Message Boards

Topic : Breaking Up

Number of Replies: 5468
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:06:14 pm
Author : dataimport
Is it time to end things with your significant other? Or, have you just been handed a relationship pink slip? Share your stories.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
February 26, 2006, 9:23 am PST

what to do when one wants it and the other doesn't

i posted on the other pages but i think this suits my situation better. my girlfriend of 2yrs  broke up with me in jan. of this year we spent x-mas & new years togetherand after that it went down hill. she said she was feeling like this for some time but thought it wasn't right to do at x-mas. our problem is that we work together and we only saw each other mostly on weekends . i know she did bring this up to me last summer but nothing changed . we still didn't do things together and i respected that she wanted time with her 2 kids 19-14. she 's a very quiet person and she would expect me to make all the decisions wether small or big about everything, and i wanted her to call me more to ask me to come over or to do things , so we have a big communication problem. this weekend i pushed too hard and made her very angry with me to the point now she doesn't want anything to do with me , she just keeps hearing what i want and i'm not listening to what she wants. she wanted a break in the beginning but i wanted to figure out what went wrong and fix it. so now what can i do ? i've lost my love and even her kids are mad at me for upsetting their mother. if i gave her a month would anyone think this good but how would i approach her after that seeing that i see her at work every day and i have to pass her in the aisles to get to my work.help me with some good advice .
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
worried
February 26, 2006, 11:37 am PST

what should i do?

Hi i am a 27 yr. old single mother of one. I am currently in a relationship with someone that i have my doubts about. the reason i have my doubts is because of my daughter. at times she is happy to see my significant other and at other times she seems afraid. I am very confused because i know he has never hit her. i find that there are certain things other than this that bother me about this man. i am trying to clean up my credit so i can purchase a home for my daughter and i but until then we have nowhere to go. Help! any suggestions or advice? 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
anxious
February 26, 2006, 12:02 pm PST

newlife01

Hi i am really new to all this and i hope i can get my feelings across correctly.  

I am trying to change my life and my lifestyle. When i was younger(19yrs.) i made some really bad mistakes as far as credit wise and now i am trying to rectify those wrongs.I also got into a very bad relationship that lasted 6+ years and now have a beautiful 4yr. old daughter to show for it. the thing is that her father see's her every weekend and 9 times out of 10 i get her back wearing the same clothes she left in! i have taken him to court and we are still battling it out. But i know that that part of my life will always be there, because that is her father. 

another part of my life is that i am in a relationship that im not too sure about but don't know how to break it off. the biggest worry i have is my liitle girl. At times she loves chris(the man im currently living with) and at other times she is very much afraid of him. but due to my reckless decisions that i made when i was younger i am unable to finance an apartment or home. i am currently at my parents because we just found out i may have had seizures or a stroke and will continue to live here for the next 3 weeks. I could use some words of encouragement or advice.Thank you 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 26, 2006, 5:19 pm PST

Breaking up Advice


Ive always been and still am a big analyzer of relationships before i started dating my ex. i never had and seriousness before i got with her. when i met her it was so easy and did not have2 do much2 impress her. just by seeing me she was happy and thats a beautiful thing because if there happy with just that when u really try2 do something special for them its goin2 be 10 times better. there are rules for dating as funny as it seems, u have2 really get2 know the person before u jump into anything, if u really want2 be with this person u have2 love the good and the bad with them or ur not goin2 make it. life is always goin2 throw hurdles ur way when it sees2 people that madly in love with each other. true love is not fake its not a fairy tale or a myth if u really think that some person might just be that one u have2 work on those things. if that person tells u what they did before they met u and they said thats what they need in there life then make sure u give that to them or its not goin2 work. make sure that if ur not living together and ur just dating, leave time for urselves because if u give them all ur time in the end they might throw that back in ur face saying that u did not do enough for them and they just want there freedom, u have to be able2 compromise, relationships are 50/50 no matter what the circumstances, if its not goin2 be that way then u have to be careful because one person can not do it all. u have2 find out there goals and ambitions and make sure that theres are compatible to yours because some people feel that love is not enough that they will never be enough without there goals, but im goin2 tell u something if u dont feel like ur enough without them ull never be enough with them u have2 love urself first if not ur goin2 end up bringing the other person in ur life down with u, always make sure that ur positive in all situations, some people think that u can love somebody so much and thats all u need, trust me its not, u need2 be able to do the little things first, so when the big things come around ull be able2 knock them down with no problem. dont always take breaking up as such a negative thing sometimes were human were goin2 make mistakes but u wont realize that until that person u wanted in ur life is gone and it may take that situation in ur life2 be able to handle that. how do u know what true love feels like, ull know when that person walks into the room and ur heart stops beating but they would have2 feel the same in order for it2 work. 50/50 thats what it boils down2. but one day everyone is goin2 want to settle down and live that life of happiness with there significant other but let me2 tell u something sometimes when ur not rdy and that person is already there and ur not goin2 know it and its goin2 be to late when u go back2 look for them. i dont know why but u have to fall flat on ur face these days to understand what it is ur truly doing wrong, dont use love as a crutch, dont lie either because one very small lie can bite u in the butt later down in ur relationship everyone depends on honesty once that honesty is broken there is a small chance that u wont be able2 get that back. i know religion is not a big part of most people but if u really want2 be with someone forever u have2 have the love of god in ur heart or its not goin2 work, ive always be an advicate of helping people out with there relationships when i was younger and my love for it is greater now, if only people these days would listen to the advice of others mistakes in the same situations would life be better but no they always have2 find out for themselves because they never thought it could happen2 them, its ok2 be optimistic sometimes u cant think that life is always goin2 be great because its not, if u find someone out there that fits that empty space in ur heart and makes ur life complete then do everything together possible 2keep them because u dont know u may not be able2 get another chance at true happiness but if ur not rdy for what im describing then dont get into a relationship with somebody that wants be serious because in the end if there not strong enough u might destroy them and there never want2 trust or love again like they did when there life was at the top. u cant force love its not goin2 work. if u try2 force it the other person is just goin2 run away, if they say they need time give it to them the more u try to get back with them the more there goin2 be driven away from u and then it might come2 the point were there goin2 call u stalker or something silly like that but thats not always the case, if u truly love someone and u break it up its not goin2 be stupidness talking its goin2 be ur real feelings. just make sure u dont hold anything back let it all out. if that person really wants u they'll come back to u but like i said u cant force it u have2 let it be what it is. everybody always has there immaturity phase and they need2 go through it with it preferably early on so they can get it out of there system, u can go out there and have fun just make sure u have a fine balance of that because u cant over do one or the other. the key2 a successful relationship is trust and understanding after that its easy. ive had2 swallow my mistakes that i have made i just wanted2 help out others that might be goin through what i am and this might be the key to understanding and fulfillment, no one should ever feel that someone is better then u because if thats the case they already have an advantage over u and might someday use that against you. keep ur head and chin held up high because no one on this earth should be able2 take away ur dignity if they do or they try they are just insecure and they want2 make sure u feel the same way. one more thing before i go dont let anyone ever tell u that its to late for u2 change ur young have fun with ur life and if ur able2 find someone that fits ur needs then take that with stride dont go looking for love it will come2 u when u dont think so, just be positive and it will bounce of u and everyone around u will be affected by it, negativity is something that can destroy a relationship so my advice would be dont have it. one thing to get ur mind over someone u lost is to find something that will take ur mind of them, my knack just happens 2 be writing, i have plenty more2 discuss but i think thats good4 now, if i could be help2 anyone with advice, feel free2 contact me. Mark Molina
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
February 26, 2006, 9:50 pm PST

Breaking Up

Quote From: newlife01

Hi i am a 27 yr. old single mother of one. I am currently in a relationship with someone that i have my doubts about. the reason i have my doubts is because of my daughter. at times she is happy to see my significant other and at other times she seems afraid. I am very confused because i know he has never hit her. i find that there are certain things other than this that bother me about this man. i am trying to clean up my credit so i can purchase a home for my daughter and i but until then we have nowhere to go. Help! any suggestions or advice? 

Please follow your heart.  I am in a similar situation where I truly believe my child is making the right decision for me.  I swear children have a good sense of human beings  with their innocence.  If you have doubts then it is not the right thing and they will prove it.
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
sad
February 27, 2006, 12:33 am PST

men and grief and being shut out

My 2 year relationship with a wonderful, kind, compassionate, do the right thing guy went from me moving to where he is (about 4-5 weeks ago)**  and visiting soon to a totally against everything he believes in short  ending things email with no call,  no discussion, no anything and this is completely out of character. This is a man who gave his friend the riot act for not breaking up with his girlfriend in person. OF course I know why he out of character. He has had more than 10 friends die this year (military) had to put both parents in a residential care situation only 3 weeks ago and spent the last 2 weeks helping a friend of over a decade see her husband through to his passing from a cancer he was diagnosed with only weeks earlier.. I know he is spent emotionally and so I understand why this happened, but what I don't know about is how does grief effect men. Our relationship had no real issues, we loved and respected each other and made it through two years mostly apart  (because of his work) with very few issues. I am not looking for why it ended today, but just if anyone there has experienced a man in their life ending things abruptly because they were going through a traumatic situation and if so what happened after the trauma passed..  just trying to sort out how men deal with grief as well..  

  

thanks 

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

** (long distance but met in person not on the internet)  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 27, 2006, 12:04 pm PST

He needs space??

Hi, I could use some good advice on my situation.  I've been seeing someone for over 2 months (I'm 24 and he's 21).  We met right before the Christmas holidays, so I was in Houston with my family while he was in Austin, where I'm going to grad school.  During the holidays, we went out once a week for a month and it was great.  However, since school started again and we're now in the same city, I told him I wanted to see him more than just once a week for dinner, twice a week is good.  Since we hardly see each other, everytime we meet up it's kind of awkward and we've to reconnect again.  I really like him and would like to get to know him better, but I feel like we're stuck in the once-a-week mode and the relationship is not growing.  Also, he keeps changing his mind about the status of our relationship.  One minute he wants to date casually before things get too serious, the next he wants to date exclusively, and if he's mad at me about something he wants to break up.   

  

Last weekend, I told him I was going to an out-of-town wedding with a guy friend.  My friend asked me to go with him to his friend's wedding because he didn't have a date.  We've been good friends for years plus I like taking road trips so I said yes.  My guy got upset and said he wanted to break up.  I explained to him my reasons for going to the wedding and now he says he needs space and time to think about things.  I told him I'll give him 2 months and he can call me after that if he wants to see me again.  

  

I don't understand why he feels like he has a reason to be upset.  If he wants to be with me, he would make time to see me, especially after I told him outright that I wasn't happy with the whole once-a-week arrangement.  The fact that he doesn't make time for me makes me feel like he's not interested in having a serious relationship with me, or he doesn't want the relationship to progress.  Also, the status of our relationship keeps changing so I don't know how to answer when guy friends ask me to dinner or spend time with them.  It doesn't make sense to me that, on one hand, he gets jealous and upset when I spend time with other guys, but on the other hand, he doesn't want to make time for me.     

  

I'm an attractive, intelligent, nice girl who doesn't have a problem getting dates.  However, I'm only interested in him for the moment and would like to have a real relationship with him if I could.  What does he mean by needing space? Why does he act jealous if he doesn't want to make time for me? 

                  

 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
February 27, 2006, 1:54 pm PST

Lost, Confused, and Depressed

I broke up with my boyfriend of a year and a half last summer and am still having difficulties with it.  he was the "hot" guy everyone wanted, and for some reason he wanted me.  Once we dated for about a month, problems began to surface.  It was an emotional tornado.  He would think about something that bothered him or get in a mood, turn his phone off, and disappear for days.  I put up with it and put up with it, then had finally had it last summer.  After that, he suddenly became available whenever, almost too much.  He would show up beating on my door randomly and calling friends to see where I was at if I wasn't at home.  I moved and now he doesn't know where I live.  He was still calling trying to "fix" things up unitl Christmas day last year.  I haven't talked to him until recently.  Now he is saying he wants to get married and he sees how he was wrong and how terribly he treated me.  He has given me the ultimatum of if  want to be with him I have to decide right now, I can't have time.  he thnks we should just be together if we love each other.  I do love him, but know I don't need to be in that situation again.  My problem is I don't know how to handle it. I'm scared if I don't take the chance I'll lose him forever, but then again, if he cares wouldn't he wait?  Plus, since being away from him, I have been better.  I enjoy classes and teaching again.  I don't have the desire to just sleep the days away so I don't feel anything.  I got into a bad habit for a while of taking sleeping pills and tring to sleep through the days.  I logically know what needs to be done, but I still hurt and don't know what to do.  Any suggestions on how to handle this???
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
anxious
February 27, 2006, 4:14 pm PST

I've had it

I am a single mom, I work part time and am a full time nursing student at college.  My husband of seventeen years left the home when I was in my first semester at school.  His main objective is to cause me to fail, and I totally refuse to quit.  My grades are better now than ever and I think its in part to my determination to "show" him I can do it without him.  I hurt so bad that the marriage fell apart, but it was due to the fact he got us so deep into debt and caused so many financial problems for us.  He see's now he made a mistake and wants to come home...I refuse to let him come back, I don't have a swinging door policy.  After a six month separation, we finally have a court date this week.  He is claiming he is broke (was self employed and made 300,000.00 last year) He took on a blue collar job to prove to the court that he has no money (temporarily closed down his company).  So....his support will be based soley on the job he currently has.  He makes 600.00/week.  IF my court ordered support is not enough for me to financially survive, I have thought about letting him have his boys until I finish school.  I would move in with my sister.  He has agreed to take the boys if he gets away with not having to "dish" out alot of money in support.  I will finish school in a year, be a Registered Nurse and be able to financially support myself and my boys.  I have always been at home with my children, and chose to begin something new for myself by going to college and HE wants me to fail....Am I wrong for wanting to finish, am I wrong for letting him have my boys until I finish school.  I feel selfish at times, but I will have a career in a year.  The boys would live about 6 miles from me while I finish school.  Please someone tell me what you think.  

 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
confused
February 27, 2006, 5:11 pm PST

dont know what I should do!

 My name is Heather and I am so depressed that I sometimes end up with anxiety attacks at work and even at home. I was dating this guy in the end of my senior year and we decided to go to the same college, get an appartment and some day he told me that he wanted to marry me. Seven months later I found myself back living with my parents, withdrawing from my classes in college and crying myself to sleep. He had been telling people that we both knew that I was a controlling person which is so far from the truth, that I had forced him to go to college with me and that he would take me to court for all the money that I had borrowed from him. I was having a hard time finding a job, so I ran out of money and had to barrow money from him.  After we had broke up I had thought that I was pregnant, and I had told my used to be best friend that I thought I was. He found out and his mother told him that I was doing/saying it to get him back. I have been really upset...And I dont know how to make myself see that I was not the bad guy here, that I loved him wiht all my heart and that I can find someone out there for me. He has a new girlfriend that we both work with  and It is really hard for me...I just want all the pain to go away and for me to find someone right for me.
Heather,19
 
First | Prev | 84 | 85 | 86 | 87 | 88 | 89 | 90 | 91 | 92 | 93 | Next | Last