Topic : 05/24 "Get My Groom to Grow Up!"

Number of Replies: 147
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, May 19, 2006, 10:14:02 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
Do you feel like you're in a relationship with a man who's really a big baby? Angee says her fiancé, Bill, pouts, whines and stomps his feet whenever they get into an argument. He also calls "Mommy" five to 10 times a day and runs to her whenever there's a problem. Bill says he isn't a mama's boy, and that Angee just wants all of his attention for herself. Is Bill's mom meddling in their lives? And, why does Angee have her profile on a Web site? Are Angee and Bill grown up enough to tie the knot? Then, Rachel says it's time for her common–law husband, Tyler, to stop drinking and partying with his band mates, while she takes care of their baby and the bills. They've lived in his mother's basement for two years, and she says it's time Tyler gets a job so they can finally move out. Tyler says he enjoys being a kid, and when people tell him to grow up, it "harshes his mellow." Is Tyler's childish behavior affecting their 18-month-old son? What does Dr. Phil tell Rachel she must do? Share your thoughts here.

Find out what happened on the show.

More May 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.


Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 7:20 pm PDT

05/24 "Get My Groom to Grow Up!"

Quote From: mollyjotx

Okay, so all of this applies to me. Sort of. I've been with my boyfriend for two years. We had a big fight at the beginning where his mother called my work to tell me how great he was... should have been a red flag. (He is 34).  

The thing is, he treats me like a princess. I get what I need and what I want. I get awakened every morning with a back rub. He runs out in the middle of the night to get what I need whether it's medicine or something silly like ice cream. He takes care of me when I'm sick and gets things done.   

The problem is his mother and sister. They each call at least 2 times (each) after he gets home from work. I cannot finish a sentence or thought without the phone ringing. I have no idea how many times a day that he talks to them, but I do know that on some weekends his mom and sister will literally call about 20 times. They call to ask for favors... they call to gossip... or to ask "where are you and what are you doing". It has gotten to the point where I cannot stand phones or the thought of his mother - they both make me ill and angry.  At family get togethers his sister gets really touchy feely with everyone - sitting in the men's (her relatives) laps and pinching and smacking butts and hugging and doing "traditional" dances. It makes me uncomfortable, but he just says that she is affectionate and her behavior is completely normal in the Greek culture.   

She has also done things to make me uncomfortable on purpose. For example, one time she wrote him a card with a bunch of English phrases sprinkeled into the greek paragraphs that would make me worry. Another time she wrote a paper for school about how Greeks should only date Greeks and made sure that I read it. She is 23 and has never had a steady boyfriend. She has always been invited to everything that her big brother gets invited to, and his friends are so used to that that they still invite his entire family to gatherings. I want to be a couple, but I feel like his mother and sister are always there, one-upping me on everything. And he thinks it is completely normal! We get in huge fights about his family all of the time. That is almost the only thing we fight about. Am I wrong? What should I do? Does anyone else think this is normal?  

I'm from a big, Greek family. I understand all of what you are describing and please believe that none of it is unusual or mean spirited.  The one thing you should realize is that culturally, we are used to an extended family system where everyone lives all together and the whole family joins in parenting (btw-if you think this is smothering, wait until you have children!) 

  

The nice thing about our culture is that we are really THERE for each other.  No matter what one of my family members need, I'm going to do it and vice versa. I have had a chronic illness almost my whole marriage and my family has always pitched in with my husband to cope with my hospitalizations.   My husband understands my love for my family and he loves them too (it's been 28 years) but I understand his need to be a nuclear family and have privacy and control over our own lives. 

  

Our compromise: We moved 3 hours away from my parent's home but we always attend any gathering I care about.  Most of my sibs have moved away from our home town too :) 

 

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 7:30 pm PDT

for Angee

When both your husband-to-be and his mother say that they believe that you are just in this for what you can get from Bill (and they both did to my absolute astonishment) you can have no other response but to end the engagement.  It is impossible to continue the relationship with any dignity. 

  

I think Bill is destined to cleave eternally with his "best friend" and you will be much happier without him. 

 

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 7:48 pm PDT

05/24 "Get My Groom to Grow Up!"

Quote From: wanabrobin

Dr Phil,  

  

You always tell people about the statistics of failed marriages, I guess as a way of discouraging them. I get so angry when you bring that up. You frequently refer to age statistics saying that people younger than 25 shouldn't marry or they have a 90% chance of having a failed marriage. Well, let me tell you, I got married weeks after my 18th birthday and have been married for 6 years and we are VERY happy. We have two gorgeous children and have made a beautiful life together.  

  

Please Doctor Phil, stick to the facts of each case, and stop offending us young, responsible, mature married people by convincing America our marriages are doomed to fail! 

The reason to give them the stats is to add to their information about their plan.  Statistics give people an idea of their probability for success.  If a couple is in major conflict over something as important as intimacy and privacy in a marriage vs. the mommaboy's need to tell momma everything they don't have hope in hell of handling the blended family / 3 ex husband / mother-in-law interference issues. 

  

If you wanted to open a restaurant, wouldn't you thank a business adviser who told you that 90% of all restaurants started in your chosen locale have failed? 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 7:58 pm PDT

05/24 "Get My Groom to Grow Up!"

Quote From: judyblue22

When both your husband-to-be and his mother say that they believe that you are just in this for what you can get from Bill (and they both did to my absolute astonishment) you can have no other response but to end the engagement.  It is impossible to continue the relationship with any dignity. 

  

I think Bill is destined to cleave eternally with his "best friend" and you will be much happier without him. 

I agree with a lot of this. I think Bill does love Angee, but Dr. Phil was right on to say that neither of them know how to be married. His relationship with his mother is just plain creepy. I disagreed with Dr. Phil that his mom was a victim in all of this who was being pulled in. That can't be true considering she actively participated in an e-mail exchange with Angee about issues that were absolutely none of her business.  

  

If the mother was simply a victim here, she would never have participated in that, she simply would have said "take your problems home son. Deal with your fiance. I don't even want to hear about it." It's not being unsupportive to tell your grown son to deal with his own issues. 

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 8:03 pm PDT

Smoker

 I can't belive Dr. Phil is on the mother-in-laws side when the parent doesn't want to subject her children to second hand smoke.  Second hand smoke is the leading cause of asthma and allergies in young children.    If the mother-in-law really wants to see the kids she should stop smoking or go to their house which is a smoke free enviroment.  I have personally seen the what type of damage second hand smoke can do to children.  I have always agreed with Dr. Phil until now!  Next thing you know he'll be telling parents it is okay to take kids to bars and casinos.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
surprised
May 24, 2006, 8:05 pm PDT

quote

Quote From: ranger4ver

She has had three husbands how could it be their entire fault, I mean come on she has to be accountable for something.  It has to be all about her just look at her MY SPACE it’s pretty obvious with those pictures she posted.  

oh ok  did not know that!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 8:38 pm PDT

RUN FOR YOUR LIFE!!!!

The man who wants to marry the 3 TIME divorcee WOMAN.   

   

RUN, RUN AWAY! this woman is a typical woman, a user. She will take you for 1/2 your assets then move on to the next sleazy man on the internet.   

   

Man to Man?   

   

Kick her to the curb, She is BAD NEWS. A loser in 3 Previous Marriages and she is 3 KIDS that are NOT yours!   

   

You want to support this? If you do then you are the dumbest man on the planet.   

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
May 24, 2006, 9:15 pm PDT

how was he when you met him

Rachel 

I am wondering why would you choose someone like Tyler to be the father to your baby?  I'm guessing that before you had your baby, he was a lot of fun to party with.  Did you accept him then and now your time line says he should grow up?   

  

Alot of people think that just because a person has a child that they will change.  I think that is true in most cases but  I think you picked the wrong dad.  

  

I guess I am trying to figure out why Rachel is all of the sudden the victim in this when she knew what kind of person he was a long time ago.  Whenever your having sex with a man you better take a good long look at who the possible father of your child might be.   

  

The victim is the child.  I feel bad that he has been brought into this selfish irresponsible relationship.   

  

Rachel.  You have seen what a wonderful thing you have in your son.  Have 20/20 in viewing his father.  Your son deserve a real dad, not just someone that passes through when it's suites him   

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 9:32 pm PDT

Where is Tyler's Dad

Quote From: charrisis1

IT WAS VERY DISAPPOINTING THAT DR. PHIL DIDN'T PUT TYLER IN HIS PLACE BETTER. HE SHOULD HAVE POINTED OUT THAT TYLER SAID "HIS PARENTS HAD HIM SO THEY SHOULD PAY HIS WAY FOR THE REST OF HIS LIFE". WELL, TYLER HAS A CHILD SO HE MUST BELIEVE THAT HE HAS A RESPONSIBILITY TO PAY FOR HIS CHILD. DR. PHIL SHOULD HAVE POINTED THAT OUT TO HIM.  

Just watching this show made me wonder"where is dad though all of this".  It seems to me that tyler needs a older male mentor to set him straight.   

  

Pay for him forever?  Tyler better get busy soon if he believes he should be paying for his son forever!!  NOT!!  He'll be lucky to get a meal out of his good ol dad!  Probably another welfare case in the making.  Poor kid.  Not Tyler, The real kid. 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 11:02 pm PDT

05/24 "Get My Groom to Grow Up!"

Quote From: dadathome

The man who wants to marry the 3 TIME divorcee WOMAN.   

   

RUN, RUN AWAY! this woman is a typical woman, a user. She will take you for 1/2 your assets then move on to the next sleazy man on the internet.   

   

Man to Man?   

   

Kick her to the curb, She is BAD NEWS. A loser in 3 Previous Marriages and she is 3 KIDS that are NOT yours!   

   

You want to support this? If you do then you are the dumbest man on the planet.   

hmmm i guess i could agree somewhat my ex husband is on his 4th wife!! but they deserve each other.  you don't know the reasons behind her divorces so how can you judge her?
 

First | Prev | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | Next | Last