Message Boards

Topic : Breaking Up

Number of Replies: 5468
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:06:14 pm
Author : dataimport
Is it time to end things with your significant other? Or, have you just been handed a relationship pink slip? Share your stories.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
March 3, 2006, 10:07 pm PST

Breaking Up

Quote From: newlife01

thank you so much for responding to my message. Its so comforting to know that there is someone else out there who understands my dilemma. I have obtained a therapist and am talking with her about my doubts.She has even had a session with me, my significant other and my daughter. The outlook looks positive but as you said i am watching for my daughter's reaction and using those to make my final decision. Because above all else, all i have in this world are myself and my little girl.Once again thank you for taking the time to reach out to me, it was much appreciated.
I am so glad.  I have a wonderful therapist who has guided me through all of this and I finally told him to move out the other day.  My daughter has been having dreams about being cruel to him and then tells me she knows it isn't right but she does not like him.  I've had a good discussion with her about this and told her that I trust what she is feeling and no matter what I love her and know she is telling me from her heart.  Children are gifts from god and I belieive he can speak through them in is ways and I have a tremendous faith in that and pray about it.  Usually I have an answer instantly.   I am just really glad for you that you are listening to her as I did because so many people out there put themselves first before their kids and it is heart wrenching to see what eventually happens.  I wish you the best. 
 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
March 4, 2006, 8:05 am PST

Was a sweet guy

Hello,   

I wanted to know how do you get through this. My boyfriend for 6 half years just left me for another women. I thought he was the love of my life I wanted to be with him forever. Now I am to the point, is how can he do this to me what did I do to devise this. I had done everything for him. He told me that I was the best thing that has ever happen to him and than he does this to me. I am trying get over but the more I think about it the more it makes me very mad. This is the first bad break up for me. I feel so empty and lost with out him I do not know how to get through it. I leave in the home we got together so I think that has a lot to do with it, but I just don’t what to walk away from my son’s home.  

 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
March 5, 2006, 7:50 am PST

Im Scared

Quote From: jb7ctx

I think you are letting this guy "control" you. And what I mean by that is, you are not going out with no one else, you are afraid to trust men due to this one guys behavior. So therefore, he has that control over your emotions which is keeping you from going out and finding even better , and more fulfilling relationships. Is he sitting at home worrying about you? No, he is out enjoying his life and he is moving on with his life. You need to do the same and give someone else a chance because NOT all men are like the one you had. You just didnt find the right one yet, thats all. Dont delay your life because of one bad apple. There are too many guys out there waiting for someone like you. Once you completely forget about him and let him go out of your heart and emotions, you will see what I am talking about. Also, once he sees that you are going on with your life, he may then wake up and realize what he had, and now lost. Life is too short to sit there and worry about him. Get dressed, put your makeup on, and paint the town girl! Life is what you make it, so go for it, without him, like he is doing without you. And another thing, I wouldnt like it either if my man was talking to another girl and put her first before me. I dont think he would like it either if the shoe were on the other foot and he was the one playing second in your life. If you guys have broken up more than 3 times in this relationship, then that alone ought to tell you, more than likely this relationship is not going to work out and be a long relationship. You deserve better, and you can find someone better who will put you first. Dont judge all men by the actions of one man. I promise you they are not all alike. go out there and meet the "real world"  where there are real men waiting to meet you. Good luck! Move forward, and dont look back :)
This may sound corny and dumb, but i am scared to go out anymore, scared to fall in love again, or even get close to anyone. Yes, i know there are good men out there, but it seems like i always attract the jerks or wrong ones, and i dont know why. My ex really scarred me in my heart and my life style, and i know he dont care for me anymore. I just dont understand and cant figure out why i just cant forget him.  I know he never really cared for me like i did him. He never even called to see how my mom was after her heart attack, so i should know that he never really cared for any of us. Its not like i lived in a large metro area where he didnt know. I live in a real small town, that everyone knows whats happened the next day about everybody. I guess that is why i should know he never cared. Oh, well i am running off at the mouth, but i totally agree with what you said, but i just dont know how to start over again, if that makes sense and dont sound stupid.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 5, 2006, 7:59 am PST

Another woman

Quote From: annette25a

Hello,   

I wanted to know how do you get through this. My boyfriend for 6 half years just left me for another women. I thought he was the love of my life I wanted to be with him forever. Now I am to the point, is how can he do this to me what did I do to devise this. I had done everything for him. He told me that I was the best thing that has ever happen to him and than he does this to me. I am trying get over but the more I think about it the more it makes me very mad. This is the first bad break up for me. I feel so empty and lost with out him I do not know how to get through it. I leave in the home we got together so I think that has a lot to do with it, but I just don’t what to walk away from my son’s home.  

You didn't do anything to deserve this! This has nothing to do with you at all. He went to another woman because of his own selfishness. He didn't break up with you first, because he is a coward!! Don't allow his cowardly act to effect your self esteem and your sense of self worth, because you deserve nothing but the best. You deserve to be happy and fullfilled in life, settle for nothing less!! You can and will move forward, it takes time to heal from this heartache. Whatever you do, don't listen to his lame excuses (especially if he blames you) and right now you need to focus on YOU.. find your passion in life. Surround yourself with positive people and keep yourself busy. It is difficult but you will survive.. and as for your ex- what comes around goes around.
 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
March 5, 2006, 9:28 am PST

what does give me space and time really mean?

what does this really mean? in my case does it mean give me time for her to deal with her finances and ex husband or does it mean move on and in time you'll meet someone else and her to? i don't even know how to approach her any more now that i've made her angry at me for pushing. i'm hoping that she still wants time to think about us and maybe in a month we can work on us but in the mean time i'm going crazy thinking about her and what she's doing. we ignored each other at work on fri. and it hurts but i want her to see that i'm human being and that i'm hurting from this and that i want her to come to me for a change ( which might never happen) when we first started i approached her and i did all the courting i even asked her how long would she have taken to ask me out and she said probably months. our argument last week wasn't very good as she kept telling me that she has changed yet this week she told me that all she wanted was time , so what do i read into this ? the next couple of weeks she's going to busy with her daughters so she won't think of me much  . so i'm trying to think about other things it's when i'm alone that i freak out. i even looked up pi's on the web .which is a little extreme. any advice any one who might have had the same situation.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
confused
March 5, 2006, 9:47 am PST

Please Advise - My Heart Is Breaking

My high school sweetheart and I recently reunited in October.  Things have been wonderful and we were even discussing wedding plans.  His ex wife left him for another man, and now, she is pregnant with this other man's child.  Now Jim is confused and is actually thinking about reuniting with her, despite this illegitimate child, a horrible 15 year marriage, and her betrayal.  We had a trip to Vegas planned, and he left without me, saying "he needs space."  My heart is breaking and I feel so helpless.  We had qualities that he never had in his marriage -- honesty, love, respect, giving, etc.  I don't know how to handle this.  I know I need to give him space but the silence is killing me considering we spoke at least twice a day since October.  Does anyone have any helpful advice?  Please post to this message or feel free to e-mail me at sebhart@earthlink.net.  I thought venting on a message board would help considering I feel so alone.  I know myself, and know who I am so I know I'll get through this -- I just need some advise.  Thanks! 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 5, 2006, 1:38 pm PST

Dating again

Have been dating a man for the past 10 months or so, there are a few things bothering me about the relationship that I would like some feedback from what others think.  I find that he is not very generous which I have a tendency to be, i.e. for his birthday I gave him a really nice watch, 2 months later for my birthday I did not get a present, I did get a nice card, with a lotto ticket inside (not a winning one).I felt kind of hard done by over this, though I did not bring it up in conversation.  How do you say where's my present.  Another thing is this guy goes  out to singles clubs dancing on a weekly basis, I have told him that I am not totally comfortable with this, he says he only goes there to dance.  He tells me he loves me, sex is great, he says that he would eventually like us to move in together, I have my reservations about this.  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 5, 2006, 5:09 pm PST

Dating for 10 months

Quote From: sundial4

Have been dating a man for the past 10 months or so, there are a few things bothering me about the relationship that I would like some feedback from what others think.  I find that he is not very generous which I have a tendency to be, i.e. for his birthday I gave him a really nice watch, 2 months later for my birthday I did not get a present, I did get a nice card, with a lotto ticket inside (not a winning one).I felt kind of hard done by over this, though I did not bring it up in conversation.  How do you say where's my present.  Another thing is this guy goes  out to singles clubs dancing on a weekly basis, I have told him that I am not totally comfortable with this, he says he only goes there to dance.  He tells me he loves me, sex is great, he says that he would eventually like us to move in together, I have my reservations about this.  

When you say "dating"... do you mean exclusively? If he is going out dancing, then why can't he go to clubs that are not single's clubs? It is a bit odd that he goes to singles clubs!! Also, why doesn't he take you when he goes out dancing?  

When you gave him the watch for his birthday, was he happy and accepting of it? Or did he tell you that you shouldn't have, etc., things like that? I'm thinking maybe he just feels its soon to be spending a lot of money on one another... or he might just be a cheap-O... Giving you a card with a lotto ticket inside is something you do for a neighbor or sibling.. not for the woman you "say" you love. I guess the bottom line is this: listen to your instincts!! Don't ever dismiss your own instincts or second guess them. You are seeing red flags and you are trying to dismiss them or make excuses for them, when you really should be paying close attention to them. Maybe he says those things about eventually moving in, etc., just to keep you hanging on. Listen to yourself!!! you know the right thing to do, you just don't want to accept it at this point, but you would be better off if you don't waste anymore time. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 5, 2006, 5:15 pm PST

High school sweetheart

Quote From: susanhart

My high school sweetheart and I recently reunited in October.  Things have been wonderful and we were even discussing wedding plans.  His ex wife left him for another man, and now, she is pregnant with this other man's child.  Now Jim is confused and is actually thinking about reuniting with her, despite this illegitimate child, a horrible 15 year marriage, and her betrayal.  We had a trip to Vegas planned, and he left without me, saying "he needs space."  My heart is breaking and I feel so helpless.  We had qualities that he never had in his marriage -- honesty, love, respect, giving, etc.  I don't know how to handle this.  I know I need to give him space but the silence is killing me considering we spoke at least twice a day since October.  Does anyone have any helpful advice?  Please post to this message or feel free to e-mail me at sebhart@earthlink.net.  I thought venting on a message board would help considering I feel so alone.  I know myself, and know who I am so I know I'll get through this -- I just need some advise.  Thanks! 

Old habits die hard! 

Maybe your high school sweet heart's self esteem is so low that he thinks, deep down, that he only deserves this woman who is toxic for him. There aren't many other reasons why he would go back to her. It sounds like after 15 years of this treatment, he has come to be either addicted to it, or to believe whole-heartedly that he deserves it. He is addicted to the chaos that this woman supplies for him, and that you can't supply for him. This is his loss.  

I know that you are hurting very much right now, but with time you will heal. Maybe you were high school sweethearts, but people change a lot over time. Please know this has nothing to do with you, it is all about his own lack of self esteem. You deserve to be happy!! Its hard not to contact him, but you are better off this way. 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
March 5, 2006, 6:00 pm PST

What it means

Quote From: racerrob

what does this really mean? in my case does it mean give me time for her to deal with her finances and ex husband or does it mean move on and in time you'll meet someone else and her to? i don't even know how to approach her any more now that i've made her angry at me for pushing. i'm hoping that she still wants time to think about us and maybe in a month we can work on us but in the mean time i'm going crazy thinking about her and what she's doing. we ignored each other at work on fri. and it hurts but i want her to see that i'm human being and that i'm hurting from this and that i want her to come to me for a change ( which might never happen) when we first started i approached her and i did all the courting i even asked her how long would she have taken to ask me out and she said probably months. our argument last week wasn't very good as she kept telling me that she has changed yet this week she told me that all she wanted was time , so what do i read into this ? the next couple of weeks she's going to busy with her daughters so she won't think of me much  . so i'm trying to think about other things it's when i'm alone that i freak out. i even looked up pi's on the web .which is a little extreme. any advice any one who might have had the same situation.

When someone tells you that they need space or time alone, it really means: 

  

1. That they want to break up with you, and instead of saying: "I want to break up, they say, I need my space". 

  

2. They want you to give them their space because they are looking for other "opportunities". 

  

3. They found something, or someone else., and they dont want to hurt you by telling you. 

  

4.  They are not interested in a relationship with you at this time. 

  

There is no need to sit around and wait on someone who needs their space, because they are not sitting around waiting on you, they are continuing to live their life. Maybe if you started seeing other people then she might realize that she does want you. OR, give yourself a deadline date, like maybe 2-3 weeks of no contact, and if she hasnt made up her mind by then, then you need to just let her go and go on with your life. Hope this helps some. Good luck! 

 
First | Prev | 89 | 90 | 91 | 92 | 93 | 94 | 95 | 96 | 97 | 98 | Next | Last