Topic : Things That Worked For Us

Number of Replies: 239
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, June 30, 2005, 12:51:05 pm
Author : dataimport
Has one method of discipline worked really well for you? Don't keep it a secret - share it with us!

Join the new Dr. Phil Community! Currently in BETA, the new Dr. Phil Community will allow you to personalize your message board experience. Start by creating your user profile here.

For help and FAQs on the new BETA Community, please click here.

User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
November 14, 2006, 12:10 pm PST

Things That Worked For Us

Quote From: hbarnes

This is my first time on this message board.  I am in desparate need of some help all suggestions please.  My son is 5, and in preschool.  This is his fifth daycare/preschool since age 2 1/2.  He has a huge problem listening to his teachers and is constantly sitting in time out at school and then staying in time out at home after school.  We have tried everything to get him to behave.   We tried spanking, effective for a while then lost it's effectivness.  We have currently taken all his toys away and he only has books and coloring books for the time being to play with.  This too seems to be losing it's effectiveness.  I get a call from his teacher at least once or twice a week because he refuses to listen.  I am tired of bargaining and trying to use the reward system that doesn't work.  He is now at the point where we are actually taking holidays away, such as halloween right now,  he did not get a pumpkin because he refused to be good at school all week long.  Now he is not going to get to participate in the party at school because he will not listen.  Is this getting too out of hand?  PLEASE HELP anyone. 
I know how you feel! my 6 year old is the same way.  I posted earlier today.  Everything I have tried as not worked.  I've started reading Love and Logic by Jim Fay.  I'm not sure if it is effective yet since I'm on Chapter one, but I'll try anything.  Here is  my email if you'd like to talk further...sdgifford@butlermfg.com
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 16, 2006, 11:55 am PST

ADHD questions

Quote From: gifftime

My 6 year old is having trouble behaving in Kindergarden.  Just to give you a little history, she has always been very bright but has always had a behavioral problem.  She has been the bitter, the hitter, spent most of here playtime in time-out etc.  The only catch is she is well disciplined at home.  When asked to clean her room she does it with out questioning.  She doesn't fight with her brothers, and never talks back to me or my husband.  But once she get's to school she fitghts with friends, talks back to her teacher, and disrupts the class.  She once even accused her teacher of pushing her  (she tripped) and screamed it load in the class.  We have tried sticker charts, grounding, spanking, time-outs, rewards for good behavior.  We are now at the point where we have everything stripped from her room and she has to earn TV time and toys with good behaivor.  I don't like treating my daughter this way.  I have wondered if she is ADD or ADHD.  How do you tell? Anyone have any suggestions?

Have you had meetings with your daughter’s teacher regarding her behavior? Her teacher should have some constructive advice for you; if the teacher does not have advice, then contact your child’s school psychologist if the district has one. Simply let him/her know your child’s pattern of behavior and that you are seeking advice on how to help her become a better behaved child at school, so that she can get the fullest benefits out of her learning experience.

I don’t have any idea at what age professionals can diagnose ADD/ADHD, but my advice is to ask your child’s teacher if she sees any of the symptoms in your daughter.

In my personal experience, my school system wasn’t particularly helpful; although I have heard of many other people who have had very positive experiences with their school systems. My daughter was very artistic and creative, but, she couldn’t concentrate on much because she was very distractible. Her teachers just passed her every year anyway, labeling her ‘creative.’ When she got to middle school is when the you know what hit the fan! By this point, I felt distrustful of the school system, so I contacted an independent psychologist, made an appt., and began the process of having my daughter tested. The psychologist told me that because girls oftentimes do not have the ’hyperactivity’ component of ADHD, they slip through the cracks and don’t get diagnosed or treated. This is exactly what happened to my child. My biggest regret was that I didn’t do this (the testing) years earlier- my daughter suffered the loss of self esteem because she had low grades for so long. It has now been 2 years, and my daughter has never been happier in school. She is now in the 10th grade, she is on the honor roll, and she is making plans for college. I urge you to ask your child’s school for testing or to obtain testing for her outside of school.

There are many people who are against having children tested, for a variety of reasons, but in my personal opinion, when our kids are happy and well adjusted, we are doing our jobs as parents.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
November 19, 2006, 8:28 am PST

Help with 6yrboy

I have a son that just turned 6.  He has been teasing his 11 yr old sister and getting into her space. He calls her names and tells her to shutup. I have tried to put him in timeouts.  But that does not work.  I would ask him to do something and he would say I would never do that. Of course I get the line I hate you and I would say that I love you.  I have now taken away all of his toys and moved them to the basement.  He goes on and on with things like, you can not come in my room or you leave this house or go away or you should run away. He has just started to tell me to be quiet and the new one is butt head to his sister and me.  He has no respect for others, but (this is the kicker) he is a good child at school. He is now out of controll.  I'm just about ready to call mental health to help get from a child therapist.  Help!!!
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
November 19, 2006, 9:13 pm PST

Things That Worked For Us

Quote From: funxtwo

I have a son that just turned 6.  He has been teasing his 11 yr old sister and getting into her space. He calls her names and tells her to shutup. I have tried to put him in timeouts.  But that does not work.  I would ask him to do something and he would say I would never do that. Of course I get the line I hate you and I would say that I love you.  I have now taken away all of his toys and moved them to the basement.  He goes on and on with things like, you can not come in my room or you leave this house or go away or you should run away. He has just started to tell me to be quiet and the new one is butt head to his sister and me.  He has no respect for others, but (this is the kicker) he is a good child at school. He is now out of controll.  I'm just about ready to call mental health to help get from a child therapist.  Help!!!
have you tried ignoring him or  do you all feed into everything and get him more wound up?  The next time he says he hates you, just say "that's your choice, I love you" and walk away and ignore anything else that is  said after that.

When he decides not to do something, just say, "that's your choice but remember I can make choices too and if you decide not to do as you are asked, then I have made the choice not to whatever" (like if you were planning a trip to the zoo, you can  use that, you decided not to clean your room so I decided I am not taking you to the zoo) leave it at that and walk away. Yes, he is gonna throw his fit, or whatever but eventually he will catch on if you are consistent and stick with your word.

I honestly thinl parents fight with their kids too much, My daughter went to bday party today and had a blast but she wasn't gonna go unless she cleaned up the play room, she didn;t want to clean cause she was excited about the party, but I looked at her and said, you either clean the room or you don't go to the party" walked a way and 30 minutes later, the room was clean. She has lost priveleges and she knows that I am gonna stick with what I say. There has been a few times when she was let slide and let me tell you, she knew it too so now days, I don't hesitate. She is five years old.

I don't know about the mental health thing for I do not know your child but if you feel the need, I am sure it wouldn't hurt but I have a feeling he is a normal 6 year old boy trying to get his way and also maybe it is an attention thing, do you have one on one times with him where it is just you and him? This goes great in my home, Once in a whilem I will take one of the girls with me out and the other stays wioththe daddy, the next time, I take the other, they love this, today, my three year old thought it was cool to have her daddy all to her self for three hours while sister was gone, they need that kind of attention.

Just a few thoughts here, just don't give up, he is only 6.


 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
December 2, 2006, 6:29 pm PST

Things That Worked For Us

My husband and I have a four year old little boy who gets very mouthy and bossy with us when he does not get his way. We have found that taking some previlages away for a little while helps. We had have tried everything from sitting him on a chair to ignoring him and nothing seemed to work. Most of the time when we tell him that something is going to get taken away he will usually do what we ask him to do and we always make it something that he usually enjoys doing the most like a favorite program or toy we have even taken his bike away from him outside and made him play with something else. Something else that I do is when I am at walmart and he starts throwing a fit I stop shopping put the cart aside and leave the store immediately. Then for a couple of times after that he can not come to the store with me.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 10, 2006, 3:11 pm PST

need help with a 5/12 year old boy

hello

I need help BAD

 

my son who is going to be 6 in march is turning into a terror.

he will some times listen to me & others times he gets very mean & mouthy.

thank goodness he doesn't swear ( yet ) 

 me & my husband fight over this Issue a lot & I know I am at fault .

when ever my husband tells one of our kids to do something they do it but with me they push. Megan is now 8 & is much better but matthew is getting very mean & he even has started hitting me & kicking me he will get mad & start yelling "your not the boss of me I hate you"

the other day at school he was throwing snow at me & I asked him to  stop, when he did not I took him by the hand & told him we were taking a walk to have a talk ( I did not want to make a big sene in front of the other mothers )  so I took him away & told him I did not like what he was doing & he would loose the computer If he did not stop  well guess what he didn't stop.

when we got home he started up aging & had to drag him to his room & told him to sit on his bed until I came up to talk to him

he would not stay in his room & he was yelling at me he has never been this bad befor & I can Imagen what he will be likeat 13 if I do not get a handel on this now

 

 

I have been a stay at home mom for most of my kids lives which would be about 8 years

I went back to work part time last January to be around other adults & make some extra $$ for the house.

  he really is a sweet boy who tells me every night that he loves me & wants to marrie me when he gets bigger but than this bad side comes out & I am not authiritative enought to get him under controll please help me & my son

it is a fight for everything now, time out ,getting him to sit on his bed I am at my witz end please help me

thanks for listen

Kathy

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 10, 2006, 4:00 pm PST

6 yr old son's temper/mouth

Quote From: kathylibby5

hello

I need help BAD

 

my son who is going to be 6 in march is turning into a terror.

he will some times listen to me & others times he gets very mean & mouthy.

thank goodness he doesn't swear ( yet ) 

 me & my husband fight over this Issue a lot & I know I am at fault .

when ever my husband tells one of our kids to do something they do it but with me they push. Megan is now 8 & is much better but matthew is getting very mean & he even has started hitting me & kicking me he will get mad & start yelling "your not the boss of me I hate you"

the other day at school he was throwing snow at me & I asked him to  stop, when he did not I took him by the hand & told him we were taking a walk to have a talk ( I did not want to make a big sene in front of the other mothers )  so I took him away & told him I did not like what he was doing & he would loose the computer If he did not stop  well guess what he didn't stop.

when we got home he started up aging & had to drag him to his room & told him to sit on his bed until I came up to talk to him

he would not stay in his room & he was yelling at me he has never been this bad befor & I can Imagen what he will be likeat 13 if I do not get a handel on this now

 

 

I have been a stay at home mom for most of my kids lives which would be about 8 years

I went back to work part time last January to be around other adults & make some extra $$ for the house.

  he really is a sweet boy who tells me every night that he loves me & wants to marrie me when he gets bigger but than this bad side comes out & I am not authiritative enought to get him under controll please help me & my son

it is a fight for everything now, time out ,getting him to sit on his bed I am at my witz end please help me

thanks for listen

Kathy

Firstly, you did the right thing by taking your son away from other people to talk to him, giving him that option to behave or to have something he values taken away from him. When you tell him that you are taking something away, be specific about the amount of time, and be sure that it is reasonable so that you can follow through without you being the one who suffers more than him! Since he won’t sit on his bed, find an alternative place. Have you considered a corner near where you are in the home? You must be consistent and remain as calm as possible with your son. If he can see that he is ‘getting’ to you, then he gets a ‘pay off’ for his naughty behavior; that will make him feel that he has power over your emotions- and you don’t want him to have that power. (or to even think that he has that power) Everything that you do now is going to help him in the long run.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 10, 2006, 4:06 pm PST

hello & thanks

I have tried time outs on a chair this used to work  now he just gets up & I have to put him back on the chair I can only do this sort of thing a few times

If I tried a corner he would just get out of it do you see where we are going?

i need him to stay put like he would do for his dad

he would never pull this type of crap with him I know it is my fault for being so whisy washy in the past & now it has come to bite me in the butt

thanks for youtr  help

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 10, 2006, 4:12 pm PST

Things That Worked For Us

I did try this chart where you had 20 points & you had to stay at that number of your would loose something

they had to earn the points back by being nice or helping around the house so on & so forth depending on what it was that they did depended on the number of points you got

like if they were good for the whole day with out me having to speak to them they could get as much as 7 points same for being bad one day I took all of his points away because he was so unruly

I think 20 points was the goal & if you only had 10 you could choose the computer or the cameboy 10 points each if you got all 20 they could do both but this too has worn off

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 21, 2006, 6:53 am PST

Help! 7 y/o son - is driving me crazy!

Hi

I was wondering if I could get some feedback on our situation.  My little boy is 7.  He is a very delightful little thing when he wants to be.  However, I have been having problems with him listening and being rude and nasty to me.  My husband is a truck driver and not home a lot.  I am a stay at home mom - and have been since he was born.  I also have a 3 year old daughter - who seems to be learning quickly from her brother! 

 

The problem is his attitude toward me.  I ask him to do something and he rolls his eyes or say, "Oh My God!"  like I am asking him to do some horrible task!  It's just things like pick up your room, hang up your coat, gather the trash for trash nite etc.  He seems to have no regard for me as an authority figure.  I have taken away the playstation, the TV, and have put him to bed early.  He takes the consequences - after some carrying on - and then does the punishment- but that doesn't change his behavior!  He continues to still be rude and nasty. 

 

He has had classroom parties, book readings etc., and I have been hesitant to go - because of his rudeness and disrespectful ways toward me.  Then he gets angry and says I don't want to spend time with him.  I tell him that he isn't very nice to me in those situations so I don't really want to go.  Am I giving him too much information?  Fuel for his fire?  I don't know. 

 

We had a church celebration last weekend for Christmas and the kids in his age group sung songs.  (Just 2 - that he didn't really know that well- which was our fault because we weren't at church the weekend they practiced) but I tried to practice it with him at home before the Sunday he was to do it.  He wasn't interested or concerned, rolling his eyes about it so I thought I'll let it go.  When he was up on stage mouthing the words, I thought he looked so DARN CUTE!  I was smiling and waving - not obnoxiously or anything.  Actually very subdued - I thought.  I was not making a spectacle of myself or him.  Well you would've thought that I was standing on the chair screaming his name the way he looked at me and mouthed for me to stop looking at him!  I was kind of sad about it.  I didn't see any other kids telling their moms to stop looking at them!  Half the moms were up in front filming or taking pictures.  Glad I didn't do that!  He may have walked off stage!  Is it his age or what? 

 

It seems that no matter how sweet, how caring, or calm I try to be with him he always has a complaint.  doesn't like dinner, doesnt want to go to practice, doesnt want to do homework before playing, - it goes on and on.  I don't know how to handle it.  I say to him - "we are not going down that road.  This is the way it is.  You need to stop your complaining now.  Rules are rules -

and my favorite - "choose the behavior - choose the consequence"  Am I not taking away enough or for long enough?  I know I need to pick my battles - but it seems that he is ALWAYS finding something to complain or be rude and disrespectful about.  he does not have a tough life at all.  I think it is rather pleasant. 

 

Sorry for the rambling!  Thanks for any feedback you might have.

L

 

First | Prev | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | Next | Last