Quote From: juliekopeHello to all of you dedicated and loving parents who feel that homeschooling is the best thing or the right thing for your children! I completely believe that you are all doing this out of love!...However, I truly feel that, even though they may be receiving disciplined and detailed educating by you, there is no possible way they are getting full life benefits. There are so many life lessons and interaction from going to school than you could ever offer your children. I'm so sorry to throw out the negative, but the reality is there. I am not an educator or teacher but I do know of at least 2 situations I can share.
I lived across the street form a family that already had "disfunctional" family issues going on. Once the one daughter seemed to have personal issues at school the mom switched her to another school district for high school. This was a positive outcome! Then, when the next daughter began having poor judgement issues and not doing well in school, the mother took her out of the public school at grade 9 (as she would have started high schhol) and made her stay home and do high school via computer - at home as she claimed was home schooling!!! This daughter has not at all had any positive outcome. She has had severe and emotionally painful issues occur! Her mom assumed keeping her at home would "shield" her from the "outside world". But it only made her rebel and make even worse choices in her young life. Not to mention, her mom did not really support or oversee her as a daughter or in her "homeschooling".
Next story...This family had 2 very young daughters and felt that from day one of school-age homeschooling was best. They were kept home and schooled by mom. By the time the girls were in 1st and 3rd grade their mom realized that they needed the life experience and interaction that school offers. Also, she realized that they may be treated as different or not included in play, etc. even from neighborhood kids they knew. Kids can be cruel even when they are not purposely doing so. Also, there are so many extracurricular "things" - like after school skating parties, classmates' B-Day parties, Field trips unavailable to home-schooled children and many more things. Your children ARE missing out in LIFE! Also, how might they survive in the REAL WORLD once they get finished w/ your schooling???
Again, I want to praise you all for dedicatiing your time and loving your children w/the best you feel you know. Let me end on that note!
Homeschooling is a very personal decision, and is one that should not be taken lightly. I shared your feelings for a long time, until my sister-in-law decided to homeschool all three of her children, staring in 1st grade. I was concerned about the childrens' social well-being and opportunities for extracurricular activities. Since she started doing this 7 years ago, I have been proven wrong over and over again.
It takes a very special parent to have the desire and will to dedicate their life to schooling their children. It appears that the people you know of who failed were not cut out to do this in the first place. There are endless opportunities for homeschooled children to participate in outside activities - the parents just need to be motivated enough to search them out. My neices and nephew are all extremely involved in basketball, volleyball, church activities, piano lessons, just to name a few. Plus, there are homeschool groups all over the country that provide opportunities for the students to meet for field trips, group learning classes, and several other activities. Again, the parents need to take the initiative to seek them out.
I'm sure some homeschooled children do miss out on fun things in life, but publicly schooled children miss out on just as much when their parents don't provide them with experiences. As for surviving in the real world after they graduate...do you think these kids have been living in a box for the past 18 years?!?! If homeschooling is done right, they fit into society just as well, if not better, than other children. Many, many Ivy League universities have a high percentage of homeschool graduates enrolled, look it up if you don't believe it.
I have tossed around the idea of homeschooling my children, simply because I'm disgusted at what kids are exposed to in public schools. I have decided that is not best for our family, because I personally don't think I could offer my children as many experiences as I would like them to have. But, there are so many wonderful parents out there who are able to do this (I have met several), and I think they deserve the utmost applause!!!
You should look into some successful homeschool stories rather than basing your opinion on two miserably failed attempts at it. Hopefully you will be able to see the positive in homeschooling before you pass on your narrow-minded, completely false ideas to others!