Message Boards

Topic : 12/20 Marry Me or Else!

Number of Replies: 684
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, September 22, 2006, 12:20:09 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 09/26/06) It’s do or die for the men today, as their partners tell them to either walk down the aisle or walk the highway! Tony and Mary have dated for 12 years, and have been engaged for eight. Mary wants to set a wedding date, but Tony says even after all these years, he’s not ready and still feels pressured to tie the knot. Does Tony fear getting married or getting married to Mary? Then, Rosanna has been dating her boyfriend, Dennis, for almost five years and says she’s tired of “playing house.” Dennis maintains that he told Rosanna from the start he didn’t want to get married. Should they just throw in the towel and move on? Plus, Robin shares some relationship tips, and the women finally take a stand and issue ultimatums for their men! Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More December 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 16, 2006, 12:07 pm PST

12/20 Marry Me or Else!

i dont know what the big deal is with getting married.  spending all this time worrying about a piece of paper which means absolutely nothing.  i dont get it.
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
hopeful
December 16, 2006, 12:23 pm PST

Well some of us women want a piece of paper...

Quote From: rugman1

To all the ladies who have done nothing but complain about there boyfriends not marrying them.If a man wants to marry you,he will.Why do you all think you deserve marriage,the cooking,cleaning and bed time,isnt your man also doing things as well,the manly chores?Relationships are 50/50.What will a piece of paper do for you,is he going to love you more?I think not.If your man has been with you for a long time and things are good and your both loving each other,then why pressure your man.If two people love each other then they should be together,one should not be giving conditions to the other .
What is wrong with wanting that complete thing...paper, flowers, family...the whole works...if he loves you it can come with a piece of paper and it is such a small deed to do for love...that is all I have to say.  Amen...
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
December 16, 2006, 12:29 pm PST

The piece of paper is so small a deed ...

Quote From: ceildh1

The laws must be different in the States when it comes to Common Law couples.

Here in Canada, a Common Law couple is cosidered married after six months of contiuous co-habitation, that means if you split after only two months and get back together, that period starts ALL OVER again.

My husband and I have been together almost 18 years, an neither one of us plans on going anywhere, our view was always, if you're going to split up, that piece of paper isn't going to stop you from going out the door.  Our two children have their father's last name, I'm really no different from the wife that keeps here maiden name after the wedding, and yes both children have the same father.

We are faithful to each other, same rules apply here, you cheat, God help you, we file our income taxes together , we can buy a home together, and raise our children.  If we split, there is still the lawyers fees of dividing up assets, and child support, or alimony, we have a joint chequing account, and joint savings, is this sounding any different from MOST married couples so far ?

Our pay cheques are pooled together, we are each other's next of kin, and executors not to mention power of attorney ( though I realize ANYONE can be given those roles) and we are each other's beneficiaries of any insurance policies, not to mention, I am also on his job's medical insurance.

So the difference, we chose another option that we were given, we couldn't justify the cost of ONE DAY, or the hassle for that matter.  Do I worry that he's just going to "walk out" no, because I know with or without the whole piece of Paper or ceremony, he could anyway, the divorce rate currently should squash those illusions

To some people, all the Bells and whistles are a necessity, and it is what they want, WONDERFUL, but you BOTH have to be on the same page, and no one is going to be happy if they feel like going down the aisle, is like that walk down death row, what it comes down to, COMMUNICATION, and figuring out what is important to you, if its marriage, be UPFRONT about that, and stick to a time limit.

My husband and I are happy with the status quo, and our kids are growing up healthy and happy, but like marriage, our relationship takes alot of work, and we are both too stubborn to give up too easily.

I just prefer to be the Bridesmaid, not the Bride.

Why is everyone so afraid of a little piece of paper...we sign things all the time.  Checks...aren't we women worth more than a check ... or what?  It just makes me wonder why we are so afraid of it...leaving can happen but so can dying...don't you want to say I love you for all time on a little note...that is legal?  Love is more...when it is more than just from the heart...it is declared for all

time to all to see...you will be remembered on that paper by all future generations that you have to follow you...to see how much you loved...not just words but on a piece of paper...this is one subject that is my pet peeve...all the great poets are gone when no one wants to sign a little piece of paper.

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
December 16, 2006, 2:53 pm PST

12/20 Marry Me or Else!

I personally do not understand why people stay together when one doesn't want the full committment but the other does, been there but no way was I going to "play house" with the guy, he eiither wanted me 100% or he didn't. Love can be hard at times and certainly worth fighting for. Thankfully, everything turned out the way I wanted it to for me, but I was prepared for the worse, wasn't easy but I took the first step, and it got him to thinking about what he really feared and wanted in life.  No one should be "forced" into something they are not ready or doesn't want to do but at the same time, one should not be manipulated and expected to sit back with shattered dreams, gotta communicate and get to the root of the issue, figure out a plan and go with it.

Marriage is a big committment which unfortunetly isn't taken serious these days, sad but true for a lot of people, so it is understandable why some may not want to commit but I think it is more of a cop out then anything for some, they want the relationship, the live in whatever,but they don't want the 100% accountability, which really is a sad thing, for marriage is a beautiful experience when you truly are in love and want it to be loving and lasting, well worth the "I do's"
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
December 16, 2006, 3:17 pm PST

Find what you want first...

 It sounds to me like Tony and Mary want different things.  If Mary wants to get married, she should look for someone else because forcing a guy into a marriage he doesn't want is just going to cause resentment.  After being engaged for even a few months without setting a date i would have to cancel the engagement, or at least talk to him about what he wants.  A woman's biological clock only ticks for so long before it stops, and he wasted 12 years of them that she can't get back.  After a certain age it becomes dangerous to have kids (if that's what she wanted) and it's not fair to her.  It's not fair to pressure HIM either,  and if he wants to date around for longer, he should be able to do that, but they both need to be honest with each other.

 

If he doesn't want to get married, i think she should just move on.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
December 16, 2006, 3:24 pm PST

piece of paper

Quote From: theresa1933

Why is everyone so afraid of a little piece of paper...we sign things all the time.  Checks...aren't we women worth more than a check ... or what?  It just makes me wonder why we are so afraid of it...leaving can happen but so can dying...don't you want to say I love you for all time on a little note...that is legal?  Love is more...when it is more than just from the heart...it is declared for all

time to all to see...you will be remembered on that paper by all future generations that you have to follow you...to see how much you loved...not just words but on a piece of paper...this is one subject that is my pet peeve...all the great poets are gone when no one wants to sign a little piece of paper.

  I think that people are afraid to get things in writing because it's legal and they can go to court and it's official.  But so is a prenup agreement if you want to cover your butt.

 

If you sign a piece of paper, it binds you to it, and it gives the other person the feeling like youre taking the relationship seriously because it's now public record.  Why would you want to hide your love in obscurity, anyway?  If it shows your spouse/fiance that you don't have any qualms committing to them, what better way to prove that to them? 

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
hopeful
December 16, 2006, 3:40 pm PST

Maybe everyone expects too much from marriage

Quote From: lovingone

First let me say that I am not implying ANYTHING about your particular relationship and what works for you is your business.

 

But as far as nomarital long term relationships succeeding is concerned....

 

Sure it's EASY to happy with your relationship to your significant other when you basically wake up every morning DECIDING whether or not you want to be together!

 

And if you don't you can just pack you bags and leave in the middle of the night and the other person has no legal right to do anything about it!

 

A lot of us have "friends" that show up for the "party" and then we can't find them when we really need support.

 

But how intimate are we with those people?

Maybe we should stop dreaming of that wonderful make believe world.  Marriage is hard work.  Not for lazy people.  You have to please and be pleased also.  It's not a 50/50 it's 200/200.  You cannot expect rewards at work for not doing it.  That is what marriage is...not just hearts and flowers...that is the beggining years.  I am married for 35 years.  It has been happy and sad sometimes both at the same time.  My husband is a better worker bee than I am.  Love is all we need.  There is not a word in our language that says what we have.  We are comfortable and

at ease with each other.  We are proud of our marriage and it's piece of paper.  I believe some people should just not marry.  Then also some people take advantage of another person.  The other person does not really matter.  Their parents do not matter.  I wanted my Dad and Mom to be proud of us...as well as My in-laws.  We would never hurt them.  Love is more than being about me me me...not a soul speaks about that anymore.  The real marriage is giving to your other half...and they give back to you.  if you cannot do this don't marry...but don't move in together either.    When there isn't any hope there isn't real love.  If someone hurts you when you ask for that piece of paper, they won't do that for you, do not stay.

They really will never give you true love.  I have been in love and out throuhtout our marriage...but we try to see the true picture.  That is where God comes into the marriage.  His ways are the way to go.  When you first marry it is hard to sacrifice...for each other... But that is true love.  Not one person winning.   He did for his people.  That is love.  Merry Christmas...

 

Message Emote
blank
December 16, 2006, 3:56 pm PST

BetteD55 got it right in her post of 23 Sept

One of Dr Phil's rules is it takes two yes's or one no. You either come to terms with that, or you get out.

 

It is foolish to make one single choice of your partner the defining aspect of their love. Are you so flawless?

 

Marriage was never about the relationship between the two lovers and certainly isn't these days, it was for the benefit of those outside the relationship, the authorities, the extended family, etc. It should not impact the feelings between the two lovers one iota.

 

Check out Dr Phil's list of what makes a successful relationship, is having a marriage ceremony critical?

 

The things that make it successful are what you do to make your lover's day better, with no expectations in return. You can't give her or him marriage, it takes two yes's. So there is no point in getting out of the current relationship until you have come to terms with that, as chances are the next lover also won't want marriage. Why go on getting unhappy and frustrated, when in all other respects these are great people to spend your life with?

 

Read what BetteD55 had to say.

 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
December 16, 2006, 5:56 pm PST

12/20 Marry Me or Else!

Quote From: theresa1933

Why is everyone so afraid of a little piece of paper...we sign things all the time.  Checks...aren't we women worth more than a check ... or what?  It just makes me wonder why we are so afraid of it...leaving can happen but so can dying...don't you want to say I love you for all time on a little note...that is legal?  Love is more...when it is more than just from the heart...it is declared for all

time to all to see...you will be remembered on that paper by all future generations that you have to follow you...to see how much you loved...not just words but on a piece of paper...this is one subject that is my pet peeve...all the great poets are gone when no one wants to sign a little piece of paper.

But why is it SO important, yes we sign things all the time, and like I said if that's what you WANT then by all means, DO IT, but not everyone wants that or feels they need it.

For some, yes it is fear, but I also said to be UPFRONT, What my husband and I are doing by the way ( see one of my pet peeves are people who judge us and get on us about that piece of paper) is PERFECTLY LEGAL in this country.

I love him and he loves me, and if no one else BELIVES that, well whatever, I make no justifacations or apologies for our relashionship, I was pointing out that there are those of us that really don't need witnesses to say that oh yes, they love each other, because it is naive to think that that paper really means much these days, again I point to the 50% divorce rate in BOTH countries.

 
User Mood
Cranky

Message Emote
blank
December 16, 2006, 6:04 pm PST

12/20 Marry Me or Else!

Quote From: theresa1933

What is wrong with wanting that complete thing...paper, flowers, family...the whole works...if he loves you it can come with a piece of paper and it is such a small deed to do for love...that is all I have to say.  Amen...

There is ABSOLUTELY NOTHING WRONG WITH IT!!!!

But NOT EVERYONE wants it, that simple.

And why exactly do people belive that common-law couples are "playing house" that really bugs me, we have the same problems and struggles of "Married Couples" and its no easier for me to leave than anyone else, to each his or her own.

 
First | Prev | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | Next | Last