Topic : Debating Among Different Religious Beliefs

Number of Replies: 63541
New Messages This Week: 609
Last Reply On:
Created on : Saturday, April 22, 2006, 09:13:50 am
Author : xoxo19

The purpose of this board is to debate your views about a particular religion or belief. I understand Religion is a touchy subject, but this board is designed for you to ask questions as well as present arguments for your particular Religion or belief.

 

You can definitely challenge others, but no calling others names. Feel free to debate away.


Join the new Dr. Phil Community! Currently in BETA, the new Dr. Phil Community will allow you to personalize your message board experience. Start by creating your user profile here.

For help and FAQs on the new BETA Community, please click here.

User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
blank
May 5, 2006, 10:11 am PDT

Debating Among Different Religious Beliefs

Quote From: hazel_eyes

 

"However, being that he never claimed to be God - I do not think Christ was God.  And when he said "son of God" he was talking about all mankind being a son of God." 

  

John 10:30 - Jesus said He was part of God. He said, "I and my Father are one." 

  

Exodus 3:14 -God identifies Himself to Moses by calling himself "I AM." Twice Jesus refers to Himself as the "I AM." Those around him knew exactly what he was saying and they were greatly offended.  

  

"Jesus said unto them, Verily verily, I say you, before Abraham was, I am. Then they took up stones to cast at him …" (John 8:58, 59a) "Whom seek ye? They answered him, Jesus of Nazareth. Jesus saith unto them I am he. As soon as he said unto them, I am he, they went backward, and fell to the ground." (John 18:4b, 5, 6) 

  

Revelation 1:8 -18 -Jesus said, he is the Almighty Lord. The following is a vision John had of Jesus. Verses 2, 13, 17,18 identify Jesus as the: 

(v 2) "… testimony of Jesus Christ …"(v 8) "I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the ending, saith the Lord, who is, and who was, and who is to come, the Almighty."(v 11) "Saying I am alpha and Omega, the first and the last…"(v 13) "And in the midst of the seven lamp stands, one like the Son of man …"(v 17b. 18a) "Fear not; I am the first and the last; I am he that liveth and was dead…" 

  

Isaiah 44:6 -In Rev 1:11, Jesus says He is the first and the last. Isa. 44:6 shows that the one who is "first and the last is actually God. "Thus saith the Lord, the King of Israel, and his redeemer, the Lord of host: I am the first, and I am the last, and beside me there is not God." 

  

Hebrews 1:8 -God the Father said Jesus was God.  

"Unto the Son he saith, Thy throne, O God, is forever and ever; a scepter of righteousness is the scepter of thy kingdom." 

  

Isaiah 9:6 -Jesus (the Messiah) is called the Mighty God.  

"For unto us a child is born, unto us a son is given, and the government shall be upon his shoulder; and his name shall be called Wonderful, Counselor, The Mighty God, the Everlasting Father, the Prince of Peace." 

  

Matthew 1:23 -Jesus is called Immanuel, which means "God with us."  

"Behold, the virgin shall be with child, and shall bring forth a son, and they shall call his name Immanuel, which, being interpreted, is God with us." 

  

"… stand before the Judgment Seat of Christ. For it is written, As I live saith the Lord, every knee shall bow to me and every tongue shall confess to God." (Romans 14:10b, 11)  

"That at the name of Jesus every knee should bow … and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord." (Philippians 2:10a,11a)  

  

John 5:23 -We have to honor Jesus that same way as God the Father.  

"That all men should honor the Son, even as they honor the Father. He that honoreth not the Son honoreth not the Father who hath sent him." 

  

  

  

  

OK...allow me to deconstruct all of your arguments

John 10:30 refers to us all being made of "God stuff". Taken in proper context he is not saying he IS God but is OF God.  A big distinction.

Exodous, John 18, : Jesus was an Essene, and Essenes (the originators of what is now Kabbalism) often referred to each other as "I am" - to acknowlege the God within us all.

Revelation: When I say Jesus never claimed to be God I refer clearly to the gospels.  Paul says Jesus was God, John says Jesus was God but JESUS never says Jesus was God.

Issaiah: This is taken way out of context.  Somehow a verse proclaiming the oneness of God is used to prove the threeness of God?

Mathew: Note the wording "God with us" God is in us, God was in Jesus - this is the core of Gnostic Christianity. To parapharase Carl Sagan (peace be unto him) "We are all made of Starstuff"

Phillipians: again, this is Paul claiming Jesus was God. Not Jesus claiming such.

John: again this can be interpreted in a Gnostic fashion, or that the messenger of God must be honored.  There are many times Elijah is asked to be honored as God is - does that mean Elijah was God too?


 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
May 5, 2006, 1:12 pm PDT

Debating Among Different Religious Beliefs

Quote From: hazel_eyes

  

Nice tapdance.  You "attach the poor pity me syndrome to Christians", but that's not judging or labeling???   

  

Thank you for the apology to whoever it was for, but to "point out" or "single out" Christians is unfair.  (Watch the news), There are many Muslims who are really feeling pity right now, many Earth worshippers who are feeling pity right now, and a whole bunch of athiests who boo hoo every day because we have a Christian president and everything with the word God or Jesus hasn't been removed fast enough from every visible place, etcetera.   

  

Perhaps you hear alot more from Christians because you work with more Christians than any other religious denomination.  Perhaps you work with Christians who are not exercising their faith in the scriptures (ie: weak Christians).  Maybe they're just exercising their right to protest the treatment that exists (removing the ten commandments from public places where they've been for years, taking the word God out of songs where it's been for years, threatening to remove God from our money where it's been for years, no bible study on break or lunch at work places or schools, no nativity scenes, or maybe they're just human and are going through a rough time with their families, children and work like the rest of the human population. 

  

Where do you stand?  What is your faith, belief, or denomination at this moment?  You seem to know about the life of Christ.  Are you a former Christian who feels that God let them down?  Or like I saw on another board a current Christian who uses hyperbole's (degrading language) to describe their own belief system, or like so many others on these boards, have you read multiple books on theories, thrillers, and fictional but facinating reading? 

  

Just curious.  Please don't take offense.   

  

My original quote was:  

"It is an interresting facet to this generation of religions and followers.  We truly have bred a generation of "poor pity me" humans.   Everyone seems to be persecuted for one reason or another by the "they" party who end up fitting the bill at the time. " 

I don't believe it was warrent of such a huge cloud of "lets attach the Christians" as you all have seem to have taken it.  It was a general statement in a forum which was to talk of all religions and faiths in a open light. 

As I have stated before I am Gnostic in my beleives if one must label my faith as anything.  If not just note that I am faithful to my beliefs as shown to me by life.  As for my choices in reading habits... what concern is it of yours?  Just curious... no offense taken but you seem to be fishing for a solid answer with weak questions.  I am honest enough to state who I am and what I am about even if I am not well in the verbage I always select, my meaning and point tend to get lost in translations. 

I work with all faith and religions not caring one wit to whom I am speaking with.  I do find if funny that one faith over all others are the people whom will state their faith during a business transaction that does not deal in faith.  I other words I don't hear Jews, Buddhists, Muslim  telling me of thier faith when purchasing a product or asking a question as often as I hear of those of another faith.  As stated before you would be AMAZED at what people will tell you ever the phone. 

  

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
May 5, 2006, 1:29 pm PDT

Misunderstand run rampt I see

Quote From: hazel_eyes

  

To single out Christians who pity themselves or play victim is judgemental on your part.  The same complaints and feeling of constant mistreatment can be said of these organizations and groups: 

  

Women 

Native Indians 

African Americans 

Jews 

Latinos 

           and so on 

  

Muslims 

Atheists 

Earth Worshippers 

Cults 

           and so on 

  

Their complaints are no more valid or more significant than a Christian's.  Each has a right to protest the treatment they believe to be unjust.  Each may have a valid reason for protesting, whinning or feeling mistreated.   

  

I stated that christians do feel vistim in response to comment Christians do not pity themselves.  Or some such matter.  I was just trying to show or demostrate a slight error on that train of thought.  No need to wash my face in information I already know.  If I was unclear before let me be clear now.    

I guess this forum might not be as open as I had hoped it to be about religions and faith.    

For the record... I am GNOSTIC my teaching of faith are my own chosing. I beleive ALL religions to be true if they are honest and open with God no matter what name they use to call him/her.  I believe that God is an all loving God and to but human beleifs on him/her is not honoring him at all.  God is without evil and loves ALL his Children (no matter the faith) equally.  WE will all return home upon or deaths in this life including Atheist, Muslims, Buddhist, Jews and Satan worshipers.  As long as they chose the light of God upon death.  WE have all lived for many years and lived several lifes at verious times.  We are eternal since our life is at home and this is just the teaching ground for enlightenment we would not receive back home.   Jesus is our brother not a God.  Judas is not a evil betrayer but an enlighten soul who knew his path in life as well as Jesus knew his.  And is also our brother.  

Anything else you would like to know.  

I am an open book.
  

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
May 5, 2006, 1:31 pm PDT

This town is full of them!

Quote From: hazel_eyes

  

There are many unstable individuals practicing religion these days.  Sounds like you're surrounded by a town of them.   

You're telling me! 

  

I have never lived in an area where the people are so depressed, angry, and down right rude!  These people have no idea what their kids are doing.  I go to the park and see the kid who's pushing the other kids or throwing things and then I look for the parent and there doesn't seem to be one!  Or they don't seem to care.  People drive so crazy, do they really need to ride my a** when I'm already going above the speed limit?!  I go to the store and can never get any help and when I do they don't seem to care either if what I need isn't in.  I'm going crazy!  These people are driving me nuts!  To top it off one-third of the kids don't graduate.  One-third!  That's huge!   

  

Okay, I feel a little better now.  I just find it funny that there are so many churches and no one is "happy" or treats anyone with respect.  I say "Hi" to someone and they look at me like I'm crazy.  We moved here only a month ago and want to get back home as soon as possible.  Hopefully within a year or two. 

  

Crazies. 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
May 5, 2006, 1:43 pm PDT

Debating Among Different Religious Beliefs

Quote From: kerowyn

I stated that christians do feel vistim in response to comment Christians do not pity themselves.  Or some such matter.  I was just trying to show or demostrate a slight error on that train of thought.  No need to wash my face in information I already know.  If I was unclear before let me be clear now.    

I guess this forum might not be as open as I had hoped it to be about religions and faith.    

For the record... I am GNOSTIC my teaching of faith are my own chosing. I beleive ALL religions to be true if they are honest and open with God no matter what name they use to call him/her.  I believe that God is an all loving God and to but human beleifs on him/her is not honoring him at all.  God is without evil and loves ALL his Children (no matter the faith) equally.  WE will all return home upon or deaths in this life including Atheist, Muslims, Buddhist, Jews and Satan worshipers.  As long as they chose the light of God upon death.  WE have all lived for many years and lived several lifes at verious times.  We are eternal since our life is at home and this is just the teaching ground for enlightenment we would not receive back home.   Jesus is our brother not a God.  Judas is not a evil betrayer but an enlighten soul who knew his path in life as well as Jesus knew his.  And is also our brother.  

Anything else you would like to know.  

I am an open book.
  

So you beleive in reincarnation?  I do. 

  

They way I explain this to people is like this, 

Have you ever met someone who you feel you have known "forever"? 

Do you want to go some place, maybe a country, just because you feel drawn to it? 

Are you very interested  with how people before you have lived? 

  

I think we do live many lives.  To say we only get one is ridicilous to me.  This world has been here for so long and to think we only live on it for a second (compared to how old the Earth is) is beyond me.  There are too many things to see that cannot be seen in one life.   

  

I learned about this in history class, about reincarnation, how the Mayans beleived in it.  I was so facinated by it that it was all I could think about for a while after that class.  I was in 6th grade. Turns out that my family history dates back to the Mayans.  Very interesting, don't you think? 

  

When I was a child, I felt a motherly presence, not just only from my mom, but I think by the Goddess.  My beleifs have been with me since I was a child.  No one really taught me any of it, I just felt it.  I didn't know my religion had a name until 41/2 years ago when I took a trip to Salem, MA.  I've felt like that missing peice is now found.  Paganism is right for me.  Not for everyone, but it is for me. 

  

Elffie 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
May 5, 2006, 1:52 pm PDT

Gnosticism

I found this symbol when I looked up gnostic.  Nice Pagan symbol by the way. LOL  It represents the four corners of the Earth.  It is also the symbol  representing the elements, Earth, Air , Fire, Water.  So I can see how gnostics use this for their symbol.   

  

Okay, that was all. 

Elffie 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
happy
May 5, 2006, 2:44 pm PDT

eternal life as I see it

Quote From: elffie

So you beleive in reincarnation?  I do. 

  

They way I explain this to people is like this, 

Have you ever met someone who you feel you have known "forever"? 

Do you want to go some place, maybe a country, just because you feel drawn to it? 

Are you very interested  with how people before you have lived? 

  

I think we do live many lives.  To say we only get one is ridicilous to me.  This world has been here for so long and to think we only live on it for a second (compared to how old the Earth is) is beyond me.  There are too many things to see that cannot be seen in one life.   

  

I learned about this in history class, about reincarnation, how the Mayans beleived in it.  I was so facinated by it that it was all I could think about for a while after that class.  I was in 6th grade. Turns out that my family history dates back to the Mayans.  Very interesting, don't you think? 

  

When I was a child, I felt a motherly presence, not just only from my mom, but I think by the Goddess.  My beleifs have been with me since I was a child.  No one really taught me any of it, I just felt it.  I didn't know my religion had a name until 41/2 years ago when I took a trip to Salem, MA.  I've felt like that missing peice is now found.  Paganism is right for me.  Not for everyone, but it is for me. 

  

Elffie 

My best friend is a pagan.  I just call her my sister in Spirit or Sprit Sister.  We arew mostly one in the same.  She has a major problem with Christianity where in I don't.  Yet her problem stems from her parents... but I won't bore all with that info.   

I grew up Christian, sunday church, schools in the summers.  etc.  kind of middle class up bringing.  One day my preacher told me in a moment I was noting my belief system leaned differently ( couldn't understand why Jesus would have such an evil person as Judas in his circle, Judas couldn't have been bad).  Well that was an odd chat and never got that cleared up till much later in life.  Still the preacher told a long time ago I was set to walk a different path.  About 20 years ago it all started.  Funny I read books on Wiccans, Druids, Pagan still want to delve more in to the beginins of Faith.  ( dyslexia can be a pain... don't you think? so please excuse any spelling errors I don't notice them most days sorry) 

My belief on reincarnations is simple at best explained that we are born of God our creator. We live with him in perfection of life. ( aka heaven).  We come into this life to perfect ourselves in his/hers eyes and for our own spiritual self.  We have one true life consider that our soul or spirit and several physical lifes here as humans. 

I am so happy for you Elfie to have found your place in this life.  I wish more people understood Paganism for what it really is.  I would see your motherly presence as one of two people could have been your guide for this life or if it was a feeling of unconditional love of eternity it was most likely the what you see as the Goddess or as I see the female half of God. 

Mayan... I have not read much on the Mayan culture.  My heritage leans into the Pagan and druids if anything at all.  Oh yeah and my favorite side to my heritage is Native American. Cherrokee.  Love thier ideas from time to time.  Not sure about peace pipe but the ritual I like... not the smoking of "exotic" weeds (putting it nicely).  :) 

  

 
User Mood
Hyper

Message Emote
blank
May 5, 2006, 4:04 pm PDT

Debating Among Different Religious Beliefs

Quote From: progdad

OK...allow me to deconstruct all of your arguments

John 10:30 refers to us all being made of "God stuff". Taken in proper context he is not saying he IS God but is OF God.  A big distinction.

Exodous, John 18, : Jesus was an Essene, and Essenes (the originators of what is now Kabbalism) often referred to each other as "I am" - to acknowlege the God within us all.

Revelation: When I say Jesus never claimed to be God I refer clearly to the gospels.  Paul says Jesus was God, John says Jesus was God but JESUS never says Jesus was God.

Issaiah: This is taken way out of context.  Somehow a verse proclaiming the oneness of God is used to prove the threeness of God?

Mathew: Note the wording "God with us" God is in us, God was in Jesus - this is the core of Gnostic Christianity. To parapharase Carl Sagan (peace be unto him) "We are all made of Starstuff"

Phillipians: again, this is Paul claiming Jesus was God. Not Jesus claiming such.

John: again this can be interpreted in a Gnostic fashion, or that the messenger of God must be honored.  There are many times Elijah is asked to be honored as God is - does that mean Elijah was God too?


  

You've deconstructed nothing by providing your own interpretation of the scriptures.   

  

I suppose when Jesus raised Lazarus and others from the dead and healed the blind and the lepers, it was only a cheap magicians trick or he used the American Medical Journal as a guide.  Do you believe he did these things?  If so, and we are full of "God Stuff" or are equal to God, can you raise the dead or heal disease (without meds and machines of course)? 

  

I think the main point you're trying to make is that if Jesus didn't say He was God, then He wasn't.  

  

My main concern is that you don't believe He was/is God at all, not whether or not He walked around stating it.   

  

  

 
User Mood
Hyper

Message Emote
surprised
May 5, 2006, 4:11 pm PDT

OUCH!

Quote From: kerowyn

I stated that christians do feel vistim in response to comment Christians do not pity themselves.  Or some such matter.  I was just trying to show or demostrate a slight error on that train of thought.  No need to wash my face in information I already know.  If I was unclear before let me be clear now.    

I guess this forum might not be as open as I had hoped it to be about religions and faith.    

For the record... I am GNOSTIC my teaching of faith are my own chosing. I beleive ALL religions to be true if they are honest and open with God no matter what name they use to call him/her.  I believe that God is an all loving God and to but human beleifs on him/her is not honoring him at all.  God is without evil and loves ALL his Children (no matter the faith) equally.  WE will all return home upon or deaths in this life including Atheist, Muslims, Buddhist, Jews and Satan worshipers.  As long as they chose the light of God upon death.  WE have all lived for many years and lived several lifes at verious times.  We are eternal since our life is at home and this is just the teaching ground for enlightenment we would not receive back home.   Jesus is our brother not a God.  Judas is not a evil betrayer but an enlighten soul who knew his path in life as well as Jesus knew his.  And is also our brother.  

Anything else you would like to know.  

I am an open book.
  

  

"Jesus is our brother not a God" 

 

Ouch!  Wouldn't do any good for me to continue debating or discussing our differences. 

 

Take care.  Hopefully  you and I will meet back at "home" someday upon our deaths.......... 

preferably in Heaven. 

 

Hazel 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
May 5, 2006, 4:42 pm PDT

Religion/ Christianity

Quote From: hazel_eyes

  

There are many unstable individuals practicing religion these days.  Sounds like you're surrounded by a town of them.   

People tend to want to put these two words together which in all reality they are completely two different things. Yes, Christianity is a religion as we believe in God the almighty and it is all about a relationship with Christ himself. Religion can consist of many beliefs and not neccessarily of God as the higher power but something else. People who claim to be Christians but are un loving and uncaring towards others do not have a clue what Christianity is about and there are certainly those out there who give Christians a bad name. Just because a person goes to church and sings and praises God does not make them a Christian, it is basically about the relationship they have with Christ and striving to live as Christ would have them to, they are not perfect as we are all human but we are also reminded that people will know us by our fruits which is basically by the way we live our lives. I definelty agree that there are unstable people practicing religion and unfortuanetly Christianity is one of them. Christianity is about love as well as speaking the Biblical truths and witnessing to others of what Christ has been to us and until one has experienced that relationship, they are not going to understand no matter how hard they try, it has to be experienced before it can actually be lived properly and effectively..................................just a few cents worth here.
 

First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | Next | Last