Message Boards

Topic : Breaking Up

Number of Replies: 5468
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:06:14 pm
Author : dataimport
Is it time to end things with your significant other? Or, have you just been handed a relationship pink slip? Share your stories.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Lazy

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2006, 8:42 am PDT

wow

Quote From: iamdada

you need to give up on controlling him.  you probably couldn't control him when you where with him, so what makes you think you can control him now?  get a darn life.  it doesn't sound like he is doing anything wrong to me.  he is moving on with life and you should try doing the same thing.  how did you hear his voicemail?  are you such a control freak that you hack his voicemail and email and ....?  no wonder he doesn't want you to meet her.

You didnt have to be so rude to her . Im sure you would of done the same thing and i think she has the right to meet this girl since she has been doing things with HER daugter anyways . And she isnt trying to control him neither . so stop with the attitude
 
User Mood
Scared

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2006, 9:33 am PDT

Breaking Up

Quote From: sandy0914

If he had slept with someone else - would you want to know?  Of course you would.  He's going to find out eventually. I'm sure he would rather hear it from you rather than from somebody else.  Honesty is always the best policy.    Could this be the end to your relationship?  Absolutely.  But you learned a really hard life lesson here which hopefully you will not duplicate in the future.  Sleeping around for even just one night is never the answer to your problems, they only create problems.  If you love and respect him, you will tell him the truth and hope he can forgive you and trust you again. 
Well I must say there is no possible way of him finding out.  He doesn't know this person whatsoever, has never met him, he lives hours away and nobody else knows about it.  Thanks for the adivce.  Part of me thinks I should too.  But then I slept with someone else knowing that my relationship was over and broke up with my boyfriend the next morning.  I knew in my heart it was over and made up my mind to leave and did it the next day. Also I'm confused, and I forgot to add this, that once like a year ago in a conversation about cheating, he had said he would never want to know if he was cheated on if it had only happened once and it wouldn't happened again.  So that whole thing makes me more confused too.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
confused
October 25, 2006, 10:14 am PDT

Should I leave my alcoholic boyfriend?

So I guess I was wondering what others thoughts would be on staying with a man who is an alcoholic who refuses to stop drinking or try and get help. Every problem that we encounter seems to be my fault in his eyes. If he goes out and gets drunk he might say that I pushed him to do it because I made him mad. Or even if he just went out and drank because he was having fun  with his friends then if I get upset with him then it is my fault for making too big of a deal about it. My boyfriend is 25 years old and has already suffered from 2 alcohol induced seizures and this past July he had to spend a week in the hospital with pancreatitis which was also caused by alcohol, but he told his mom it was caused by stress. What a joke! Everytime he goes out and gets drunk he has some kind of cut or bruise on him and he doesn't remember how he got it and he rarely remembers how he got home. Recently he drove to another town and met me and a friend of mine when we were heading home he rode with us because he told me that he gotten a ride there with somebody else. The next day he went outside and said his car had been stolen and he was very upset and was looking everywhere for it. Come to find out that he had actually driven his car there and not remembered it, yet he doesn't act like that is a big deal. Well I think it is. I feel like I can't handle it anymore. I don't want to abandon him but I feel like I'm wasting my life on someone who really doesn't want to live it with me. I'm so hurt and confused, also a couple of weeks ago on a Sunday he grabbed his bag and packed it and just walked out the door. I finally tracked him down at his mothers house and he said that he was going to stay there for awhile until he got things together in his life because he wasn't happy. Which I completely understand but then he showed up at my house drunk twice in the following week. So now we don't live together so I don't get the companionship but I guess when he's drunk he doesn't want his mom to see so he shows up at my house. That is the last thing I want. Please give me your input.

 
User Mood
Scared

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2006, 10:36 am PDT

I would leave him

Quote From: violet4996

So I guess I was wondering what others thoughts would be on staying with a man who is an alcoholic who refuses to stop drinking or try and get help. Every problem that we encounter seems to be my fault in his eyes. If he goes out and gets drunk he might say that I pushed him to do it because I made him mad. Or even if he just went out and drank because he was having fun  with his friends then if I get upset with him then it is my fault for making too big of a deal about it. My boyfriend is 25 years old and has already suffered from 2 alcohol induced seizures and this past July he had to spend a week in the hospital with pancreatitis which was also caused by alcohol, but he told his mom it was caused by stress. What a joke! Everytime he goes out and gets drunk he has some kind of cut or bruise on him and he doesn't remember how he got it and he rarely remembers how he got home. Recently he drove to another town and met me and a friend of mine when we were heading home he rode with us because he told me that he gotten a ride there with somebody else. The next day he went outside and said his car had been stolen and he was very upset and was looking everywhere for it. Come to find out that he had actually driven his car there and not remembered it, yet he doesn't act like that is a big deal. Well I think it is. I feel like I can't handle it anymore. I don't want to abandon him but I feel like I'm wasting my life on someone who really doesn't want to live it with me. I'm so hurt and confused, also a couple of weeks ago on a Sunday he grabbed his bag and packed it and just walked out the door. I finally tracked him down at his mothers house and he said that he was going to stay there for awhile until he got things together in his life because he wasn't happy. Which I completely understand but then he showed up at my house drunk twice in the following week. So now we don't live together so I don't get the companionship but I guess when he's drunk he doesn't want his mom to see so he shows up at my house. That is the last thing I want. Please give me your input.

I know it's easier said than done and easier to say when you're not in the situation.  I mean I have my own relationship issues that are far from perfect.  But what I'm trying to remind myself right now as well is that NOBODY WILL CHANGE IF THEY DON'T THINK SOMETHING IS WRONG IN THE FIRST PLACE.  So unless you won't to deal with this forever, you should let him go. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2006, 12:01 pm PDT

alcoholic boyfriend

Quote From: violet4996

So I guess I was wondering what others thoughts would be on staying with a man who is an alcoholic who refuses to stop drinking or try and get help. Every problem that we encounter seems to be my fault in his eyes. If he goes out and gets drunk he might say that I pushed him to do it because I made him mad. Or even if he just went out and drank because he was having fun  with his friends then if I get upset with him then it is my fault for making too big of a deal about it. My boyfriend is 25 years old and has already suffered from 2 alcohol induced seizures and this past July he had to spend a week in the hospital with pancreatitis which was also caused by alcohol, but he told his mom it was caused by stress. What a joke! Everytime he goes out and gets drunk he has some kind of cut or bruise on him and he doesn't remember how he got it and he rarely remembers how he got home. Recently he drove to another town and met me and a friend of mine when we were heading home he rode with us because he told me that he gotten a ride there with somebody else. The next day he went outside and said his car had been stolen and he was very upset and was looking everywhere for it. Come to find out that he had actually driven his car there and not remembered it, yet he doesn't act like that is a big deal. Well I think it is. I feel like I can't handle it anymore. I don't want to abandon him but I feel like I'm wasting my life on someone who really doesn't want to live it with me. I'm so hurt and confused, also a couple of weeks ago on a Sunday he grabbed his bag and packed it and just walked out the door. I finally tracked him down at his mothers house and he said that he was going to stay there for awhile until he got things together in his life because he wasn't happy. Which I completely understand but then he showed up at my house drunk twice in the following week. So now we don't live together so I don't get the companionship but I guess when he's drunk he doesn't want his mom to see so he shows up at my house. That is the last thing I want. Please give me your input.

I know this is easier said than done, but at this point, he is only using you because he wants to hide his alcoholism from his mother- so you need to be strong, keep your self respect, and when he shows up at your home, either tell him to leave or call someone to come and get him. He hasn’t shown up sober or attempted to talk to you while he was sober at all? It sounds like his alcoholism is worsening; but please know that YOU had nothing to do with it, that is just his convenient excuse. Alcoholics have the need to blame others for their problems, but you don’t have to be his victim. You will end up feeling used and drained if you allow this to continue. Be good to yourself, you deserve so much more.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
confused
October 25, 2006, 7:59 pm PDT

Confused

I have been with my boyfriend for a year and a half now.  We live together and get along great and love each other.  Lately we have been talking about getting engaged.  I would love to be engaged, but i have these weird feelings.  Some times i feel like i want to be single again, but then i think about it and think if i break up with him i really may not find someone that is as good as him.  He treats me very well, and loves me and would do anything for me.  I don't know if that makes me seem like I'm scared to be alone and if i break up with him then i might not find someone else.  I don't know what it is.  We have not talked about this, and i don't think it would be a good topic for us to talk about.  We recently got into a fight about the same one stupid thing that we fight about and i told him i was done with it because I'm sick of fighting over the same thing, and I'm done.  I told him if we fight about it once more I'm done with it all because its too hard emotionally on me.  When i said that he broke down and he didn't want that to happen, and at that moment i felt like i did love him and he is the one i want to be with.  But then a couple of days later i start to feel like sometimes i want to be single again.  I know i love him and when i think about it i couldn't find anyone better for me and i don't want to loose him.  But i just get these urges to go out and party like I'm single and see other people, but i would never want to loose him.  I am sooo confused.  Are these feelings at all normal?  Does everyone want to be single again at some point in their relationship,  or do i really not love him like i think i do?  PLEASE HELP ME!!!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2006, 8:23 pm PDT

Any ideas how to let go?

Hello.  I have been in a relationship for ten years with a man who I thought was the love of my life - a good, decent, hard working man.  We have two children and his son also lives with us.  A year ago I found out he had been having an affair for a year.  We went to counseling for six months and he swore he wasn't seeing her.  I found out now that he never stopped seeing her and has been seeing her for two years.  She and I have talked.  I told him I couldn't live like this any more and he needed to make a decision.  He says he loves me and wants to be with me but wants me to get my act together (lose weight), and so he would like to give me six months to do that and while I do that, he lives elsewhere.  Tonight his girlfriend called me and said that he wasn't coming home tonight.  I demanded to speak to him and he said that he just needed rest and would talk to me in the AM.  I am about 50 pounds overweight.  Now that I read this, it sounds pretty pathetic.  I do have his bags packed and by the door.  But, how do you let go of the father of your children, the man you love?  I can't sleep, can't eat.  I want him home where he belongs.  I think he would like freedom, but I'm not sure that I can give him that.  I'm a 43 year old professional woman with a college education.  Days like this, I feel like a teenager!
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
October 25, 2006, 11:27 pm PDT

Thanks

Quote From: sandy0914

I assume because you mentioned it twice in your message that you are thinking of telling the other woman about you and him.    This really has nothing to do with her, it has to do with him.  She is innocent as far as I'm concerned.

 

This man is dating someone else, tells you he loves her.  What more do you need to know???

 

So he slept with you a week ago (cheated on her) and told you he still loves you - sounds like one hell of a guy!!   Andy why do you want him back?  Because he is an honest trusting person?

 

Do yourself a favor and move on.  You need him like a hole in the head!

I know it is what I have to do and I thank you.... I do go to counselling and she said to be friends if possible because of the child ... I need to work on me and move on and I know this.    I know you think she is innocent  and that maybe true but she should have a right to know what he has done.....I feel sorry for her.  If it was you wouldn't you want to know.

 

But thanks again much appreciate you opinnion

 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2006, 1:51 am PDT

Breaking Up

Quote From: sandy0914

This topic of watching porn on TV and on the computer has been discussed soooo many times on this site with everybody having different opinions and stories.    Now I see nothing wrong with a grown man watching porn as long as it is not done on family time,  it is not an addiction and it is not being hidden from the spouse.  However, teen porn just sits wrong with me for a 41 year old man - especially since you have teen agers in the home. This would make even me uncomfortable.

Question - If it was 30 year old women - would you be as concerned?

No I wouldn't be as concerned.  Its the word 'teen' that he keeps looking up that bothers me tremendously and then I find the printed pics.  If he wanted to look at normal porn go ahead as long as he is still interested in me and finds me desireable.  He stills thinks its none of my business and he says he can look at what he wants.  He even takes the ethernet cord to work with him so I can't access the internet.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 26, 2006, 6:24 am PDT

You will let go when you are ready.

Quote From: bsf1234

Hello.  I have been in a relationship for ten years with a man who I thought was the love of my life - a good, decent, hard working man.  We have two children and his son also lives with us.  A year ago I found out he had been having an affair for a year.  We went to counseling for six months and he swore he wasn't seeing her.  I found out now that he never stopped seeing her and has been seeing her for two years.  She and I have talked.  I told him I couldn't live like this any more and he needed to make a decision.  He says he loves me and wants to be with me but wants me to get my act together (lose weight), and so he would like to give me six months to do that and while I do that, he lives elsewhere.  Tonight his girlfriend called me and said that he wasn't coming home tonight.  I demanded to speak to him and he said that he just needed rest and would talk to me in the AM.  I am about 50 pounds overweight.  Now that I read this, it sounds pretty pathetic.  I do have his bags packed and by the door.  But, how do you let go of the father of your children, the man you love?  I can't sleep, can't eat.  I want him home where he belongs.  I think he would like freedom, but I'm not sure that I can give him that.  I'm a 43 year old professional woman with a college education.  Days like this, I feel like a teenager!

The only person here who is pathetic is your boyfriend!!!  This is not about you, this is about what he is doing and the choices he has made.  This is about you having no self worth or respect for yourself to even consider taking a man who has no morals and character.  He doesn't need to make a decision, you do.  He is cheating on you, lies to you and puts the blame on you.  What are you missing??   He wants you to get your act together??????  What about him?  If he truly loved you and wants to be with you then he would dump his girlfriend of 2 years and start working on your relationship.  The problem is that he doesn't want to !!!!!  He's moved on whether he knows it or not and just forgot to tell you.  He's giving you 6 months???  What the hell is that!!! 

I know this is hard - please find a therapist today to help you deal with your emotions and getting through this.  And you will get through this and realize that this guy isn't worth it.  You can't make him come home nor can you stop him from having his freedom - the only person you can control is you.  Call him and tell him to come pick up his bags- He's got 24 hours to do it or they go into the garbage!.  Get child support settled via the courts, see a therapist for emotional support and start healing.  Start exercising is this weight bothers you as well, but do it for you! 

 
First | Prev | 270 | 271 | 272 | 273 | 274 | 275 | 276 | 277 | 278 | 279 | Next | Last