Message Boards

Topic : Breaking Up

Number of Replies: 5468
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:06:14 pm
Author : dataimport
Is it time to end things with your significant other? Or, have you just been handed a relationship pink slip? Share your stories.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
November 28, 2006, 7:20 pm PST

You can't worry about him..

Quote From: aba1969

Hi all,

 

My ex common law husband for 4 years and me had a 6 yrs. old daughter.  During those time of separation, we were off and on until last time was December 2004.  He had dated here and there and had a girlfriend in 2004 but only lasts 5 months.  He introduced our daughter to this girl only once.  After that girl, he dated another one that only lasts 3 months.  He came back to me and got back together again but only lasts for not even 2 weeks.  After a month he started seeing a new girl and already started exposing our daughter to her.  They are still together and both been spending time with my daughter sometime every other weekend when my daughter is with him. I overheard on his voice mail messages that this girl is already saying I love you to him.  I know it is not illegal for him to expose my daughter to her..but it's making me really angry.  I wanted to know this girl so I know who my daughter is spending time with when she is with her dad but he would not introduce her to me.  He already introduce her to her family but not to me.  Am I entitled to know or for him to introduce to me to his girlfriend or is this out of my business? 

He will not put HIS daughter in dangers. You don't have to meet the female he is with. If he lets you meet her, good, but he won't. You cannot stress yourself about something you cannot change. Can you stop him from dating other woman? Can you stop him from introducing HIS daughter to woman? No. Move on. Focus on your daughter. Keep raising your daughter to be a wonderful, respectful, confident and smart young girl. Men are different from women. What have you been doing from 2004 until now? Are you dating? If you are, did your daughter meet your date? Find a hobby, read a book, go to dinner with a friend, go to the movies. Life is to short to be stressed out. If you believe in God, pray. Leave it in God's hand.
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
November 28, 2006, 7:22 pm PST

Breaking Up

Quote From: sherisekr

I am a  female who was engaged to male. We were together for a total of 8 months. He cheated on me and I broke up with him. We are back together. We were apart for seven months. He dated other girls and I dated other guys. We are back together. I'm scared that he will hurt me again. What should I do?

Run- RUN LIKE HELL-- a relationship for the most part should not be questioned all the time. IT should have everthing to do with trust and that is gone- Once a cheater always a cheater....
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 28, 2006, 7:36 pm PST

I CAN RELATE!!!

Quote From: keepgoing

Hello everyone-

I have not wrote in over 8 months and now I feel like I may need some support. I did very well with not calling my ex and staying away from him for every reason known to man.

 

To make a long story short- We met and fell in love- he fell out after 7 months and we stopped being intamite and pretty much went to dating- he said he wanted to take it slow and I put up with a morning phone call and seeing him maybe 1 night a weekend. I finally had enough and just walked away from him. He didn't call me and I didn't call him. It still makes me sick to think that I wasted almost 2 years being absolutly miserable.

 

Anyway back to the reason I am writing again.

 

He called me on Sunday and I have not talked to him in 8 months and I was instantly shaking when I answered the phone. He went on to say that he called my house all through these months but called PRIVATE and asked me how I could just walk away from him. He asked me if we could start dating again and I told him NO.

 

I have been very strong and now I am not feeling that anymore. I am glad I told him no- BUT I never got any questions answered and there still is no closure.

 

I was dumb and called him on that next Tuesday ( i left a message) and of course he didn't call me until Wednesday (he left a message I wasn't home until real late that night)  (one thing he was great for) he had an excuse pretty good one but none the less an excuse. I didn't call him back until the next Monday and left a message on his answering machine and guess what it is Tuesday and no returned phone call- I guess I am being punished for waiting 5 days by not calling him back.

 

I just don't see myself doing all this again. I couldn't sleep last night b/c all I could do was think and that has been a long time since those days have haunted me. I told him it was ok to call me so I put myself right back there and now I just want to tell him that I wish he would not have called and not to call again.

 

He said that he didn't want to hurt me and he misses me so much and that he had alot of time to think and I have too --I have become a different person but now I feel like I may have told a fib because I feel like I took a thousand steps back from  the healing process.

 

I feel like I am never going to find what I had with him in the beginning of our relationship. We were great and I am not sure what  changed and after all this time he still can't tell me what happened.

 

How do I just let him completely go? I know don't answer the phone but we all know that we will. I know I will never call him again. But know I am waiting for him to call back and I feel so stupid all over again that I let him BS me 2 times now. What am I to do? Oh yeah he is 37- never married and his longest relationship was 2 years and I was 1 year and 8 months- so I was the second longest. He has commitment issues and I don't know why I still love him and can't stop thinking if I made a mistake by not seeing him again. I know it took alot to call me but I left him alone why couldn't he do that for me if he really cares?

My ex in I broke up in April 2006. I did not talk to him for 7months. He called me private and I wouldn't answer the phone. I knew it was him. Just recently, I called him and left a message on his phone. I called to tell him that I forgive him and to wish him a safe trip to Iraq. He called me back the next day and we have been together since. I can't believe we are together again. He can't believe I took him back. He thought he would never see me again. I thought I would never see him again. Enough about me...

 

Your ex should have called you back. Maybe he is still upset with you. When he asked you to get back with him, you said NO!. Men don't like rejection. They don't know how to handle rejection. I hope he is not playing games. He is too old for that. He still wants to be with you. Don't call him, he will call you. I know...I didn't call my ex for 7 months. He called me and text me monthly. 2months before I called him, he stopped calling. He said, he had to accept that he lost his one and only love.

 

Be patient. He will call. You need to figure out what you are going to say when he calls. You will be caught off guard when he call. Try to prepare yourself for his call. If you don't think it will work, then don't waste your time AGAIN. Your TIME is very precious!!!!

 

Goodluck!

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
November 29, 2006, 12:33 am PST

So much to say

Quote From: sandy0914

I have a lot of advice for you but I have a few questions.

 

 

What did he go to jail for?

How much was he drinking & doing drugs?

Do you do drugs as well?

 

 

Well he is a three time felon, I know that sounds terrible, he broke a beer bottle on his ex's head in june, she attacked him.  She's crazy so I understand where he's coming from.  He was drinking alot before he went to jail.  Probably 5 times a week if we had the money.  He was doing alot of pills and stuff.  But when he went to jail he promised to change.  Well when he got out he was doing okay for a week till I told him what happened when he went to jail.  Then he slowely started drinking.  As far as I know all he does is smoke pot, which isn't so bad compared to what he used to do.  It's been 3 days since I've heard from him now.  I was thinking about it today, and I think I'm in love with the man I think he can be and not the man he is today.  You understand what I mean.  I want him back but not as he is today.  I'm not sure if I sure throw everything away.  My life will probably be miserable with him, but I really do care for him.  Is this one of those situations where I should just love him from far away.  As of the question do I do drugs.  Not anymore. And I think this may have alot to do with why we don't get along like we used to.  When he went to jail I decided to straighten myself out.  ITs been 5 months, I just don't understand if I can do it why can't he.  We got along okay partying, but I want to amount to sumething.  Maybe he is dragging me down.  I just don't know what to do anymore.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 29, 2006, 5:37 am PST

real love

Quote From: keepgoing

Hello everyone-

I have not wrote in over 8 months and now I feel like I may need some support. I did very well with not calling my ex and staying away from him for every reason known to man.

 

To make a long story short- We met and fell in love- he fell out after 7 months and we stopped being intamite and pretty much went to dating- he said he wanted to take it slow and I put up with a morning phone call and seeing him maybe 1 night a weekend. I finally had enough and just walked away from him. He didn't call me and I didn't call him. It still makes me sick to think that I wasted almost 2 years being absolutly miserable.

 

Anyway back to the reason I am writing again.

 

He called me on Sunday and I have not talked to him in 8 months and I was instantly shaking when I answered the phone. He went on to say that he called my house all through these months but called PRIVATE and asked me how I could just walk away from him. He asked me if we could start dating again and I told him NO.

 

I have been very strong and now I am not feeling that anymore. I am glad I told him no- BUT I never got any questions answered and there still is no closure.

 

I was dumb and called him on that next Tuesday ( i left a message) and of course he didn't call me until Wednesday (he left a message I wasn't home until real late that night)  (one thing he was great for) he had an excuse pretty good one but none the less an excuse. I didn't call him back until the next Monday and left a message on his answering machine and guess what it is Tuesday and no returned phone call- I guess I am being punished for waiting 5 days by not calling him back.

 

I just don't see myself doing all this again. I couldn't sleep last night b/c all I could do was think and that has been a long time since those days have haunted me. I told him it was ok to call me so I put myself right back there and now I just want to tell him that I wish he would not have called and not to call again.

 

He said that he didn't want to hurt me and he misses me so much and that he had alot of time to think and I have too --I have become a different person but now I feel like I may have told a fib because I feel like I took a thousand steps back from  the healing process.

 

I feel like I am never going to find what I had with him in the beginning of our relationship. We were great and I am not sure what  changed and after all this time he still can't tell me what happened.

 

How do I just let him completely go? I know don't answer the phone but we all know that we will. I know I will never call him again. But know I am waiting for him to call back and I feel so stupid all over again that I let him BS me 2 times now. What am I to do? Oh yeah he is 37- never married and his longest relationship was 2 years and I was 1 year and 8 months- so I was the second longest. He has commitment issues and I don't know why I still love him and can't stop thinking if I made a mistake by not seeing him again. I know it took alot to call me but I left him alone why couldn't he do that for me if he really cares?

You wonder why he can’t just leave you alone if he really loves you- the answer is because he doesn’t know what true love is, he doesn’t know what he wants, BUT, you know what you want- and that is to not be involved in his confusion any more!
You said you regret wasting almost 2 years of your life. The only thing you can do is make a resolution with yourself to learn from this relationship and move forward. There are many reasons why your relationship was great for the first few months- one reason is because that is the ‘honeymoon’ period, where people are on their best behaviors, trying to impress one another, etc. Then, the ‘true colors’ begin to show, and it sounds like you tolerated mistreatment/disrespect for too long. You don’t deserve to do that again. I can understand that you feel he has given you no closure, but it is doubtful that he will ever do that, it is up to you to find that closure for yourself, to take comfort in the knowledge that you already wasted enough time, and the next worst thing you could do is to waste eveyr more time on this relationship.
 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
sad
November 29, 2006, 8:38 am PST

Am I being selfish?

So I thought I would write to get some advice. I really need to know if I'm making a big deal of something that might be nothing..

Here's the situation. My boyfriend and I have been together for 3 years. I live on my own ( just recent) and he lives with his parents. We got engaged a year ago but I called of the engagement when I found him chatting on-line with some other girl  ( which it wasn't the first time) at that point we took a break from the relationship but came back together shortly there after. Things were going good until our 3 year anniversary came up and he didn't show up at my house until 3 am. Was not impressed.. I came to find out a couple days later, through going into one of his e-mail accounts, that he had been out on a date with another girl!!! Most people would have broken up on the spot but not me.. I always think that if you don't work on a relationship it will never work.. He promised that I was the girl that he wants to be with no one else.. He had broken it off Whit the other girl that night, nothing happened between them but a kiss.. that kinda stuff.. I'm finding it hard to trust him again. So here is the thing that I need some advice on.. Yesterday he told me that he will be working New Years so i won't be able to see him.. He has Christmas off but does not want to spend time with me because I will be going to see my family and he doesn't get along with my mom or my brother ( very long story). Am I being selfish for wanting him to spend Christmas with me at my family's house knowing that he doesn't want to go?  Or should he make the effort because he loves me and wants to spend time with me?

HELP!

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
November 29, 2006, 1:07 pm PST

We got back together Please help

I broke up with my boyfriend of a year and a half on two different occasions, not only because we have our differences but the fact that i wasnt happy nor was i making him happy. I came back begging for him after 2 weeks because i was and still am miserable without him. He means the world to me. I found out that during our break up that he fell hard for someone else. It breaks my heart even though i trust him that he wont act up on it knowing that me and him are together. Ive been begging for him back and finally agreed to get back together last night. He keeps telling me hes happy that were back together and i know im being like a patrol hound and hanging off of his neck asking him ALL the time .. are you happy? do you love me a lot? will you defend me? the defending part comes from the fact that his friends.. whom USED to be my bestfriends basically screwed me over so we dont speak anymore. And i told my boyfriend in a mature matter that You should defend me if they say anything about me or if im out with you and they try to pull you away from me to defend that fact that im there. When i brought that up to him he said oh so if i defend you ill lose them then . I dont care that hes friends with them i just want to know that hes happy i want to know that he feels just as strong for me as i do. I want him to be happy and i want to stop feeling upset. I am just scared. Please give me some advice on what i should do .. Thank You :)
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
November 29, 2006, 4:26 pm PST

Wow

Quote From: sherisekr

My ex in I broke up in April 2006. I did not talk to him for 7months. He called me private and I wouldn't answer the phone. I knew it was him. Just recently, I called him and left a message on his phone. I called to tell him that I forgive him and to wish him a safe trip to Iraq. He called me back the next day and we have been together since. I can't believe we are together again. He can't believe I took him back. He thought he would never see me again. I thought I would never see him again. Enough about me...

 

Your ex should have called you back. Maybe he is still upset with you. When he asked you to get back with him, you said NO!. Men don't like rejection. They don't know how to handle rejection. I hope he is not playing games. He is too old for that. He still wants to be with you. Don't call him, he will call you. I know...I didn't call my ex for 7 months. He called me and text me monthly. 2months before I called him, he stopped calling. He said, he had to accept that he lost his one and only love.

 

Be patient. He will call. You need to figure out what you are going to say when he calls. You will be caught off guard when he call. Try to prepare yourself for his call. If you don't think it will work, then don't waste your time AGAIN. Your TIME is very precious!!!!

 

Goodluck!

Wow we are pretty similar with our stories. Is he in Iraq now? I mean you said that you were back together- but did he leave?

 

My ex is a really nice guy and I love him and miss him alot but he plays to many head games and it was alot of crap to go through and people don't change all that much.

 

There was no cheating just an emotional roller coaster and I had to get off.. How are things now do you feel like you are in control now?

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
November 29, 2006, 4:38 pm PST

Thanks

Quote From: jaimie1974

You wonder why he cant just leave you alone if he really loves you- the answer is because he doesnt know what true love is, he doesnt know what he wants, BUT, you know what you want- and that is to not be involved in his confusion any more!
You said you regret wasting almost 2 years of your life. The only thing you can do is make a resolution with yourself to learn from this relationship and move forward. There are many reasons why your relationship was great for the first few months- one reason is because that is the honeymoon period, where people are on their best behaviors, trying to impress one another, etc. Then, the true colors begin to show, and it sounds like you tolerated mistreatment/disrespect for too long. You dont deserve to do that again. I can understand that you feel he has given you no closure, but it is doubtful that he will ever do that, it is up to you to find that closure for yourself, to take comfort in the knowledge that you already wasted enough time, and the next worst thing you could do is to waste eveyr more time on this relationship.
Thank you I know deep down that I know all the wise stuff you said. I don't deserve that and I am just sad that he called and it has been back and forth again and it was only a few times. I have really been good and if you knew what I was like for those 13 months you wouldn't believe that I would have been that strong- the problem was I would never tell him how I felt. He is just and idiot sometimes. I know that I need to stay away from him- FAR AWAY. Thank you though I think I need more advice through the next days to come because it really is hard to stay  away when you know that they still have feelings- why is it so much easier when you think that they don't care about you anymore.
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
November 29, 2006, 4:46 pm PST

Confused in Michigan

I am reposting this message in the hopes of getting some advice about my situation....

 

I have been in a relationship with a 37 year old woman for the past three years. I am 44 years old. We both are divorced in the past three years. We both each have two children from our previous marriages ages 6 thru 11. We have known each other for 25 years as she grew up across the street from my parents. My parents and her parents were good friends. She is an academic with a bachelors and two masters degrees.  I am working on completing my bachelors degree.

 

For the past three years we have built a very stable and functional relationship in my opinion. Our children have also developed a strong relationship with each other. My girl friend has a huge heart and is always taking on extra activities and often finds herself overloaded. She is very strong willed and uncompromising. She just finished up her last masters degree for which she was attending school for the entire time we have been together. She has never held a job as she was a house wife for 15 years in her previous marriage. She comes from a broken family that went totally dysfunction shortly after the divorce of here parents.

 

My issue is the she came to me a week ago and said that she could no longer continue our relationship and that she would like to remain friends. She insists that this is not my fault and that it has nothing to do with me.This naturally devastated me. I love her very much and I do not want to walk away from what we have together. I believe that the reason she is doing this is due to the other demands and stresses in her life right now.She has explained to me that she is not happy with things in her life right now and because of this she cannot be happy or make me happy. She also told me that she has decided that she is not relationship material due to her compulsive controlling nature. Naturally I disagree, these issues have never been a problem in our relationship. One time in the last two months she made a condescending remark to me and I immediately called her on it and told her that it hurt my feelings. She apologized and I forgot about it. It seems that she did not and has taken that as a sign that I do not like certain aspects of her personality. We have always been very open and honest with each other from the beginning and our communication has always been wonderful until the last two months.

 

I want to remain friends and give her some space. She absolutely refuses to talk to me about this and tells me that it is not fair to me to see her and talk to her due to my deep feelings for her. I just want her to open up and talk to me. I do not expect to be able to fix her but i feel if she talks about her feeling with me it might help her work through the issues. I even offered counseling and she flatly refused and told that I should just accept the fact that she does not want to see me.

 

 

What should I do? I love her and i do not want to loose her.

 
First | Prev | 286 | 287 | 288 | 289 | 290 | 291 | 292 | 293 | 294 | 295 | Next | Last