Quote From: fischertcHi there. I wanted to just chime in with a thing or two. First of all, I agree with everyone here that your hubby needs to get a spine. Maybe what has been said about him being the man of the family after his dad left is true but he still is now supposed to be your defender. You and your children are his family now and you deserve his protection from his families issues.
Mostly though, I would like to add to that something about the story you told your MIL about her son, the brother-in-law that made a pass at you. It do not believe in her mind she was doing a 180, what she was doing was defending her son. First of all, the BIL that said these things should be the one to be told exactly how it is not to be tolerated, preferably by his brother, your hubby. If my brother ever said anything like that to my g/f I would not be out of his face until he knew in no uncertain terms just how disgusting a person he was for doing that and he would be apologizing to her until I felt he had attoned.
Second, any mother is going to at first blush defend her son. She took his side and looked back to you as the cause. I am not saying it was the right thing to do based on what the BIL did but I believe it is what happened. Your BIL made a really, really bad choice in coming to you with whatever vulgar comments he made. That was his choice. I am not sure of his age or anything but I assume he is an adult. Your hubby needs to take him to task. Your MIL is not responsible for his actions, he is. Telling your MIL something like this, possibly expecting her to do something about it, was, in my opinion not a good choice either. She has already demonstrated in the past that she doesn't trust you, pushing this out there just added more fuel to the fire. If I were your hubby I would go to BIL, make him repent and then have the BIL explain to MIL that he had done it and was sorry.
Barring any of that happening, don't expect MIL to come back anytime soon. She doesn't believe her other son could do something like that, thinks you are a liar and why would she want to be around a liar? Hubby needs to get a spine and fix this, now. You say you had agreed to keep this from the rest of the family to keep the peace. Did you break that promise and say this to MIL anyway to see if she would do something? Maybe your hubby doesn't trust you now. Maybe he is hurt that you would even think about putting this out there when you both had agreed it was not to be.
You have to look first to yourself and your responsibility in this. Always, no matter what the situation. If you broke that promise, apologize and explain your ownership of that. I would then later approach him with "I" statements like, "I feel hurt because I do not feel you are standing up for me with your family. I feel frustrated with the situation because it is just sitting here unresolved. You are a better person than this. I love you and require your help to fix this. You are my husband and have been my life for 12 years and we need to work this out. I feel alone, exhausted and depressed because this is a constant source of pain in my life". Something along those lines to get the ball rolling between you and he about your family relations.
Find what you are doing first and foremost. Get Self Matters or Relationship Rescue by the good doc and read.
Best Wishes
Tim
Thanks for the response.
The brother-in-law I was referring to is not her son, it is her daughter's husband. Sorry for not being more specific.
The guy cheated on my SIL one month in to their relationship. The guy is bad news all the way around. He has a criminal record, a drug habit, he admits he has genital herpes, he doesn't work ever since his daughter (from a previous marriage) became disabled in a recent car accident. He, his daughter, and his grandson, have all moved in to my SIL's house and are all living off of her. Really, I don't care what my SIL chooses for her life but I find it repulsive that he would even think to approach another woman, much less me, a relative. And even knowing all of this, my mother-in-law opts for giving him the benefit of the doubt over me! I am in complete shock, disgust, and disappointment.
I take responsibility for discussing this with the wrong person, my MIL. But I never expected this to turn out like this. So no, I was not telling her this to test my relationship with my husband. Possibly to test my relationship with her, but not with him, and certainly not on a concious level.
I do know first hand that this is a difficult thing to handle and I understand that her daughter is at the center of all this and so, this puts my MIL in a position where she has to decide whether or not to tell her daughter this. And if she tells her, she knows her daughter is stupid and will just get angry at everyone else (much like her own mother). Really, she is faced with the same issue we were faced with. What to do? I guess it was easier to attack me.
As far as me breaking a promise to my husband, I don't think that was the case. I think we agreed that we did not want to create any conflict out of this but we were both not sure how to handle things so we just kept quiet about it. Honestly, I did not think that talking to my MIL would create any conflict. I really felt that she might actually help in some way. Especially since she started out saying she didn't trust her son-in-law either. Who knew her position would change completely.
Really, after taking so many insults from her, I almost feel like they all deserve what they get, and I know this man will cheat if he hasn't already.
But my relationship with my husband is my main concern. My husband was not angry that I told her about this, I think he became bothered when I defended myself. I think that he would prefer me to stick my head in the sand like everyone else. That's how his family handles problems.
I do analize and question my own actions, I am in therapy and doing the best I can to charge along and live in a way that is pleasing to God.
I have read the books you mentioned as well as countless others and I do my best to apply them to my everyday life. Thus, I am here sharing this with you.
I live by Dr. Phil's methods, it's just that sometimes we need a different perspective of the way we view things.
I thank you for giving yours.