Message Boards

Topic : Ready for Marriage?

Number of Replies: 1011
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:09:04 pm
Author : dataimport
Contemplating taking the plunge? Talk with others who are ready to make things permanent.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 28, 2006, 6:20 am PDT

extended family

I have been dating a woman for almost two months now. I have nevr been in love this way in my life, i never realized how real it all was. i have no doubt in any way she is the person i want to be with the rest of my life. things are really great between us. but she sometimes seems to get upset that i have been married once before and have two children from that marriage. i was married for about 10 years and it was i mistake from the very start. the marriage was a result of a pregnancy, which is not the reason you marry someone i realize now. she was unfaithful several times during the marraige and because of the kids i tried to stick with it. i was just not capable of doing that and withdrew more and more. after the dvorce i pretty much just completely shut down. gave up on people and love all together. figured i would live out the rest of my life that way. I dated but was never anything serious or really anything i was much interested in. but i was always up front with people about that, i never wanted to misslead anyone. so when this girl came along, needless to say it was a total surprise. i guess thats maybe the way it happens sometimes, when you least expect it. the issue is that she seems to get upset sometimes about the ex wife and the kids as well. we have talked about the possibilty of a future together. marraiage, kids and so on. we both want the same things. she has never been married or had children. she asks me how us have a baby will work since i already have two. i dont know how to reassure her and comfort her to the fact that i want a family with her, and that is something i have never had. i understand her concerns, i just dont know how to express how i feel about this. i want to be a part of something bigger than just me. im sure it will be fine once she meets the kids. they are both so sweet and i know she loves me so im sure she will love them as well. but she seems to get jelous over my ex. and i dont even know how to react to that. i have no feelings for this person. she has been horrible throughout the entire marriage and seperation and divorce. i dont claim to be a saint or anything but she has really been impossible, hurtful, manipulative, you name it. its finally gotten to the point where i cant even feel the hate i once felt towards her. to me she simply doesn't exist. so how can i deal with the woman i love being worried that there is still something there. i understand her concerns, just not sure what to do about it. she says it is her problem to deal with, she loves me and she just needs to get it worked out for herself. should i just give her time or try to help. when she tells me her concerns i just get crushed. here is a woman that has shown me what true love really feels like and she feels treatened by someone i have no feelings for at all. i dont want this to keep building into a bigger problem... 

 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
May 28, 2006, 7:39 am PDT

Some People!!!

Quote From: netsurfer6

Men are cowards.  They like the status quo.  This is his way of telling you he's tired of your relationship but doesn't have the guts to break it off. 

  

This is where you have to be mature, realize that the relationship is falling way short of meeting your needs.  You should explain to him that you are unhappy and that's why you are leaving. 

  

Don't tell him where you're going.  If he asks, tell him you haven't decided yet and when you're ready to speak to him again, you'll let him know.  Then drop him from your life and move on. 

  

  

I would not drop anyone, especially like THAT! that's is immature, rude and very mean. Would it break your heart if you were left like that, because the last time I checked men are human too and they also have feelings. 

  

So, here's my take on this one... 

Sit down and talk to him, it never hurts, how do you think I got engaged, I have no ring, we have the date set both families and our friends know. Sure I would LOVE to have a ring too, I even showed him one I like but he says he won't buy it for me because it doesn't cost as much as the promise ring I already were everyday. 

Talking helps a lot of problems in relationships. Talk about everthing, never hold back how you feel. Look at me I have been with my fiance for 11 years (since I was 15) and we're still together. WE TALK.  There is no running away, no immature BS. Just talk whene there is a problem. It doesn't hurt, and like my fiance always says, "it doesn't hurt to ask". I hope this helps you. 

 
User Mood
Nervous

Message Emote
blank
May 28, 2006, 1:50 pm PDT

Just keep in mind

Quote From: lsgunter

I am newly engaged of about 3 months and I'm 20 years old.  Many of my friends are also getting engaged and getting married.  I am very worried that my generation isn't taking marriage very seriously in the sense that they have no plan - they just want to "live on love."  I think it's great that they have that passion and commitment, but I believe marriage is entering into sharing your entire life with a person which includes finances, jobs, and religion, among others.  Many of my friends don't have any financial plan or even full-time jobs.  Because so many marriages end in divorce especially over financial problems, it really scares me for them.  My fiance and I have already started to map out our budget for when we get married in about 10 months, and it really makes me feel a lot more secure that we have a plan.  I know this doesn't ensure that we won't encounter money problems, but I do feel like it is more preventative than doing nothing.  This could be a big concern of mine because I'm in school to be a marriage and family therapist, but does anyone else share my fear for society's lack of seriousness concerning marriage?

That  you need to think of you and what make you guys happy. I love my husban and I would never change that or all the fights in the world. But  to me a big wedding is just a waste. I did not walk down the aisle. I gohat t married @ the court house and NO i do not regret that. I you get married  in jeans and a T-shrit. Thats fine too. There is no way i would spend what my best friend did to get married in 2 weeks we are up to 20,000. that is a basic.  

mandi  

 
User Mood
Nervous

Message Emote
sad
May 28, 2006, 1:55 pm PDT

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: ari_djsmom

I would not drop anyone, especially like THAT! that's is immature, rude and very mean. Would it break your heart if you were left like that, because the last time I checked men are human too and they also have feelings. 

  

So, here's my take on this one... 

Sit down and talk to him, it never hurts, how do you think I got engaged, I have no ring, we have the date set both families and our friends know. Sure I would LOVE to have a ring too, I even showed him one I like but he says he won't buy it for me because it doesn't cost as much as the promise ring I already were everyday. 

Talking helps a lot of problems in relationships. Talk about everthing, never hold back how you feel. Look at me I have been with my fiance for 11 years (since I was 15) and we're still together. WE TALK.  There is no running away, no immature BS. Just talk whene there is a problem. It doesn't hurt, and like my fiance always says, "it doesn't hurt to ask". I hope this helps you. 

That was a little bit childish to do. I mean come on . We are all adults here. I think there a I know when i cought my husban talking to some one on the net i was mad but we have talked and  we are still working things out . It takes awhile befor you start to for give. BUT YOU NEVRE FORGET. And i think that is my problem here.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 28, 2006, 6:15 pm PDT

RUN LONELY GRIL, RUN !

Quote From: lonelygril

I'm not quite certain that you have hit it on the head.  We are planning to buy a house or property and build a house closer to his job.  We even talk about us having kids one day.  I am just now starting to think I want kids and he is still in the not ready stage.  I don't think he is going to leave me or that he is tired of me.  Just the other day I have spoken to evidentally a very wise lady.  She told me its not me, it's him being a man and some men need to look at other ladys and do the sort of things he is doing.  As for the match.com, he is not subscribed to it and able to talk to any of the women on there.  I am keeping a check on that and believe me as soon as he does subscribe I will loose it. 
  I TOTALLY AGREE WITH NETSURFER THAT YOU SHOULD DUMP THIS GUY !!!   1. Someone who cares about you... does not check out other girls infront of you...(some  never do, even  behnd your back-- even at their friends prompting)   2.  Anyone who tells you that it's "him being a man and some men need to look at other lady's and do that sort of thing ..."  is as in much need of professional help as you are.   3.  Any guy going on Match. com to "check it out" ... is fishing.... do you get it ?  He's seeing who else out there is available.  I dont care if he subscribed or not-- that is a slap in the face of your relationship.  Next he'll have girls calling his place to set up dates, and he'll use you for his answering service.  He'll probably tell them your his sister....and no, Im not kidding.   There are so many real men out there, interested in JUST YOU, who does not have a need to check out other women, surf Match.com or any other DATING site, and would show you respect whether he was with you in your presence or not.   DO NOT MOVE IN WITH HIM ! ... because if you do, your going to find yourself 5 years from now, wondering why your Still not married, and how he never spends anytime with you-- or the kid you create.  Your worth more.  I'm with netsurfer... I'd dump this bozo like a hot rock... but I guess some "lonelygrils" are desperate for male attention. I pity you Lonelygril.  I pity the fact you never had anyone tell you that your worth something more than this brokedown losers second or even 3rd best.  Have some self respect-- there is WAY better out there than what your putting up with...    If your still in school, stay in, and if you didn't graduate, I suggest you call your school and find out how you can get back in to graduate.  Then go to school, get a career you like, make a ton of money, meet a billion people and travel the world !... Yeah you can, and this hoser your with now, he wont remember your name long enough to walk to his car honey... That's not a joke either... and somewhere in side of you,  Im telling the truth, and you know it.   Go have fun, spend your time wisely...   OMG... "Some men are just like that ".... OMG !.... No, those are the PLAYERS... Run as fast as you can....he's a hose beast !... lose him.  Do better, be better...You deserve better.  OMG, and in your travels, when you meet a real man... and I mean  a REAL MAN-- who only has eyes for you... it will blow you away.. and you'll wonder why you spent 5 minutes with this turd your with now...   Suprise him, dump him... and go live your life.  Give yourself adventures your proud to tell your grand kids about.  Not about some hoser who surfs match. com while he talks you into being his bed warmer.  You can do better !
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 28, 2006, 6:24 pm PDT

What is the Time Lapse on a "promise" ring ?

  

  

 is it a year ?  2 years ?  

  

  How long should a woman place herself on "hold"  when given a promise ring ?  

  

 I ask because I am seeing this trend... where a guy will give a woman a "promise ring" and there they sit.... 3, 5, 14 years later... 2 kids... and no marriage.    In my state that presents a problem because my state does not recognize common law marriage unless that common law marriage is recognized in another state.  Alot of people are under the misconception that  California does recognize common law marriage after 10 years.  No, in Texas, if you live together for 1 year, and refer to one another in public as wife or husband-- your cosidered common law, but in CA, it does not matter how long you live together. your not married.  CA's take on it is-- if you dont care enough to make it legal-- neither do we "...  

  

 So, alot of women are contributing to a household, house payments, car payments, etc...without benefit of marriage, and if the property is in HIS name,(as it usually is-- Cars, Home, dog, etc)  and they break up ?  She is shiza out of luck for her contribution (more to marriage than a peice of paper ladies)  so since the new scam is to giver her a promise ring, and then move in together under the pretense of "Common Law"  what is the life expectancy of a promise ring ?  How long should one place herself "on hold"  ? 

  

This is one of the reasons I am against women moving in with men, without benefit of marriage.  You stand to lose alot more than just your sanity.  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 28, 2006, 6:38 pm PDT

Your way too mature for this guy...

Quote From: mariesw49

The guy I have been with for 4 years and have lived together for  3 of those years.  Well he retired at a young age and we moved to another state *he is semi retired works alittle just to have something to do.) We owned a home together but when we moved down here we decided we each should buy our own place and we were both in total agreement with this.  Well we decided he would  move into my home and we would rent his out.  After he moved in with me, everytime something does not go right or he feel frustrated or says I nag to much he leaves and goes to his place for days, this is not a new habit of his!  Well I allow him to do this to do as he needs to get over his frustration  Well this has happened so often and finally this last time he emailed me and said he wanted to move back with me, he missed me and loved me!  This time I said we needed to talk first and he didn't like this (before he would  just came back and I allowed it)  this time I couldn't.  He said he understood but then in the next breath said to me he feels I just want a casual relationship and he needs to think about whether we should be an exclusive couple or he should start playing the field!  I felt this was a threat he was intimidating me as he knows how much I love him!  I have stuck to my guns and have told him we need to have a long talk and should start dating again but he is welcome over here anytime just not moving back in till we can come to terms we both can agree on.  Now he is saying things at times that he knows will hurt me but I am trying to keep my cool.  He has said when he feels he is being treated unfairly or I'm talking crazy (I don't feel I am) he will do whatever he needs to to strike back!  

  

This is where we are at, him acting cool, or avoiding me or at times acting around me like everythig is fine and then I will just be the old me again.  I have also had issues of trust with him in the past with his ex and have told him he needs to earm my trust, he says I bring up things from the past (which yes I do as he keeps repeating the actions that lead to my no trusting him, I don't know what he is doing this time,) I want to trust him but I feel he needs  to earm it.  He says I need to put the past in the past, I want to but how do I when his actions are the same actions that caused me to not trust him, he maybe doing it again maybe not, I don't know, but I know I do not want to doubt this time.  I also do not want him to move back in then be gone again the next time he gets upset.  He has a short fuse, he gets very defensive whenever I try to talk to him.  He also expects me to do the running to him most of the time.  I do admit he is much better then he was but still has a ways to go.  

  

Any suggestions or insights here if you would I would appreciate it.  

  

  

  

 As I was reading your post (I'm 42 by the way)  I was laughing about his antics.  Re-read what you wrote about him.. 

  

 "He will do whatever he needs to, to strike back !"  Does that sound like a grown man to you ?  

  

 You have trust issues with him from the past... (Good for you for not allowing that basket case to move back in )  and  he keeps REPEATING THE ACTIONS THAT LEAD TO MY NO TRUSTING HIMI".. Darlin' right there... You dont need a private detective to know what he's up to.   

  

I have met so many older men like this.  I know you dont want to be alone, but they're are men much nicer and more suited to you that this old fart... ha, ha.   He's still toying with his ex, and Im willing to bet he's toying with her as well.   You can do better.  I understand you want to be friends, but honestly, if this were me-- I'd cut him loose, join a golf group and go find others with my own maturity level.  He's probably been doing this his Whole life....and honestly, how much time do we have left for this kind of drama ??  

  

 Im glad you wont let him move back in, because you right (as experience has taught you) that he'll just be gone again, the next time he gets upset".  If I were you, I'd find other friends... this can't be good for you with all the stress, and I think  your teaching him to be more respectful of you by not letting him move back in, or come and go as he pleases like you used to.   Still I had to laugh " He says he's being treated unfairly or I'm talking crazy and he will do whatever he needs to-- to protect himself ".   Funny how you get blamed for standing up for yourself..  BRAVO ! 

Well, a good cure of him might be your absence for a little bit.  Amazing how that clears the senses for them when they get to be spoiled brats :)   Good Luck.  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 28, 2006, 6:49 pm PDT

Jealousy is HER Problem.

Quote From: samiam35

I have been dating a woman for almost two months now. I have nevr been in love this way in my life, i never realized how real it all was. i have no doubt in any way she is the person i want to be with the rest of my life. things are really great between us. but she sometimes seems to get upset that i have been married once before and have two children from that marriage. i was married for about 10 years and it was i mistake from the very start. the marriage was a result of a pregnancy, which is not the reason you marry someone i realize now. she was unfaithful several times during the marraige and because of the kids i tried to stick with it. i was just not capable of doing that and withdrew more and more. after the dvorce i pretty much just completely shut down. gave up on people and love all together. figured i would live out the rest of my life that way. I dated but was never anything serious or really anything i was much interested in. but i was always up front with people about that, i never wanted to misslead anyone. so when this girl came along, needless to say it was a total surprise. i guess thats maybe the way it happens sometimes, when you least expect it. the issue is that she seems to get upset sometimes about the ex wife and the kids as well. we have talked about the possibilty of a future together. marraiage, kids and so on. we both want the same things. she has never been married or had children. she asks me how us have a baby will work since i already have two. i dont know how to reassure her and comfort her to the fact that i want a family with her, and that is something i have never had. i understand her concerns, i just dont know how to express how i feel about this. i want to be a part of something bigger than just me. im sure it will be fine once she meets the kids. they are both so sweet and i know she loves me so im sure she will love them as well. but she seems to get jelous over my ex. and i dont even know how to react to that. i have no feelings for this person. she has been horrible throughout the entire marriage and seperation and divorce. i dont claim to be a saint or anything but she has really been impossible, hurtful, manipulative, you name it. its finally gotten to the point where i cant even feel the hate i once felt towards her. to me she simply doesn't exist. so how can i deal with the woman i love being worried that there is still something there. i understand her concerns, just not sure what to do about it. she says it is her problem to deal with, she loves me and she just needs to get it worked out for herself. should i just give her time or try to help. when she tells me her concerns i just get crushed. here is a woman that has shown me what true love really feels like and she feels treatened by someone i have no feelings for at all. i dont want this to keep building into a bigger problem... 

Dear SamIam35,  

  

   I too, left my husband after he cheated, and I also have kids from that marriage. (notice I said Marriage ladies, not shack up) and I too have come across people, threatened by my previous relationship and having a "Repore" with my ex.  

  

  They dont seem to understand that I have to deal with his guys visitation with my kids.  I have to speak to him for the next 11 years.  I know what you mean by not even being capable of feeling hate for them for all the stuff they pull.  They don't seem to get that your lessons from that relationship are engrained, and no way would you go back.  

  

 Now, the only question I have is-- if you NOT behaving in a way that makes her suspicious, clandestine meetings with the ex,  secret phone calls, you know the games....because if your not then she has no reason to suspect any wrong doing on your part.  If you are where you say are and your with who you say your with, then the insecurities are on her side, and they are her problem.  So long as you dont have a past history of cheating on your present relationship, then she has no RIGHT to question you.  The jealousy is HER Problem .  What drives me nuts is when potential dating material wants to punish me for their past relationships.  Just becasue they got cheated on by some girl in college, they suspect every woman of cheating.  Honestly, they are not worth my time and effort, when I have done nothing to earn their suspects.  That's just me.  I know I deserve better than that, and I am in a committed relationship now.  Each relationship has it's own merits, and the past should not be a factor if the person who hurt her is NOT you.   I can understand mistrust if it's earned, but I never understood this guilty before the crime is done stuff.  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 28, 2006, 6:53 pm PDT

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: money1

dr phii, why do we always have to convince women of all ages when a man does not want to get married that is what it means?  I had to learn the hard way several times and am currently married very happy.  I had to wait 12 years for him!  I have friends who constantly talks about their boyfriends who do not want to get married.  they have great excuses, I got hurt, i have been cheated on, used, i have been married before, im not emotionally ready or finanicially ready.  then there is the but i love you! please! they even buy them engagement rings to keep them quiet and keep getting fed, sex, etc. wah wah wah...  when someone puts but in there you should worry.   I keep telling them not to hurt their feelings just like someone told me I wasted problably 3 years HE DOES NOT WANT TO GET MARRIED PERIOD!  no one wants to here the truth and then we are all crying about it several months or years later because we did not listen.  there are plenty of men who want to get married.  leave the ones that don't alone.

 Money 1 

  

 VERY WELL STATED !  :)   Now if we can just train the women to stop hearing what they want to hear, and start listening to what they dont like... the whole species will be better off... (alot less fatherless children for starters)  Bums are bums... 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 28, 2006, 7:01 pm PDT

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: carmelo75

A little background info first. My fiance is the father of my youngest daughter. We met in college about 14 years ago. We had a on and off again relationship, because of him. He decided to be with someone else after I got pregnant.  About 10 years ago he came to me and really impressed upon me that I was the one he wanted to be with, that he wanted to marry me etc. We were living in different cities in the same state, which was the case most of the time.  Anyway...he cancelled a date with me once when he was supposed to come in to town and go see a comedy show with me. Come to find out he did come to town...he did go to the show, but with an ex-girlfriend, who also had a ring she called an engagement ring. It's a small world because one of my best friend's was in town, met a girl friend of hers to go to the same show, and the girl's boyfriend just happened to know "my guy". That's how I found out. I ended up finding out that he was living with the ex. So of course I knew I had to move on. I became celibate that day and have remained so until now. Sorry this is taking me so long. I dated someone else for about 5 years, that relationship ended, but  while I was still in that relationship, my daughter's father came to me again. He gave me details of bad relationships, women using him and professed his love for me once again. I didn't give in then. But two years after my other relationship ended I started dating him again long distance. He said he wanted to get married etc. but then my heart gets broken when he says  he got a young woman pregnant. He swears it was a mishap due to drinking and partying too hard and says he does not even remember the act. Several people I know think he should have a DNA test and that I should not marry him until he does. He has matured a great deal within the last two years, but I still have a hard time getting over this last incident with the child. I love him but I worry he will choose someone else over me again. Any thoughts?

 A. I am just a font... I have no powers here.  

  

B.  He should get a DNA test, because he will be paying child support if that child is his.  So he should be paying for a child he KNOWS is his.  

  

C.  If you should decide to keep him in your life-- as Dr. Phil says "The best predictor of future behavior is past behavior"  and so you know the score.  Personally, I wouldn't, but then again-- Im just a font, and I have no power.   :)  

  

D. If you should choose to keep him in your life, marry him-- he has this child.  Which means you have to deal with the kid--and any future, present children you have,  even when your apart from his father.  Expect to be the "caregiver 'but in the end you have a bonus kid... it's your choice.  If that is his child, it's a package deal, and more than likely-- your going to be dealing with the mom, not your boyfriend.  (He's not a very good boyfriend is he ?)    

  

e.  P.s... .You can't save your boyfriend  from himself, but you might beable to save that kid....if it's his kid, and he really should find out.   If he "loves" you so much-- he should get a test.  

 
First | Prev | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | Next | Last