Message Boards

Topic : Infidelity

Number of Replies: 4804
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:02:24 pm
Author : dataimport
Has your partner been unfaithful? Have you been the one to stray? Share your advice and support with others that have experienced infidelity.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
October 27, 2007, 7:48 pm PDT

What has changed....

Quote From: ritehere

 Over the course of your 11 year marriage you say your husband has left you "more times than you can count."  He has also been active with inappropriate chatting and porn on the internet.  2 years ago you "caught him attempting to cheat with a woman."  He has always lied to you.
You say that you hate to tear up your daughter's world, but you can only "play pretend for so long." You say that after his stunt 2 years ago you are not so quick to forgive but you have religious beliefs that make you want to hold on. You ask where do you stand with God, what about unconditional love vs self respect?

This is what I'm wondering: has all of this taken on urgency now that your husband has had a stroke?
Your last question is a valid one and one that you should have been asking the second or third time your husband left you because he couldn't deal with whatever argument you were having. Where is your self respect? And where was your self respect when you found porn and the other things on the computer?
You say you are not quick to forgive, but what did you do about these immature and selfish things your husband was doing?
And last, if he is leaving you all the time and cheating on you, what kind of role model is he for your daughter? What are YOU teaching her? That it's OK for men to treat women this way?

I'm sorry, I know you have your plate full at the moment, and his cheating is not your fault. What is your fault is letting him get away with it all these years. Letting him strip away your self respect and dignity to the point that now that he is in a health crisis you have no pity for him and are considering leaving him. I guess he must have had some redeeming quality before, that kept you around even though he did the things he did. What has changed now that he has had a stroke? You have "played pretend" for 11 years, what is different now?

Unfortunately I didn't find these things again until a few weeks after he had the stroke and I got on his computer. So here I was nursing this person, being a good wife and human being and pretty much just getting crapped on. Sorry to be so blunt but I see no other way to put it.....In fact I HAVE pity for him is the problem vs NO pity if you read what I wrote....If he was not sick I would have left and gone to take care of my mother where I know I would be appreciated. His being sick  is a great part of why I am here. I will say that monetary reasons are  also a huge part of things and even when he was gone he always left a majority of the money to pay the bills and I will go as far as to say relieve some of his guilt. He wrote me a letter a few weeks ago and basically acknowledged that he knows he has a problem and has for years. Dishonesty has been a way of life apparently for a large portion of his adulthood and has torn up past relationships as well as this one. I have turned into an extremely tolerant person as I have aged and have been living my life for my children who are now all nearly grown. Maybe it isn't much in the way of self respect but keep in mind that this is my third marriage, I am a person of deep commitment and also have religious views now that I didn't hold several years ago. On the other hand I have the harsh slap of reality telling me that the minute he is better his behavior will repeat.

 

My family knows very little. "Our" daughter just happens to be the youngest of six and we have one more child left at home. (yours mine and ours.....)  I hide so much inside and put on a happy face. No one at church knows and very little people outside of my closest circle of friends know.

 

Do  I love this man? Absolutely with all my heart. I know he hates the messes he has created but it is like he is an addict of some sort who doesn't know how to handle his issues and I am a person who feels like they are treading water to help everyone else stay afloat.  

 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
October 28, 2007, 4:11 am PDT

lost

I have been married to my husband for 14 yrs. and have two young children.  He was an alcoholic and was verbally abusive.  My entire world revolved around him and the kids.  I haven't worked outside of the home for 11 years.  I barely have any friends...to the outside world, my life is perfect.  I've threatened to leave him many times and never did go through with it.  3 1/2 years ago, I cheated on him with someone we casually knew.  It was a one night stand and I didn't feel good about what I did.  He suspected that I had cheated but I denied it, fearing that I would lose my children in an ugly divorce.  One year ago he quit drinking because he finally did hit me.  Things between us seemed better than ever.  Six months ago, I confessed what I had done because I felt the incredible guilt consuming me.  Now we are at the brink of a divorce.  He is uncertain whether or not he still wants to be with me.  Although I want to stay and make it work because I do love him and the kids, I myself is torn.  Is my staying really good for the both of us?  We argue over the past and decided that we need a marriage councelor.  I just don't know.  I have not cheated on him since and will not.  It was truly out of my character, and I absolutely have been  making the right steps toward earning his trust.  He is still very angry and hurt. 
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 28, 2007, 5:50 am PDT

Therapy is a must

Quote From: needhelpasap

I have been married to my husband for 14 yrs. and have two young children.  He was an alcoholic and was verbally abusive.  My entire world revolved around him and the kids.  I haven't worked outside of the home for 11 years.  I barely have any friends...to the outside world, my life is perfect.  I've threatened to leave him many times and never did go through with it.  3 1/2 years ago, I cheated on him with someone we casually knew.  It was a one night stand and I didn't feel good about what I did.  He suspected that I had cheated but I denied it, fearing that I would lose my children in an ugly divorce.  One year ago he quit drinking because he finally did hit me.  Things between us seemed better than ever.  Six months ago, I confessed what I had done because I felt the incredible guilt consuming me.  Now we are at the brink of a divorce.  He is uncertain whether or not he still wants to be with me.  Although I want to stay and make it work because I do love him and the kids, I myself is torn.  Is my staying really good for the both of us?  We argue over the past and decided that we need a marriage councelor.  I just don't know.  I have not cheated on him since and will not.  It was truly out of my character, and I absolutely have been  making the right steps toward earning his trust.  He is still very angry and hurt. 

I definately think that marriage counseling is a good idea regardless of the outcome of your marriage.  You two need to get your hurt and anger out in the open in a controlled environment such as a therapists office.

Many couples need direction as they can't fix the issues that are destroying their marriage.   If you should both decide that this marriage is not salvageable then at least a therapist can help you two co-parent the children and help you through a divorce.

Living with an alcoholic all those years is more than most of us can handle.  This disease ruins lives and families.  You have to work on forgiving yourself as well as him as I'm sure you are holding alot of resentments towards him.  He needs to forgive himself for ruining your marriage and the emotional and physial abuse he made you endure.  Sounds easy but we all know it is not.  

If you two can ever get on the same page and forgive yourselves and eachother for the past you could have an incredible marriage.  I hope that the both of you are in AA and AlAnon as well. 

Make an appt. with a therapist and agree not to argue about the past.  Fighting will get you no where at this point both of you are too upset, angry, hurt and confused to make any headway or decisions.  Most therapist will recommend a year in therapy before any final decision should be made.   

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 28, 2007, 8:04 am PDT

Infidelity

Quote From: needhelpasap

I have been married to my husband for 14 yrs. and have two young children.  He was an alcoholic and was verbally abusive.  My entire world revolved around him and the kids.  I haven't worked outside of the home for 11 years.  I barely have any friends...to the outside world, my life is perfect.  I've threatened to leave him many times and never did go through with it.  3 1/2 years ago, I cheated on him with someone we casually knew.  It was a one night stand and I didn't feel good about what I did.  He suspected that I had cheated but I denied it, fearing that I would lose my children in an ugly divorce.  One year ago he quit drinking because he finally did hit me.  Things between us seemed better than ever.  Six months ago, I confessed what I had done because I felt the incredible guilt consuming me.  Now we are at the brink of a divorce.  He is uncertain whether or not he still wants to be with me.  Although I want to stay and make it work because I do love him and the kids, I myself is torn.  Is my staying really good for the both of us?  We argue over the past and decided that we need a marriage councelor.  I just don't know.  I have not cheated on him since and will not.  It was truly out of my character, and I absolutely have been  making the right steps toward earning his trust.  He is still very angry and hurt. 
Working with the counselor is a good idea - they should be able to provide guidance.

Take deep breaths and don't do anything rash.  Has he forgiven you for the affair? Have you forgiven him for the way has has treated you all those years? Have you forgiven yourself?

If you don't know my story - I had an emotional affair two months ago - out of my character as well. As i have said to others before, there is no rational explaination for infidelity. Even though it is socially wrong, I can understand how you became susceptible. You are not a horrible person.  It does happen, even to the best of us.

Every since I confessd to Wendy - it has been a rollercoaster of emotions. Some days we find it impossible to think it can get any better - hang in there.

Just keep in mind it is a new day.  You can't change the past - but you can learn from it and become a better partner. Stop beating yourself up and remember you deserve a quality relationship. Turn over every stone to find a way to make this work for the both of you. If the two of you cannot work it out, then like pp said, find a way to be good co-parents.

Hope you two can reconcile,

Chris
 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
October 29, 2007, 10:44 am PDT

Thanks

Quote From: sandy0914

I definately think that marriage counseling is a good idea regardless of the outcome of your marriage.  You two need to get your hurt and anger out in the open in a controlled environment such as a therapists office.

Many couples need direction as they can't fix the issues that are destroying their marriage.   If you should both decide that this marriage is not salvageable then at least a therapist can help you two co-parent the children and help you through a divorce.

Living with an alcoholic all those years is more than most of us can handle.  This disease ruins lives and families.  You have to work on forgiving yourself as well as him as I'm sure you are holding alot of resentments towards him.  He needs to forgive himself for ruining your marriage and the emotional and physial abuse he made you endure.  Sounds easy but we all know it is not.  

If you two can ever get on the same page and forgive yourselves and eachother for the past you could have an incredible marriage.  I hope that the both of you are in AA and AlAnon as well. 

Make an appt. with a therapist and agree not to argue about the past.  Fighting will get you no where at this point both of you are too upset, angry, hurt and confused to make any headway or decisions.  Most therapist will recommend a year in therapy before any final decision should be made.   

Thanks for your empathy, and help putting it into perspective.  My emotions get in the way of logic and having someone who can share their thoughts brings me back to reality.  Thanks to you too Chris.  I guess I am not alone.  I understand I need to be realistic of the whole healing process and how long it will take for us to get there. 
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
chillin'
October 31, 2007, 2:53 pm PDT

Still confused here...

Quote From: jelebean1

Unfortunately I didn't find these things again until a few weeks after he had the stroke and I got on his computer. So here I was nursing this person, being a good wife and human being and pretty much just getting crapped on. Sorry to be so blunt but I see no other way to put it.....In fact I HAVE pity for him is the problem vs NO pity if you read what I wrote....If he was not sick I would have left and gone to take care of my mother where I know I would be appreciated. His being sick  is a great part of why I am here. I will say that monetary reasons are  also a huge part of things and even when he was gone he always left a majority of the money to pay the bills and I will go as far as to say relieve some of his guilt. He wrote me a letter a few weeks ago and basically acknowledged that he knows he has a problem and has for years. Dishonesty has been a way of life apparently for a large portion of his adulthood and has torn up past relationships as well as this one. I have turned into an extremely tolerant person as I have aged and have been living my life for my children who are now all nearly grown. Maybe it isn't much in the way of self respect but keep in mind that this is my third marriage, I am a person of deep commitment and also have religious views now that I didn't hold several years ago. On the other hand I have the harsh slap of reality telling me that the minute he is better his behavior will repeat.

 

My family knows very little. "Our" daughter just happens to be the youngest of six and we have one more child left at home. (yours mine and ours.....)  I hide so much inside and put on a happy face. No one at church knows and very little people outside of my closest circle of friends know.

 

Do  I love this man? Absolutely with all my heart. I know he hates the messes he has created but it is like he is an addict of some sort who doesn't know how to handle his issues and I am a person who feels like they are treading water to help everyone else stay afloat.  

 OK, so you're saying that you thought your husband was being faithful until after his stroke when you found evidence that he was still carrying on the same sad saga of porn and setting up meets with people. Don't worry about your words, they are apt. You HAVE been crapped on, more than once.

What I was asking was what has changed this time?

 He has never been a good husband, and you have caught him in the past in infidelities and lying. Yet you stayed with him. You do admit that part of the reason you stayed was because he always provided for you and the kids. You don't have to say anything on these boards if you don't want to, but you MUST be brutally honest with yourself.  Did you settle for this arrangement because it enabled you to take care of your children better than you could have as a single parent? Did you delude yourself about what he was up to because it was easier to do so than to divorce him and have the kid's lives uprooted again? And now that he has had a stroke you may have to see more of him in the future than you care to, and THIS is what has you contemplating leaving him? I would add, is this why you feel guilty and protest that you DO love him, etc etc etc?

Understand, I'm NOT judging you. I know all too well what it feels like to be trapped in a marriage that seems to be all in favor of the one who is lying and cheating. What you have is a crisis. He has been slapped with his mortality and you are not so sure you can muster the proper sentiments, especially in the face of the latest discoveries.

I can't tell you what to do, beyond what I have- face your demons. If you really believe that he will revert to his former ways when he is better, then maybe it's time to take stock of your life and what you have been deluding yourself about all these years.

So that means things have to change. I can sense in your posts the reluctance, the wishing it would all just resolve itself and life go on much as it did before. I know this feeling also, he made the mess, he should have to do all the work. The thing you have to realize is that you enabled him to get away with it all these years. He may have developed some nasty habits, but you let it get swept under the rug. I know how easy that is when you're raising kids, when your husband is uninvolved, you tend to put the kids above the marriage. When he doesn't beat you and pays the bills and leaves for periods of time, it helps you to set up your life in a way that gets you through the day. It's not a glamorous life, but you feel "normal." Until things are upset and there's no going back. (This is the "change" I wanted you to zero in on.)

Dr Phil recommends that you work your way out of a marriage, by availing yourself of counseling and anything else that you can try. My suggestion is that if your husband is truly remorseful, but doesn't seem to be doing much to make it up to you, YOU need to fill in the blanks for him. Decide what you need from him and let him know. Hold him to any agreements he makes with you. Beware of ultimatums though, like "I'll divorce you if you ever___again" unless you are absolutely prepared to back them up with action.

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
chillin'
October 31, 2007, 3:12 pm PDT

Definitely counseling...

Quote From: needhelpasap

I have been married to my husband for 14 yrs. and have two young children.  He was an alcoholic and was verbally abusive.  My entire world revolved around him and the kids.  I haven't worked outside of the home for 11 years.  I barely have any friends...to the outside world, my life is perfect.  I've threatened to leave him many times and never did go through with it.  3 1/2 years ago, I cheated on him with someone we casually knew.  It was a one night stand and I didn't feel good about what I did.  He suspected that I had cheated but I denied it, fearing that I would lose my children in an ugly divorce.  One year ago he quit drinking because he finally did hit me.  Things between us seemed better than ever.  Six months ago, I confessed what I had done because I felt the incredible guilt consuming me.  Now we are at the brink of a divorce.  He is uncertain whether or not he still wants to be with me.  Although I want to stay and make it work because I do love him and the kids, I myself is torn.  Is my staying really good for the both of us?  We argue over the past and decided that we need a marriage councelor.  I just don't know.  I have not cheated on him since and will not.  It was truly out of my character, and I absolutely have been  making the right steps toward earning his trust.  He is still very angry and hurt. 
 I agree that you two should get the counseling. I would also remind your husband that just as he is not perfect, you aren't either. YOU were the one that took the brunt of his drinking all those years. Even though you admit that his drinking didn't make you cheat, neither of you were participating in a functional relationship and this caused you to be vulnerable. Just as he decided to take control of himself when he hit "bottom" and struck you, you are taking accountability for YOUR hitting bottom and cheating. You can point out to him that you admitted your mistake because you love him and respect him enough to let him decide how to react to it. You can say that you hope he will decide to hang in there with you as have done with him, but the choice is his.
Make no mistake, your telling him about your affair was the supreme act of your love for him and the respect you owe him as your husband. Just as much as his deciding to get sober when he committed an act that was repugnant to him.
 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
angry
November 1, 2007, 7:20 am PDT

why is this happening so much

Quote From: ritehere

 OK, so you're saying that you thought your husband was being faithful until after his stroke when you found evidence that he was still carrying on the same sad saga of porn and setting up meets with people. Don't worry about your words, they are apt. You HAVE been crapped on, more than once.

What I was asking was what has changed this time?

 He has never been a good husband, and you have caught him in the past in infidelities and lying. Yet you stayed with him. You do admit that part of the reason you stayed was because he always provided for you and the kids. You don't have to say anything on these boards if you don't want to, but you MUST be brutally honest with yourself.  Did you settle for this arrangement because it enabled you to take care of your children better than you could have as a single parent? Did you delude yourself about what he was up to because it was easier to do so than to divorce him and have the kid's lives uprooted again? And now that he has had a stroke you may have to see more of him in the future than you care to, and THIS is what has you contemplating leaving him? I would add, is this why you feel guilty and protest that you DO love him, etc etc etc?

Understand, I'm NOT judging you. I know all too well what it feels like to be trapped in a marriage that seems to be all in favor of the one who is lying and cheating. What you have is a crisis. He has been slapped with his mortality and you are not so sure you can muster the proper sentiments, especially in the face of the latest discoveries.

I can't tell you what to do, beyond what I have- face your demons. If you really believe that he will revert to his former ways when he is better, then maybe it's time to take stock of your life and what you have been deluding yourself about all these years.

So that means things have to change. I can sense in your posts the reluctance, the wishing it would all just resolve itself and life go on much as it did before. I know this feeling also, he made the mess, he should have to do all the work. The thing you have to realize is that you enabled him to get away with it all these years. He may have developed some nasty habits, but you let it get swept under the rug. I know how easy that is when you're raising kids, when your husband is uninvolved, you tend to put the kids above the marriage. When he doesn't beat you and pays the bills and leaves for periods of time, it helps you to set up your life in a way that gets you through the day. It's not a glamorous life, but you feel "normal." Until things are upset and there's no going back. (This is the "change" I wanted you to zero in on.)

Dr Phil recommends that you work your way out of a marriage, by availing yourself of counseling and anything else that you can try. My suggestion is that if your husband is truly remorseful, but doesn't seem to be doing much to make it up to you, YOU need to fill in the blanks for him. Decide what you need from him and let him know. Hold him to any agreements he makes with you. Beware of ultimatums though, like "I'll divorce you if you ever___again" unless you are absolutely prepared to back them up with action.

My husband of 19 years has had multiple extra marital affairs, I found out recently. His excuse was alcohol and drug use. he has since quit that, and we are now living seperatley. He would always and still flys in to a rage when I want to discuss why, when and how could this happen, we now have three very good teenagers, and this is hard on them, what is wrong with men? some just are not happy with what they have. no matter how great it is. The worst part of my life was we went to vegas to renew our vows in Feb 2004. I found out just last July through his medical records that he had an affair in March 2004. this person is unstable, he claims he found God, AND GIVES THE CHURCH 100.00 A MONTH. Is he trying to buy his way to Heaven? Help, the counselors do not seem to help me.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

i

 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
November 1, 2007, 7:30 am PDT

what is the real reason men cheat

why do we even get married in the first place, is this a conspiracy? I have been in a marriage of lies, betrayal, emotional abuse, etc. I am now 50 and on my own again as if I were 21. going back to school to get a nursing degree. I am so upset about the stories I read on here about men that cannot appreciate their wives and kids, I think there are too may sleezy women with sleezy clothes that prance around our husbands hoping to get there attention well they do. and if I ever get a chance to confront the women who have ruined my life, they will be saying a prayer.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 1, 2007, 8:16 am PDT

Infidelity

Quote From: jw1956

why do we even get married in the first place, is this a conspiracy? I have been in a marriage of lies, betrayal, emotional abuse, etc. I am now 50 and on my own again as if I were 21. going back to school to get a nursing degree. I am so upset about the stories I read on here about men that cannot appreciate their wives and kids, I think there are too may sleezy women with sleezy clothes that prance around our husbands hoping to get there attention well they do. and if I ever get a chance to confront the women who have ruined my life, they will be saying a prayer.
I am truly sorry you had to experience the pain of being cheated on. I understand your anger. When it comes to having an affair, I believe it is mostly driven by most peoples emotional needs. There are people who do it just out of spite - but for others I believe it is an emotional release.

I remember the OW in my affair rationalized her acts as "Sometimes, people do what, at the time, seems like the right thing to do." Sounds like a cop out? Maybe. I felt there was a closed door between me and my wife. What I have learned through therapy is my depression/OCD distorted my perception of the situation. While I am still working to get over my issues, I have to do a sanity check when I feel negative about something.  Mental illness is a real thing.  While I do not want to use it as a cruch, it does helps me understand myself better.

I speculate you would always look down on me and others who have cheated. Thats ok. I have forgiven myself.
 
Just like myself, you are a good person.You deserve quality relationships. You are a loving person.

I hope you find your peace,

Chris
 
First | Prev | 409 | 410 | 411 | 412 | 413 | 414 | 415 | 416 | 417 | 418 | Next | Last