery, but to me that is like cheating on a test it is taking the easy way if I can't loose it now whose to say after the surgery I won't gain it all back and then have had to go through this procedure for nothing. For me if I were to try to go to a gym I would be afraid of all the THIN people laughing at me while I was trying to work out. Being made fun of for trying to loose weight is not a motivativor.
 I too was an overweight , stay-at-home mom, but I have began working out and I have lost 80 pounds in 6 months, and have kept it off for five years.   But, what I wanted to tell you is that you CAN go to the gym!  My best friend was well over 400 lbs.  when I talked her into going to the gym with me.   At first she was scared, but she is very friendly and people cannot help but love her.  She gets so much love and support from most of the people who work out there, and no longer concerns herself with the rest.  I am completely in awe of her courage, and her progress.  She has lost almost two hundred pounds, by watching calories, and excercising faithfully.  She is in such good shape now that we are planning a hiking trip this summer.  At one time I too was self conscious about going to the gym, but I knew that not going to work out was going to result in my being even more self conscious in the long run.  You say that you are a stay-at-home mom, so I am sure you are an active person.  Do you take time to do anything for yourself outside the home without your family?  Having female friends to go and do things with and share with is so important!  When we were younger and had small children we would always go out to eat.  Now we do things together that cause us to get out and move and we are spurred on by one another.  Whenever one of us wants to quit,  someone will reach a milestone, or drop us a card and we are suddenly inspired to keep going!  Movement and friendship are an unbeatable combination for lifting your spirits as well as your metabolism, and you will have so much more energy for your kids and husband!  Don't have surgery yet, give the gym a try first I think you will be surprised at how wonderful you will feel after the first two weeks.
 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
April 27, 2006, 10:51 pm PDT

Touched my heart

I just finished watching the show and I was moved to tears by both Dee Dee and MaLynn.  I instantly liked them both and hope they find success in their journey.  I used to weigh 415 lbs and I felt for them both.  This wont' be an easy road for either of them but I have faith they are going to do it.  Does anyone know if there is anyway to send cards to them to offer encouragement and let them know they are not forgotten as the months go by??? 

  

Thanks 

AJ 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 27, 2006, 11:01 pm PDT

i'm so sorry :(

Quote From: mulana

I have been where  her children are.  The only problem is that it is too late for me to help my mother.  My mother died a little over a month ago, weighing over 600lbs, and that is just a guess because our hospital has nothing large enough to weigh her.   My mother was a wonderful caring person.  I miss her so much I can't even express it. 

in 37 years (how long her and my father were married untill she died) my mother went from wieghing 140 to 600lbs.  Almost 2 years ago in June we had our first scare.  She almost died cause her sugar was over 1000 and we had no clue she was diabetic. When she went in it took 6 men to get her in the ambulance and then she was transported to a hospital where they could take care of someone her size and that is where we found out she was about 570lbs.  It was a long road to get her back home, She left the hospital weighing 470.  She had lost 100lbs. She was doing great, but then it started again, She became a hurmit. Stayed in her bedroom all the time, my father making her meals and bringing them too her.  It got so bad to the end that she would be calling us kids to come over and do things as simple as get her lunch or get her insulin for her because she could not walk out to th litchen which is abouta 50ft walk.  She had gain back all her wieght plus more sence leaving the hospital.

The day she died it took 8 men to get her in the ambulance.  And later I found out that they had to call the fire department in to remove her from the hospital to the funeral home.  We cremated her because the casket would have been to expensive cause it would have had to been specialy made for her and triple the size.  My mother never liked people looking at her anyways so it was the best thing for her.

I guess my point is that she needs to do something today because there may not be a tomorrow. My mother could have had many more years with us if she would have done more to lose the weight. And this mother needs to do more so she can be there for her children and grandchildren.  My youngest was 7 months old when she pasted and will never get to know what a wonderful grandmother he had. But I am sure going to tell her how much she loved her.  I

Walking into the hospital that night I was thinking that this is it, I am not going to stand by anymore and let her kill herself , I was going to tell her she needed to do something and she needed to do it now, but it was too late. I never had that chance, but these kids do.  I really hope she takes Dr. Phils help now, before it is too late.

I'm so sorry for your loss. That must have been so difficult and must have been really difficult to watch the show. While I was watching the show I myself was tearing up a little. I felt really bad for all them. One of my best friends who i've known since I was three, her sister is morbidly obese. I've known her sister since she was born (as she was younger). When she was 6 months old she started gaining a tremendous amount of weight. At age 3 she was very overweight. Through the years she just kept gaining weight. The thing is her whole family is really thin. They took her to all these doctors and could not find anything wrong. They didnt know why she was gaining all this weight. By 3 though, she was overeating. My friend would want a box of donuts so she would hide it under her bed from her sister, (so my friend could eat it in small portions at her leisure over a normal period of time), but her sister would find the donuts and eat the whole box in one sitting. I just wonder what would cause a 3 year old to eat so much at such a young age. I know her family had a lot of issues espeically with a mentally disordered dad and a mom who just never really had it together.  

My friend's sister is now 18, she just had the gastric bypass she did lose about 80 pounds, but she was supposed to lose more than that. And I think she has begun gaining a little weight. (She started at around 400-500 lbs). I feel so bad for her cuz I know her family situation really hasnt gotten better, I hope one day she gets out on her own and gets herself and her emotions healthy.  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 27, 2006, 11:21 pm PDT

you are so sweet

Quote From: mgilman

Hello my name is MaLynn and i was the fourteen year old that was on the show and i love the fact that i can get on here and see so many supporter!!!!!  i hope that all of you enjoyed the show and are having a good day!!!  

   

MaLynn  

You are a sweet girl. I coudl tell right away from the show. I wish you all the success and best of luck! :)
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 28, 2006, 12:27 am PDT

Very courageous

I think the people on this show were very courageous to go on national television and face the issue of weight head on --especially the 14 year old girl.  The world, in general, (and *especially* high school kids) is not very kind to heavy people...why?  I don't know.  Do people think that heavy people do not have feelings, a heart beating inside their chest?  It does seem like the general public likes to blame heavy people for the condition of their own bodies --and don't get me wrong -- I'm not saying that someone who is overweight has no responsibility in that, but let's also look at it another way (I had a doctor point this out to me one time).  Everybody is different.  If you took 100 people in the same basic height/weight range, fed them all the same exact diet, made them do the same exact amount of exercise ...after a year, would all those people have *exactly* the same shaped bodies?  Be exactly the same weight?  No, they would not.  People *are* different, and those differences must be taken into account.  While everybody should try to maintain an appropriate weight to height ratio, we must deal with the fact that not everybody is going to be supermodel thin, no matter what they do. 
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
hopeful
April 28, 2006, 12:28 am PDT

YOU ARE NOT ALONE

Quote From: amillman

MaLynn...you were so courageous to go on Dr. Phil and tell it all.  I am 42 but I was very heavy all my life up until I was 37 when I had surgery.  I was 415 lbs that day and had been for many years.  I wish I'd had the help at your age so I could have done it sooner and not wasted so many years focused on my size.  I applaude your energy and spirit! I wanted you to know that I and I'm sure others would say the same are here if you have a hard day and need extra encouragement or someone to vent to. We're here and totally plugged into helping you succeed!  Just remember you're not alone...I for one know exactly how you are feeling and if I can ever help you all you need to do is say so!  Congrats on your success so far!  You're beautiful and I think you will achieve whatever you set out to do! 

  

Aj 

Just want to tell you I can truly relate to your story.In 1988 my daughter graduated High School weighing in at 350.She was very alone and had even considered suicide.Unfortunately I was exactly like your Mom,never could say no or deny her of anything.She was 6'1 and was called everything from Lard Ass to Kumala which was about a 400 lb wrestler.After graduation I decided I had to do something.At the time I lived in Longview Tx but I heard of a Dr.in Houston,Dr.Marcel Molina which did a gastric segmentation not like the by-passes today.Hes the only Dr in the US that does .He pulls your stomach up and places a  Teflon Band around it so you can only have an intake of 6-8 oz but its the greatest thing I ever done for her.After 2 years I also had it done.I WAS 42 at that time and wish we had bothhad it done sooner.She lost 147 lbs and I lost 78 lbs.We now are members of a Gym and live to eat instead of eating to live .I wish you much Luck and Success.Please remember lots of people care about you.Judy Cooper  
 
First | Prev | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | Next | Last