Message Boards

Topic : Living Together

Number of Replies: 1749
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:07:28 pm
Author : dataimport
Cohabitation is sometimes a smart (and economical!) way to learn about your compatibilities before taking the plunge. How is living together working for you?

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Sad

Message Emote
blank
November 14, 2006, 9:54 am PST

How can We Make It happen???

Hi im 32 and have been dating my BF for 2 years. We do not live together but we want to but due to lack of funds cant. This causes alot of fighting because my bf lives an hour away with a friend and does alot of things with the friend and im always alone. I always find myself feeling depressed because it seems we are leading separate lives. I live with my parents and i do not like the situation but i cant seem to get emough money to even attempt to get us an apartment. It leaves me feeling very depressed and anxious. Does anyone have advise how to make this happen?
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
upset
November 15, 2006, 5:26 am PST

Still living with him after divorce.....

     Well I was married for 2 years and everything started to come apart......my son joined the national guard and he was going to be a father, from my step-daughter......but he didn\t know it until she was a little over a year(after paying for a paternity test).  That was one of our problems was his daughter always came first.  Well we are still living together and intimate, but he has changed and I think he may be cheating.  I found a condom in his wallet, he has never used one on me and never had any until I found this one.  Please let me know what to do??????? 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2006, 8:38 am PST

Self respect

Quote From: dianne83

Hi, I am a 23 yr old woman who is expecting her first child. My name is Dianne. I wasn't with my boyfriend for very long when we found out I was pregnant. At the time we found out I felt that I truly loved my boyfriend as we had already spoke of marriage and had great times. Soon after finding out, we moved in together. I had seen signs that he was insecure and possibly a little controlling before but after moving that was the only side I saw. I am about 3 credits shy of a BC in Psych . and with that find myself constantly thinking my boyfriend has narcissitc tendencies and o.c.d. Because I have felt this way for a couple of months I have researched forth on the internet and everytime I read a story or info. about a narcissist I feel like I'm reading about him. Everything I read says to run from these people. I'm so upset. He is getting worse and worse with the controlling. I can't see my friends (which he will not come out and say but throws a temper tantrum and huge guilt trip until I cancel plans), I have no access to the money -which I contribute 50% of. I feel like I sound like a fool. Before him, I lived on my own already since 19 , had a great group of girls to call bestfriends and so much happyiness. He has the ability to bring a smile to my face but those days are far and few between now. I'm coming to terms with the fact that I'm only around now because of the baby. I still love him but my self respect is worth more. He had a "messed up" childhood accordin to him, where all this stems from. Talking to him doesn't work- which is everyones usual advice. From what I get he grew up in a household that was unpredictable. His father was not a good mentor -verbally abusing mom and stepping out. His father took money from him showing him he could not trust even the ones close to him. His mom decided to rebell against her husband at jsut the wrong time for my boyfriends development. Because of the fact that she stopped being there for her husband she stopped being there for everyone is the house. He literally has not one friend, but many acquaintances. Because I have friends (all girls) he holds that over my head and gets very mad even if my phone rings. I walk on egg shells because he is unpredictable and easily irritated- I realize now that there is no pleasing him he is comfortable only in his own misery. I need encouragement to make this work or the right words to say to encourage him to change. As of right now, in the aspect of progress, he will (after much coaxing) admit that he has these faults because of his past and family and wants to chang, that all the mean things he says isnt true and he doesn't want to control me but does feel the need to. help!

You said that you need encouragement to make this relationship work, or the right words to say to encourage him to change- but that advice does not exist. It sounds like your relationship began with a lot of love, and now, it is like a jail/prison sentence for you.

Whether or not he is narcissistic and/or ocd, you deserve so much more than you are getting out of this relationship. When your baby is born, do you want her/him to grow up, always walking on eggshells, trying not to p*ss of dad? You know that this man is comfortable with his misery, and he has the desire for the people around him to also be in misery- this is how your child will live if you stay with him. He isn’t going to change, he has to want to change- and even then, it will take him a very, very long time. It isn’t impossible; it just is so far away- and you are living a life right NOW. Your unborn child is growing right this moment, every second you are closer to giving birth, so if you can’t leave the relationship to retain your own self respect and self worth, then think about your innocent child.

You deserve to have the love and support of family and friends around you. Don’t allow him to take these people away from you! You don’t deserve to feel like you have to walk on egg shells- that is his power over you; and if you think it will get better when the baby is born, you are wrong. It only gets worse, because then, you will have a little person who needs you more than he needs you, and it will enrage him. Please listen to your instincts and go to the safety of your family/friends!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 15, 2006, 8:41 am PST

sunny

Quote From: sunny129

Hi im 32 and have been dating my BF for 2 years. We do not live together but we want to but due to lack of funds cant. This causes alot of fighting because my bf lives an hour away with a friend and does alot of things with the friend and im always alone. I always find myself feeling depressed because it seems we are leading separate lives. I live with my parents and i do not like the situation but i cant seem to get emough money to even attempt to get us an apartment. It leaves me feeling very depressed and anxious. Does anyone have advise how to make this happen?

You need to force yourself to get out of the house and do something! Go do something with friends, or just go for a simple walk; taking time out for yourself is so important- no wonder you are depressed. You can’t just sit home and wait for this man to call you with a magical solution to this problem; it isn’t going to happen- it would have happened by now if it was going to! It is time to focus on the only person that you have any control over, and that is you- get involved with activities or a hobby that you enjoy, something that brings you a sense of self worth and/or accomplishment. You will feel so much better about yourself when you do this!

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
November 16, 2006, 12:07 pm PST

KEEPER OF THE FUNDS

I am in a serious relationship & we have been living together for the past 1 1/4 yrs.  We live as though we are married.  We have no separate accts.  He is in charge of the funds because I like it that way & a better job is done.  However, I'm concerned about what happens if a break up occurs.  Everything is in his name only. If he were to want me to leave I would be penniless & in the streets. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 17, 2006, 5:14 pm PST

living together....

Quote From: wnglydplt

I am in a serious relationship & we have been living together for the past 1 1/4 yrs.  We live as though we are married.  We have no separate accts.  He is in charge of the funds because I like it that way & a better job is done.  However, I'm concerned about what happens if a break up occurs.  Everything is in his name only. If he were to want me to leave I would be penniless & in the streets. 

It is wonderful that you trust him this much, and that you don’t have to worry about the bills not getting paid, etc., however, your other concerns are very valid.

You said that everything is in his name only, is there a reason for that? The first thing you need to do is let him know that you would like to have your account be a joint account, and both of you can go to the bank and add your name onto the account- it only takes a few minutes; its no big deal- and it will make you feel a bit better.

What about your lease or rental agreement? Your name should also be added to that. If your boyfriend has your best interests in mind, he will absolutely understand your concerns. If you are ‘worried’ to mention that you want to do these things, then I urge you to consider what your relationship is based on in the first place. If he has the need to control every aspect of your relationship with no consideration for your best interests, then your relationship is based on his mistrust of you- very unhealthy!

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
worried
November 20, 2006, 9:02 am PST

reasons for everything

Quote From: jaimie1974

It is wonderful that you trust him this much, and that you dont have to worry about the bills not getting paid, etc., however, your other concerns are very valid.

You said that everything is in his name only, is there a reason for that? The first thing you need to do is let him know that you would like to have your account be a joint account, and both of you can go to the bank and add your name onto the account- it only takes a few minutes; its no big deal- and it will make you feel a bit better.

What about your lease or rental agreement? Your name should also be added to that. If your boyfriend has your best interests in mind, he will absolutely understand your concerns. If you are worried to mention that you want to do these things, then I urge you to consider what your relationship is based on in the first place. If he has the need to control every aspect of your relationship with no consideration for your best interests, then your relationship is based on his mistrust of you- very unhealthy!

Thank you for responding. I like & agree with your advice however, as usual things aren't as easy as they seem.

The reason everything is in his name is because I have a really crazy ex-husband that for 10 yrs. has made my life a living hell.  He tries to take everything away from me so to protect my assets I did not want them in my name, also he can't find where I live so easily. He has put freezes on my accts. when he finds them. He has given out my SSN along with personal info to whomever & I had my identity stolen through my credit card which was because of him.  He has filed bankruptcy just before our divorce was final so this is on my record for 7 yrs. I can't get a loan, credit card, mortgage, etc. until this is finished.

We live in a hs. which is in my boyfriend's name only because it's his home, I only live here. If I were to put my name on it, it would be an asset that my ex could go after.

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
November 20, 2006, 9:05 am PST

Living Together

Quote From: jaimie1974

Is there any explanation for his change in behavior?

You said that you have mentioned moving out, but you didnt say if you talked about how you feel taken for granted, etc., before talking about moving out- did you have that conversation?

Have you two gone out or done anything fun together lately? Although it would be great for him to make the first move, you cant just wait for that to happen- maybe if you make the plans and take him out, it will remind him of how much fun you used to have.

The only thing that could be worse than feeling taken for granted would be feeling taken for granted for years.you dont want that to happen to yourself. If you feel that this could be it, this could be the way things will be forever- then you should seriously consider moving back out and go back to dating. Perhaps it hurts him that you think about moving out, but what about your feelings? You have made him aware of how you feel, but he hasnt done anything to change- that is a big red flag.

    You say his attitude has changed. It doesn't matter when it changed. Relationships has stages and you are going through one of those stage now, where your mate has become so what content and relax and feels he doesn't have to do as much to impress you now. You both have agreed your interest to take the relationship to another level and youv'e done that by moving in together. It almost like living at home with your parents and siblings- you know that they're there and you don't expect things to change, so you become content with that for how long- that is totally up to you. I heard you say that you were happy when you were dating, he did things to make you. My question to you is have you did the same things for him? If you haven't then it's time you explore some  different possbilities.Prepare a nice candle-light dinner for the two of you, with some nice instrumental music, and try a different approach to your conversation with him or have a luxurious bath ready for him when he gets home with candle-lights around the bathtub and some wine lay out your sexiest lingerie and bath oil and let the rest be history. Show him that you can appear to his senses as well.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
November 20, 2006, 9:12 am PST

Living Together

Quote From: natalie878

My bf and I have lived together for nearly 4 years now, I'm 47 and he's 50, but if I had it to do over again, I'd just date or spend weekends cohabitating!

When we first started dating, I thought here is the most honest upfront guy, holds nothing back, wow, I didn't have that in my marriage of 23 years. We had a great time, the kids all got along great, all was wonderful. We moved in together and silly me had visions of getting remarried and he just kept saying, I'm not ready for that or I need to be sure before we do that..the blow comment was I want to be sure you're the one. That hurt..alot. It certainly made me back off and rethink my position. Increasingly I felt the need to stay 'single'.

Lo and behold ON our 3 year anniversary early in the morning there was a knock at the door, with a woman standing there..asking for him. He came back from the door white as a ghost holding papers, even with sleepy eyes, I could see they were DIVORCE papers. I didn't have a CLUE that he was married. You could have knocked me over with a feather!!!!! They had been married for 3 1/2 years, she disappeared after 4 mo. of marriage, and he'd never heard from her again until that day.

After a blur of lawyers he was divorced in 6 weeks. He just thought she'd fall off the face of the earth I guess.LOL

NOW  he's all into let's get married blah blah blah, and I have no interest what so ever. He took the 'us' out of trust and it's something I can't get past. I've bought a house with only my name on it, we still live together, altho I sometimes really wonder why..

 

 

Sometimes we  become so infatuated with infatuation that we lose sight of what's really going on. In this case a little  probing would have paid off.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
November 22, 2006, 8:39 am PST

to break up or not to break up...

I also posted this on the breakup forum, but I would like to post here as well to try to get some help.

 

I hope I can get some outside opinions about what is going on in my relationship.  Any help would be appreciated.

 

My boyfriend and I have been together for about 1 1/2 years.  We have been living together for 10 months.  Our relationship has been going well and overall I would call it above average.  We have only had a few major issues.  These issues have been:  him recieving phone calls, text messages, and emails from his ex girlfriend and subsequently lying to me about talking, texting, or emailing her.  The messages that I saw were inappropriate considering he was in a committed relationship with me, such as "I miss you - luv ya" "Thinking about you always" and things of this nature.  He was also on an internet dating website, browsing profiles, and contacting single girls (saying he was single) for the first 4 months of our relationship.  After I found out about both the ex g/f stuff and the online dating thing I freaked out, was very upset, and he promised to stop.  As far as I know he has stopped with the online dating thing but the messages and phone calls continued until at least last May (when we had been together for 11 months).  So needless to say these actions have made trusting him very difficult for me.

 

Since then the only two things we ever fight about are household chores and the way he speaks to me/treats me.  The chores thing is pretty cut and dry and I do recognize that I contribute to the fighting there.  He is a bonefide clean-freak and I am what I consider normal - I like a clean house, do a major clean up once a week, pick up daily, do dishes and things like that daily, etc.  He considers two dishes in the sink and a magazine on the coffee table "a s#$t hole" and I am not exaggerating at all.  Our apartment is never remotely dirty.  The other fighting topic is he often says things that hurt my feelings but he considers it either 1) just joking or 2) I made him so mad its my fault for the things he says.  An example would be him calling me a name like "dummy" or "chubby"...he says its just a joke but it hurts my feelings.  I get mad at him and tell him that it bothers me and then he just gets mad and says I can't take a joke, and it goes on from there.  In his opinion we only fight about cleaning.  He doesn't even recognize my issue with the way he talks to me.  He says because he drives me to work and spends lots of time with me that he treats me well.  While I appreciate everything he does for me and tell him so on a regular basis I just wish he could consider my feelings before saying and doing things.

 

This is getting really long so I will try to get to the point.  Yesterday he fell asleep in the spare room and I asked him to come to bed.  I turned on the light and woke him up to come to bed.  He responded by telling me to f-off, get the f out of there, and called me a f-ing retard.  I left in tears and cried myself to sleep.  This morning before work I tried to talk to him about it and he just flipped out saying he can do whatever the f he wants and sleep wherever the f he wants and that he's done playing games (not sure what the heck he meant by that).  After he left he shut his cellphone off so I can't contact him.

 

Part of me wants to break off the whole thing.  The other part of me thinks about all the good times we have together and how the majority of the time we really enjoy eachothers company.  We value the same things in life, have similar goals for the future, and usually get along well.  I know I'm not perfect and I push his buttons etc. but at least I recognize that.  He refuses to compromise on anything (hence the fights about chores - his way or no way) and refuses to try to see my point of view.  He has told me that all our fights are my fault.  He only thinks about himself and his feelings/needs and rarely considers mine.  I don't understand. 

 

So what to do?  Is it worth it?  Is there a way to get him to see and at least consider my point of view?  Or is this a big waste of my time and I should just move on??  Since we live together its not as simple as just breaking up.  I would have to find another place to live and financially I don't think I can swing that right now.  Not to mention the fact that christmas is around the corner and I was looking forward to spending it with him.  I love him alot and I thought we had a future.  We are both in our late 20's so I feel like if we aren't headed towards and more healthy relationship I am just wasting my time.


Any insights?

 
First | Prev | 84 | 85 | 86 | 87 | 88 | 89 | 90 | 91 | 92 | 93 | Next | Last