Message Boards

Topic : Relationship Myths

Number of Replies: 1001
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:02:55 pm
Author : dataimport
Think there's something wrong with your marriage because it doesn't go along with one of the common relationship myths that Dr. Phil outlines in "Relationship Rescue"?

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
December 13, 2006, 9:43 pm PST

Relationship Myths

Quote From: sally_ray

Hi,

 

Thanks for your reply. I know what you said is exactly right. I should have really called police when he hit me first time ,that would have got him on the right track...But it was a new country for me and i did not know what he was capable of doing. That was the worst day of my life i felt so horrible and hopeless i would have ended my life almost. But by god's grace my own classmate also lived in the same city i called and told her everything, she gave me lot of moral support.

but he was also very scared after the incident as i said i will call police,he also appologized and has not hit me since then...I was also trying to contact local distress center in USA ,that also scared him quite a bit. But he has started this new thing of saying "get out".........it hurts me a lot...

But honestly i have also added some fuel to the fire i think....like this week end i had done lot of cleaning in the morning when he was enjoying his 1 hr bath..later in the afternoon he saw some a week old food stuff in container in fridge and that when the argument began that i dont keep the house clean etc...but he indirectly said getout which made me angry and i tore our marriage photograph which made a big fire and he said get out.....I was so angry that i almost charged at him with great anger but did not do anything just walked away..he was trying to stop me all the way till the entrance of our building when i said some of his weeknesses tohim which is the truth...then he said GET OUT and DONT COME BACK..it was bitter winter weather outside and i just walked down the road and sat in the park nearby crying...but then suddenly i felt that he may call my parents and i was just coming out of the park when i saw him coming looking for me.....then i just walked with him...He said " there is no use crying...Our marriage is working..if something happens to us we both will cry but the world will go on....why do you tear marriage photographs? It breaks my heart...." for this i told him why do you tear my heart by saying getout everytime....but he doesnot realize the difference!!!!! I dont know how to treat this guy.....Do you still feel that this guy is abusive? you should help me out because i dont have much experience in life....

it sounds to me that you both can use some marital counsleing and it would be good if you did it together but if he refuses to do it then you should any way, it can help you to sort out your feelings and give you some input from a  professional. and Yes, I do think he sounds abusive, words hurt and he needs to realize that and get a grip on life and his responsibility as a husband and he is very manipualtvie. He sees your faults (tearing the photgraph) but he doesn' see his (telling you to get out) Don't make it so easy on him butyet keep the communication lines open. Marriage takes a whole lot of work and for it to be loving and caring, then you have to be on the same page and work together and respect one anothers feelings, and it doesn't sound like he does this.

honeslty, if my husband told me to get out and not come back, I would pack my stuff in a heart beat and get on out of there and even with him following me, I would have made him earn his way back into my life. I believe in working ona marriage 100% but I do not believe in being a doormat. Stand up for yourself and make him "hear" you. It maynot be an easy process but you are worth loving and respecting, therefore you have the right to demand that in your life, there is a mature way of handling issues and the way things are being handled, doesn't sound to mature to me.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 14, 2006, 11:08 am PST

Breaking mom and dad's hearts

Quote From: sally_ray

When I find a mistake in him

I keep it in mind, but dont really make it a big deal.. I dont really say anything atall.

I am a person who likes to mind my own business.

 

When he finds a mistake..

Tries to talk meanly about it and uses it to show me down

 

When there is a fight.

He uses harsh words like get out and tries to talk meanly about my parents

I argue for the actual reason of the fight and I do fight, I dont use any harsh words or talk about his parents.. I mean he really hurts my self respect through his words.

 

Who cools down first?

He. He comes talking sweetly as if nothing has happened.

It takes a couple of days for me to cool down.

 

Who apologizes ?

None

 

A little about his background : He is a very arrogant guy ,because he has an MS degree and an MBA degree. His mom always poisions his mind about my parents so that he has a bad opinion about them and also to some extent me.

 

I am only a bachelors degree holder ,got married and moved to USA to join him.

I used to work back home and have a very good salary and was in a very good company.

But I did not get work visa when I moved to USA there was no way I could work.

Even now I dont have job and have to depend on this guy.  And hear get out whenever there is argument even for a small thing. He says u have come to my house so if you dont want to obey me u get out..He also hit me once ,but I also gave him slap on in face in answer to his beating and told him I will call policebut I had got bad bruise

 

Yes I would never mind leaving this jerk behind but I am only sticking to this marriage because I want my loving parents to be happy.if I break my marriage ,it will break their heartThis may sound funny but I love my parents that much

 

Some of my mistakes --- 
I get angry quickly when provoked

I may be in some worries and forget to cleanup bathroom or fridge some time as I have this marriage worry and job worry

 

Some of his good thingshe supports whatever I want to do with job or career as long as it does not cause him any inconvenience. He always accompanies me to all my interviews.But still at the bottom of my heart I hate him ,because I feel he is a kind of guy who will be there with me as long as I am useful to him.But I want this marriage to workoutbecause I just cant afford to break my parents heart because they are already struggling with other retirement problemsWhat should I do please help.

Do you think that your mom and dad WANT their daughter to be emotionally, verbally and sometimes physically abused?

You believe that your parents would be heartbroken if this marriage doesn’t work out, but what about your happiness? You have no power or control over anyone else, not even your parents- the only person that you have any power over is YOU.

Are your parents still in your home country? If they are, keep in mind that they do not need to know about your circumstances. The best advice I can give you is to look in your phone book for a domestic violence hot line- the people on the other end of the line can give you a lot of valuable advice and even assist you with finding a new home and even a job- there are people out there who want to help you have a happy, healthy life. Your husband has his own selfish reasons for having you around; its as though you are his ‘pet’ or his toy, as long as you don’t make a mess, etc.

The only way you can be happy is to resolve the issues within your relationship; but you can’t do that on your own. Your husband has to be willing to work on these issues with you, he has to WANT to extend common courtesy to you, his own wife- but it sounds like he isn’t interested in that at all. Please look in your phone book and seek outside help. The phone number is a toll-free phone number that won’t show up on the phone bill, and you can call just to talk and receive moral support, you don’t have to make a plan to leave right away; this is just something to think about. I wish you the very best, and I'm sure that your parents want the very best for you, too!!

 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
December 17, 2006, 5:58 pm PST

Relationship Myths

Quote From: jaimie1974

Do you think that your mom and dad WANT their daughter to be emotionally, verbally and sometimes physically abused?

You believe that your parents would be heartbroken if this marriage doesnt work out, but what about your happiness? You have no power or control over anyone else, not even your parents- the only person that you have any power over is YOU.

Are your parents still in your home country? If they are, keep in mind that they do not need to know about your circumstances. The best advice I can give you is to look in your phone book for a domestic violence hot line- the people on the other end of the line can give you a lot of valuable advice and even assist you with finding a new home and even a job- there are people out there who want to help you have a happy, healthy life. Your husband has his own selfish reasons for having you around; its as though you are his pet or his toy, as long as you dont make a mess, etc.

The only way you can be happy is to resolve the issues within your relationship; but you cant do that on your own. Your husband has to be willing to work on these issues with you, he has to WANT to extend common courtesy to you, his own wife- but it sounds like he isnt interested in that at all. Please look in your phone book and seek outside help. The phone number is a toll-free phone number that wont show up on the phone bill, and you can call just to talk and receive moral support, you dont have to make a plan to leave right away; this is just something to think about. I wish you the very best, and I'm sure that your parents want the very best for you, too!!

    Hi,

 I know i should do that. I was only worried abt breaking their heart because my only sister is herself going through divorce :( . My parents are already very upset about it....But i already have contaced local people who will help me and i have their number.  My husband happened to findout about it and was very upset. Looks like he keeps track of all the calls i make. He will make a good spy. But i really want to leave him....

 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
worried
January 6, 2007, 10:44 pm PST

RELATIONSHIP MYTHS

 I THINK THATWHEN A MAN GETS MARRIED HE SHOULD ,PUT HIS WIFE FIRST ,BUT AS FOR MINE IT,S NOT THAT WAY ,I CAN,T BUILD A HOME WITH MY HUSBAND BECAUSE HE IS ALWAYS DEFENDING HIS BRO.MOTHER ,AND GROWN KIDS. IN WHATEVER THEY WANT,WE CAN.T EVEN HAVE A GET TOGETHER WITHOUT THEY DONT HAVE TO ASK MY HUSBAND ,S EX-WIFE TO COME  IVE TOLD MY BRO.IN LAW THAT IT MAKES ME CONCONFORTABLE TO HAVE MY HUSBAND,S EX-WIFE AT THESE THING,BUT IT SEEM NOT TO MATTER. I WAS PLANING TO HAVE CHRISTMAS AT OUR HOUSE BUT AT THE LAST MIN. MY HUSBAND SAID IT WOULD BE BETTER TO LET HIS BECAUSE WE DIDNT REALLY HAVE THE MONEY TO FED THEM ALL,HOW DUM DO THEY THINK I AM IT WAS ALL SO HIS EX-SISTER IN LAW COULD BE AT HIS HOUSE BECAUSE SHE CANT COME TO OURS NOT TO ANY THING, IM TIRED OF BEING DISRESPECTED IN MY HOME AND NOT ENJOYING THE TIME WITH THEM ,MY MOTHER IN LAW  DOESNT  LIKE ME SHE TOLD ME SO. AND SHE HAS TOLD ME TO SHUT UP SIX TIMES ALREADY,BUT HE NEVER SAYS ANYTHING TO HER,IT MAKES ME FEEL LIKE MY FEELING DONT MATTER,MY HEART IS HEAVEY ,I MISS OUT ON CHRISTMAS THIS TO BECAUSE OF THE EX-WIFE BEING THERE. SHE CHOSE 28 YEARS AGO TO GET THE DIVORCEFOR HIM, BUT THEY STILL INVITE HER TO EVERTHING ,I DONT WONT TO LIVE IN THIS WOMAN,S SHAOWO I NEED TO HAVE TIME TO BOND WITH HIS FAMILY WITHOUT HER THERE AND I NEED TO FEEL THAT HE IS ON MY SIDE ,AND NOT ALWAYS TAKING HIS FAMILYS SIDE WHAT SHOULD I DO?   MEANDLUKE(LUKE,S MY PET) 
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
January 11, 2007, 2:41 pm PST

Relationship Myths

Quote From: sally_ray

When I find a mistake in him

I keep it in mind, but dont really make it a big deal.. I dont really say anything atall.

I am a person who likes to mind my own business.

 

When he finds a mistake..

Tries to talk meanly about it and uses it to show me down

 

When there is a fight.

He uses harsh words like get out and tries to talk meanly about my parents

I argue for the actual reason of the fight and I do fight, I dont use any harsh words or talk about his parents.. I mean he really hurts my self respect through his words.

 

Who cools down first?

He. He comes talking sweetly as if nothing has happened.

It takes a couple of days for me to cool down.

 

Who apologizes ?

None

 

A little about his background : He is a very arrogant guy ,because he has an MS degree and an MBA degree. His mom always poisions his mind about my parents so that he has a bad opinion about them and also to some extent me.

 

I am only a bachelors degree holder ,got married and moved to USA to join him.

I used to work back home and have a very good salary and was in a very good company.

But I did not get work visa when I moved to USA there was no way I could work.

Even now I dont have job and have to depend on this guy.  And hear get out whenever there is argument even for a small thing. He says u have come to my house so if you dont want to obey me u get out..He also hit me once ,but I also gave him slap on in face in answer to his beating and told him I will call policebut I had got bad bruise

 

Yes I would never mind leaving this jerk behind but I am only sticking to this marriage because I want my loving parents to be happy.if I break my marriage ,it will break their heartThis may sound funny but I love my parents that much

 

Some of my mistakes --- 
I get angry quickly when provoked

I may be in some worries and forget to cleanup bathroom or fridge some time as I have this marriage worry and job worry

 

Some of his good thingshe supports whatever I want to do with job or career as long as it does not cause him any inconvenience. He always accompanies me to all my interviews.But still at the bottom of my heart I hate him ,because I feel he is a kind of guy who will be there with me as long as I am useful to him.But I want this marriage to workoutbecause I just cant afford to break my parents heart because they are already struggling with other retirement problemsWhat should I do please help.

Please check out the "abuse" message board on this site. There is TONS of information there...including how to recognize whether or not you're in an abusive relationship. I have a feeling you might recognize yourself in a LOT of the posts there. Many of the women there have already "been there, done that"..and are on the other side now...including myself. I found the site extremely informative and there's support there that's not to be believed. You'll get the truth...no one's going to "sugarcoat" the truth from you. But it's all done with loving intentions towards helping someone else. Please. Check it out...

Peace to you....

 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
upset
January 23, 2007, 6:56 am PST

no more trust

i am in desperate need of some kind of advice and emtional help!  Here's my situation.  My husband and i have been married for 3 years and just recently had a baby.  when we got married i clearly stated that i would have zero tolerance for drugs and cheating.  I had a bad experience with drugs with a friend of mine so i decide that i would not have them in my life or around me.  I just found out that my husband has been experimenting with drugs before our child was born.  I knew something was going on but everytime i asked him anything he blew me off.  Now i've come to find out that  he's been lying to me this entire time.  How can I trust him now?  I was very upfront with him about my feeling on drugs and now he has betrayed me.  He crossed the line.  To make matters worst we have a new baby and we agreeed that we wouldn't have a child until we were both mature enough and ready.  It turns out that he wasn't.  He promises me that it's not a habbit but the way i see it is that the damage is already done.  what do i do?   I don't want to divorce but he's told me too many lies and i can't trust him anymore.  we've had other problems and i've given him many chances to make things right but he just can't do it.  is there anyone who is in a similar situation?

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 23, 2007, 8:29 am PST

Lying husband

Quote From: carriep26

i am in desperate need of some kind of advice and emtional help!  Here's my situation.  My husband and i have been married for 3 years and just recently had a baby.  when we got married i clearly stated that i would have zero tolerance for drugs and cheating.  I had a bad experience with drugs with a friend of mine so i decide that i would not have them in my life or around me.  I just found out that my husband has been experimenting with drugs before our child was born.  I knew something was going on but everytime i asked him anything he blew me off.  Now i've come to find out that  he's been lying to me this entire time.  How can I trust him now?  I was very upfront with him about my feeling on drugs and now he has betrayed me.  He crossed the line.  To make matters worst we have a new baby and we agreeed that we wouldn't have a child until we were both mature enough and ready.  It turns out that he wasn't.  He promises me that it's not a habbit but the way i see it is that the damage is already done.  what do i do?   I don't want to divorce but he's told me too many lies and i can't trust him anymore.  we've had other problems and i've given him many chances to make things right but he just can't do it.  is there anyone who is in a similar situation?

This is very sad! It sounds like you have only wanted to do the right thing from the very start, but your husband isn’t on the same maturity level and he doesn’t have it in him to be honest with you. The only suggestion I have for you is marriage counseling; talking to a professional about your thoughts, feelings and the reasons why you are so disappointed will be validating for you, and it could help your husband to understand better how much damage he has caused. If he won’t go, then you need to go by yourself; this is something you need to do for yourself. You have a child now and you have to think of what is best for that child. Having a father around who does drugs, even “only” once in awhile, is harmful. Take care of yourself and I wish you well.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 23, 2007, 12:06 pm PST

Men can be slu_ _ too

I was married to a man I met while we were in the military.  He was considered a "man's man",  and all the women wanted him, too.  I wasn't in love with him, just wanted to be married because I was in my early 30s and figured it was what I was supposed to do (be).  I knew he couldn't keep it in his pants, the night  before we got married he was sleeping with his female boss, an Army Major.  Well, I hoped once we were married he'd change.  He certainly did that!!! It wasn't two years later the romance and sex stopped between him and me.  He was spending late hours at work, being very secretive, would not communicate with me regarding issues of our married life together, when we visited his family consisting of four sisters, his mom and dad, he would go off for hours with his sisters, one who even gave him French kisses when she thought I wasn't looking, and ultimately ended up being impregnated by my husband.  Yes, I learned quickly that his interest was sharing his affections with as many other people he could, except me.  Even other men in the Army would need him to go places with them for hours at a time, and I found out there was much, shall we say hanky panky, going on with some officers who found him to be quite attractive.  One night when my husband was drinking and had quite a bit, he broke down and began to cry, then he told me all sorts of things, like his escapades with his sisters, nieces, nephews, other women and some of the men.  This confession was in 1985, after 11 years of marriage, nine of which we spent living together more as roommates than anything else.  I moved out of the home shortly thereafter and our divorce was final in December, 1986.  The man divorced me at a time I was unable to contest the provision of the divorce, so even after being married for 12 years, I received nothing, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING in the divorce.  I was always faithful to him, and contributed to the marriage 100% with regard to finances, etc. but he always put his parents and other family members, his job and his friends ahead of me.  I  was his fourth wife, and I hear he has married at least two more women since. 

I have been on my own for the past twenty years, and I've got the best life I've ever had.  Being a woman doesn't mean I need a man.  There is nothing a man can do for me that I can't do for myself (think about that, lol).  I had the perfect man my very first marriage, he died at age 27 in 1971 of a stroke.  I'm not interested in a committed relationship anymore. 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
January 24, 2007, 1:45 am PST

Relationship Myths

Quote From: jaimie1974

This is very sad! It sounds like you have only wanted to do the right thing from the very start, but your husband isnt on the same maturity level and he doesnt have it in him to be honest with you. The only suggestion I have for you is marriage counseling; talking to a professional about your thoughts, feelings and the reasons why you are so disappointed will be validating for you, and it could help your husband to understand better how much damage he has caused. If he wont go, then you need to go by yourself; this is something you need to do for yourself. You have a child now and you have to think of what is best for that child. Having a father around who does drugs, even only once in awhile, is harmful. Take care of yourself and I wish you well.

Drugs destroy people, and entire families.  I am sure of that. Join ALANON, a program for families and friends of people who are in drugs; this is a program from AA (Alcoholics Anonomus.  They will support you, and they might even help you find a good councelor.  It's good that you realize you need help with this; to me, people who mess around with drugs are troubled, unhappy, unpredictable, and very comfused.  You have yourself and your baby to think about;  while your husband gets his "high" from his drugs, you and your baby will get the pain that goes with it.  (and it's always there... believe me.)

I'll keep you and your baby in my prayers.    

 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
February 15, 2007, 4:33 pm PST

emotional affair?????

hi i am new to dr phil. i have a question?my husband of almost 9 years of marriage keeps on doing things that i dont approve of . like going to nude strip bars , watching porn , flirting around at work  and also confessing to masturbate while thinking about a sexy women he met at a conference. he tells me that he has  not had sex with anyone  so all this is ok and if i make a fusy i am just over reacting after all he is here with me

Tell me people am I over reacting is this normal .I think we should take conselling.almost every day i think about divorce. i have 3 kids and that makes me think twice

 
First | Prev | 75 | 76 | 77 | 78 | 79 | 80 | 81 | 82 | 83 | 84 | Next | Last