Message Boards

Topic : Breaking Up

Number of Replies: 5468
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:06:14 pm
Author : dataimport
Is it time to end things with your significant other? Or, have you just been handed a relationship pink slip? Share your stories.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
giddy
September 16, 2007, 4:04 pm PDT

It is hard but keep your chin up

Quote From: merumsal

 Hi there.

I'm a 43yo divorced mother of three (27,22,16) and am currently in a 3 1/2 year relationship with the view to marriage.  We do not live together - I live with my elderly father and the youngest two of my children.

We've had a few problems in the last few months which have been based on my feeling that the man in my life has become distant - showing little affection, no interest in sex and not wanting to talk about what may be happening to have brought this on.

We decided to set aside a month where we limited the time we spent together, to allow for a little "space" to try and work out our feelings etc. (we normally spend a lot of time with eachother during the day as we work together in his homebased business). 

The whole idea was that, we spend time apart regrouping our lives and have certain times where we would hang out as a couple, kind of like dating, and talk about what we had been doing (in regard to the regrouping).

After three weeks I called quits to what we were doing because within that time he became even more distant (not wanting to spend any intimate time together at all) and only wanting to meet for a "coffee" and was guarded in talking about "how things were going" for him.

I found it extremely difficult feeling so emotionally and intimately shut out of his life in this way.  I became very tense and guarded on our last "coffee" meeting and I could see that he was becoming frustated at my behaviour so I sugested we go somewhere more private to talk. 

We talked and through his frustatration he said that he hadn't had time to think about "us" much and he  wasn't even sure he wanted to be in a relationship with me anyway.  I was stunned at hearing that.  I walked out on him because I didn't quite know what to say and I didn't want to say anything I would be sorry for later.

I didn't hear from him for a week so I decided that I would go to see him and talk things through to either end the relationship or decide whether we were going to work through this patch.

We talked for hours.  We talked about working together on being together - it was really wonderful to be relating at such a deep level again.

Today we talked again and he told me that his problem has been that he won't marry my while I still have my children living with me.  He doesn't have children of his own and would find it difficult living with me and my family because so much of what happens in "that" household goes against his value system.

Once again, I'm absolutely stunned.  We (my children and I) live in what I would call an almost boringly typical parent/child existence.   He's never spoken of this before and when we talked about "working things out together" I imagined that part of that would have taken in blending our family (well, my children, him and me).

He wants to keep our relationship going with the view to marry when my brood have all flown the coup. 

I understand the difficulties of second marriages with children involved, that's why we didn't rush in to marriage in the first place.  We had talked about allowing everybody to get to know eachother slowly to give everyone time to become accustomed to "us"; to build on our relationship during this time and our future (hence working together).

At the moment I find his "offer" unacceptable and I'm quite cranky about the whole thing. 

I'm wondering whether I'm just being altogether too emotional, maybe his suggestion is the most logical one and maybe I'm simply taking his rejection of my children all too personally.

I don't know.

If anyone can think of any questions that maybe I should be asking myself - I'd be more than grateful if you would share them because I'm feeling just a little too lost in the forest to think of any right now.

Cheers!

Speaking as a man first time post.....Can I begin by saying, the other person is right.  If this guy can't accept now what you’re trying to do, get on with it, leave him and because there is a lot more to life and who knows you may meet someone WHO does care for your children, and you!

 

"I'm wondering whether I'm just being altogether too emotional, maybe his suggestion is the most logical one and maybe I'm simply taking his rejection of my children all too personally."

 

Your not. I find we men need a wake up call sometimes and if this guy hasn't woken up and smelt the roses, move over....Your reaction is totally normal and believe me it's not you. He is manipulating your kindness and the children and trying to make his word law. ‘Bugger that mate,’ we say here in New Zealand. Even though I'm a guy I would appreciate what little or all if I had a partner that sounds half as endearing and trying as you are.

 

Getting on or moving on is the question. Can you?

Finally; "If anyone can think of any questions that maybe I should be asking myself - I'd be more than grateful if you would share them because I'm feeling just a little too lost in the forest to think of any right now."

 

The only question to ask is of you.

·          Do I need this guy?

·          Does he love me and MY children?

·          Is he playing me for sex and whatever...? 

 

I’m sure your mentally struggling with this and have already said these over and over to yourself. Time to act on it. We men are as I said, not able to discern sometimes the beauty that we should sacrifice. My question is, and this is you, "if I loved you and say my children did leave but for some reason needed me, wanted to come back home, how would you be able to handle this?"

 

I personally think this guy is selfish and taking HIMSELF into consideration while making out YOU need him. NAh, it’s the other way around. You go for it girl. Get him OUT of there and start to believe in yourself and your kids.

 

Regards

The Kiwiguy

 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 12:59 pm PDT

This is not so difficult a decision really......

Quote From: alysha1221

Let's see, where do I start?  I was dating this guy we'll call "John".  And after a while we finally thought we'd take our relationship to the next level and he proposed.  Things were going GREAT, until he found out about something I had lied about in the past.  I explained why I had done so and apologized.  He was fine with that, but after a while things went bad.  We started arguing over stupid pety things.  Our engagment ended horribly after his mother died four months ago.  Her death was hard on both of us and when he blamed it on me, I couldn't even look at him.  He kept constantly calling me.  It got to the point when it was 13-18 times in a row before he would finally leave a message.  I had to change my phone number.  I am over him now.  And I thought I had finally found a nice guy for ONCE in my life, when he tells me that he is completely anti-girlfriend and completely against relationships.  My relationship with this man isn't anything more then a "friendship with benefits".  I go over to his apartment every once in a while and talk for about 20 minutes at the most with him and a few of his friends that are now friends of mine.  Then we go to his room and have sex.  Then I go home.  And for a while it wasn't much more than that until I finally had the nerve to ask him what I meant to him.  He went on to explain certain things about how he had been hurt too many times by women.  But he says, "I care about you more than the other girls."  Girls?  I finally realized that I wasn't the only one dating this guy.  But I know for sure I'm the only one he's sleeping with.  I just don't know what to do about this situation.  I'm not sure if I should stop seeing him or just keep doing what we're doing.

1. Do you have an "overall" feeling of happiness about the situation?

 

2.  Would you be happy with things staying the way they are for the next 2,5, or 10 years?  If not, break it off because he is not saying there is any possiblity of anything more. 

 

3.  Would it bother you to know that he was sleeping with other girls?  If so, you need to end the relationship, because sooner or later he's going to (if he won't commit, then he will play the field).   If not, go ahead and keep seeing him.  The minute you decide that it bothers you.....you know what to do.  Good luck. 

 

P.S. Just don't get pregnant and use condoms every time.  If you use them every time you will never have regrets later in life about not using protection......

 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 1:13 pm PDT

The answer is ....time

Quote From: jennnny_

I dated this guy for a while, and we were very serious in our relationship, and we spent almost every day with eachother and such.

We had a bad break-up, and it lasted for about two months.  It's kind of complicated, but we broke up because a situation that happened between his mom and I, but we still talked and hung out.  It was like "friends with benefits" pretty much, but I didn't want to say we were going out,  because I wanted to wait until the whole thing with his mom blew over, you know?  So, anyway, he finds out that this one girl I hung out with a few times, and knew very well, liked him.  So, they started liking eachother, but he would still hang out with me.  Let's just say he was very confused, and he didn't know what he wanted.  Well, in the end, I finally got the hint that there is only one way to stop this, so I stopped talking to him completely.  And I haven't talked to him since.. that was about three weeks ago.

 

But I am still not over him!  I always think about him, and just the thought of him being happier with HER gets me everytime.  I just need some help getting over him, because eveything I try, never works!

 

 

 

It really is hard to get over these things isn't it?  The only answer I have is.....time......

 

Not really what you wanted to hear right?  There is no miracle cure for getting over a relationship that you didn't want to see end.  Spend time with family, friends, work, school, hobbies....Keep busy.  You never know who you might meet next.....maybe you will be happier than you were with him.

 

Good Luck and remember to always use protection every time.  If you use it every time you will not have regrets later in life.  Who you are now may not be who you will be in the future.  People change.

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 1:31 pm PDT

Two people loving each other may not be enough

Quote From: smiley66

I recently had a similar situation.  My boyfriend broke up with me, but continued to call, email, and text message me. I couldn't understand, why if he broke up with me he would keep reaching out to me. We went to counseling - just one session - and decided to get back together. It has been a roller coaster of emotions. I love him completely and I know he loves me, but I was so scared of getting hurt that I did not invest 100% of myself to him. It's been 2 months since we got back together and I'm slowly coming around.  I just try to concentrate on the here and now and not overthink too much. If everything else is good and he makes you feel loved and appreciated and if he realizes he made a mistake the first time, then let it go. All relationships run the risk of failing and you always are putting yourself out there to get hurt, but without risk, there's no reward!

This works for me...... access the overall relationship.....how do you feel about it "overall", like 90% of the time?  Does it feel positive with a few rough patches once in a while.  Dig deep and think about it.  Don't disect it by saying that this piece is good and the other piece is bad, but I like this about him.......just an overall feeling and summarize it as "yes its good" or "no not really".......what is it?  You know what to do from there.

 

PS Don't forget to use protection every time, its so important. No regrets!

 

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 1:39 pm PDT

Need Advice...

I'm a 27 year old man and I've been dating my girlfriend for a little over a year. We've known each other for 5 years. She is amazing in so many ways, she is everything I ever hoped for in a partner. She is sweet, considerate, intelligent, and has a huge heart. The problem is that she has always wanted to have kids, lots of them. I really don't want children, never have. This has started to cause problems in our relationship and it seems like breaking up is the only solution.

 

I love her and wish we could have a future together but I don't want to live a life I don't want either. If I give in to what she wants I'm afraid I would ultimately resent her and the kids.

 

Any thoughts?

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 2:17 pm PDT

I'm with you.............

Quote From: canadianguy

I'm a 27 year old man and I've been dating my girlfriend for a little over a year. We've known each other for 5 years. She is amazing in so many ways, she is everything I ever hoped for in a partner. She is sweet, considerate, intelligent, and has a huge heart. The problem is that she has always wanted to have kids, lots of them. I really don't want children, never have. This has started to cause problems in our relationship and it seems like breaking up is the only solution.

 

I love her and wish we could have a future together but I don't want to live a life I don't want either. If I give in to what she wants I'm afraid I would ultimately resent her and the kids.

 

Any thoughts?

I don't want children either and the thought of having them to please someone else instantly makes me resentful.  Of course I am a female, so its a bit different.  This would not be a difficult decision for me since I really, really do not like children.

 

Everyone says that its totally different when the childern are your own............  think I'll just take their word for it ....don't plan to find out if its true.

 

Perhaps you two should have discussed this 5 years ago????

 

Sounds like you run the risk of suffering either way.  If it were me, I would take the shorter road.........18 years to be unhappy is a long time.  Hope this helps. 

 

 

 

 

 

 
User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
September 17, 2007, 7:58 pm PDT

Not over him yet

Hello,

 

I'm a twenty-something single student who fell in love once with a guy. We had a serious 1 1/2 year relationship and then I dumped him because I wanted to have new adventures and find someone more suitable for me. I was bored and frustrated by a lack of passion and communication. Even though I initiated the break up, he agreed but wanted to stay friends. This was 2 years ago and I'm still not over him. I thought I was at the time, but I think about him practically everyday. I cut communication with him completely and even blocked him from my e-mail in fear that I will become emotional. I attempted to re-connect only to find out he fell in love with someone else.

I think about e-mailing him a lot and fantasize about bumping into him on the street but never do. I just need to calm my mind and get over him! I haven't felt anything but innocent infatuation for anyone else. Should I try re-connecting again just so I can see why I broke up with him in the first place. To have peace of mind and tell him all my great accomplishments that I have achieved in the past 2 years? It's just to be able to talk to him, as a friend.

 

I am afraid of how I would feel but at the same time I just need to re-connect with this person I shared so much with and who I now totally blocked off.

 

What should I do?

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
September 18, 2007, 12:08 pm PDT

What would you do????Please Advise!!!

I have been with the same man for over 5 years.

Last Friday I found 122 riske/sexy photos of a co-worker on his work email folder inbox from 3 weeks ago.

I have confronted him and called her and told her husband about it. She is married.

I am looking for some opinions and advise on what others would do given this situation.

 

Thanks in advance

 

Devastated mntkagirl

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
September 19, 2007, 2:50 am PDT

Let him be

Quote From: lauren_colver

Hello,

 

I'm a twenty-something single student who fell in love once with a guy. We had a serious 1 1/2 year relationship and then I dumped him because I wanted to have new adventures and find someone more suitable for me. I was bored and frustrated by a lack of passion and communication. Even though I initiated the break up, he agreed but wanted to stay friends. This was 2 years ago and I'm still not over him. I thought I was at the time, but I think about him practically everyday. I cut communication with him completely and even blocked him from my e-mail in fear that I will become emotional. I attempted to re-connect only to find out he fell in love with someone else.

I think about e-mailing him a lot and fantasize about bumping into him on the street but never do. I just need to calm my mind and get over him! I haven't felt anything but innocent infatuation for anyone else. Should I try re-connecting again just so I can see why I broke up with him in the first place. To have peace of mind and tell him all my great accomplishments that I have achieved in the past 2 years? It's just to be able to talk to him, as a friend.

 

I am afraid of how I would feel but at the same time I just need to re-connect with this person I shared so much with and who I now totally blocked off.

 

What should I do?

He has moved on with his life and is happy and in love with someone else.  To contact him I think would be a selfish gesture on your part considering how you may still feel about him. Your motives for contacting him seem to have a hint of wanting him back.  Why complicate his life?   You two broke up because you were bored and frustrated due to a lack of passion and communication.  End of story. Be happy for him from a distance and move on with your life and let him be. 
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
September 19, 2007, 3:00 am PDT

There is only 1 solution.

Quote From: canadianguy

I'm a 27 year old man and I've been dating my girlfriend for a little over a year. We've known each other for 5 years. She is amazing in so many ways, she is everything I ever hoped for in a partner. She is sweet, considerate, intelligent, and has a huge heart. The problem is that she has always wanted to have kids, lots of them. I really don't want children, never have. This has started to cause problems in our relationship and it seems like breaking up is the only solution.

 

I love her and wish we could have a future together but I don't want to live a life I don't want either. If I give in to what she wants I'm afraid I would ultimately resent her and the kids.

 

Any thoughts?

You two have different dreams, she wants children and you don't.  There is no compromise available, it is black and white.  Anotherwords you can't have a child and give it back because it is not what you wanted a year down the road.    I do not see any soluton to your problem other than to break up and allow eachother to fulfill your own dreams separately. 
 
First | Prev | 412 | 413 | 414 | 415 | 416 | 417 | 418 | 419 | 420 | 421 | Next | Last