Message Boards

Topic : Breaking Up

Number of Replies: 5468
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:06:14 pm
Author : dataimport
Is it time to end things with your significant other? Or, have you just been handed a relationship pink slip? Share your stories.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
sad
June 28, 2006, 11:53 am PDT

Broken heart

I was with this guy for almost 3 years.  We just officially broke up 2 weeks ago.  He is now driving me crazy!  When I first got with him I was very insecure and depressed.  He was very charming and I thought we would be very happy.  During the course of our relationship he became very controlling and mean and nasty.  Everyday he would point out every bad quality I have.  Meanwhile he expected me to pay for all of his bills and support him while he laid around and did nothing.  To make a long story short, finally, I got a good job and I feel alot better about myself and I finally told him I am not taking it anymore.  Now, unfortuntaly, he will not return things to me that are mine, he is threatening me over the phone, he has threatened my parents.  He calls my daughter who is out of town on vacation with my ex husband to tell him that I wont let her talk to him, (hes not even her father) I am actually afraid.  But then I sit back and feel guilty and actually feel sorry for him.  Then when I call to pursue him returning my things to me he is so nasty and cruel, I wonder how could I have ever been with this person?  And it is now starting to effect my job and my health again and all I want is it to be over... I need some advice....
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
June 28, 2006, 1:25 pm PDT

thanks again juballl

Quote From: juballl

If you click on a person's name, their profile comes up, and many have email addresses right there. The only reason they are shown, is people don't mind being emailed. That is an option given when you fill out your profile. 

  

I would bet a strap on was the thing you didn't want to  mention in your post. You need to stop wondering if he was emotionally with you during your love making or not. At this point it doesn't matter, he is out of your life, and if he was not there emotionally, again it was not your fault. 

  

Surely there are some sort of state run counseling in or around your area, and it would be based on your income. There is one in my area, and a friend of mine goes and due to his income, he pays only five dollars, but if it were less, he would not have to pay anything. Research this by calling your local health care center in your area. You need to get into counseling. 

  

Hang in there Lisa, this too will pass. I hope the test turns out in your favor, and even if it doesn't, HIV is not the death sentence it used to be. Medications have come a long way, and if you do turn out positive, it is better to know now, than five or ten years down the road. The not knowing and always wondering would be worse than the disease itself. 

  

Again, good luck, and keep us posted. 

Hi, thanks again. Okay, I've changed my profile to show my email address so if anyone out there is dealing, or has dealt, with something similar feel free to contact me.  At the very least we can commiserate (sp?) together. 

  

I LOL'd at the strap on thing!  Yup, that would have been one of the red flags, but there were others also.  As for state counselling, I'm a Canuck, and I live in Ontario, Canada.  Many rave about the 'wonderful health care system' we have but it's simply not what it used to be.  I could make arrangements through my dr. for a therapist but I did that once years ago and the counsellor just wanted to medicate me.  I think people are over-medicated, but that's just my humble opinion.  Depression meds certainly have their place, don't get me wrong, but it's just so easy for a dr. to fill out a RX and send you on your way.  I think it's important to really deal with issues rather than mask them ... anyway, not diss'n the meds, really I'm not.   I agree with you about testing - I would much prefer to know for sure than to always wonder.  Thank you for your thoughts - I'm sure (?) I'll be fine, but I'll know next week for sure. 

  

Lisa 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
June 28, 2006, 3:58 pm PDT

Therapist are like any other service industry, (Sorry Dr Phil)

Quote From: canuck329

Hi, thanks again. Okay, I've changed my profile to show my email address so if anyone out there is dealing, or has dealt, with something similar feel free to contact me.  At the very least we can commiserate (sp?) together. 

  

I LOL'd at the strap on thing!  Yup, that would have been one of the red flags, but there were others also.  As for state counselling, I'm a Canuck, and I live in Ontario, Canada.  Many rave about the 'wonderful health care system' we have but it's simply not what it used to be.  I could make arrangements through my dr. for a therapist but I did that once years ago and the counsellor just wanted to medicate me.  I think people are over-medicated, but that's just my humble opinion.  Depression meds certainly have their place, don't get me wrong, but it's just so easy for a dr. to fill out a RX and send you on your way.  I think it's important to really deal with issues rather than mask them ... anyway, not diss'n the meds, really I'm not.   I agree with you about testing - I would much prefer to know for sure than to always wonder.  Thank you for your thoughts - I'm sure (?) I'll be fine, but I'll know next week for sure. 

  

Lisa 

There are good ones and bad ones, and if you are not satisfied, (ask the therapist how they feel about it so you are both on the same page) then go to another one until you get one on the same page as you. You wouldn't stay with a hairdresser you didn't like. Feel free to email me, if you would like, with your results. My prayers are with you.
 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
June 29, 2006, 7:55 am PDT

Breaking Up

 My boy friend doesnt seem to be happy unless we are fighting. I dont know how to tell him that I cant take it anymore. I dont wanna be with him if the fighting cant stop. We are fighting everyday and I just cant handle that right now, no one should have to deal with that. I dont know how to tell him that I want him gone and out of my life. Im afriad that if I do tell him that I dont wanna be with him that he might hurt me or something. He is very mean and he has told me before that if I tryed to leave him that I would be dead. I need help on what to do so if there is anyone out there plz help me out. thank you. my email is evilkitten237@yahoo.com if you have any advice for me plz let me know. 

 

 

Edith 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 29, 2006, 9:26 am PDT

Some advice

Quote From: cap721

I was with this guy for almost 3 years.  We just officially broke up 2 weeks ago.  He is now driving me crazy!  When I first got with him I was very insecure and depressed.  He was very charming and I thought we would be very happy.  During the course of our relationship he became very controlling and mean and nasty.  Everyday he would point out every bad quality I have.  Meanwhile he expected me to pay for all of his bills and support him while he laid around and did nothing.  To make a long story short, finally, I got a good job and I feel alot better about myself and I finally told him I am not taking it anymore.  Now, unfortuntaly, he will not return things to me that are mine, he is threatening me over the phone, he has threatened my parents.  He calls my daughter who is out of town on vacation with my ex husband to tell him that I wont let her talk to him, (hes not even her father) I am actually afraid.  But then I sit back and feel guilty and actually feel sorry for him.  Then when I call to pursue him returning my things to me he is so nasty and cruel, I wonder how could I have ever been with this person?  And it is now starting to effect my job and my health again and all I want is it to be over... I need some advice....
Almost three years is a long time, long enough to know if the relationship would work or not- and you know it wasn't going to work anylonger, and you did what needed to be done. But, he doesn't want to face the truth. Your ex is the type of person who lives his life getting his way by getting sympathy from others- he sounds like a master at it, if he can still get you to feel badly for him even now!! This is pure manipulation on his part, and you can't allow him to have that power over you every again. Its time to take your power back, and keep it- only you should have power over your thoughts, feelings, and emotions.
there is an old saying, "you never really know someone until you divorce them/break up with them..." and I think that can be so true in many cases. This man that you broke up with isn't the same man you fell for, this is the manipulative, nutty guy that you need to get away from. My advice: tell him, clearly and without emotion, that you want to make a time and date to retrieve your items. If he won't comply, then let him know you will get a police officer to assist you, and then, DO IT! Once you get your stuff, it will be done and over with. Don't hesitate to ask the police for assistance, they have to do this a lot. I wish you well.
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
hopeful
June 29, 2006, 2:04 pm PDT

Keep yourself as happy as you can on your own

Quote From: teemarie03

pregnant and alone

Where do I start? Right now my life is pretty messed up right now. I am 7 months pregnant and my boyfriend of 2 years has ran off to Virginia. I already have a one year old son with him and things werent great but they werent the worst. about 2 weeks ago he was helping his god parents move to Virginia, then on my sons first birthday july 09 he calls me and says he wasn't going to make it to the party. He had  the nerve enough to tell me that he could've gotten a bus ticket home but he needed time to himself he was too stressed out. Boy was I hurt to the bone. I figured its your sons 1st birthday and your being so selfish by saying that you needed to get away. At a time like this? His reply was "me missing his first birthday is between me and him and I don't  have to answer to anyone but him." Well that may be true to a certain extent but come on it's your sons first birthday why would you want to miss out on that? I was furious. I told him not to bother me for awhile. He calls the party to speak with his brother and tells him he on his way to Virginia Beach. Does anyone else see something wrong with that. he tells him also that he would be back later on that week. After that I didnt hear from him until the following Saturday and he  calls me and tells me that he might be staying down there for awhile and that he's going to the shipyard to find work every morning. I was so hurt. I was crying hysterically I mean I loved this boy. I would do anything for him. I mean it just happened so fast. The day before he left we were doing fine we watched a movie after I got off work then he took me home we did our I love yous and kisses. He says he understands why I am so hurt but I dont see how you could do somebody like this if  you love them. His main rebuttals i are I need time to myself to get my head on straight. you dont know what is going oon in someones head or what people are thinking, I am too stressed out. Sometimes you have think about yourself no matter who it hurts or you'll never be happy.

I know it's not all about me but I am crushed I need my boyfriend right now to get through this pregnancy to hug me kiss me talk to me but he says he to stressed out and he needs to get his life togather and start thinking more about himself. I feel like I am worthless. I cry every night . I cant believe he just left me like he did. He was my first for everything. This was even a big blow to his family. If you knew Justin you thought he would always be there for his kids if not his girlfriend. I feel embarassed when someone asks me how we're doing or where he's at.

He called me yesterday to ask about our son the convo was dry and forced. he began telling how he found a job and that he even started going to church. It looks like to me he's not coming back and that hurts more than anything. when he talks i can truly hear happiness in his voice. I want to be happy for him but I am not happy with how he left me. I feel burdened and stressed. I am begining to blame him for my anger, sadness, and depression. i feel like his happiness costed me what little happiness i had. at times I hate his guts at other times i miss him and I still love him. I cry all the time I need help.  does anyone have any advice.

 

thanks

Teena marie

Columbus Ohio

Hello Teena Marie,  

   I really feel for you.  I am have had similar feelings as you, although my situation is much different, but I am feeling better now that some time has passed.  I won't bore you with my story, but if interested it's posted under my profile.  So I have felt rejected, betrayed, heart broken, insulted, weak, vunerable, crushed, need I say more?  I cried for hours for about a month everynight, would dream about the guy who hurt me and wake up crying.  I couldn't wait to get home from work so I could cry and let all the built up sadness out that I had held in all day.  I had just got out of an abusive relationship and been "friends with Benefits" with a guy who I had known for at least 2 years after I left my abusive EX.  This guy Ron, was good support for the two weeks we hung out and he helped bring my spirits up after being made feel like dirt for 10 years with Ralph(I'm 30).  Then Ron told me we couldn't be friends for awhile because my ex was giving him a hard time, but it's been over 6 weeks and I haven't heard from him since.  At first I didn't think I could be OK without Ron.  All the good things he did and said to me felt like a joke because he changed his mind so fast about me.  I felt worthless and hopless and angry. 

  

   Some days were  better than others, but then when I just thought I was OK I would slip again and want to be with Ron and feel so rejected by him.  The point is--- Us ladies have to learn to take care of ourselves, mind body, sex, emotions ect.  I have to go, but I will continue later today, June 29, take care, I will pray for you! 

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
June 29, 2006, 3:26 pm PDT

hey again teena!

Quote From: teemarie03

pregnant and alone

Where do I start? Right now my life is pretty messed up right now. I am 7 months pregnant and my boyfriend of 2 years has ran off to Virginia. I already have a one year old son with him and things werent great but they werent the worst. about 2 weeks ago he was helping his god parents move to Virginia, then on my sons first birthday july 09 he calls me and says he wasn't going to make it to the party. He had  the nerve enough to tell me that he could've gotten a bus ticket home but he needed time to himself he was too stressed out. Boy was I hurt to the bone. I figured its your sons 1st birthday and your being so selfish by saying that you needed to get away. At a time like this? His reply was "me missing his first birthday is between me and him and I don't  have to answer to anyone but him." Well that may be true to a certain extent but come on it's your sons first birthday why would you want to miss out on that? I was furious. I told him not to bother me for awhile. He calls the party to speak with his brother and tells him he on his way to Virginia Beach. Does anyone else see something wrong with that. he tells him also that he would be back later on that week. After that I didnt hear from him until the following Saturday and he  calls me and tells me that he might be staying down there for awhile and that he's going to the shipyard to find work every morning. I was so hurt. I was crying hysterically I mean I loved this boy. I would do anything for him. I mean it just happened so fast. The day before he left we were doing fine we watched a movie after I got off work then he took me home we did our I love yous and kisses. He says he understands why I am so hurt but I dont see how you could do somebody like this if  you love them. His main rebuttals i are I need time to myself to get my head on straight. you dont know what is going oon in someones head or what people are thinking, I am too stressed out. Sometimes you have think about yourself no matter who it hurts or you'll never be happy.

I know it's not all about me but I am crushed I need my boyfriend right now to get through this pregnancy to hug me kiss me talk to me but he says he to stressed out and he needs to get his life togather and start thinking more about himself. I feel like I am worthless. I cry every night . I cant believe he just left me like he did. He was my first for everything. This was even a big blow to his family. If you knew Justin you thought he would always be there for his kids if not his girlfriend. I feel embarassed when someone asks me how we're doing or where he's at.

He called me yesterday to ask about our son the convo was dry and forced. he began telling how he found a job and that he even started going to church. It looks like to me he's not coming back and that hurts more than anything. when he talks i can truly hear happiness in his voice. I want to be happy for him but I am not happy with how he left me. I feel burdened and stressed. I am begining to blame him for my anger, sadness, and depression. i feel like his happiness costed me what little happiness i had. at times I hate his guts at other times i miss him and I still love him. I cry all the time I need help.  does anyone have any advice.

 

thanks

Teena marie

Columbus Ohio

             I had to stop writing there before because it was quiting time at work, I'm home now and I had to finish.  So as I was saying I felt similar to how you are feeling, I still do quite often, but thing are getting better.  The advice that people gave me worked in some ways, and really I knew all of this stuff rationally, but emotionally it was totally different.  My mind knew, and people told me.  If he made you feel this way then he wasn't reliable anyway.  If he did come back he may betray you again and the stakes could be higher.  The time you spend with people who do not treat you with respect is wasting precious time from yourself, and gettting to know yourself, understand yourself clearly without the need for others approval or time.  

  

             It does sound korny, but think of it this way...What's his face comes back to you and you and go for a walk.  You would have normally went down Main St, but What's his name and you walk up Maple Ave. Main was always so quite before, but the day you and What's his face(WHF) go there was someone on Main who you would have met along the way.  This man on Main could have been you future husband, love, equal, who treated you better than even you have imagined.  He would have loved you and you children and never hurt you as deep as WHF, but you didn't go down Main that day.  Mr Wonderful left town and didn't return.  You never met him, you don't miss him or really hurt over this because you were with WHF and missed your chance and you are oblivious to this knowlege. 

  

                Now don't get sad, becasuse if you believe in The LOVE OF THE Universe, God, the Life force, cupid or greek love goddessses, then you will one day meet this man another day or another time, when the time is right.  But if you want to really make yourself happy, and get respect and be strong, have more stability and love, then you will decide a.s.a.p that you will not do anything that will prevent you from obtaining that love.  This includes spending time with WHF and worrying about how much you miss him and need him and how much he hurts you.  Spend this time in a postive way.  You can do it, even practice at least a little each day, nurturing yourself.  I read (Get INNER LOVER, by valerie harms, it's good on this topic, using your fantacies about people who are inappropriate or let us down, or die or runway,  to heal. Dr Phils Love Smart is great too). I take bubble baths, walk, goto the gym, listen to music, doodle and journal (This really helps get stuff out too, and it's fun to go back and read what you wrote a day or a few days later.  Seriously, sooner , not later and you will be able to laugh about this, even if it still hurts too, you will feel better in many ways.    

  

  

                     Like a rainstrom and thunder comes and it down pours, you will see a rainbow and it will last longer. Even if you do see WHF more in the future, tell him how you feel, honour your feelings.  I only hope I am strong enough to take my own advice! It is so much harder to do this than to write it, or it even might sound like preaching to you?) But I read your post and I was like, " I was, I am in a similar place as you are  in my heart.  I want someone to come back to me, say sorry and just be nice and loving and supportive to me, do the manly thing, have answers, closure, the truth, or something. "I wanted to tell you there is someone else out there feeling similar to you, and I know it is hard to function, especially with a child( I don't have, I can only imagine) and I hope you don't give up, I pray things will go better for you.  I know it helped me just reading you post because I smiled and said, "That's me... I know how that feels.  

  

  Anyway, I am blabbing now, but Best Wishes!  I am sure I will write updates later!  

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
June 30, 2006, 8:15 am PDT

Please Help, Need to forgive...move FW

I need encouragement and I guess permission to allow myself to move fw with my relationship.  I have been dating a guy for 2 years now. We have lived together for almost 1 year. I founds out about 8 months ago that when he was transferred on a project for work to another state that he spent alot of time with another female he was working with. I found a card she sent and by her words, could tell there were more than a few lunches involved. He said she persued him but he told her he had a GF.  He swore nothing happened and they were friends. Well, I finally broke down and called her about 1 month ago b/c the imagination is always worse than the truth and she said that they were not intimate (sex) but that they were friends and he would come over a few times a week after work. The way I approached it feel she would have been mad and told me if they had sex. She did say that they kissed before but that was it. She felt he had a GF b/c in the 4 months he was gone he always made it home to me...every weekend so she didn't totally trust him. Anyway, We had only been dating for 2 months b4 he left however feel we were exclusive and he was not the one to tell me the truth.. It has been very hard b/c when he kisses me, I think of him kissing her and feel sick. Another thing is he is younger, 26 and know he has never been in love b4. He has never told anyone he loved them b/c it IS a big deal to him. All of our mutual friends agree that he has changed and it committed bigtime. He didn't really tell me he loved me until recently so we were taking our time emotionaly. I know him better than anyone else and how complicated his feelings are. Am I stupid to believe that now that we are at a different level he would not do anything at this time? I know he has taken awhile and has come a long way. I am 30 and this is the 1st time I have truly fallen in love as well. I get upset when another guy hits on me and am totally dedicated to him. I feel afraid all the time, find I try to test him alot, and feel I am missing out on enjoying us now...at the level we are at with loving each other. Dr. Phil's advice is helping but is a long road and need to move FW to forgiving him and knowing the person he is now b/c it is harming our relationship the way I can't let go of past. Please help. I need feedback, 
 
User Mood
Nervous

Message Emote
confused
June 30, 2006, 9:07 am PDT

Not Breaking Really??

I met this guy in March on Match.com but we started the relationship backwards - too much too soon.  

  

We fell madly in love in with one another but shortly after I met him - we had a four wheeler accident which hurt both us so I moved into his home so that we could take care of each other.  But after a month of so I should have gone back home but asked him a couple of times if he wanted to leave which he never did give me a straight answer, yes or no.  He said to do what I wanted to do - (wrong answer) so of course I stayed.  Big mistake.  The prelude up him asking me to move out was a killer.  I knew something was wrong because we communicated very well not perfectly up that point.  He said that he didn't want to break up but wanted to go back to dating.  I agree it was too much too soon and realized that the relationship wouldn't last if it kept up the way it was going.  Even though I am totally ready to move forward he isn't.  I am a smart person and I know it is understandbly so.  He has been divorced three times, and after his third divorce, he took on a rebound relationship which I found did not end until shortly before we met.   He has spent approximately six months by himself.    He was very honest said he thought he was ready for someone to be around all the time but he isn't.  He wants to take the time to heal before starting a new relationship, which he and I had started.  But in the meantime he wants me to be his friend (which I totally agree) and date.    Moving backwards in a new relationship is the hardest thing I have ever done in my life. 

  

Am I crazy to wait?  I care about him deeply and if the circumstances were right - we are good for each other.   It has been three weeks since this episode took place during which I suffered a tradegy of my father dying. 

  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
June 30, 2006, 9:46 am PDT

Should I break Up

I am dating this guy who I thought (and am still confused about) may be the one.  In the beginning, he informed me about another female who explicitly told him she loved him. For his birthday, she gave him herself (sexually), and she has given herself to him a few more times since then. We were dating ironically during this period and began a serious relationship some months following. He kept assuring me that he cared nothing for her, but he slept with her. He told me a few months ago, and I am really crushed. It hurts because I thought he was the one. I was falling in love with him. We became sexually involved during the period as well. Before this, he promised the other woman that he would simply end the relationships both with me and with her. Then, he ended their "affair" and stayed with me. I asked him when he revealed to me if he cared for her and what his intentions were towards me. He claimed he wanted me. I confronted the other woman, who claimed she didn't know when in fact she knew we were dating from jump. My problem today is that I am hurt. This girl keeps at her emotional attempts to talk to him via a mutual interest that they have invested in. He occasionally will mention her name or what is going on with her to me, which hurts my feelings. He doesn't publically acknowledge me as his girlfriend, which hurts too and also shows me that there is some confusion as to what I am to him. Now, I recently learn of one of his friends telling him that I along with the other woman were being crafy with his emotions. I am now extremely cautious and upset over this. Number one, I hate the thought of being compared to the other woman. Number two, how can I be crafty when I am the one who was hurt thinking the relationship was A-OK. I am confused and deeply upset. I am now not sure what step I should take next. What should I do?   

 
First | Prev | 196 | 197 | 198 | 199 | 200 | 201 | 202 | 203 | 204 | 205 | Next | Last