Quote From: motherto4boysWe're in a similar situation right now. Has your son been tested officially for IQ? If he's truly that gifted it is like torture to expect him to behave day in and day out in a class that's far behind him. Research the literature on giftedness (nagc.org, sengifted.org?). Punishments and denied priveledges only make things worse in these situations. GIfted kids need truly advanced curriculum,different class environments, and teachers who understand the difference in the way the gifted learn. If he has an IQ well over norm, he deserves as many accomodations as those with IQ well below norm. My 2nd grade son is at home with a tutor now because the anxiety became too much for him. He doesnt have outbursts at home anymore because he's working at a 6h grade level and because we better understand the way his mind works (mental age really effects how they respond to discipline). good luck
Our third grade son is reading at 8.8 grade level and is way ahead in math. His teacher recongizes that he is gifted. We, too, are in a small school district. There is no program for gifted kids. Our son's teacher has been wonderful about letting our son work at his level. We would never consider skipping a grade for him. There are things that he will only experience once as a third grader, and there are things to learn, even though he learns much faster than most of the other kids. Our son's teacher has him "tutor" some of the other kids who need help. Our son his kind and helpful, and he loves his tutoring job. The other kids look up to him for being helpful.
On another issue, the state's standardized tests have taken over the school's entire K-12 curriculum!! They spend so much time teaching the kids how to take the test that there isn't enough time to teach them how to live their lives!! Any other thoughts on this? We live in Washington State, and the WASL is the bain of my existence, and my kids' too. Passing the WASL in 10th grade is a requirement to get a high school diploma...less than half the kids who take it are passing, so more than half the kids can only hope for a GED!!!
As far as disclipline goes...taking away Cub Scouts isn't the answer...my son is a Cub Scout, and we are teaching him that he needs to stick to it and follow through...quitting is not an option when he is having so much fun. Outside activities give a kid a chance to express themselves and learn in their own style...Cub Scout leaders can tailor the lessons to the kids and be flexible on how the requirements are achieved.
Perhaps the other mom (sorry I couldn't find the original post) should consider rewards for good behavior. And perhaps some visits to the classroom to observe. I volunteer in my son's class once a week as a way to help the teacher and as a way to keep in touch with what's going on in the classroom. Teachers will be much more accomodating to a parent who shows dedication to the school and the classroom.
I believe it is the law that kids with very high IQ scores have an IEP or 504 plan...individual education plan...if you can get the teachers to adhere to it.