Message Boards

Topic : Breaking Up

Number of Replies: 5468
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:06:14 pm
Author : dataimport
Is it time to end things with your significant other? Or, have you just been handed a relationship pink slip? Share your stories.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 29, 2006, 11:33 am PST

Re:Confused and needs to be enlightened..HELP!!!

Quote From: mktx26

How can he move  on so quickly?  Consider  yourself lucky.  Consider it closure and move on.  The love of my life , the man I've been with for 2 yrs and thought I was going to marry has slowly been moving on with his life without telling me.  He recently told me he was going skiing and would be back the next day and would call me.  I drove by the bar he hangs out at-- saw his car-- went in to find out he had plans to go out and party it up with another guy and 5 girls.  I pretended everything was fine to save face.  They decided to go somewhere else and he let me know that I ( his girlfriend, the women he professed to love) was not invited.  If I had not left first he would have walked out with all of those girls leaving me (his girlfriend) sitting alone  at the bar.   

Learn from my mistakes.  No man is worth the emotional turmoil.  I  am intelligent, some say beautifuland I usually have a good head on my shoulders.  But I let this man beat me down emotionally.  He said he loved me but actions showed different.  Maybe I wanted to be loved so badly I ignored the signs.  Now I feel he's robbed 2 yrs of my life.   How do you move on?  Hopefully youhave good friends  to  hang with.........if not maybe you live in a town that has a museum, zoo, etc.  ,  concentrate ongetting through school.  Most of all-- Love yourself.  There is nothing wrong with you-----he's the problem.  And the girl he's with?  Most likely won't last.  But you'll be well past that by then.  When you are lonely--  you tend to remember only the things you miss.  Once you get passed that you'll  remember  what you want from a relationship...........and  9 times out of 10...........he won't even be on the chart..............Good Luck---  remember you are not the only one with heartache--------but it will pass.  And you'll find better!!!!  

You asked "How can he move on so quickly? It wasn't that quick as you indicated he was away for 1 year. Truly when each of us realizes that a relationship isn't working for us anymore, the "moving on" part happens quickly... at least the part of letting to of the emotions for the other person. He could move on because he's doesn't have that emotional connection with you that you once had or thought you had. So, in reality he's been gone for sometime, you just don't know when it took place. You may not be ready to really date right now. I'm in a similar situation as I've recently left a man from only a 4 month long relationship and my heart aches for him. You'll go through a process of letting go all those thoughts and feelings and yes, it hurts knowing that he's already moved on. It's not easy to hear, however, your thoughts and feelings of him will fade as time goes by. Try to get involved with doing something or going out with a girlfriend. This time now you will grieve the relationship and take time to learn about yourself what kind of man is worthy to have you in his life. Take time away from dating before jumping onboard before you've had time to heal. Jumping into dating now could keep you from recognizing abusive or bad behaviors from other men. We can get through the pain of these heartaches.... I know I'm missing my guy, however, I know in time I'll be over him. Best wishes to you.
 
User Mood
Apathetic

Message Emote
blank
January 29, 2006, 5:56 pm PST

Breaking Up

Quote From: joyfullife

I didn't take near as long as you to recognize the unhealthy "friendship" that your boyfriend has. You have my support and I hope that you will decide to leave him entirely and not just hang "I will not have sex with him anymore" over his head until he decides to leave you and find another woman who will accept his decided situation. He's kept you around this long and continues to have "affair" like behaviors that are damaging to any committed relationship. He's pushed his unhealthy friendship as far as it will go without the physical act of a complete affair. An emotional affair is far more damaging and this is what he has with his ex-girlfriend. Your man sounds very self centered and most likely "needy". He's forcing you to accept the relationship he wants to keep with his ex-girlfriend and until HE realizes that he has an unhealthy "friendship" with her, there's nothing that will change. What you're also missing is that the ex-girlfriend is getting something out of that arrangement and she has a lot of control over him. Run, don't walk away from this man and find a man who is loving towards you. A Pastor once said the difference between Lust and Love is: Lust is looking out for oneself to satisfy our own desire without a first thought of the other person or their feelings, and Love is looking out for the other person, their feelings and making them feel safe in a relationship over our own feelings or desires. It's about putting the other person first in a relationship. I've always said that each of us need to live for someone else, in other words putting other people first and helping where we're needed.... then each of us would truly know how to be selfless. Best wishes to you. 

Thank you for confirming to me what my intuition was telling me over all this time. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 29, 2006, 10:33 pm PST

would like to hear some opinions

Hi all, 

  

Sorry for the length of this message, it's just a long story. 

  

I'm in an untypical kind of situation, totally stumped about what to do, and I'd like to hear some opinions. 

  

I'm 47, divorced 7 years with grown kids. 5 years after my divorce, when I was good and ready to settle down, I met someone through internet dating. He listed himself as divorced, but on our first date confessed that he was separated, just starting divorce proceedings. I normally don't date separated guys because they are, in general, at a time in their lives when they are, understandably confused, but we had so much potential. 

  

This guy was everything I wanted and more. We share so many of the same hobbies, interests, values - on almost every issue, such as spirituality, we were on the same page. Even the physical side was a great match. He always treated me with great respect. 

  

2 months into the relationship, I saw that he was still on the dating site (yes, this is not respect!). To make a long story short, we decided not to be in touch at all until his divorce came through. I would have left him for good (why was he looking for something else if we were supposedly having an amazing love affair?) but the thing was that he really "got it". He was truly sorry, not defensive. 

  

After 6 months apart, his divorce came though, we got back together and everything was incredible. I felt like the luckiest person alive. Since my kids are grown and his not, I relocated to his city, only an hour away, but very different from the town I lived in.  

  

In August, everything started to melt down. We went to counseling, but I felt we weren't discussing the real issues. He claimed that we became a permanent couple without his ever really agreeing, we just slipped into that state. (BTW, I told him that I'm not interested in marriage, I'd rather make the committement without the ceremony). By the beginning of Sept. we broke up. I had no idea what the real reasons for the breakup were, though we since the breakup, we met twice and he's explained many things and opened up. The reasons for the breakup have to do with his relationship with himself - getting past his divorce/ overcoming his conflicts over religion - none of it has to do with real relationship problems. 

  

Since the breakup, he's been going for intensive therapy. He told me he wants me back. He suddenly realises what he's given up. Since we already experienced 6 difficult month apart, how could he not see this before?  Since November, I have told him not to contact me in any way until March. 

  

March is approaching and I don't know whether to see if we can salvage this relationship (I feel like he's taken something rare and beautiful and special and just killed it) or move on.   

  

Since the breakup, I have been very actively looking for someone new and I can't even get to a first day. I have a clear idea of what I'm looking for (I'm an English speaker in a foreign country, and I really want a bilingual partner, so that already narrows things down a lot), after my divorce I won't accept bad treatment which further narrows things down etc. I'm optimistic by nature, but I know that there isn't a long line up of suitable guys waiting for me. Not because there's something wrong with me, just because it isn't easy to find someone. The vast majority of my divorce/single friends are alone, or in relationships that are very problematic. 

  

I want to mention that while we were together, I took Dr. Phil's relationship profile questionnaire and got a near perfect score (34 out of 35, or whatever the maximum # was). You don't find another relationship like that every day. 

  

HELP!!!  Try again  or move on?????? 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
hopeful
January 29, 2006, 10:45 pm PST

If it looks like infidelity....

Quote From: paulacdwl

I have been seeing a man for 4 years and his ex-girlfriend is always in the picture. 

  

The straw that broke the camel's back was when she asked him to tape a TV show and then goes over to his house every Friday night to watch this taped show.  She spends the night with him and sleeps in the same bed with him, and when I say this is inappropriate, he argues that they don't have sex, so what is my problem.  I don't think it is appropriate whether they have sex or not for them to sleep together in the same bed.  I told him I will not have sex with him anymore since this is going on.  I feel he is being disrespectful towards our relationship in having this woman over every Friday night and her spending the night.   

  

He says it is all perfectly innocent and doesn't understand why I am so upset over the situation.  Am I being completely unreasonable.  To me, it is completely wrong for him to do this and totally disrespectful of my feelings.    

I wasn't in the bedroom with the two of them, and I always like to give people the benefit of the doubt, but I think that the chances that the two of them shared a bed and did nothing are slim. Just think, under what circumstances would you get in bed with some guy that you didn't have a sexual relationship with? She couldn't drive home?  

  

Your guy sounds like the kind of guy who, if you caught him with his hand in the cookie jar, crumbs on his face, and lots of cookies gone, would say that he didn't eat any cookies.  

  

Whether he slept with his ex or not, his actions are disrespectful to you. You deserve better. 

  

Good luck to you! 

 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
January 30, 2006, 8:37 am PST

Advice Needed----GF just dumped me

My girlfriend of just a year dumped me rather suddenly last week. I had borrowed her cell phone since mine had died to check messages for work while I was getting her coffee and delivering it to her like I always did. While at Starbuck..the phone beeped. She was at a party the night before doing some networking tyring to find a job. The message was from a some guy named Paul saying "see you again soon". Naturally I asked who Paul was? Next thing I know this is over. She initially said she did not know. I said then "ok..I believe you". Just a few minutes later she starting yelling you don't trust me and ended our relationship right then. It is very painful right now as I did love her. Seems silly to end a relationship over this issue but my gut does tell me she was planning to get together with Paul or her reaction would not have been so severe. She has been married three times all one year or less. I can't help but think this quick trigger may have been something the previous relationships also experienced.  There is no track record of working on relationship issues. My friends tell me this was a blessing in disguise.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 30, 2006, 9:11 am PST

Friends - Right On

Quote From: john8walt

My girlfriend of just a year dumped me rather suddenly last week. I had borrowed her cell phone since mine had died to check messages for work while I was getting her coffee and delivering it to her like I always did. While at Starbuck..the phone beeped. She was at a party the night before doing some networking tyring to find a job. The message was from a some guy named Paul saying "see you again soon". Naturally I asked who Paul was? Next thing I know this is over. She initially said she did not know. I said then "ok..I believe you". Just a few minutes later she starting yelling you don't trust me and ended our relationship right then. It is very painful right now as I did love her. Seems silly to end a relationship over this issue but my gut does tell me she was planning to get together with Paul or her reaction would not have been so severe. She has been married three times all one year or less. I can't help but think this quick trigger may have been something the previous relationships also experienced.  There is no track record of working on relationship issues. My friends tell me this was a blessing in disguise.
Your friends are right.... this was a blessing in disquise.  Be grateful.
 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
January 30, 2006, 9:34 am PST

GF Dumped me

Quote From: scrapqwn

Your friends are right.... this was a blessing in disquise.  Be grateful.
Thanks for the response. The hard part is the twisting around of the issue to the text message she received to making it an issue of "I don't trust her". That is nothing more then deferring from the real issue in my opinion. Yes....I was curious who the message was from and what it meant. I think anyone would.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
January 30, 2006, 9:54 am PST

still undecided

Quote From: smileym

Hi, 

I'm not sure where to start???...I'm currently dating a man that i've been on and off with for 6 years. I'm 27  yrs old now. We first got together when i was away at school and he lived about 2 hours away so somehow we maintained a long distance relationship but I had issues with being in a relationship. For the first 3 years everything was going well and then we started arguing alot because I was pursuing my career and he was still undecided about what he wanted to do and tehn he would ask me questions like "why am I with him?" or "why do I love him?" and he was always complainig about feeling worthless because he didnt know what to do with his life. After awhile we were always arguing so we broke up but it only lasted a few days and we got back together w/o resolving any issues. I started writing in a journal about 2 years ago because i was noticing huge changes in him like this sudden interest in going to the gym, it was difficult to get ahold of him. His mother and him werent getting along so he said he was staying at his friends house but yet he would always meet me at his house instead of the friends house, so finally in 2004 we broke up for a year but we would talk everyday and sometimes see each other, including sleeping with each other. Then last year on Good Friday he asked me to spend the night at his house and I did and that night we were up for hours talking and told each other we loved each other still and i opened up about all my feelings and he was shocked because i've never been someone to open up about my feelings because it was more important to me to keep myself from being hurt adn i felt that opening myself up to him in the past years would make me too vulnerable. Then that morning i found out that he had a girlfriend! and in the last year that we were together they had been seeing each other! so they had been together for almost 1.5yrs and then i found out that he had also cheated on me with 2 other women in that time span! So I walked away from him and maybe a month later he emailed me asking to talk to me. So i agreed and he poured his heart out to me, telling me how disgusted he is with himself and that our relationship seemed to be falling apart but he couldnt let go of me and that he acted selfishly and as unhappy as he was in the relationship he found it too hard to leave so he would turn to these woman who were willing to give him the world and everything they would tell him and do for him he would wish deep down that i wouldve said and did all those things. So I listened to him and I also forgave him because i felt that i needed to forgive him to be able to move on and then started dating other men.  Then one day his mother wanted to talk to me so i sat down with her and she told me that despite her son's disgusting behaviour she knows that he loves me deeply and she felt that a big problem is his insecurity and immaturity. She said that because me and him are still friends we should talk about why things ended the way they did and how we both contributed to the rift in our relationship and what brought us together in the beginning? So that's what happened and we were both shocked at how many times we had said and done things to each other that were hurtful, at how needy he is, so tons of things came out of that talk but he was still seeing that girl but kept askign me if i wanted to be with him and i said no, i was happy being single. So moving on to 6mos after that convo, he broke up with that girl and we started talking more often and seeing each other again as friends first and then it progressed to dating each other again. He makes it a point to call me everyday at work, when he finishes work and I also try to call as often. He still wants to go the gym all the time but nwo he invites me to come with him or when he goes over to his friends he'll call me from there or invite me over. Before we would only see other once a week and sometimes once every 2 weeks but now we try to see each other a few days a week. We've spent more weekends together in the last couple of months than we ever did in the years we were together. We confide in each other more often, when i'm having feelings of worry I tell him and we talk about it, so we decided that b/c we were only 20 whn we got together, this time around we were going to tackle this like adults BUT there's also those times when something will happen that will remind me of the times when things werent so great. I find that sometimes if i call him and dont get him right away i start to panick, yesterday i almost drove by his house to see if his car was there so i would know he slept at home :S There's some people who are saying to me that i'll never be able to get over what he did and it will always be in the back of my mind and then there's others taht are rooting for us to make it through because they see how we are when we're around each other now and tell me that i'm teh problem now. So now i've been noticing that when we're together i'm the happiest person but then when we're not i start to worry if he's seeing other people :(  and i know he's getting tired of hearing about now b/c he doesnt know what more to do to get me to believe him, so i guess i just want to know if this is a relationship that can be saved or not? 

Thank you for the reply it did give me alot to think about....I never realized it until now that I am also very needy right now. I actually had a talk with him a few days ago because i felt like my head was going to explode so i needed him to know exactly what was going on in my head and he was very understanding but he also brought up the fact that perhaps too much damage has been done and maybe i need to be with someone else, now i dont know if he was being genuine with that or he wanted to see what i would say....anyways i'm still undecided and we have talked about marriage but that would be a long way down the road and we would definitely get counselling, i think that perhaps we should get couples counselling now..........
 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
January 30, 2006, 11:46 am PST

Relationship Question---input needed M and F

I posted earlier. Going thru some pain now. My question is.....if you saw an email in your partners email  from a the opposite sex that you did not know.....saying "see you again soon". Would you ask "who is so and so"? My relationship ended when I did that. I was told I did not trust. I feel bad for asking but see nothing wrong with it. Your thoughts??
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
January 30, 2006, 1:40 pm PST

Is This Relationship Over????

I've been divorced for 1 year.  In August 2005 I started dating a women that works in the same place whose husband left her in 2004.  We dated and our relationship was going great until the holidays came around.  We spent Christmas together with my family and after that, she said that she need time and space to clear her head.  For the time we were together, she said that I treated her like she wanted and that she loved me.  We talked earlier this month and she said that we should be friends for now.  I aasked how do we work this, can I call (she said yes, but not everyday like we used to), can I ask you out (she said not right now. I don't want you to get the impression that everything is alright).  I asked her what was all that talk about loving me and the cards, were they bologna? .  She said that she wouldn't digify that with an answer.  Last week, she called and said we should be friends now.  I told her to please keep me in mind.  She said yes, yes I will.  Later that day we had another talk and I told her that I would like another chance when she clears her head and she said I'll think about it and keep it in mind (this was a different response from the yes, yes I will that she said before. Does this mean that she doesn't have the same feelings for me as she used to?  She said that she can't handle any more stress right now (her divorce proceedings are starting and her ex is being an idiot).  She also said that she's really screwed up right now.  Since that day, I haven't heard from her at all, not even a phone call.  Is this relationship over??? or does she really need time to deal with her divorce?  Nothing happened in our relationship that would make her break up with me.  She's never came right out and said it's over.  Any ideas?? 

 
First | Prev | 64 | 65 | 66 | 67 | 68 | 69 | 70 | 71 | 72 | 73 | Next | Last