Message Boards

Topic : 12/28 What Would Robin Do?

Number of Replies: 217
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Thursday, October 12, 2006, 05:59:44 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 10/17/06) Dr. Phil’s better half weighs in on all your burning questions! Kasey says her husband, Nathan, controls all their money, even though she earns 40 percent of their income, and his controlling behavior is wreaking havoc on their marriage. She has to live on $20 a day, show him receipts for every cent spent, and she's not allowed to have access to their bank accounts. Nathan says his wife is lethal with cash and spends too frivolously. Robin shares what happened when Dr. Phil tried putting her on a budget! Then, Paul promised his wife, Linda, that a certain family tradition wouldn't take place at their wedding. Paul broke his promise and played the prank anyway. Eighteen years later, Linda says she still holds a grudge and feels like she can't trust him. Can Paul get her to forgive and forget? Next, Robin goes undercover and puts "the world's biggest doormat" to the test. Will this “people pleaser” learn to stand up for herself? And, Robin honors an inspirational woman. Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More December 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
naughty
December 28, 2006, 1:43 pm PST

Ha!

Quote From: gwarrior6

So, are you saying she should lower her standards and marry just anybody?  Or were you alluding to the no sex before marriage thing?  For some ppl it IS worth it to take things slower and fall in love with someone, not just their penis.  People CAN have meaningful romantic relationships without sex, and it's better I think to work on the relationship.  So if you withhold sex, does that mean the person doesn't love you anymore, uh, NO!  Or at least it shouldn't affect the way someone feels about you.

 

 

Of course she should NOT lower her standards.  I just find the thought of committing yourself into a marriage without knowing everything about one another is foolish.  Believe me, I do not take sex lightly.  I do not think, as you said, witholding sex means the person doesn't love you, of course not.  You are right, it should not affect the way someone feels about you.  But let's be REALISTIC, shall we?  Sex is an extremely imporant part of a marriage, and any committed relationship.  It is a personal, but important aspect of things.  Deciding to commit yourseves to one another forever under the eyes of god and in front of family, friends, etc., BEFORE having the most intamte moments?  INSANITY!!!

 

 
User Mood
Silly

Message Emote
chillin'
December 28, 2006, 1:49 pm PST

12/28 What Would Robin Do?

I think it's totally traditional to shove cake in each other's face. She should get over it. Its fun
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 28, 2006, 2:10 pm PST

12/28 What Would Robin Do?

Quote From: audraann

I think it's totally traditional to shove cake in each other's face. She should get over it. Its fun

 

I could not agree more!  If this is their worst problem, I think they have a very blessed life.  Get a grip!

 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
December 28, 2006, 3:11 pm PST

12/28 What Would Robin Do?

Quote From: audraann

I think it's totally traditional to shove cake in each other's face. She should get over it. Its fun
Really? Never seen that at any of the weddings I've attended. Must be a local thing.

 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 28, 2006, 3:32 pm PST

12/28 What Would Robin Do?

Quote From: gwarrior6

If my husband gave me $20 a day to live on, I'd say no thank you very much.  I would then go and spend $40 a day just to send the message that he can't financially abuse me.  If he wanted a receipt, I'd tell him where he could put it.  My husband knows that the more he tries to control me, the more i resist like the stubborn a** I am.  If she just says no everytime he tries to put her on  $20/d allowance, and take the credit card and put $40 dollars on it, he'll realize it costs him everytime he tries to control her.

I read one post I agree with I think the solution is counseling and from that they will learn respect and treating each other with dignity. If you dont have togetherness and respect for each other I think its due to be challenging for anyone. I love how they said about togetherness. I think everyone should be on some sort of budget because if your not we all know things can get bad. Just make your marriages work and seek help from a therapist.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
chillin'
December 28, 2006, 3:33 pm PST

point missed... again

The point has been missed again. The same as the first time this aired. The point is the man didn't listen to her, broke a promise, and made her look ridiculous on the most important day of her life. It was so mean spirited. Her feelings were hurt. You cannot dismiss how someone feels. I would have divorced him. Not because of the cake, but because he had no qualms about lying, putting his and his families needs above me, and he didn't take my desires seriously.

It isn't about the cake, or the traditions. It used to be traditional for the lord of the manor to deflower the bride in  room full of people. Now tell me how important traditions are... that one went on for centuries in the western world, and still goes on in the rest of the world to this day.

Traditions shouldn't override the desires of the people involved, and if they are outdated or undesirable then they need to go.

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
December 28, 2006, 3:34 pm PST

12/28 What Would Robin Do?

Quote From: golyadkina

Really? Never seen that at any of the weddings I've attended. Must be a local thing.

 
I've never witnessed it either. I think it's nasty.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
December 28, 2006, 3:44 pm PST

12/28 What Would Robin Do?

Quote From: mustbecrazy

Neither I nor my husband are controlling about money, or anything else.  We have ONE joint checking account.  All of our money goes in, and all of our money goes back out to pay bills, house payments, medical expenses, groceries.  We have three kids, and there isn't much, if any, extra money.  Once in awhile, I get to get new clothes...I prefer to get the bargains at Goodwill...more for the money, and more of a challenge to find just what I want.  My husband gets the occasional computer game...I guess since we don't have much money, we don't have much to fight about. 

 

The point here is that it is OUR money...not mine...not his...OURS, and WE decide how to spend it...together.  I don't understand how married couples can keep their finances separate after marriage...marriage is a JOINT VENTURE.

do you like shopping at goodwill? Not to be rude but you say you have three children? Shopping at goodwill must be hard for them to accept expecially if they are girls. How do they react when friends ask them where they got something from?This might be crazy of me but I would work three jobs around the clock before I would put goodwill clothes on my kids. Not that I'm a snob or too good but I want the best for my kids. I guess if it doesn't bother you or them thats great. You must live in an area where its accepted. We live in the biggest snob town :) No...its nice but lets say glamorous :) My twin girls are running around with blackberry pearls and fancy jackets, I resent the fact that I live here sometimes but my girls have been here since kindergarden, everyone knows them (they have their cliques since K) and dad won't let us move for anything. Oh well, money goes fast and I'm learning better how to control my spending and maybe getting a full time job that doesn't involve my X.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
chillin'
December 28, 2006, 3:50 pm PST

where is it traditional?

Quote From: audraann

I think it's totally traditional to shove cake in each other's face. She should get over it. Its fun
I've never seen that done (except on T.V.).  It's not traditional in any of the cultures represented in my family. I don't think it's fun at all. I think it's humiliating and childish. I asked my husband about the so called tradition and he's never heard of it either, and the thinks it's borderline abusive. If it's one of those things you both want to do then go ahead, if one doesn't, then have some respect and don't.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
chillin'
December 28, 2006, 4:23 pm PST

do you have fendi? a whatie? ;-P

Quote From: kellybsierra

do you like shopping at goodwill? Not to be rude but you say you have three children? Shopping at goodwill must be hard for them to accept expecially if they are girls. How do they react when friends ask them where they got something from?This might be crazy of me but I would work three jobs around the clock before I would put goodwill clothes on my kids. Not that I'm a snob or too good but I want the best for my kids. I guess if it doesn't bother you or them thats great. You must live in an area where its accepted. We live in the biggest snob town :) No...its nice but lets say glamorous :) My twin girls are running around with blackberry pearls and fancy jackets, I resent the fact that I live here sometimes but my girls have been here since kindergarden, everyone knows them (they have their cliques since K) and dad won't let us move for anything. Oh well, money goes fast and I'm learning better how to control my spending and maybe getting a full time job that doesn't involve my X.

The best doesn't involve designer this and thats, or blackberry whatevers. If you are trying to teach your girls to be slaves and followers then you are doing a great job. I'd rather teach my children to have character. They will respect you, and others much more if they understand the work and sacrifice needed for all the status symbols. I feel badly for people that aren't brave enough to leave the pack. Your children won't remember all the things you bought them, but they will remember making cookies and having a food fight, or horseback riding in the snow, or skipping school to go to a movie, or just lazing about in pj's playing games. The only thing that matters in this world is the memories and the love you leave behind. Make your children strong, so they can survive anything with or without a blackberry.

 
First | Prev | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | Next | Last