Message Boards

Topic : Living Together

Number of Replies: 1749
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:07:28 pm
Author : dataimport
Cohabitation is sometimes a smart (and economical!) way to learn about your compatibilities before taking the plunge. How is living together working for you?

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 11, 2008, 11:44 am PST

Dear Tammy,

Quote From: ramtuff69

  

Wondering if my feelings towards my boyfriend doing extra fix it things or extra errands for his son's mom is out of line.  Personally I don't think so. 

 

I've been dating this man for 6months.  He has a 7 year old son with a previous relationship. They were not married and they ended the relationship when their son was 1.  We all live in the same small town. Yet of course he has always been seeing his son since their relationship ended.  He told me that they have continued to have sex whenever she wanted to about 3 times a year or so.  Up until last August when we started going out.  He always did extra things for her because of his son like fix her car when needed, put up xmas lights, install new light fixtures in the house, pick up cat litter and drop it off.  He just recently got his truck back and now she is asking him to pick their son up from school about 2x a week and drop him off at home.  I can accept that, it's the extra things that she feels she has the right to keep asking him to do. She calls whenever she

wants him to do something for her.   When he goes to have time with his son, my boyfriend visits and stays at their home.  We only been dating 6 months so I don't want to say well you can bring him over to my house when it's your time to be with your son.  I want to be sure our relationship is strong before I would offer that.  ( My boyfriends place right now is not suitable to bring his son over for visiting, small trailer, renovations going on).  So my question to anyone who will read this,  Do I have a right to ask my boyfriend to limit the extra fix it or pick it up things that his ex girlfriend asks him to do.     I feel that if it is a errand to help out his son, like picking him up from school that of course is fine.   But I feel like I am in two relationships to a point.  I would like to ask him to stop doing these things for her because he is no longer with her and has not been for 6 years, but has been helping out for that long.  Now he is in a new relationship and if he should be focusing on our relationship to start building a good foundation.

 

P.s  This woman still thinks that their relationship just ended last year, yet they've lived in seperate houses and he has been with other woman in those 6years.  So there is no her and him.  She seems a little strange,and demanding.

 

Advice needed desperately.

 

 

 

Tammy

You’ve only been dating for 6 months; it isn’t your place to say how his relationship with his ex should/should not be. The only thing you can do, at this point, is enjoy the good times with this man. If things get more serious, then you can bring up your thoughts regarding his ex. My advice to you is to not ‘demand’ that there is a change, instead, begin a dialog with him, asking him, does he think that the relationship with his child’s mother is normal and healthy? Ask him to pretend that he is you; that YOU have an ex who calls anytime for anything, and how would he feel about that? Be sure to remain calm at all times, remember that this is a discussion; it isn’t an argument. You are simply giving him some things to think about. He might be defensive at first, because this involves his child. After the initial conversation, give him some time to think about what you’ve said. Hopefully, he is a reasonable and rational man, and he will understand your thoughts. I wish you the best!
 
User Mood
Scared

Message Emote
worried
February 12, 2008, 6:36 am PST

being together in a seperated relationship

I have been with rob for 8 almost 9 years. He is divorced and has a18 year old son. I have a 27 year old that is married and on her own and a 14 year old that lives with me. My son and I moved in with rob and his son 7 years ago.  Things have been okay for the first 5 years, but the seperation of trying to make this family work is very fragile right now.  I have looked for a place to live about 4 times, he always talks me into staying.  He has been on the internet porn and chat  sites 2 times that i caught him and just yesterday i found out he was calling the dating line on the telephone.  He admitted to me (because he was caught) Wants me to stay because he claims he LOVES me and does not want anyone else.My heart is soooooo crushed with the trust issue. Never!!!! did i ever dreamed he would look else where because I believed he wanted me. He keeps telling me that there is no one else that he wants. And believe me I KEEP!! asking him because my insecurities and breaking down. I really need some advice what I need to do.  I keep going back and forth, with wanting to move out, I look for a place then he talks me into staying, I am sooo  confused and my son just figures I defiently am not going to go through with what I say because I keep renigging on what i say I need some advice
 
User Mood
Scared

Message Emote
blank
February 12, 2008, 12:06 pm PST

Living Together

Quote From: cmb2007

I have been with rob for 8 almost 9 years. He is divorced and has a18 year old son. I have a 27 year old that is married and on her own and a 14 year old that lives with me. My son and I moved in with rob and his son 7 years ago.  Things have been okay for the first 5 years, but the seperation of trying to make this family work is very fragile right now.  I have looked for a place to live about 4 times, he always talks me into staying.  He has been on the internet porn and chat  sites 2 times that i caught him and just yesterday i found out he was calling the dating line on the telephone.  He admitted to me (because he was caught) Wants me to stay because he claims he LOVES me and does not want anyone else.My heart is soooooo crushed with the trust issue. Never!!!! did i ever dreamed he would look else where because I believed he wanted me. He keeps telling me that there is no one else that he wants. And believe me I KEEP!! asking him because my insecurities and breaking down. I really need some advice what I need to do.  I keep going back and forth, with wanting to move out, I look for a place then he talks me into staying, I am sooo  confused and my son just figures I defiently am not going to go through with what I say because I keep renigging on what i say I need some advice
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 12, 2008, 3:12 pm PST

decision time

Quote From: cmb2007

I have been with rob for 8 almost 9 years. He is divorced and has a18 year old son. I have a 27 year old that is married and on her own and a 14 year old that lives with me. My son and I moved in with rob and his son 7 years ago.  Things have been okay for the first 5 years, but the seperation of trying to make this family work is very fragile right now.  I have looked for a place to live about 4 times, he always talks me into staying.  He has been on the internet porn and chat  sites 2 times that i caught him and just yesterday i found out he was calling the dating line on the telephone.  He admitted to me (because he was caught) Wants me to stay because he claims he LOVES me and does not want anyone else.My heart is soooooo crushed with the trust issue. Never!!!! did i ever dreamed he would look else where because I believed he wanted me. He keeps telling me that there is no one else that he wants. And believe me I KEEP!! asking him because my insecurities and breaking down. I really need some advice what I need to do.  I keep going back and forth, with wanting to move out, I look for a place then he talks me into staying, I am sooo  confused and my son just figures I defiently am not going to go through with what I say because I keep renigging on what i say I need some advice
You are the strongest female role model that your child will ever have. If keep staying, waiting for something to “magically” change, you are teaching your son that this is ‘normal,’ that this is what men and women do. I am also a mother, and I know that you want the best for your children; you want them to have better then you have had in your life. You want your child to grow up to be a happy, healthy and productive member of society. For that to happen, he needs to have a happy, healthy mother. That is the greatest gift you could give to him.
I urge you to seek professional therapy for yourself ASAP. You need and deserve to have a place where you can talk about your thoughts and feelings, where you can receive guidance on how to create positive change in your life. You know that there has to be a change; having the guidance of an unbiased professional will be helpful for you to create that change. This is one of the greatest gifts you could give to yourself.
It is understandable that you have been deeply hurt by this man’s actions, and it is understandable that you’ve allowed him to sweet-talk you into staying when your brain tells you to go. You are only human, we learn something new every day; now it is time for you to take action with the knowledge that you have regarding him. It won’t be easy, but if the right thing to do was always the easiest thing to do, we would all be living perfect lives, wouldn’t we? You deserve to experience true happiness, and right now, that happiness will be found by putting distance between yourself and this man who betrays you. I wish you the best- take care of YOU.
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
February 12, 2008, 8:48 pm PST

Moving out?

I'm 20 years old and I still live with my parents while I go to school. My boyfriend has been living with us as well for more than a year. Last November, we almost moved out, and would have if the landlord hadn't pulled something illegal.

Anyway, I'm worried about making rent because, though I love my boyfriend more than anything, he isn't very careful with his money. Before the schedualed move-in date in November, I had to convince him not to buy a new car, because he would have been making about $650 a month, and owing about $700. I was also going to have to front his half of the rent for the first month.

I really want to get out of my parents house, and I really want to have our own place, but I'm worried about whether he'll be able to afford it.

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
confused
February 13, 2008, 8:49 am PST

Trust issues

Quote From: cmb2007

Sounds like you have the same problem I have.  TRUST!  My boyfriend told me he wasn't happy.  I start to leave and guess what?  He tells me he loves me and doesn't want me to leave.  He doesn't want anyone else, but he loves me.  Doesn't make any since.  Men are truly from mars.  They like to think they have us on a string.  We love them so much that we will do anything to make it work.  But what do they do?  They sit back and let us take the blame for a relationship gone bad!!
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
February 13, 2008, 6:05 pm PST

No, he can't afford it.

Quote From: redfeathers

I'm 20 years old and I still live with my parents while I go to school. My boyfriend has been living with us as well for more than a year. Last November, we almost moved out, and would have if the landlord hadn't pulled something illegal.

Anyway, I'm worried about making rent because, though I love my boyfriend more than anything, he isn't very careful with his money. Before the schedualed move-in date in November, I had to convince him not to buy a new car, because he would have been making about $650 a month, and owing about $700. I was also going to have to front his half of the rent for the first month.

I really want to get out of my parents house, and I really want to have our own place, but I'm worried about whether he'll be able to afford it.

I'd be worried as well if I were you. 

 

He's obviously not responsible enough at this point to be sharing an apartment with you right now.  Moving out together I'm sure sounds great but realistically you guys can not afford it right now.  Before taking that step both of you should have good steady employment with money in the bank for the unexpected.    Not all people are naturally good with money, some need to be taught.  Living paycheck to paycheck is no way to live, you both should have at least a minumum of 6 months worth of "expenses" in the bank before you sign any lease as a "slush fund" for those incidentals that will pop up.  That way in case either one of you lose your job you can use that money to pay your bills and you don't have to borrow from one another to cover expenses.

 

In this day and age your credit report must stay completely clean, no late payments or missed payments for rent, credit cards and loans etc.  .  Until both of you have a few thousand dollars in the bank for savings don't even consider moving out.

 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
February 13, 2008, 8:15 pm PST

Living Together

Quote From: sandy0914

I'd be worried as well if I were you. 

 

He's obviously not responsible enough at this point to be sharing an apartment with you right now.  Moving out together I'm sure sounds great but realistically you guys can not afford it right now.  Before taking that step both of you should have good steady employment with money in the bank for the unexpected.    Not all people are naturally good with money, some need to be taught.  Living paycheck to paycheck is no way to live, you both should have at least a minumum of 6 months worth of "expenses" in the bank before you sign any lease as a "slush fund" for those incidentals that will pop up.  That way in case either one of you lose your job you can use that money to pay your bills and you don't have to borrow from one another to cover expenses.

 

In this day and age your credit report must stay completely clean, no late payments or missed payments for rent, credit cards and loans etc.  .  Until both of you have a few thousand dollars in the bank for savings don't even consider moving out.

I think you're right. I recieved some social security money relating to something that happened to my mom a few years ago (and they just now told us about it...but that's our government...XD) and I have about $2000 in the bank now. Last night he asked me if I could front him $250 for a payment on a charger!

He has 2 jobs, he makes money, and both jobs are ones that yield tips. He should have at least $250.

Sometimes I wonder where the money goes, and when I ask him about it, he tells me not to worry and that he'll be okay.

He almost did get a new car a few months ago, but the loan was withdrawn by the bank and he got his downpayment of $600 back to his credit. He spent $400 of it on a PS3.

I love him very much and I have no intention of leaving him at all, I'm just very concerned about future financial situations.

 

I don't want to give him the money, because I have a feeling it would be counter-productive in this situation, but it's a car that he can fix up and his father wants to turn that into a father/son project. Both of them are really excited about it, and he may not be able to get the car if I don't give him the money. I'd feel guilty, like I was taking that opportunity away from he and his father, but I don't think it would be the best idea to give in to him.

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
February 14, 2008, 3:29 am PST

Smart girl.

Quote From: redfeathers

I think you're right. I recieved some social security money relating to something that happened to my mom a few years ago (and they just now told us about it...but that's our government...XD) and I have about $2000 in the bank now. Last night he asked me if I could front him $250 for a payment on a charger!

He has 2 jobs, he makes money, and both jobs are ones that yield tips. He should have at least $250.

Sometimes I wonder where the money goes, and when I ask him about it, he tells me not to worry and that he'll be okay.

He almost did get a new car a few months ago, but the loan was withdrawn by the bank and he got his downpayment of $600 back to his credit. He spent $400 of it on a PS3.

I love him very much and I have no intention of leaving him at all, I'm just very concerned about future financial situations.

 

I don't want to give him the money, because I have a feeling it would be counter-productive in this situation, but it's a car that he can fix up and his father wants to turn that into a father/son project. Both of them are really excited about it, and he may not be able to get the car if I don't give him the money. I'd feel guilty, like I was taking that opportunity away from he and his father, but I don't think it would be the best idea to give in to him.

You are very smart for a 20 year old!  Please do not feel guilty for not giving him money.  He needs to becom financially responsible and learn that if you want something you have to save for it. 

I am a parent and one of the best gifts you can give to your child is to teach them the value of a dollar and how to handle money, it's a life lesson.  Make a little, spend a little and save a little.  If your BF wants that car he can make payments I'm sure to the seller on a weekly basis until it is paid off.    When people continue to rely on others for their finances they never ever learn how to manage their money.  He may have to lose this opportunity to realize that it is essential that he put money away for the extra incidentials that do come up.  Don't feel guilty as you will become his biggest enabler time after time, year after year.

 
User Mood
Scared

Message Emote
blank
February 14, 2008, 9:30 am PST

hard decision

Quote From: jaimie1974

You are the strongest female role model that your child will ever have. If keep staying, waiting for something to magically change, you are teaching your son that this is normal, that this is what men and women do. I am also a mother, and I know that you want the best for your children; you want them to have better then you have had in your life. You want your child to grow up to be a happy, healthy and productive member of society. For that to happen, he needs to have a happy, healthy mother. That is the greatest gift you could give to him.
I urge you to seek professional therapy for yourself ASAP. You need and deserve to have a place where you can talk about your thoughts and feelings, where you can receive guidance on how to create positive change in your life. You know that there has to be a change; having the guidance of an unbiased professional will be helpful for you to create that change. This is one of the greatest gifts you could give to yourself.
It is understandable that you have been deeply hurt by this mans actions, and it is understandable that youve allowed him to sweet-talk you into staying when your brain tells you to go. You are only human, we learn something new every day; now it is time for you to take action with the knowledge that you have regarding him. It wont be easy, but if the right thing to do was always the easiest thing to do, we would all be living perfect lives, wouldnt we? You deserve to experience true happiness, and right now, that happiness will be found by putting distance between yourself and this man who betrays you. I wish you the best- take care of YOU.
I know i deserve what is best for my child and i.  I love rob whole heartedly and when i came into this relationship it was for life.  We dated for 2 years before he decided he wanted me to move in. I did because i wanted to have a happy life with him.  we do enjoy the same things in life but it is so hard to bring a blended family together as one.  My son has alot of things here than i wonder if he would if i would have stayed on my own. He has hobbies, he succeeds in school, plays the guitar seems to be okay only that he is angry with me because i keep being  "undecided" .  I am trying to find faith in god and find a way to help this relationshi[p get healthy.  I already have a counselor and the 4 of us have counseled about many things, but the counselor wants me to focus on making my child and I happy.  I agree with that I       also need some help in relationship and blended family problems. At one time we were happy and i believe and have faith that it can work again. we just need to recognize the problems and own up to them and work on  negative and begin getting positive attitudes in the household.  Please help with some suggestions on how to work onl this without just throwing it away. I am not in denial of what rob did to me and hope that i have enough strength to get through this and get the right help that is needed. I pray everyday that god gives me the strength and hope that i need. Me and rob have begin to go to church. Just started to search different churches last week but at least he is willing to go with me. .I feel he wants to work things out  just doesnt know how to handle a relationship where he has someone who "REALLY" Loves him and wants to spend the rest  life with him. I am not a "giver upper"  so to speak.  I love him and i know deep down inside he love me, but doesnt want things the way his first marriage was.  Neither do I.             cathy
 
First | Prev | 149 | 150 | 151 | 152 | 153 | 154 | 155 | 156 | 157 | 158 | Next | Last