Message Boards

Topic : Breaking Up

Number of Replies: 5468
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:06:14 pm
Author : dataimport
Is it time to end things with your significant other? Or, have you just been handed a relationship pink slip? Share your stories.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 7, 2005, 6:56 pm PDT

Canada

Quote From: mikkic

My ex has blamed me for numerous problems in our relationship.  I understand how you feel.  My thoughts on this are as follows: 

  

There are two people in a relationship and if he blames you for all the wrongs he is not worth crying over.  I totally understand that you want to do everything in your power to fix this situation, but until he understands that it takes two to tango, that will never happen.  I have three children as well and I am finding it extremely difficult to "move on", but I am trying.  Letting go is something that is unattainable.  I still have feelings from high school relationships.  What you need to do is think of things that you want and things that would make you happy and start there.  Obviously if he is making you "crazy" and "foolish" that is not making you happy.  Take some time for you and figure out what it is that you want.  If you project happiness and content in your own life, then everything will fall into place, either with or without him. 

  

This is just my opinion, hope it helps you. 

Please feel free to E-Mail at GloriaJNavarro@aol.com if you want to talk.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 7, 2005, 7:00 pm PDT

MIKKIC

Quote From: mikkic

My boyfriend of 7.5 years and I recently separated.  We now live in separate towns about 4 hours apart.  I have three children from a previous marriage and they have all come to know him as their step dad and love him very much.  It is now October/05 and we split up in May /05.  We still speak on the phone about once or twice every couple of weeks.  I can tell that he loves me by the way he looks at me, but that is an irrelevant point.  He has come to visit me three times since the split and each time, he acts like we are still where we were.  I agreed with the breakup because I knew we needed some space to figure out what we both want, but I did not expect to be so conflicted with my feelings.  I love him still, but I know that it would not work out in anyone's best interests to try again.  We have a spectacular sex life, we get along amazingly well, we are best of friends, we can go out just the two of us and have a great time.  Problem areas in our relationship:  Money.  We do not agree on money whatsoever and that is what has come between us.  I am only 33 years old, but dating is a scary concept for me.  I am unsure where to even begin and I don't want to make the same mistakes ever again.  I want to be with someone who understands me and works with me for a better tomorrow.  Is there even hope of moving on??  Where do I begin???  My youngest child is 10 and my oldest is almost 15.  How do you set an example for your children without denying your own personal needs.
I left a message for you with my e-mail I hope you get it if not here it is again GloriaJNavarro@aol.com Your opinion is valued more then you know. Thank you. I addressed the answer to CANADA . Sorry for the mix up. Gloria
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 8, 2005, 7:08 am PDT

problem with his female friends

i am a 40 yr old divorced woman (married 18 yrs) with 2 grown children one still living at home. i have been dating a 43 year old man with no children who has never been married. he is a good guy  who has old fashioned values and has lived the single lifestyle almost all of his life. he has  been in 2 or so long term relationships in which he tells me they have cheated on  him. he has a m.s. (multiple sclerosis) but this was not an issue for me. my problem is that he has alot of single female friends that he enjoys spending time with. this has been an issue from the start of the relationship....8 months now. we were at a point in our relationship where he was hinting of moving in together...but this issue has not been resolved. he has lied to me about seeing them in the past. he says they are just friends....i asked him not to spend time alone with them unless i am there and we see them as a couple....he has a major issue with this so much so it has destroyed our relationship.his response always is (what am i supposed to tell them? i cant see them because you dont like it?)  he has alot of couple friends that i really like alot and a good amt. of male friends...but he tends to drift back to these women...all who he says have boyfriends who "trust him" and dont have issues with it. (one did as he slipped and mentioned the boyfriend was "insecure" about it at one point but is ok now with it.)  i told him that i could not deal with it as if he knows how i feel about it and continues to do it...that my feeling was that he is more willing to hurt my feelings than theirs.  i told him if they were true friends they would understand....he tells me he has discussed this with them and they dont understand me.....i told him they have been single all thier lives.......they never will. my question is.....am i kidding myself that this is going to work? and am i wrong to believe that he shouldnt be spending time alone with these women when he is in a committed relationship?        would appreciate all views.........thanks.........luv2ski215
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 8, 2005, 1:11 pm PDT

ex boyfriend avoids me completely

Hi everyone, 

I'm new to the board here.  Very nice how everyone gives support to each other. 

My question may be odd.  I recently broke-up with a man I was dating for 5 months. 

Unfortunately, the words I used were not kind.  I said what I felt but it was mean.  For example, I said you bring me down, and gosh this is hard to admit, but I said to him," You are the biggest mistake I've made. "  The reason I broke-up is because I felt he did not treat me well.  He called back after I said these things and said," I'm sorry I hurt your feelings, and that I'm not the man you want me to be." Anyhow, we have not seen each other for almost 4 weeks.  I ran into him at a public place we both frequently go too, and he completely avoided me.  He would not make any eye contact even when I said hello.  He actually looked down when he said hello back.  I was with a guy friend.  My girlfriends said after me and my friend left, he walked away from the group hand folded, looking down at the ground and looking sideways as he watched me and my friend walk away.  They said he was rubbing one foot in the ground.  My question is this, do you think he is upset or angry? 

Just did not expext him to avoid me in such an obvious way.  Has anyone ever experienced someone avoiding them in such a manner?  And, why do you think he is?  Mind you, the reason I did break-up was I felt he did not care for me, and did not treat me well. 

  

Please, any feedback will greatly be appreciated.  

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
confused
October 9, 2005, 10:31 pm PDT

Breaking Up

me and my ec-boyfriend just got back together and i was really happy to get him back and all but nothing is the same and he doesnt say he loves me or calls me hunny like before. i realy dont know what to do anymore....and plus im pregnant with his kid...he thinks i had an abortion but i cant do it and i really dont know what to do anymore 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 3:16 pm PDT

HELP!

Anybody who can help me, I would appreciate it so much!  (Im 19 yrs. old, by the way) 

  

Okay. Basically, Im thinking about breaking up with my boyfriend. He is driving me absolutely insane, and he has gotten to the point where he is emotionally abusive to me. He doesnt trust me whatsoever (but I've never given him a reason not to) and he's always asking me who Im trying to "impress" whenever I look nice. He throws a fit whenever I dress up nice and he isnt there. He doesnt want me to wear makeup, and questions me when I do. None of my friends like him, and he is always talking badly about them. He gets an attitude if I go out with my FEMALE friends, even if its just out to eat or to go shopping. He questions me about the tiniest little details, and I feel like I cant take it anymore. He has become physically abusive on some level.. once I said something under my breath, and he asked me what I said, and he slapped me on the back repeatedly until I told him what it was, even after I told him to stop because it was hurting me. And he punched me on the arm and left a bruise for a week. He's also slapped me multiple times "on accident." He's just so insecure and he's always so paranoid that I'm cheating, because his ex cheated on him. My ex cheated on me, but I dont treat him this way!! Also, he calls me a "whore" and things like that, which I absolutely HATE, and I've told him so. My ex boyfriend had some mental problems, and my current boyfriend brings up things that my ex used to do to my family (like pointing a gun in my grandfathers face) and makes a joke out of it. He's just so disrespectful towards me, its pathetic. Not to MENTION the fact that he watches pornography behind my back, even when he promised he wouldnt do it. He made me cry the other day and he acted like he didnt even care. He actually got mad at ME for crying! I would break up with him, but I signed for the dirtbike he is paying for, and Im scared that he would blackmail me or not pay and ruin my credit. He has already threatened to tell my family things that I dont really want them to know (when I almost broke up with him before). I just feel so lost and I dont know what to do. I mean, sometimes he can be really sweet, and I see the guy I fell in love with. But his behavior has changed so dramatically over the last year, he's like a completely different person. Im sorry this was so long, but if anyone could help me, I'd appreciate it soooooo much!! Thank you!! 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 10:26 pm PDT

Breaking Up

Quote From: samantha08

Anybody who can help me, I would appreciate it so much!  (Im 19 yrs. old, by the way) 

  

Okay. Basically, Im thinking about breaking up with my boyfriend. He is driving me absolutely insane, and he has gotten to the point where he is emotionally abusive to me. He doesnt trust me whatsoever (but I've never given him a reason not to) and he's always asking me who Im trying to "impress" whenever I look nice. He throws a fit whenever I dress up nice and he isnt there. He doesnt want me to wear makeup, and questions me when I do. None of my friends like him, and he is always talking badly about them. He gets an attitude if I go out with my FEMALE friends, even if its just out to eat or to go shopping. He questions me about the tiniest little details, and I feel like I cant take it anymore. He has become physically abusive on some level.. once I said something under my breath, and he asked me what I said, and he slapped me on the back repeatedly until I told him what it was, even after I told him to stop because it was hurting me. And he punched me on the arm and left a bruise for a week. He's also slapped me multiple times "on accident." He's just so insecure and he's always so paranoid that I'm cheating, because his ex cheated on him. My ex cheated on me, but I dont treat him this way!! Also, he calls me a "whore" and things like that, which I absolutely HATE, and I've told him so. My ex boyfriend had some mental problems, and my current boyfriend brings up things that my ex used to do to my family (like pointing a gun in my grandfathers face) and makes a joke out of it. He's just so disrespectful towards me, its pathetic. Not to MENTION the fact that he watches pornography behind my back, even when he promised he wouldnt do it. He made me cry the other day and he acted like he didnt even care. He actually got mad at ME for crying! I would break up with him, but I signed for the dirtbike he is paying for, and Im scared that he would blackmail me or not pay and ruin my credit. He has already threatened to tell my family things that I dont really want them to know (when I almost broke up with him before). I just feel so lost and I dont know what to do. I mean, sometimes he can be really sweet, and I see the guy I fell in love with. But his behavior has changed so dramatically over the last year, he's like a completely different person. Im sorry this was so long, but if anyone could help me, I'd appreciate it soooooo much!! Thank you!! 

Get out now!  I have been in a relationship just like yours.  If you are living with the boy, make arrangements ahead of time for a place to move to and have your family and friends show up with a moving truck while he is at work.  Get your things and go.  Take the dirt bike with you, and put it up for sale!  Or call the dealership and ask for a voluntary repo and they will come take the dirt bike.  You can explain it to future creditors later, but don't let this be used to trap you.  I know you are worried about what he might tell your family or friends, but beat him to it and tell them yourself in your own words.  I have a suspision that your personal safety may be at stake here.  Run Girl!  Run! 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 10:37 pm PDT

Breaking Up

Quote From: halley

Hi everyone, 

I'm new to the board here.  Very nice how everyone gives support to each other. 

My question may be odd.  I recently broke-up with a man I was dating for 5 months. 

Unfortunately, the words I used were not kind.  I said what I felt but it was mean.  For example, I said you bring me down, and gosh this is hard to admit, but I said to him," You are the biggest mistake I've made. "  The reason I broke-up is because I felt he did not treat me well.  He called back after I said these things and said," I'm sorry I hurt your feelings, and that I'm not the man you want me to be." Anyhow, we have not seen each other for almost 4 weeks.  I ran into him at a public place we both frequently go too, and he completely avoided me.  He would not make any eye contact even when I said hello.  He actually looked down when he said hello back.  I was with a guy friend.  My girlfriends said after me and my friend left, he walked away from the group hand folded, looking down at the ground and looking sideways as he watched me and my friend walk away.  They said he was rubbing one foot in the ground.  My question is this, do you think he is upset or angry? 

Just did not expext him to avoid me in such an obvious way.  Has anyone ever experienced someone avoiding them in such a manner?  And, why do you think he is?  Mind you, the reason I did break-up was I felt he did not care for me, and did not treat me well. 

  

Please, any feedback will greatly be appreciated.  

Are you kidding?  If someone just broke up with me, I don't think I would want to run into them in a public place either.  I would be afraid they might say something to humiliate me even more.  You dated this guy, gave it a go.... and it wasn't a love connection.  It doesn't mean you are entitled to be  friends afterwards.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
confused
October 11, 2005, 7:43 am PDT

going is

I'm recently new to the bored and would love some feed back I was seeing this man who was two years my junior for about five months and I didn't like him at first but after awhile he kinda grew on me . and now i love him and he's gone he moved away down south and I miss him vey much he mad me laugh and made great love and I feel cheated because I wanted to get to know him better and see were the relationship could have went I knew he was leaving and I understood that but I still miss him like crazy and I can't get him out of my head but my question is this we e-mail each other me more than him he e-mail's every couple of weeks or so and my queston is am I missing something or do I need to catch a clue he said he was sorry and that he wish things could be different.  signed seeking all honest answers
 

Message Emote
blank
October 11, 2005, 8:18 am PDT

ouspanky

Quote From: ouspanky

to not sure what you want to do....are you kidding.  this guys is seeing other girls and only considers you as friends with benefits?  you are being used by him for what he wants.  he does not have to take you out to eat or on dates and you still give him sex.  Maybe that is all you are looking for but i am sure that his friends do not think highly of you because you do sleep with someone, and they are not even your boyfriend.  They may even think that you do not have much self respect or self worth because you and him are not really in a relationship and he is seeing other girls.  wether he is sleeping with them or not should not matter you need to end that relationship and fast before you get "attached emotional" and want more and then get hurt more in the end.  there are plently of other guys out there who will and can treat you better than that.

You are so right about getting out of a bad relationship before you get "emotionally attached".  I wish I had done this in my situation.  And you can believe me that I will be paying attention to those RED FLAGS.  In my case the first obvious one was the fact that I did not have any way to contact him.  Either he was a player, married or living with someone else.  Now I have to heal from the hurt and shame.  I hope other women read your post and be alot wiser.  I know I will.  Thanks for the great advice!
 
First | Prev | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | Next | Last