Message Boards

Topic : Ready for Marriage?

Number of Replies: 1011
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:09:04 pm
Author : dataimport
Contemplating taking the plunge? Talk with others who are ready to make things permanent.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 29, 2007, 8:08 pm PDT

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: girl_2

I have been in the same relationship for more than a decade. It started when I was 17. It is the only serious relationship I have ever known. We are engaged to be married.

My problem is my ambivalence towards my partner. There are quite a few things that are a part of his personality that I wish were different to the point of thinking about these things most days. I don't care about menial things like who does the housework or the dishes.. but the differences about who we are fundamentally. For example, I love for people to be around; he finds flaws in most people and would rather stay at home than socialise. I hate the fact that he does not have many friends and often wonder why he doesn't. I think someone being really friendly and nice is the best qualities a person can have. So how did I end up with someone who's not really like this? But he does have really great qualities, I mean I'm not with a monster! He's also very loyal, generous, and funny.

I'm wondering if I can handle his character flaws and I am in a really bad mental state of fighting with my doubts. I think that maybe I am not right for him and vise versa.It's so hard to see the real situation from this close.

I do love him alot though. We have had a few serious talks about this and we've opened up to each other and I get reminded about how much I love him & all is good for a while, but soon the doubts and concerns return.

I feel hopeless and helpless. Most nights I have bad dreams and sometimes even wake up in a sweat dreaming of the actual wedding day.

Then why don't I leave? I sometimes think if I left I'd be back in a few days because I just love him and I would miss him terribly, and we are good friends and generally get along well together.
I don't know if my doubts are something I should be taking more notice of, or less. Sometimes I think, "I should listen to my instincts." But then again, there are other quotes like "feel the fear and do it anyway." I don't want to sucumb to fear, yet I don't want to ignore warning signs! How do I figure out what my doubts are? Warning signs and instinct, or fear of commitment and a "the grass is greener on the other side" syndrome? What if I leave and regret it for the rest of my life? What if I stay and regret it? How can I have kids in a relationship where I feel like this?
Will I ever be sure? About anyone?

I read somewhere that 20 percent of people in relationships have serious doubts about whether to stay or go, and undecided they just float along, unable to make a decision. I wonder if this is really true to the extent that I am feeling? Wouldn't I hear more about the subject if it were?

It's a hopeless situation that I feel is driving me literally crazy. I lack the experience & knowledge of being in different relationships which I think is a major aspect of me not being able to make a decision.

I have searched for answers within myself and elsewhere (shows, books, friends, family, counsellor) but am no closer. When I finish writing this I know I'll just tell myself I'm being silly and slip back into my normal routine and try to forget about the doubts. After all, I have a good life and am generally happy. At this rate I'll drift along not fully committing myself to this relationship, slipping in and out of dedication, all the time just getting older and still not married or with kids... not to mention all the time wasted thinking about this all the time when I could be doing something more constructive.

Any advice, or anyone that has felt the same, or does? Please help!

Is the only problem that you are more out going and he's more of a home body? 

 

My boyfriend and I are like this as well. He's doesn't really like going out much. I can usual get him to go out to one movie theater once every two or three months. So I think I understand how you feel.

 

I like to go out, so I do. I go out to dinner once every two weeks with some women I work with. Also I try to do something with one of my friends one night a week too.

 

Spending time out with my friends gives me the social life that I need and gives him time to spend doing what he wants, usually staying home.

 

But then when I get home I am glad to spend time with him. 

 

You can try finding something he likes to do and join him. My boyfriend likes to take the ATV's out four wheeling. It scares me half the time but is also exciting so I go. Plus I get to spend time with him out doing something he enjoys.  Then he's more willing to go out to a barbque or something I want to do.

 

Maybe you cant get everything you need from one person.  If you need a more active social life then get some friends to go out. Single friends, married friends, whatever. Plus if you are having so much fun He might even want to see what all the fun is and ask to go out one time too.

 

If not then do what you enjoy. Go to the gym, take an art class, join a book club. The more interesting you are the more interested he will be.  

 

But hey its your life and if you arent happy then get out there. Do something fun and different, maybe you'll find someone else along the way or maybe you'll go home and find you love staying in sometimes too. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 10:57 am PDT

Wedding

Quote From: amanda21a

 I am 25 years old and my Fiance is 27. We have been together for the last 4yrs. He proposed to me in september of this year and we have steadily been planning our wedding which is to take place in 5 months. The other day he had a fight or disagreement with his parents who in turn blamed me for the issue. I feel his parents don't really like me. After all this happened he now tells me he is having doubts when just 2 days ago everything was going fine and we were still getting married. Now he wants to put everything on hold. We just did our marriage course and have everything booked and everything. I am so hurt & heartbroken I just don't know what to do.

Have you ever had a good relationship with his parents, or have they always seemed to not like you? . Have you thought about things you could do or say to endear yourself to his parents? Just to make things go smoother?

I understand that you are very hurt, this is every bride’s nightmare. But, I urge you to think about the bigger picture- you wouldn’t want your fiance to go through with the wedding knowing that he had doubts, would you? Only to then have your marriage fall apart a few years later? I know that isn’t what you want to hear- you want him to come through the door and tell you he wasn’t thinking clearly, that he is ready to do this….but you have to be prepared for the worst. I urge you to put your focus on yourself right now, because you are the only person that you have any control over.

Do you know what your fiance’s specific doubts are? That is a good place to start to grow and heal, creating a solid foundation. I wish you the best.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 30, 2007, 11:02 am PDT

kids, no kids

Quote From: lost_in_books

My boyfriend and I got engaged on Valentines and we are planing our wedding for October. Everything is great but there is one thing that have not agreed on and thats children.  I am 24 and he is 28 neither of us have any children. He doesnt really want to have kids but thats becuase his friends who do have kids are not married or even together with their child's mother anymore.  He thinks children ruin the relationship. I am not sure if I want children or not. I can see life together either way. If we are without any then I see us going on vacations and enjoying time with each other. Then I can also see a life family functions, camping, PTA meetings, sporting events, Christmas morning, bike rides, ect with children. I just dont know how to figure out which life I want. Because children really do change your life and how you live it.  I feel like this is something we need to decide on.

Unless your fiance is saying that he absolutely does not ever want children, I urge you to just enjoy the time that you have together for now- you don’t have to worry about having children right now. It is understandable that your fiance has reservations about having children because of the struggles he sees other people going through, but hopefully, over time, he will come to realize your solid foundation is a wonderful place to have children, IF that is what you both want. It sounds like both of you know that you don’t want children right now, or anytime soon, so relax and allow yourself to enjoy all of your life experiences with one another. Good luck.

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
April 5, 2007, 10:53 pm PDT

some concerns

Let's start with the basics.  My girlfriend and I have been dating off and on for 5 years.  She now is wanting to know if we are on the same page.  She's been asking me for a while now if we are to get married. She wants to know if there is something to come of our relationship, which I understand completely.  I am concerned on a few things.  I'm scared of getting married and divorced for one, 2, we have almost nothing in common and that in itself REALLY FREAKS ME OUT!!! Our communication styles are totally different.  I have a real hard time just trying to get to know her. Even after 5 years.  I keep second guessing us, and wonder should I really be with her.  I love her, though it's hard "coping" with someone you don't have hardly anything in common with.  My main concern is with both properties.  If we were to get married, our communication is still a complicated matter, if it got bad enough then we get divorced. I don't want any of that to happen.  I ask for your help please.  thanks.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
confused
April 9, 2007, 7:30 pm PDT

non-committed man

help! i have been dating a wonderful man for two years now..98% of our relationship is great except the fact that he does not know whether he wants to get married again? have kids? he was divorced and it seems to be getting in the way of him thinking of the future...I have dreamed of being married since i was two and cannot imagine my life without kids and family...and he says he just wants to find someone to love and go from here...but at this point he is not sure if he will e ver get married..at times he says he thinks i am picking my dreams over him..but i try to explain that he is apart of the  dream..and if all i cared about was my dreams i would be married to the last ex...who was horrible...i love this man more than i ever thought i could love..he is my best friend..but at times i feel that i am giving more and he is just having his cake and eating it too..i know that he is struggling..and i am trying to understand and do what is best...but i am hurt by it..and do not know if we ever will be on the same page? so i guess if anyone had suggestions on what to do? say? or just get through the days of feeling bad.. i would really appreciate it...
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
April 10, 2007, 3:56 am PDT

My two sense

Quote From: gizonga

Let's start with the basics.  My girlfriend and I have been dating off and on for 5 years.  She now is wanting to know if we are on the same page.  She's been asking me for a while now if we are to get married. She wants to know if there is something to come of our relationship, which I understand completely.  I am concerned on a few things.  I'm scared of getting married and divorced for one, 2, we have almost nothing in common and that in itself REALLY FREAKS ME OUT!!! Our communication styles are totally different.  I have a real hard time just trying to get to know her. Even after 5 years.  I keep second guessing us, and wonder should I really be with her.  I love her, though it's hard "coping" with someone you don't have hardly anything in common with.  My main concern is with both properties.  If we were to get married, our communication is still a complicated matter, if it got bad enough then we get divorced. I don't want any of that to happen.  I ask for your help please.  thanks.
Let's face it, with the divorce rate so high we all have concens about getting married and "being" happily married let alone going through a divorce!  Your communication skills are what would concern me the most as strong communication skills are essential in a marriage. She more than likely grew up in a home where she was unable or afraid to speak of how she felt emotionally or was hurt badly in a previous relationship where she is afraid to show her true feelings.She may have an emotional wal put up to protect herself from being hurt again. (Most issues go back to our childhoods).  If you believe that she may be the one for you then I would definately go to counseling together to learn how to improve that aspect of your relationship. As far as having things in common - if you two have the same goals, dreams, values, beliefs, morals, character etc..  Aren't those the most important things you should have in common?  They are the ones that matter the most.  My husband and I are exact opposites but what holds us together aren't "hobbies" but who we are inside as we do share the same beliefs, morals etc.......
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
April 10, 2007, 3:38 pm PDT

scared mother

i am a 19 year old mother of a 3 month old baby and want so advice and tips if anyone out there can help me.

I have been with my fiancee on and off for almost 5 years. i have done alot of things to hurt our releationship but i was young.

April of 06 we found out that i was pregnant he never wanted me to keep it and i wonder why it was so easy for him to say that. He was mad very mad when i told him i wouldnt have an abortion and i went and moved back with my mother to get some support. we talked all the time and after a few months went by he wanted me to move with him so i worked hard got my hours and quickly moved with him cause i wanted my daughter to have and know her father. Soon after i moved we got engaged and now im not sure if im ready for marrage. im 19 and almost 20 and dont want to be with him just cause we have a child together. i have told him that im not ready to marry but he wants it to happen in the new year. i dont feel happy with him and i cant go on with my life with him just for my daughter. I nknow i could do it without him cause i have alot of support from my family but i do want my daughter to grow up with her father around. If i go our engagement will be off and i will be over 3 hours away. I need him in her life but i feel like im to young to commit to anything. Im young. Should i be free? 

 

Message Emote
blank
April 10, 2007, 10:27 pm PDT

yes, I can relate

Quote From: girl_2

I have been in the same relationship for more than a decade. It started when I was 17. It is the only serious relationship I have ever known. We are engaged to be married.

My problem is my ambivalence towards my partner. There are quite a few things that are a part of his personality that I wish were different to the point of thinking about these things most days. I don't care about menial things like who does the housework or the dishes.. but the differences about who we are fundamentally. For example, I love for people to be around; he finds flaws in most people and would rather stay at home than socialise. I hate the fact that he does not have many friends and often wonder why he doesn't. I think someone being really friendly and nice is the best qualities a person can have. So how did I end up with someone who's not really like this? But he does have really great qualities, I mean I'm not with a monster! He's also very loyal, generous, and funny.

I'm wondering if I can handle his character flaws and I am in a really bad mental state of fighting with my doubts. I think that maybe I am not right for him and vise versa.It's so hard to see the real situation from this close.

I do love him alot though. We have had a few serious talks about this and we've opened up to each other and I get reminded about how much I love him & all is good for a while, but soon the doubts and concerns return.

I feel hopeless and helpless. Most nights I have bad dreams and sometimes even wake up in a sweat dreaming of the actual wedding day.

Then why don't I leave? I sometimes think if I left I'd be back in a few days because I just love him and I would miss him terribly, and we are good friends and generally get along well together.
I don't know if my doubts are something I should be taking more notice of, or less. Sometimes I think, "I should listen to my instincts." But then again, there are other quotes like "feel the fear and do it anyway." I don't want to sucumb to fear, yet I don't want to ignore warning signs! How do I figure out what my doubts are? Warning signs and instinct, or fear of commitment and a "the grass is greener on the other side" syndrome? What if I leave and regret it for the rest of my life? What if I stay and regret it? How can I have kids in a relationship where I feel like this?
Will I ever be sure? About anyone?

I read somewhere that 20 percent of people in relationships have serious doubts about whether to stay or go, and undecided they just float along, unable to make a decision. I wonder if this is really true to the extent that I am feeling? Wouldn't I hear more about the subject if it were?

It's a hopeless situation that I feel is driving me literally crazy. I lack the experience & knowledge of being in different relationships which I think is a major aspect of me not being able to make a decision.

I have searched for answers within myself and elsewhere (shows, books, friends, family, counsellor) but am no closer. When I finish writing this I know I'll just tell myself I'm being silly and slip back into my normal routine and try to forget about the doubts. After all, I have a good life and am generally happy. At this rate I'll drift along not fully committing myself to this relationship, slipping in and out of dedication, all the time just getting older and still not married or with kids... not to mention all the time wasted thinking about this all the time when I could be doing something more constructive.

Any advice, or anyone that has felt the same, or does? Please help!

Hi -- I can really, really relate to what you're going through. I've been there. About 10 years ago (when I was 21), I was engaged to my high-school/college sweetheart, who I had been with for nearly six years. Even though I'd spent years dreaming about our wedding day, by the time we actually got engaged I began to have serious, gigantic doubts. It took me a long time to acknowledge it to myself and even longer to tell him the truth. I, too, became very anxious when thinking about our wedding day, even breaking into a cold sweat. I had the same thoughts about our differences, about whether we were right for each other, etc. I was plagued with anxiety for months after we announced our engagement--absolutely tormented with doubts. I began to feel like I was suffocating in the relationship, too, and had a longing to be free from it and to learn who I was separate from him.

 

Over time, I slowly realized the truth (for me, doesn't mean this is true for you). My fiance and I had grown apart immensely in those years we were together (after all, we started dating when he was 14 and me 15). I had become so attached to him that I had no idea who I was, but I also felt deep down that I was fundamentally different from him, in a way I hadn't realized before. Our common ground had shrunk considerably. I finally had to admit that my gut and my heart were telling me that I wasn't going to be happy with him, and that we weren't right for each other.

 

Breaking up with him is still the hardest thing I've ever done, and it was very painful, I won't lie. He was heartbroken and angry, and I was devastated too. But looking back from where I am now, I know I made the right decision. The pain passed, and now I feel peaceful -- I believe that we are better off where we are today.

 

Ironically, however, I'm going through something similar now, and the answers don't seem quite so clear. I've been dating someone for 2 years, and we are compatible in many ways. He is pretty clear that he wants to marry me, and I'm hesitant. Again, I have doubts creeping in; again I'm wondering if we're right for each other. So after thinking I had it all figured out 10 years ago, I'm back in the same place and I don't know what to do! I'm starting to wonder if it's me!

 

I will pass on a few things that I've heard could be helpful, and maybe they can help me too. First of all, the good ol' pros and cons list. List the things that you love about your partner, and then list the things that bother you. Consider how important the things in the "con" column are to your happiness and satisfaction in a relationship. Then, list the qualities you're seeking in a partner, as well as the things that are "deal-breakers" -- qualities/problems you absolutely can't live with. How does your partner stack up compared to those? Are the things that bother you on the list of "deal-breakers"?

 

I, too, have been living in this state of limbo, not making a decision, being afraid I'll make the wrong one. I think it would be a good idea if we both got the stuff in our heads on paper and really identified what's going on.

 

And in the end, trust your heart, trust yourself. If you have doubts, there's a reason. Maybe it means "not now," maybe it means "not with him," maybe it just means you're scared. But don't let others pressure you or rush you -- listen really closely to yourself. I think if we both do that, we'll find the answers.

 

Good luck and take care!

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
April 11, 2007, 12:37 am PDT

Do what you need to do for "YOU" and never settle

Quote From: scaredmother

i am a 19 year old mother of a 3 month old baby and want so advice and tips if anyone out there can help me.

I have been with my fiancee on and off for almost 5 years. i have done alot of things to hurt our releationship but i was young.

April of 06 we found out that i was pregnant he never wanted me to keep it and i wonder why it was so easy for him to say that. He was mad very mad when i told him i wouldnt have an abortion and i went and moved back with my mother to get some support. we talked all the time and after a few months went by he wanted me to move with him so i worked hard got my hours and quickly moved with him cause i wanted my daughter to have and know her father. Soon after i moved we got engaged and now im not sure if im ready for marrage. im 19 and almost 20 and dont want to be with him just cause we have a child together. i have told him that im not ready to marry but he wants it to happen in the new year. i dont feel happy with him and i cant go on with my life with him just for my daughter. I nknow i could do it without him cause i have alot of support from my family but i do want my daughter to grow up with her father around. If i go our engagement will be off and i will be over 3 hours away. I need him in her life but i feel like im to young to commit to anything. Im young. Should i be free? 

Getting married for the wrong reasons would clearly be a mistake.  He will always be your daughters father regardless of where you live or if you were married or not.  You would be doing a huge injustice to yourself as well as to your daughter by marrying a man just because he fathered a child with you.  I commend you for realizing this now before you walk down that aisle.   You should want to get married because you want to spend the rest of your life with this man and it's evident that you you can't make that committment because it's not how you feel.

 

Don't feel guilty for how you feel. 

 

Make arrangements for child support  and set up a visitation schedule that works for the both of you.  You sound like you've gt a good head on your shoulders, don't allow yourself to be talked into someting that you clearly are not ready for.

 
User Mood
Hyper

Message Emote
confused
April 11, 2007, 7:50 am PDT

Should I

I have a small issue on my hands that I need advise on. I am dating a guy who is 9 years older then me. I just turned 21 a few weeks ago. He brought up the subject of marriage about a week ago. I love him to death and I do want to marry him but the catch is I am still in school I have about two years left and I would really like to finish before I make the commitment of marriage. However, on the other hand I think why am I waiting school is still going to be there I can finish even if I am married. I feel bad for making him wait for my selfish wants. Any advise would be awesome.....

 
First | Prev | 74 | 75 | 76 | 77 | 78 | 79 | 80 | 81 | 82 | 83 | Next | Last