Topic : Things That Worked For Us

Number of Replies: 238
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, June 30, 2005, 12:51:05 pm
Author : dataimport
Has one method of discipline worked really well for you? Don't keep it a secret - share it with us!

Join the new Dr. Phil Community! Currently in BETA, the new Dr. Phil Community will allow you to personalize your message board experience. Start by creating your user profile here.

For help and FAQs on the new BETA Community, please click here.

User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
worried
April 6, 2008, 9:45 am PDT

what?

Quote From: mustbecrazy

I'm sorry, but a cold shower will NOT make a child want to go to bed.  The idea is to calm her.  A warm bath and a story.  Start about an hour before bedtime.  Make this HER time with you...spend the hour with pleasant activities.  Let her sit with you on the couch, cuddling her.  Slowly wind her down.  Have her help put away her toys for the night before the rest of the routine starts.  If she feels too rushed at bedtime, she will be less cooperative.  She just wants attention...give it to her BEFORE the tantrum, and you can prevent the tantrum all together.

 

This worked with our kids.  Our 9 year old still likes to cuddle at bedtime.  Our first child was a learning experience.  By the time we got to the third one, we had the routine down pat.  When the routine is disturbed, it is harder to get a young child to conform to the rules.  Don't schedule any evening activities outside the home.

 

Make sure that you are getting your child to bed at a reasonable time...around 8 PM for a 3 year old.  Start at 7 PM...just work this into your schedule...after she is in bed, you can do the things that you need to do.

 

Are you a stay-at-home mom, or do you work outside the home, with your daughter in daycare?

 

With dad absent, it puts all of the pressure on you.  Getting your daughter calmly to bed at a reasonable time makes the rest of your evening much more enjoyable...you need to take care of yourself in order to be able to deal with a 3 year old.

 

I realize that I am talking with the person replying to the one with the 3 year old...this advice is aimed at the mom of the 3 year old.

 

Keep the bedtime routine positive...the calming approach works a lot better than punishment at bedtime.  The goal is to calm the child and help her change gears from playtime to bedtime.  Keeping the same routine every night is important...schedule the bedtime hour just for your daughter...let the answering machine get the phone if it rings.

 

I hope my suggestions have been helpful...I wrote a longer post previously with lots of advice on dealing with a 3 year old...it is important to realize that she is 3, not 12, so expect her to act like a 3 year old...keep commands simple and clear.

 

Becky

I agree Becky.  I am however appalled at what I read.  That is in no uncertain terms abuse.  I cannot fathom treating a child that way.  What nightmares she would have.  That is cruel!!!!  I hope that "mother" is reading all of these comments and takes heed.  Why doesn't she ask Dr. Phil his opinion on her form of "dicipline" .  Somehow I don't think he would agree with her.  She needs help.

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
worried
April 6, 2008, 10:02 am PDT

?????

Quote From: ellybail25

Thank you very much for your reply,
The BIG reason why she is like this i know is my fault, since she was baby i could never let her cry and so on. Little later her dad went to IRAQ and i felt bad, cuz we are moving from place to place, she lost her FIRST BFF, so i let it slide. And now i cant take control.
We use to have time outs but when she got to my moms they never did it.
I did tried bed time like you said, but she will get hysterical.
And about cold shower? just put her straight to shower or something.
Once again, thank you so much

Hi.  I would like to just say...PLEASE do not listen to that crazy & abusive woman about the shower.  And if any Pediatrician or Dr. of any kind would advocate this, I would think twice about them.  That is the most ridiculous thing.  It's not ok to do that.  NOWAY!!!!!  Please just remember; she is only 3 and you can change her behavior in a more productive ways.  Like someone else said, try to estalish a routine: Bath, cuddling, story, hugs n kisses then lights out.  If she is uncooperative in the beginning...just remember this will be new to her and she will need to adjust.  Be patient and tell her, firmly, "it is bedtime, goodnight and mommy loves you."   If she gets up, you calmly take her back.  Again and again until she realizes you mean business.  It should only take under a week for her to embrace the routine.  Do not let her bully you or manipulate you.  Stick to your guns and be loving and firm.  Keep a routine her whole life.  Children need that very much.   It gives them some sense of stability.

 

I am a mother of 3 and I promise you these things work.  NOT cold showers.   If you need to talk more, feel free to email me.  (on my profile).  Good luck.

 

Angela

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
April 6, 2008, 3:26 pm PDT

Things That Worked For Us

Quote From: angelaincleve

Hi.  I would like to just say...PLEASE do not listen to that crazy & abusive woman about the shower.  And if any Pediatrician or Dr. of any kind would advocate this, I would think twice about them.  That is the most ridiculous thing.  It's not ok to do that.  NOWAY!!!!!  Please just remember; she is only 3 and you can change her behavior in a more productive ways.  Like someone else said, try to estalish a routine: Bath, cuddling, story, hugs n kisses then lights out.  If she is uncooperative in the beginning...just remember this will be new to her and she will need to adjust.  Be patient and tell her, firmly, "it is bedtime, goodnight and mommy loves you."   If she gets up, you calmly take her back.  Again and again until she realizes you mean business.  It should only take under a week for her to embrace the routine.  Do not let her bully you or manipulate you.  Stick to your guns and be loving and firm.  Keep a routine her whole life.  Children need that very much.   It gives them some sense of stability.

 

I am a mother of 3 and I promise you these things work.  NOT cold showers.   If you need to talk more, feel free to email me.  (on my profile).  Good luck.

 

Angela

to the woman she was replying too....I agree with her I did this with both  my boys and  it does work the hardest part is being the mom and sticking to it you can do it.   and please don't do the shower thing..that could shock her system. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
angry
May 26, 2008, 4:49 pm PDT

Horrifying

Wow...throwing a 3 year old in a cold shower for punishment for not going to bed....that's child abuse.  I hope that woman is not doing it anymore.  I guarantee you that child develops a bed wetting problem or becomes extremely shy or something.
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
surprised
May 27, 2008, 12:24 pm PDT

Things that work for us

Quote From: samanthajones

Wow...throwing a 3 year old in a cold shower for punishment for not going to bed....that's child abuse.  I hope that woman is not doing it anymore.  I guarantee you that child develops a bed wetting problem or becomes extremely shy or something.

I am watching  Dr Phil's Brat Camp today and here is what I did when my boys got

out of controle after the father passed away,

They were 12 and 14 years old,    I sent them to boot camp for 6 weeks,

after that they went to Military school

that is what should be done to those two boys  that are on the show today.

 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
May 27, 2008, 12:27 pm PDT

things that work for us

Quote From: samanthajones

Wow...throwing a 3 year old in a cold shower for punishment for not going to bed....that's child abuse. I hope that woman is not doing it anymore. I guarantee you that child develops a bed wetting problem or becomes extremely shy or something.

Put that her in a cold shower and see if she likes te treatment.

No that child will not be a bed wetter or be shy,  he will grow up resenting his mother

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
May 27, 2008, 12:31 pm PDT

things that work

Quote From: charise820

to the woman she was replying too....I agree with her I did this with both  my boys and  it does work the hardest part is being the mom and sticking to it you can do it.   and please don't do the shower thing..that could shock her system. 

   I agree with you also,

bedtime stories and lots of love, huigs and kisses and also

letting the child know he/she is very special.

 

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
May 30, 2008, 7:40 pm PDT

how did that work?

Quote From: bainbridge107

I am watching  Dr Phil's Brat Camp today and here is what I did when my boys got

out of controle after the father passed away,

They were 12 and 14 years old,    I sent them to boot camp for 6 weeks,

after that they went to Military school

that is what should be done to those two boys  that are on the show today.

 

I think my emotion here would be:  curious.
Was the father your husband at the time? You can read my post on the last brat camp and see that I went through the loss of my husband and was left to raise my three very little ones. And, you can see what I thought should happen with Wendy and Noah - a different take.
Really, did that work?  How are your boys now? Thanks.
 

Message Emote
blank
June 10, 2008, 1:22 pm PDT

Things That Worked For Us

Quote From: sunshl

I SEEM TO BE LOSING CONTROL OF THE MOTHER DAUGHTER RESPECT FROM MY 13 VERY SOON TO BE 14 Y/O DAUGHTER.... SHE IS A BEAUTIFUL, TALL THIN PRETTY GIRL, I DONT WANT HER TO DRESS WITH SHORT SHORTS ON OR A BELLY SHIRT, I DONT LIKE HER TO WEAR THE MAKE UP I TRY TO TELL HER SHE DOESNT NEED IT, BUT OVER TIME I HAVE SHUFFLED HER AROUND TO MANY DIFFERENT CIRCUMSTANCES, AND I FEEL LIKE SHE IS NOW REBELLING FOR TIMES I MAY NOT HAVE BEEN THERE, OR SHE FEELS I DONT LOVE HER.... SHE IS NOW STARTING TO RAISE HER VOICE THROW TGINGS IN THE HOUSE, AND STOP OFF. HER ATTITUDE STINKS.. VERY SNOOTY SNAPPY. SHE HAS A 6 Y/O SISTER, WHO I DONT WANT TO PICK UP THESE AWFUL TRAITS. IM NOT SURE HOW TO HANDLE THIS, AS ANY STORY THERE IS MUCH MORE TO IT THAN THIS, BUT JUST TO GET A HANDLE ON THE ATTITUDE, OR THE GLARING LOOKS THAT BURN A HOLE THROUGH YOU......HELP ME START A GREAT FUTURE WITH MY CHILDREN, NOT AN EASY END.....

Ummm...please...use less caps....thank you.

Anyway, here is what I say...

Have you tried talking to her about her behavior? maybe if you explain to her why she shouldn't wear that sort of stuff at her age because it's dangerous can help. But don't be the only one talking, you gotta also listen. Maybe you can compromise, like...she could wear a light shade of pink eye shadow and nude lipstick if she gets rid of the floozy looking clothing. There are ways to be stylish and still be modest about it.

 

I have a very weird style, but it's my own. My Mom doesn't care as long as the shirts that would show a lot of cleavage has an undershirt on. I never wear those belly shirts because I think their stupid, and the same with the shorts. The only time I'd wear shorts is for bed! *lol* and then I really just like pajama bottoms anyway.

 

She may think that the rules are too strict. So, like I said. Make a compromise, and stick to it with your other kids. Trust me on this, my little sister wants to get a peircing when she's fifteen, but I didn't get mine till I was 21-22. (I got it twice). So, if she's gonna wear make up at sixteen, then your other girls will want too as well and if you tell them no when they are sixteen...than your gonna have problems.

 

So, stay consistent. That's the trick.

 

What about your own clothing choices? maybe she's learning it from you and you don't know it?

I'm not accusing you, but as she is your daughter, she watches you. I should know, I watch my own Mom.

My Mom is very stylish and I let her pick out most of my clothing. Also, getting hammy downs and not putting a lot of importance on clothing helped me to not really care if I was in style or not.

 

I hate most of the styles these days because they're just stupid!

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
July 8, 2008, 4:41 pm PDT

love and logic

For over a year now we have been using Love and Logic and it works well when we use it correctly. I would love to know if there are others our there who use it and start a conversation about it and help each other.
 

First | Prev | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | Next | Last