Message Boards

Topic : Breaking Up

Number of Replies: 5468
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:06:14 pm
Author : dataimport
Is it time to end things with your significant other? Or, have you just been handed a relationship pink slip? Share your stories.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
July 31, 2008, 3:11 pm PDT

thaNks

Quote From: jaimie1974

Sounds fishy to me, too!
Do you and your boyfriend live together? Do you hope to be married to him someday? If you were/are expecting a long term committed relationship with him, you need to confront him and have a serious discussion. Your goal is to have a conversation and come to an understanding and/or a solution. You dont want this discussion to become an argument, because then you will get no solution. To prevent an argument, force yourself to remain calm and totally rational; dont say things that you might not mean. Use what is called the validation method when you approach him. The validation method goes like this: you start out with a positive statement, then state your issue, then end with another positive statement. For example, you might say something like, I love you and appreciate you very much. Weve been together for over five years, weve had many great times together, and I want for us to continue having great times. For us to move forward and have a happy, healthy relationship, I need for you to be honest with me from this day forward. If you need to resolve issues with a high school girlfriend, you can tell me before you meet with her. I want to know these things about you Then from there, see how the conversation goes. If he becomes defensive, it is very likely that he is hiding something. People dont become defensive unless they are trying to hide something, and the best way to hide something is to create another issue over something else- that way youll become distracted and go on to that other issue, forgetting the original issue for the moment. Remember that when you approach him to talk about your future together. I wish you the best!
thanks for your advice, I did confront him and he wasnt defensive. I think he realizes how much he hurt me, but I still think it's fishy. Guys dont' think about feelings at all. We do not live together, he lives in another town not far from me, we both have kids of from previous marriage. Someday we might live together, we have talked about it. So a good thing to do is to communicate, and he has always had a problem with that. thanks.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
confused
August 1, 2008, 3:28 pm PDT

14 years down the drain!!!!!!!!

You know I just find it so hard to let someone go, that I love so much. But I know that I half to, I believe that I half to.    We've been together since I was 16 years old. I am 30 years old now. I have been faithful to him the whole 14 years that we've been together. But he hasn't been!!!!!!!  I know that in the 14 years  that we've he's cheated more times then I know. But what I do know is that he cheated on me and had a child by another woman. That was about 6 years ago, we broke up for a year, got back together, then that's when I found out about the child that had come from the affair. Then we broke up for another year, then got back together. So, we have been back together for around 3 years or more now. But during this time, I found another woman's number in his pants, and called her and found out that he had came on to her and got her number. That was just around 3 to 4 months of us just getting back together. I should have lefted him then, but I didn't. Then I fought out he was still talking to his baby's mother that he had from the affair, he's not in the child's life because her husbsnd knows about the affair that she had, but she has her husband thinking that the child is his and it's not. So, he just said that the whole summer that he had been talking to her about the child. But he was in my eyes still being dishonesty with me. Then the next year I fought him at a grocery store parking lot with her after a disagreement that we had.

 

And now this, I fought out through his cell phone that he's been talking to a woman that he met on his new part-time job. He was doing it behind my back. It's decentful, and this is not away to work on trust issues in the relationship. He's been wanting to get married and have kids with me. But I don't  trust him enough to marry him. So, now were broke up, and he is saying that he will come back if I will marry him. I can't trust him. How long does someone suppose to put up with lies, decent, pain, cheating, etc. He says that he hasn't cheated on me since his been back with me this time. But I'm feeling even if they hadn't had sex yet, it was just a matter of time, but I'm sure that they have had sex by now. But, that's besides the point, I feel like he did cheat, because the time that he was spending with her, he was short changing me. The only thing he would admit to, is when I asked him that if I had a friend on the side like he did, would that be o.k. with him and he said NO it wouldn't.      How do you really know if and when you should walk away? How do you let someone go when you still love them so? Being totally alone is so scary for me, I've really never been totally alone before. Help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
August 2, 2008, 9:45 am PDT

Help

Quote From: onelove7481

You know I just find it so hard to let someone go, that I love so much. But I know that I half to, I believe that I half to.    We've been together since I was 16 years old. I am 30 years old now. I have been faithful to him the whole 14 years that we've been together. But he hasn't been!!!!!!!  I know that in the 14 years  that we've he's cheated more times then I know. But what I do know is that he cheated on me and had a child by another woman. That was about 6 years ago, we broke up for a year, got back together, then that's when I found out about the child that had come from the affair. Then we broke up for another year, then got back together. So, we have been back together for around 3 years or more now. But during this time, I found another woman's number in his pants, and called her and found out that he had came on to her and got her number. That was just around 3 to 4 months of us just getting back together. I should have lefted him then, but I didn't. Then I fought out he was still talking to his baby's mother that he had from the affair, he's not in the child's life because her husbsnd knows about the affair that she had, but she has her husband thinking that the child is his and it's not. So, he just said that the whole summer that he had been talking to her about the child. But he was in my eyes still being dishonesty with me. Then the next year I fought him at a grocery store parking lot with her after a disagreement that we had.

 

And now this, I fought out through his cell phone that he's been talking to a woman that he met on his new part-time job. He was doing it behind my back. It's decentful, and this is not away to work on trust issues in the relationship. He's been wanting to get married and have kids with me. But I don't  trust him enough to marry him. So, now were broke up, and he is saying that he will come back if I will marry him. I can't trust him. How long does someone suppose to put up with lies, decent, pain, cheating, etc. He says that he hasn't cheated on me since his been back with me this time. But I'm feeling even if they hadn't had sex yet, it was just a matter of time, but I'm sure that they have had sex by now. But, that's besides the point, I feel like he did cheat, because the time that he was spending with her, he was short changing me. The only thing he would admit to, is when I asked him that if I had a friend on the side like he did, would that be o.k. with him and he said NO it wouldn't.      How do you really know if and when you should walk away? How do you let someone go when you still love them so? Being totally alone is so scary for me, I've really never been totally alone before. Help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I know that this is very painful and feeling like these past 14 years have been “for nothing” is understandable. However, I urge you to look at this in a more positive light: it would have been much, much worse if you were married and then all of this happened. These 14 years haven’t all been for nothing, you have learned very valuable life lessons through this relationship. You’ve learned what ‘red flags’ are, and in the future, you won’t ignore them or allow someone to excuse them away; you will demand the truth and the respect that you deserve. Being alone might be scary, but the alternative is even worse- being with someone who lies to you, disrespects you, and who you can’t trust. That is even more scary if you ask me. I urge you to be strong and to be good to yourself at this time in your life. Focus on yourself, making YOU a stronger, more positive woman who doesn’t “need” a man to validate her. Yes, it will be difficult at first, but you will grow from this experience. I wish you the best!
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
August 2, 2008, 11:20 pm PDT

update

Quote From: jaimie1974

Sounds fishy to me, too!
Do you and your boyfriend live together? Do you hope to be married to him someday? If you were/are expecting a long term committed relationship with him, you need to confront him and have a serious discussion. Your goal is to have a conversation and come to an understanding and/or a solution. You dont want this discussion to become an argument, because then you will get no solution. To prevent an argument, force yourself to remain calm and totally rational; dont say things that you might not mean. Use what is called the validation method when you approach him. The validation method goes like this: you start out with a positive statement, then state your issue, then end with another positive statement. For example, you might say something like, I love you and appreciate you very much. Weve been together for over five years, weve had many great times together, and I want for us to continue having great times. For us to move forward and have a happy, healthy relationship, I need for you to be honest with me from this day forward. If you need to resolve issues with a high school girlfriend, you can tell me before you meet with her. I want to know these things about you Then from there, see how the conversation goes. If he becomes defensive, it is very likely that he is hiding something. People dont become defensive unless they are trying to hide something, and the best way to hide something is to create another issue over something else- that way youll become distracted and go on to that other issue, forgetting the original issue for the moment. Remember that when you approach him to talk about your future together. I wish you the best!
Hey, i asked my boyfriend about this meeting with ex gf, and he said, that she is really religous now and would like to clear old sins etc...and he did tell her that he has a gf, (me) and he admitted to me that this was stupid to even meet up with her, apparently she found my boyfriend thru one of his brothers, they live in small towns. He doesnt plan on seeing her again cause he has me. He also bought me roses on friday and the card said he loved me. He said he would never cheat on me either, since his ex wife had cheated on him, he knows what it feels like. So, I guess I'll give him a chance.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
August 3, 2008, 11:50 pm PDT

Thank you!!!!!!

Quote From: jaimie1974

I know that this is very painful and feeling like these past 14 years have been for nothing is understandable. However, I urge you to look at this in a more positive light: it would have been much, much worse if you were married and then all of this happened. These 14 years havent all been for nothing, you have learned very valuable life lessons through this relationship. Youve learned what red flags are, and in the future, you wont ignore them or allow someone to excuse them away; you will demand the truth and the respect that you deserve. Being alone might be scary, but the alternative is even worse- being with someone who lies to you, disrespects you, and who you cant trust. That is even more scary if you ask me. I urge you to be strong and to be good to yourself at this time in your life. Focus on yourself, making YOU a stronger, more positive woman who doesnt need a man to validate her. Yes, it will be difficult at first, but you will grow from this experience. I wish you the best!
Thank you for your advice. But I'm weak right now and I need all of the support that I can get, to know that I'm doing the right thing by letting this 14 year relationship go. Because I'm still learning about myself. I'm trying to learn how to trust my dicisions, without always second guessing myself all the time. Maybe it's because I have allowed myself to live in deinal for so long, and to believe lies for so long that, I don't trust myself enough to make the right choice. Do you think I'm making the right choice. I mean I know that I wasn't perfect in the relationship, noone is. But I love myself enough, and loved and respected him and our relationship enough not to cheat!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The most thing of all that I am mostly scared about is why leave him, the man that I love. For the next man to cheat on me. I don't know of men that don't cheat do you? Are there men out there that don't cheat?  Help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
August 4, 2008, 12:31 am PDT

I understand

Quote From: aba1969

Thank you for the response.  My only concern is for my daughter's well being.  I did not want her being exposed to a variety of girlfriends that when the other does not work he'll introduce her to another.  I reacted before when he said he was not even sure if it was going to work out with her since he already let them spent time together for the first couple of days they started seeing each other.  I know his lovelife should not be any of my concern as he was the one who have asked me if I have found anybody or going to moved in with anyone.  I was not controlling him, I don't even response to his personal comment regarding his relationship with this girl.  There was one time he drove to my new place to drop our daughter to me and she came with them but did not see me that's why I asked him to introduce me to her but did not do it, and again today the girlfriend just decided to go to his place in the morning just to drive them to my place to drop my daughter off and not use my ex's car.  I mean, what is this?  I feel like he is trying to use our daughter to get back at me.  I hope I am really wrong.  I feel like he does not want me to be happy. 

I can understand why you have such a problem with your him exposing your daughter to all of those different women. If he was a real man, first of all he wouldn't be going from woman to woman like that in front of your daughter.  If he really loved his daughter more than he loved hisself, the way it's suppose to be when you have a child, he wouldn't be exposing your child to so many women.  So, yes you have a right to be upset.  Sounds like a very selfish man to me. Sounds like his putting his needs ahead of his childs. Because all he's doing is teaching her, about how it's o.k. to go from one person to another. He should not be bringing a woman around his daughter, until he knows it's serious, like a engagement. It's wrong for a woman to bring so many men around her kids, and it's wrong for a man to bring so many women around his kid. Doesn't he think that the child is going through enough, all it's doing is confusing her.

 

Don't let him steal your power from you, take your power back. Don't let him see you without your hair done, your make-up done and etc. Don't let him talk to you about his relationships when he knows all it does is hurt you,  spare yourself the pain!!!!!    He wants you to be miserable, take your power back. If you need to cry or hollar, do it after he's gone, don't do it in front of him that's what he wants.  You are a strong woman, you can do anything that you put your mind to. Your most important role is your daughter, and what she sees in her mother. Show her the mother that is strong, powerful, loving, caring, beautiful, wise, woman.  YOU  ARE WOMAN, DON'T LET A MAN BREAK YOU DOWN SO MUCH THAT YOU STOP BELIEVEING IN YOURSELF, NO MATTER WHAT,   ALWAYS REMEMBER YOUR DAUGHTER'S EYES ARE ALWAYS WATCHING YOU NO MATTER HER AGE.  LET HER BE YOUR INSPIRATION!!!!    GOD BLESS YOU, PRAY HE WILL HELP YOU WITH THIS, JUST BELIEVE. 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
August 4, 2008, 12:36 am PDT

Writing this to you, is helping me too.

I read what I wrote to you, and it's helping me to get through my break up too!!!!  I will take my own advice as well!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
August 4, 2008, 1:42 pm PDT

to "one love"

Quote From: onelove7481

Thank you for your advice. But I'm weak right now and I need all of the support that I can get, to know that I'm doing the right thing by letting this 14 year relationship go. Because I'm still learning about myself. I'm trying to learn how to trust my dicisions, without always second guessing myself all the time. Maybe it's because I have allowed myself to live in deinal for so long, and to believe lies for so long that, I don't trust myself enough to make the right choice. Do you think I'm making the right choice. I mean I know that I wasn't perfect in the relationship, noone is. But I love myself enough, and loved and respected him and our relationship enough not to cheat!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The most thing of all that I am mostly scared about is why leave him, the man that I love. For the next man to cheat on me. I don't know of men that don't cheat do you? Are there men out there that don't cheat?  Help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
In my opinion, leaving the relationship is the right decision to make. It is understandable that you are afraid to be alone; that is only natural after being in a relationship for as long as you have been. You say that you love this man, but his words (lying) and his actions (cheating, having a child, etc.) are not loving towards you. To have a happy, healthy and stable relationship it takes both people to have love and respect for one another.
You are right that no one is perfect. As we go along in life, we live and learn from our mistakes and other people’s mistakes. To continue to stay in a relationship where you are being so disrespected is detrimental to you. (If you stay in this relationship, do you think that you would ever truly be able to trust him?)
Not all men cheat. You are trying to talk yourself into staying in this relationship by using the excuse that all men cheat, however, it isn’t true. I know many men in long term relationships/marriages who have never cheated. There will come a time in your life when you are happy with yourself and you will meet the right man. It is better to be alone then to be with someone who makes you feel badly about yourself! Being alone is healthier, because you can take this time to work on yourself, focus on YOU, instead of worrying and wondering what your boyfriend might be doing. I urge you to read the book “Self Matters” by Dr. Phil. It is a good book that will help you learn how to raise your self esteem. When you have a healthier sense of self esteem, you will be strong enough to leave this unhealthy relationship. I wish you the best- don’t second guess yourself on this decision; do what is best for YOU.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
August 4, 2008, 6:24 pm PDT

Thank you!!!!!! once again!!!!!!

Quote From: jaimie1974

In my opinion, leaving the relationship is the right decision to make. It is understandable that you are afraid to be alone; that is only natural after being in a relationship for as long as you have been. You say that you love this man, but his words (lying) and his actions (cheating, having a child, etc.) are not loving towards you. To have a happy, healthy and stable relationship it takes both people to have love and respect for one another.
You are right that no one is perfect. As we go along in life, we live and learn from our mistakes and other peoples mistakes. To continue to stay in a relationship where you are being so disrespected is detrimental to you. (If you stay in this relationship, do you think that you would ever truly be able to trust him?)
Not all men cheat. You are trying to talk yourself into staying in this relationship by using the excuse that all men cheat, however, it isnt true. I know many men in long term relationships/marriages who have never cheated. There will come a time in your life when you are happy with yourself and you will meet the right man. It is better to be alone then to be with someone who makes you feel badly about yourself! Being alone is healthier, because you can take this time to work on yourself, focus on YOU, instead of worrying and wondering what your boyfriend might be doing. I urge you to read the book Self Matters by Dr. Phil. It is a good book that will help you learn how to raise your self esteem. When you have a healthier sense of self esteem, you will be strong enough to leave this unhealthy relationship. I wish you the best- dont second guess yourself on this decision; do what is best for YOU.
I don't know you, but you are like a god send to me. At the same time you are helping me believe in myself, because your confirming everything that I already know. I'm realizing through you that the more I talk to you the more I realize that the reason that I doubt myself so much is because  everytime I let him talk me out of the truth, out of reality, I lost a little of myself everytime.  So over the 14 years of us being together, I have allowed him to use his lies, to make me think that I was crazy and that I didn't know what the truth was. It's amazing what happens to a woman when she gives all of her power up  to a man.  That she believes him over her spirit, her heart, her mind, and her soul, OVER GOD!!!!!!!!!!  Why am I and other women so desperate  to have a man in our lives, that we are willing to be miserable, to be with a man!!!!  You know sex is a powerful thing, it really does blind us or is it just love that blinds us !!!!!!!   I just want to say once again, thank you for taking time out to writing me back!!!! Your helping me more than you can every know, your giving me strength!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! To your Question, no I would never be able to trust him, and I'm realizing more and more that without trust you really have nothing. All you have are 2 miserable people.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
August 5, 2008, 11:03 am PDT

Dear "one love"

Quote From: onelove7481

I don't know you, but you are like a god send to me. At the same time you are helping me believe in myself, because your confirming everything that I already know. I'm realizing through you that the more I talk to you the more I realize that the reason that I doubt myself so much is because  everytime I let him talk me out of the truth, out of reality, I lost a little of myself everytime.  So over the 14 years of us being together, I have allowed him to use his lies, to make me think that I was crazy and that I didn't know what the truth was. It's amazing what happens to a woman when she gives all of her power up  to a man.  That she believes him over her spirit, her heart, her mind, and her soul, OVER GOD!!!!!!!!!!  Why am I and other women so desperate  to have a man in our lives, that we are willing to be miserable, to be with a man!!!!  You know sex is a powerful thing, it really does blind us or is it just love that blinds us !!!!!!!   I just want to say once again, thank you for taking time out to writing me back!!!! Your helping me more than you can every know, your giving me strength!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! To your Question, no I would never be able to trust him, and I'm realizing more and more that without trust you really have nothing. All you have are 2 miserable people.
I am glad to know that my words have been helpful for you. The advice that I give to you comes from personal experience; I’ve been there and I know how difficult it is to be in the situation that you are in now. I also allowed a man to talk me into staying with him for the craziest reasons; I look back now and I am amazed at the things I tolerated from him. It has been 12 years since I got out of that toxic relationship and I am happier then ever. So please know and believe that life goes on, and that you can and you will be happy! You have a bright future ahead of you; you need to close the door on this man and make him in the past. I wish you the very best, be good to yourself.
 
First | Prev | 505 | 506 | 507 | 508 | 509 | 510 | 511 | 512 | 513 | 514 | Next | Last