Message Boards

Topic : 09/05 The Divorce Experiment

Number of Replies: 533
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, May 12, 2006, 10:03:49 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 05/16/06) Are you married to a man who doesn't know how good he has it? You do the cooking, the cleaning, take care of the kids, and he still takes you for granted? After seven years, Amy finds herself in a marriage where she is expected to wait on her husband hand and foot, and never voice her opinion. Her husband, Greg, is a self-proclaimed male chauvinist pig, and says his wife's job is to take care of the family without questioning his role as "king" of the house. Amy says if Greg doesn't learn to treat her like his equal and not his servant, she's going to divorce him. Dr. Phil sends in a Relationship Rescue team of strong women to teach Greg a lesson! While Amy is sent off on a special trip to build her self-esteem, Greg gets three new "wives" who give him a dose of his own medicine as they put him through all that he demands of his wife on a daily basis. Will he finally see Amy as his equal and become a better spouse in the process? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More September 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Embarrassed

Message Emote
blank
May 14, 2006, 6:45 pm PDT

Put My So-Called Husband on That D.E. show!

Quote From: twininwy

Good for you for doing what it takes to make it work!  My first marriage did only last 5 years, but what I expected out of marriage, and what he did were so different that there was no changing him, or me for that matter.  This was a long time ago for me, and I am now married to a wonderful man, we have 2 children and I have been married to him for almost 20 years!   So marriage can be great!  Sure we have had our share of ups and downs but it has been worth it!  So yes you are right, it does get better!
How can you say it has been 'worth it'? You are in serious denial. I have never, ever seen a happy marriage in my whole life. Not one. No, "it" does not get better. One gets bored. Old. Fat. Set in Ways. The spark is long past. The only good marriage I've ever seen is Dr. Phil's and he is blessed with intelligence, patience, Oprah and T.V.-- to see it through and still be in love. All the stupid, lamebrained people are just plain stuck with the idea of a happy marriage. Sitting around "hoping" it would get better. Dang B.S.  And in this case where the woman has stayed for seven years, well, that might as well be ME;  just add 7 more years and change the names around. I am in hell even as I type this. -N.A.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 14, 2006, 7:00 pm PDT

Dear Amy

Quote From: etiamwiam7

  

Dear Amy, 

 

Your husband who grew up without any respect for women because his parents didn't rear him up properly.  Your husband has obviously had his way far too long as it took you 7 seven years to implement an action plan or make you realise that you needed to threat to divorce him if he doesn't treat you like his equal.   

 

HOW SERIOUS ARE YOU ABOUT THIS DIVORCE STRATEGY OF YOURS? 

 

I'M GLAD THAT DR.  PHIL HAS GRANTED YOU A SPECIAL TRIP TO BUILD YOUR SELF-ESTEEM AFTER SEVEN YEARS OF SLAVERY AND OPPRESSION WITHOUT APPRECIATION. 

 

YOUR GREG NEEDS MORE THAN 3 STRONG WOMEN TO TEACH HIM A LESSON.  I THINK HE NEEDS TO GO TO A REHABILITATION CENTRE OR BOOTCAMP FOR MEN WHO THINK THEY ARE SELF-PROCLAIMED MALE CHAUVINIST TO GET THEIR PRIORITIES STRAIGHT AND REAL ABOUT WHAT TRUE EQUAL PARTNERSHIP IN A MARRIAGE IS ALL ABOUT. 

 

IF GREG THINKS HE'S THE KING OF THE HOUSE, HE BETTER THINK AGAIN. 

 

WITHOUT YOUR PRESENCE AND YOUR FULL CONTRIBUTION TO YOUR MARRIAGE'S TASKS, HIS STATUS AS KING WOULD BE NOTHING MORE THAN, A MAN IN HIS CASTLE WITHOUT A QUEEN TO ELEVATE HIS HIGHNESS AS WELL AS FOR YOUR DIPLOMATIC RELATIONSHIPS AND LAW IN ORDER IN KEEPING THE KINGDOM IN SUCH MAGNIFICENT ORDER HIS KINGDOM AND HIS STATUS AS "KING" WOULD SEIZE TO EXIST. 

 

 

GREG, YOU SHOULD GET OFF YOUR HIGHNESS BEFORE, YOU, SEIZE TO EXIST FROM ALL THAT GLORY WITHOUT "MEANINGFUL WORK" OR "KINGDOMS TO CONQUER", BECAUSE YOUR QUEEN IS LIKELY TO ABANDON, YOUR, KINGDOM, DUE TO YOUR IDLENESS AND YOUR FAILER TO BE A REAL KING. 

 

REMEMBER A KING ON A THRONE WHO HAS NO WISE COUNSEL OR ADVISERS TO DO THE DELEGATION AND KEEP THE KINGDOM(Household) IN AN ORDERLY FASHION, WILL SOON FIND HIS KINGDOM IN RUINS OR DISINTEGRATION.  HIS HIGHNESS, MAY ALSO FIND THAT HIS ONCE SHINY THRONE HAS LOST ITS SPARKLE OR OPULENCE DUE TO ABANDONMENT BY HIS QUEEN AND ALL THE NOBLES. 

 

Marriage is like your Kingdom, Greg, you have to nurture it and work at together with your Queen, if, you want your status as King to known all around the world. 

 

I wish you both well with your KINGDOM. 

 

 

May your Kingdom prosper and give emancipation and equality to all women, especially, the Queen. 

 

 

PEACE OUT. 

 

 

YOUR 

 

Wise Counsel 

ET 

  

 

 

I totally understand how you feel.  I was married to a man who abused me and I was afraid to speak up.  I knew others would tell me to leave him.  That was easy for them to say, they were not in the middle of it.  While growing up I never saw physical abuse and would fight with my brother with no problem.  What I later discovered was I did not like myself and felt he was the best I would ever be able to get.  The abuse did not start with him hitting me one day.  I would have walked out, I believe.  But, rather started with emotional abuse.  Each day got harder and harder.  He hit me before we were married, but I felt my parents had already spent too much on the wedding and reception for us to call it off.  I actually thought it would stop once we got through the first year, but it did not.  He hit me when I was pregnant and I still did not have the nerve to walk out.  We were military and when my daughter was three months old I had to go TDY for one week.  In my mind I knew I could not leave her, but I told myself she was with her father and he would not hurt her.  I told him to take her to her caregiver each day to have a break, but he wanted to play "daddy".  Within five days of leaving I got an emergency visit from my supervisor who told me I needed to take the first plane home.  I was told my daughter had choked on her bottle and was in the hospital.  I was not able to leave until the next day.  Once we landed he did not want to take me to the hospital, but to other friends houses.  I made him take me there where she was hooked up to a heart monitor and IVs.  The doctors and police told me she was brought to the hospital by him with bruises over 90% of her body, a subderal hematoma, and suffering from grand-mal seizures.  I was devistated to find out he had beat her each day I had been gone.  His excuse was she was "cying too much".  I knew he had done this, but was still afraid to tell the officers he had hit me.  If I would have he would have gotten 17 years in prison without parole.  That, though, was the end of the line for us.  She is now a 21 year old police officer who grew-up in the gifted and talented program.  She is one of the biggest blessings the Lord has ever given me.  My Ex-husband only recieved four years probation, but if I had to do it over again I would have told everything and prosecuted him harder.  It was only after we left that I was able to regain my self-esteem and do better for the both of us.  My reason for telling you all of this is to let you know you too can get out of this situation.  It is hard, but listen to all of the advice people are giving you.  They are right.  You deserve to be treated better.  I felt I took my vows forever.  I knew the Lord did not agree with divorce, but I really don't think the Lord wants his people to live being beaten and abused.  I will keep praying for you and your family.  You can always send me a message and we can keep in touch.  My email address is dwoodford2@satx.rr.com.   

  

In Christ's Love, 

Donna Woodford 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
hopeful
May 14, 2006, 7:08 pm PDT

Self-Esteem: Comes From Within and Won't Accept Abuse

Quote From: tsolemate

My personal opinon is one self esteem comes from her loveing partner. (provided she had one in the firstplace)  Being one that has gone thru a marrage that distroyed my self esteem, I can say that if she had been more up lifting and suportive I wouldnt be looking for some one like my self (happy and full of llive and love to share.  Suport from the partner will do wonders for a marrage and the more he gives to her self eteem the better the marrage gets.  

I say this because my parents have been married for 45yrs now and I still see that newlywood wedding blitz in ther atattude.  There is no low self esteem that I can see in thier marrage.   A example I hope to make happen finding my soulmate...  

  

She is out there I just have to open the right door!  

Hvae a GREAT day  

Terry  

Self-esteem does not come from a partner, loving or otherwise. Self-esteem can only come from inside oneself.  When one is with a partner who is verbally and/or emotionally abusive that can certainly be destructive to a person's self-esteem, but if the victim had good self-esteem to begin with she (or he) wouldn't have put up with an abusive partner after it became clear the partner was abusive.   

   

If you love and respect yourself you won't allow anyone else to disrespect or mistreat that special, valuable, wonderful person you know yourself to be. If you believe you are "less than", not good enough or for some other reason deserve rotten treatment, you'll accept it until you reach a breaking point. (Dr. Phil always says that you teach people how to treat you. That is part of what I'm talking about here.) These beliefs about the self can be so ingrained that someone who has them may not even realize how strong or destructive they are.  Perhaps a parent or other authority figure planted the seed for them in early childhood.  

   

There are usually early warning signs that a potential mate is unsupportive or abusive.  Often, people expect that the person will change and improve with time and marriage. What time and marriage do is bring out the quirks, warts, and whatever dysfunctional upbringing people have and opens the door to unrestrained abuse from those who are abusive.  

   

I believe that poor self-esteem PRECEDES an abusive relationship, and is at the core of why victims become victims.  The abusive spouse simply pries open the crack and makes it a chasm. The crack had to be there to start with.    

   

I can tell you that no man will ever get away with being verbally/emotionally abusive toward me again.  After much self-analysis, I could finally see how I didn't respect and love myself and in turn didn't require men to respect and love me.  Marriage or no marriage, I guarantee you that I will walk away from any man who doesn't treat me as an equal, valuable, wonderful, true partner, or who doesn't recognize and appreciate the unique and wonderful woman that I truly am.  

   

-Hannah R.   

 

Message Emote
blank
May 14, 2006, 7:11 pm PDT

05/16 The Divorce Experiment

Quote From: a_muse

Guff about "soul mates" is one of those fairy tales that gets us into trouble. It's wishful thinking. If "self-esteem" comes from something outside of us and beyond our own accountability, we are indeed doomed. I'm not buying that at all. It requires work and a certain amount of sacrifice and delayed gratification to earn one's own respect, not a magical prince/princess behind some mystical door, just waiting to rescue us from the normal hardships of life and from ourselves.

Obviously marriage needs give and take and supportive partners, but it also needs two people who are healthy to begin with. It doesn't matter how much one person gives if the other is not in a position to receive. If the "low self-esteem" partner is not doing anything for her/himself, nothing anyone else does will change anything. It also requires a large dose of humor! It seems to me that a lot of people are taking themselves way too seriously.

I couldn't agree more. Adults that talk about "soul mates" are living in a bit of a fairy land.  Not trying to be rude but the whole concept makes no sense to me. It takes away from the idea that marriage takes work, no matter how well matched you are it takes work.

As unromantic as it sounds my husband and I both fully understand that there are other people in the world we could have ended up with and we would have been just as happy. But we chose each other and that is that.


 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 14, 2006, 7:55 pm PDT

The Divorce Experiment

More power to you for doing this show. i was in such a marriage for 37 years! I worked, i paid bills, I took care of the kids and their needs, I took care of the bills that my spouse did not take care of to save face in society as I wanted us to be the all American family...I divorced after 37 years of marriage after many a roller coaster years of thinking that he finally understood what family was all about.    The only person that did not get it was me.  

   

If this program helps couples to get it right sooner than in 37 years, you are on the right track.  

   

I finished my Masters after my divorce, bought a Twin home, and am doing amazingly well on my own. Would love to have been married till death do us part, but it would have been my death to stay in the marriage.  I certainly have my moments, because I wanted to be married and a partner in life, work, family, sharing and caring. But it was so one sided. I was the enabler at my own expense and apparently that must have gotten me something, but to this day, I do not know what if got me!!!  

   

I do have 2 children and 2 grandchildren. I have one child that understands and cares about me. I have another child that has a very difficult time with me.The child that I can talk to is the child that has the grandchildren of mine and the one that did not get as many material things and help in life. The one that I worried about, gave to for her education, her inability to make ends meet is the one that can not deal with me now in my single life.   

She is so much like her father in her thinking and then comes back at me for not being Christian enough, not treating everyone fairly and honestly.But I am to promise her that what ever she tells me that I will not tell her brother.I do not make promises that I can not keep. So could not promise that. She is also 40 and pregnant with her first child with a man she is living with.  They are both grade school principles in schools out in Ca. Almost forgot to tell you that he is black and that is not an issue, but the issue is that they moved into a wonderful, beautiful house that my daughter had the funds to put down to get them into the house and only because, I got a home equity loan on our house to help her buy her first house,(my spouse could not have done this because the refinancing on our house was only on my credit and not his) and her live-in person who is the father of her child, did not have any equity to put down on a house of his own at the age of 47. So this is not a black and white issue, it is an issue of personal responsibility.  

I have tried to make arrangement to go out there to help after the baby is born, and now she tells me that her father is coming out there in June and she is not sure if he will still be there in July, when I wanted to come out there to help her with the baby. We had words and so now we are not speaking anymore and this is all my issue for my stupidity. I must have not said the right thing at the right time.  

   

So great you are working on this issue and hopefully people will listen and learn a lot earlier than i did.  

   

I am still not totally well and healed from all of this, but on the road to recovery.  

   

Diane   

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
frustrated
May 14, 2006, 7:59 pm PDT

takin for granted and still no sex

 I think my husband takes me for granted.  He thinks because he's the man he gets to make all the decisions and never takes fault for his mistakes.  I do the laundry, fix his lunch to take to work, I work full time, try to keep the house clean etc... All I ask in return is a little love making.  And he makes into a game.  I guess it makes him feel like he's in charge and makes him feel like a real man.  I am almost at my whits end.  He also spends money like it's going out of style without taking into consideration for the bills.  I treat him very well and I feel he doesn't see it sometimes. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 14, 2006, 8:23 pm PDT

Get out & get help or Get Out!

I also am at the end of my rope.  Yes, in the beginning while we were dating my husband put on his Dr. Jeckyl face and then after we were married showed his Mr. Hyde face.  But I think we all do.  I believe we all have issues that we hide in the beginning and then they start to surface and show once your married. He has OCD and ADD and I have Depression. I have gotten the help I need with my depression but although he was diagnosed with his problem he doesn't want to admit to it and get help. And our issues need to be dealt with to make the marriage work.  He actually helped me in changing alot of my issues but I helped him to continue in his issues. I allowed him to dominate me, make me feel inferior, make me feel he was always right  in all decisions and I was always wrong. But it took me hitting rock bottom and just being totally miserable when finally I said to him "get out and get help or get out". He exploded over that and it took a little help to get him out but he's out.  Now we're going through counceling and he's learning to deal with his issues as well as am still learning to deal with mine. It's not a perfect world and there's not a perfect person but we do have a "freedom of choice" that was given to us from the beginning of time. So it's up to each person to make their own choice to either do something to make things work, be miserable, or just leave. I also think it probably takes more energy to live miserably than it does to live happily. We still see each other and have been on a few dates. It's kind of like we're starting over fresh. He's tried to squirm his way back home but I said absolutely not, not until I am convinced you have gotten all the help needed so we can be happy ever after.  So, until then, I'm happy right where I am, and that's at peace. 

  

 

Message Emote
blank
May 14, 2006, 11:21 pm PDT

I was this woman

I was the woman who waited on my ex-husband hand and foot.  He was not then and never will be capable of appreciating me.  I bore his children and maintained his home, his children  and always had a full time job bringing in a supplemental income.  He believed because he made more money than I, these things were his right and privelage and my duty to take care of him.  He came to a rude awakening when he left me when our second child was one year old.  You know, "The grass is alwasy greener..........".  Now, that he is at the end of his military career, he is rethinking his options, and I have no use for him.  Divorce is the best thing he ever did for me.  I have gone nowhere but UP without him.
 

Message Emote
blank
May 15, 2006, 12:16 am PDT

DIVORCE EXPERIMENT

I know how she feels.  I have been married for 17 years and the last few years things have been like that.  If I ask him to help do something around the house, I get the "smirk" and the " it's not my job".  It really upsets me to think that he doesn't respect me anymore than that.   I have become very bitter in my life because of it.   I don't know how to feel any other way.  Last November I had enough and told him that I wanted a divorce.  He was very upset to think that I wanted to leave.  I told him how I felt about everything and he wanted to try and make things better.  I agreed with the understanding that if I thought things weren't going well I would leave.  Things were fine, but now it's back to the same old crap.  I don't understand why he is like this.  Men like this need to see what  it's like to have to do everything and not be appreciated for it.     

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
May 15, 2006, 5:21 am PDT

Divorce? Why marry!

I just cannot understand people. I do not understand the desperation of a woman (or man) to stay in relationships where they are unhappy. I mean, why bother all of us with this constant lack of discontent...Why does it go on and on. I mean, if you are unhappy do something about it...and if you are unwilling to act...well, then just go on and on with your miserable lives. In life, their are no "do-overs"--we have one life...why should any of us spend it unhappily? I wonder if the only way some people can get attention is  to constantly stay in a position of disfunction...Debra
 
First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | Next | Last