Message Boards

Topic : Breaking Up

Number of Replies: 5468
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:06:14 pm
Author : dataimport
Is it time to end things with your significant other? Or, have you just been handed a relationship pink slip? Share your stories.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Good

Message Emote
sad
September 7, 2006, 4:38 pm PDT

Take Your Time!

Quote From: greendragon

I can't stand men that play games!  This one is playing a game with you.  I had the same thing happen, except my ex said mean things to me and then cried as I was leaving, saying he felt he was losing his best friend.  I never did find out if the mean things he said were a lie or the crying was at will, but down the road we got back together, with much sweet talking from his side.  It was a mistake to go back once more.  When I said goodbye for good, I realized how empowering it was - he realized he couldn't play me for a fool anymore.

Sure I miss the good parts of him, but now I look back and thank my lucky stars that relationship didn't last longer! 

Get out and date right away, even if its awkward or strange...believe me, it will feel better than sitting around brooding about a guy that doesn't deserve the respect he obviously never shared with you.

 

All the best.

 

  

I think that no matter how bad you're hurting right now, you should heal first before getting into another relationship or even dating anyone else!  I've been going through alot myself from a recent breakup ( I threw him out), and I  know I'm not ready to even look at another man right now!  I've become very distrustful when it comes to even believing one word out of a guys mouth at this point!  All of them tell you just what they think you want to hear when you first meet (remember that!) Then things loosen up,  and they start showing who they REALLY ARE!  No one is perfect....not me, not you.  In the past, I've been abused physically , verbally, put up with drug / alcohol abuse and the effects that it has on a person and their significant other....I can finally say that I'm fed up with men and dating!  For me, if it's meant to happen, it will....but when the time is right!  I'd actually like to see if it's true that when it's meant to happen....it will!  I'm not looking for Mr. Right......It's Mr. Acceptable and he's gotta find me!
 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
September 7, 2006, 7:58 pm PDT

do I hold on or let go???

HI everyone

 

I have been in a relationship for almost 5 yrs now. He is a really nice guy but I think he has a problem with commitment. He has never been married or lived with anyone. He is 44 and i am 43yo.  We recently talked about getting a place together and he said he needed a few mos to think about it. (This was not the first discussion of this kind) We talked about it the other nite and he said he couldnt do it because of money issues and medical issues. He says I am a wonderful person and deserve someone better than him. He said he cant make me any promises for the future but does see me in his future. He said he loves me to death but realizes I want more.  He said it could be another yr or 2 before he will be ready for the move. MAYBE! We have fun together but only see each other once or twice a wk because of work schedules. And sometimes its only at nite. He has no contact with my friends or family , only me. I feel like this is not a normal relationship especially for 5 yrs. Should I give him more time or should I move on??  I am really confused. I don't want to lose a good man.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
September 8, 2006, 10:09 am PDT

Dear boop--

Quote From: boop10

HI everyone

 

I have been in a relationship for almost 5 yrs now. He is a really nice guy but I think he has a problem with commitment. He has never been married or lived with anyone. He is 44 and i am 43yo.  We recently talked about getting a place together and he said he needed a few mos to think about it. (This was not the first discussion of this kind) We talked about it the other nite and he said he couldnt do it because of money issues and medical issues. He says I am a wonderful person and deserve someone better than him. He said he cant make me any promises for the future but does see me in his future. He said he loves me to death but realizes I want more.  He said it could be another yr or 2 before he will be ready for the move. MAYBE! We have fun together but only see each other once or twice a wk because of work schedules. And sometimes its only at nite. He has no contact with my friends or family , only me. I feel like this is not a normal relationship especially for 5 yrs. Should I give him more time or should I move on??  I am really confused. I don't want to lose a good man.

Five years is a LONG time!! If he isn’t going to commit to you now, or soon, then he isn’t going to. After five years of dating, he should know by now if he will marry you or not. He probably does know that he won’t marry you, but he also doesn’t want to “lose a good thing” by telling you that. Unless you are willing to settle for your relationship staying exactly the same, its time for you to go and don’t look back. You teach people how to treat you.
 
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
September 8, 2006, 12:22 pm PDT

Breaking Up

Quote From: benna1

I met this guy on a dating site. we clicked right away. we had everything in common form sports to cooking. everything. even our children shared similiar interest, both very passionate about animals. we started chatting. we talked everyday on the phone, online everyday. i ididnt join the site really looking for a relationship. he also told me the same thing. initially he joined the site to meet women with similar interest, like biking, rafting, sports. then he said if he happened to be in the state they were from, then he would look them up and meet them. platonically. i then he said he met me, and we were so comfortable it was so easy, effortless talking. it was, like id known him all my life. we talked and decided that he could, would come to meet me. he drove 10 hours. we spent 5 wonderful days together. we had so much fun, enjoyed everything together, but we talked about how it wasnt the real world and he'd have to go back to work and his hectic schedule of working , taking care of his 15yr old son, whom hes raised since he was 2. he is divorced if i didnt mention that. anyway he said too that he ended his last relationship of 5 years because of her pessemistic attitude and his lack of time to spend with her, that she complained about. so he said intially he wasnt going to get into another relationship for at least 3 years when his son was out of high school. then he met me and thought this could work. so after he went back home we talked again everyday, he said he was crazy bout me and wanted to try a relationship and he wanted his next relationship to be his last. to me that was ours. he talked, we talked about moving me to his city, moving into his home becoming a family all of that. we then made arrangements for me to go sprn time with him and his son (in the real world) i arrived on friday, we had a great weekend. i met his mom and spent all day momday with her. he had to work. he picked me up that affternoon, we went home. he said he was stressed from work so i gave him some quality private time. tuesaday was his birthday so he went in half a day for that afternoon. i stayed home and baked cake and cookies and did some work on computer. initially  when we were planning my trip it was to be from friday till wednesday, but he said he wanted me to stay thru the 5th. after i arrived that was never mentioned again. anyway he came home tuesday, we took a walk together, his mom came over for cake and we cuddled on the couch till late that night. i was to fly home the next morning wednesday. we had a great time while i was there. he was very affectionate and i was so relaxed and at home there, i git along great with his son. then on wednesday morning we're lying in bed and he says, my schedule is so hectic. i didnt have time to take off and spend it with you. on monday when i got home from work i was so stressed i didnt want to be around people. ( we had discussed thind early on online chatting. how he knew his world was hectic and sometimes he just didnt want to be around people and thats part of the reason he broke up with his last gfriend of 5 yrs)  i thought we, i was ok with that. then he tells me.. I DONT HAVE TIME FOR A RELATIONSHIP....so this isnt going to work. i dont have time to fit you in. of course this was devastating to me because  i thought all was fine. i sayed u lied to me you said jump ill catch you...thatd didnt happen. he says IM SORRY I HURT YOU. he takes me to the airport. im a crying mess. he holds me close says he call me later and i look at him and hes crying.

he calls me that eveing and i said what now? he says id like to keep talking to you if youd like. what do we talk about now? i said i understand the not having time now, but is there a future for us. HE SAYS NO...i dont understand this. hes crazee about me he then says. but no future. then  i get an email stating he said that cos he doesnt know if he has a future with anyone. thats what he was trying to say. so now he says since i know im not relationship material, i can be a really great friend. i feel in love with him and things were so great, tell me how can it go wrong so quickly, how can he stop caring about me. i cant stop crying. how do i get over this. i still hope for a future with him. tell me someone how i get over this. do i wait? how can i be just a friend? i want him in my life but its so painful. im afraid if im not a friend ill never see him again. which if problably going to happen anyway. someone please help me with this............thank you...heartbroken and hurting

The best thing for you to do is get busy.  Don't waste anymore time talking to him.  If you feel there are things you want to say to him, write it down in a letter, then rip it up or throw it away. 

If it is painful for you to have him in your life, then you DON'T want him in your life.

But most importantly, you need to get a clean break.  I broke up with my boyfriend of 3 years, 2 months ago.  At least you weren't told that he's known motorcycles longer than he's known you.

But for the past 2months all I can do is think about him, if I would have given him more time, etc. etc.  But all that has accomplished is me feeling lonely and depressed.  Today I am taking the letter that I have been writing for two months about all my anger, and frustration, and love towards him, and all the pictures of us together and burning it all.

I know that I am the one that broke it off tihs time, but it's a long history of things with him, on & off again, etc.  But I still think that I'm in love with him despite what he has said and done, or not done. 

Don't be like me and keep this man in your life because you think you love him.  You will be stuck where I was for 3 years.  Then at the end of it you wonder why the hell you did it.

Cut it off, no more calls to him, no more emails, nothing.  He is NEVERgoing to give you want you really want.  And you can't be friends with him because of how strongly you feel about him.

And don't worry about being afraid of never seeing him again, I've been terrified of not seeing Jim ever again, but I'm slowly coming around to realizing that it's ok.  Soon he will just be someone I used to know.

Start a list for yourself of the qualities you want in a man, and what you don't want.  I call it my deal breaker list.  BUT DONT FORGET ABOUT IT!!!   I wrote mine after my divorce, then 2 years later forgot about it, then met Jim and "fell in love" with him.  It wasn't after I broke up with him that I pulled the list out, andwhat do you know....out of 20 deal breakers, he had 15 of them!!!!

But the best thing you can do for yourself right now, is no more communication with him.  Everytime you do that you bring yourself right back down, because he has told you there is no romantic future for you. 

I'm not going to lie and say it's not hard.  It's hard as hell, and you will have good days, but then you will fall back into crying and missing him.  When you have those days, call a friend, call afamily memeber, hell call QVC.  Just don't call him.  I wish you much luck, it is a hard road to go down, but trust me, you will be a stronger person for it. 

also heartbroken and hurting, and right there with you girl.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
sad
September 8, 2006, 4:52 pm PDT

I don't know what to do! Advice please!!!

I have met the man that i thought that i was going to spend the rest of my life with. Everything that i wanted in a mate he was. Now this is where everyone is going to gasp and be like girl you are crazy what are you thinking but here it goes... We were only together for 3 months before we got into a huge fight and when i say huge i mean huge. He told me that he need sometime to think about things and to make sure that this was 100% percent what he wanted because he KNOWS (and i put that in caps because he still tells me he loves me) that he loves me just that i was the one for him. I of course read too much into what he was saying and over reacted and blew up at him calling him a few names that i would prefer not to repeat and when i did this it reopened some wounds from his childhood and now even though (and this is not something that i have come up with he has told me this himself) he loves me and wants to be with me more than ever he can't let himself be around someone that yells like that. Now in my defense after what he said to me i didn't know what else to do i was hurt and upset and all that i could see or think was that i was going to loose the love of my life i know that all this talk about forever probably a Little premature i just can't help it. I know that i have hurt him but i don't know what else i can do other than tell him that i am sorry and that i will do my best to not let it happen again. I know what that sounds like "oh baby baby please i promise i wont ____ as long as you don't leave me"  but its not seeing the hurt on his face when i used those words was enough to show me that i would rather die than hurt him again. Now i own what i have done and said and all i want is to have him back but i don't know what else to do please if you have any advise please reply.

Thanks

Katie

P.s. if you think that what i did was wrong please don't leave me messages yelling at me because i already feel bad enough. Thanks

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
September 8, 2006, 10:32 pm PDT

Advice PLEASE??????

Ok here it is. Over 6 months ago me and my first love broke up. But his mom and I remain friends. She wants me to come and visit her. She calls me on my cell. She asks me how life is going and how I am doing. She will ask me all sorts of things about my life.

 

 

Question is this normal. For a mother of and ex boyfriend to want to stay close?

 

 

Anybody PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
upset
September 9, 2006, 5:25 am PDT

confused

Hello, Im knew to the group and here is my story::

 

Last night I ended a 3 year relationship with a man I love dearly.  My ex was very abusive, he hit me alot, Dec 10, 2005 he gave me 6 stiches in my upper lip.  Many would say im stupid for staying and now that I guess im fed up and tired of the controlling, selfish, disrespectful, ways I ended it.  No this isnt the first time I have walked away from the relationship, however it is the last!!!  Whats funny is I didnt end the relationship because he hit me, because he for the hundreth time called me out my name,...I ended it because he wouldnt allow me to stay the night at his house.  I have been with this man cooked meal, spent money, supported mentally, and in three years we have never woke up in each others arms.  Even after we made love, I would always get and he would escort me to the door.  I have brought the issue up and told him how uncomfortable it makes me feel, he never really has a comment, he normally responds with "I will work on that baby, im just used to being by myself"   I cant go back to him, I am at the  lowest point in my life.  I feel so cheap, so whorish!!!.  Im not happy with me or my life  and the way I allowed him to control  me.   I miss him and love him but I know I cant be with him.  Part of me wants him to call and beg me back pleading that he will change,  however i know he wont, and no he doesnt even care that im gone.  im hurting, Please any advice would be helpful.

 

Thanks

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
September 9, 2006, 5:48 am PDT

Breaking Up

Quote From: spicycandy31

Hello, Im knew to the group and here is my story::

 

Last night I ended a 3 year relationship with a man I love dearly.  My ex was very abusive, he hit me alot, Dec 10, 2005 he gave me 6 stiches in my upper lip.  Many would say im stupid for staying and now that I guess im fed up and tired of the controlling, selfish, disrespectful, ways I ended it.  No this isnt the first time I have walked away from the relationship, however it is the last!!!  Whats funny is I didnt end the relationship because he hit me, because he for the hundreth time called me out my name,...I ended it because he wouldnt allow me to stay the night at his house.  I have been with this man cooked meal, spent money, supported mentally, and in three years we have never woke up in each others arms.  Even after we made love, I would always get and he would escort me to the door.  I have brought the issue up and told him how uncomfortable it makes me feel, he never really has a comment, he normally responds with "I will work on that baby, im just used to being by myself"   I cant go back to him, I am at the  lowest point in my life.  I feel so cheap, so whorish!!!.  Im not happy with me or my life  and the way I allowed him to control  me.   I miss him and love him but I know I cant be with him.  Part of me wants him to call and beg me back pleading that he will change,  however i know he wont, and no he doesnt even care that im gone.  im hurting, Please any advice would be helpful.

 

Thanks

Um-   Hi -I saw this (  I am new here) and I know exactly  how you feel-  But all I can say-  I know you are hurting and  it will take time to heal-  Each time  you call or visit- all it is going to do is prolong your healing-Like -you know when you pick a scab-and it bleeds (but slowly heals-some times leaving a scar?)  That is the same with your heart and soul-  

Please do not go back to him-  Your self estteem is crushed right now-  Very low- He will NOT change -you actually know that-  

( He is hiding something from you-Lying about something if you can't stay the night-)  But the BIGGER ISSUE- if I may ask-Why did you put up with his abuse for so long???  

How old are y'all?  But it doesn't matter- Please do not put up with this crap any more- 

Leave and heal and move on-or you will have regrets-  I had to learn that-  You deserve better and more-Don't you think?

I wish you the best-

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
September 9, 2006, 11:28 am PDT

Katie

Quote From: grease570

I have met the man that i thought that i was going to spend the rest of my life with. Everything that i wanted in a mate he was. Now this is where everyone is going to gasp and be like girl you are crazy what are you thinking but here it goes... We were only together for 3 months before we got into a huge fight and when i say huge i mean huge. He told me that he need sometime to think about things and to make sure that this was 100% percent what he wanted because he KNOWS (and i put that in caps because he still tells me he loves me) that he loves me just that i was the one for him. I of course read too much into what he was saying and over reacted and blew up at him calling him a few names that i would prefer not to repeat and when i did this it reopened some wounds from his childhood and now even though (and this is not something that i have come up with he has told me this himself) he loves me and wants to be with me more than ever he can't let himself be around someone that yells like that. Now in my defense after what he said to me i didn't know what else to do i was hurt and upset and all that i could see or think was that i was going to loose the love of my life i know that all this talk about forever probably a Little premature i just can't help it. I know that i have hurt him but i don't know what else i can do other than tell him that i am sorry and that i will do my best to not let it happen again. I know what that sounds like "oh baby baby please i promise i wont ____ as long as you don't leave me"  but its not seeing the hurt on his face when i used those words was enough to show me that i would rather die than hurt him again. Now i own what i have done and said and all i want is to have him back but i don't know what else to do please if you have any advise please reply.

Thanks

Katie

P.s. if you think that what i did was wrong please don't leave me messages yelling at me because i already feel bad enough. Thanks

When he told you that he wanted time apart to know that your relationship was 100% what he wanted, the best way for you to react would have been to say to him, “okay.” (Of course, you probably know that now!) My advice to you is to really think about why you reacted the way that you did, be totally honest with yourself. It is important for you to learn why you reacted the way that you did so that, in the future, you don’t repeat this same mistake. It is natural for people, like your boyfriend, to feel the need for some ‘space’ before committing 100%. And then there are other people, such as yourself, who don’t need to take that time- we are all different and you need to learn how to embrace other people’s differences. When you learn how to accept that everyone is different and imperfect, you will learn how to accept your own imperfections too. You are only human, so don’t beat yourself up too much over what has happened, you need to learn and grow from this experience because that will suit you better in the long run. Remember that it is possible this relationship simply was not meant to be!
 
 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
confused
September 9, 2006, 2:53 pm PDT

breaking up

Quote From: jaimie1974

When he told you that he wanted time apart to know that your relationship was 100% what he wanted, the best way for you to react would have been to say to him, okay. (Of course, you probably know that now!) My advice to you is to really think about why you reacted the way that you did, be totally honest with yourself. It is important for you to learn why you reacted the way that you did so that, in the future, you dont repeat this same mistake. It is natural for people, like your boyfriend, to feel the need for some space before committing 100%. And then there are other people, such as yourself, who dont need to take that time- we are all different and you need to learn how to embrace other peoples differences. When you learn how to accept that everyone is different and imperfect, you will learn how to accept your own imperfections too. You are only human, so dont beat yourself up too much over what has happened, you need to learn and grow from this experience because that will suit you better in the long run. Remember that it is possible this relationship simply was not meant to be!
 

I feel for you, I also thought I was in a relationship that would last, well we had up and downs but over all I really realise when I kept putting up with his abusiveness making excuses for him, his drinking making excuses for him, his children interferring in our relationship I still tried. I was fully committed but when it came down to committment and loyality and support he wasnt there to give it. he also said after a small fight he needed time to think, which is a nice way to say I dont have the guts to tell you but i want out. Giving time will allow him to think of ways to come up with excuses of breaking up.  It hurts bad but believe me there is Mr Right out there. It will take time and like you I alway rush in so this time I will take time....My advise, give up on him, apologise and move on.

 

nungagirl from aussie land

 
First | Prev | 241 | 242 | 243 | 244 | 245 | 246 | 247 | 248 | 249 | 250 | Next | Last