Message Boards

Topic : 12/26 Cheating Disasters

Number of Replies: 374
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 27, 2006, 02:15:59 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 10/31/06) Cheating can take many forms: secret meetings, romantic text messages and flirtatious e-mails, among others? Dr. Phil’s guests say they need help moving past an infidelity. Noelle says she can’t stop obsessing about her husband, Robert’s, affair. She calls the other woman "a whore" and even beats Robert up in front of their children. Find out what happens when the ex-mistress weighs in. Can Robert and Noelle get closure and get their family back on track? Then, Randy recently found out his wife, Kally, was cheating on him while he was at work. He says Kally went on dates with another man and even brought the kids along! Kally says her husband’s controlling and jealous ways made her cheat. Will Randy and Kally be able to salvage their relationship? Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More December 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 31, 2006, 9:33 am PST

It wasn't your place to tell husband

Quote From: debhgn

My daughter recently had a one night stand with a guy  who works with her husband.  They were out at a bar one night, her husband wanted to go home and go to bed, he left her there with his friend and figured she was in good hands.

This is absolutely totally out of character for her to have done this.  Completely opposite of what she believes and stands for.  She lost a baby just a few short weeks prior to this incident and had lost her grandfather just 2 months prior to that.

She told me about it the very next day and I decided that I needed to tell her husband.  Many factors played a part in my deciding to do this, but one was that he has tried to commit suicie on more than once occasion and I felt that he needed to find this out in a "controlled enviorment" so to speak.

They have been separated for 4 weeks now, she is living with me.  For the first couple of weeks he was very upset as expected.  He then started to examine how this could have happened and actually got over it for a few days, long enough for them to take a mini vacation together.

Then suddenly out of the blue he turned into a raging bull.  He has torn their home all to peices, even tried to burn it down.  Holes in the wall, if it was glass it's now broken, and even cutting down some trees that her beloved grandfather had gotten her prior to his death.  He has done several thousand dollars worth of damage to the home.

As for her husband, he is a 30 year old child, she is 25.  He has tried to commit suicide twice, he has a very bad porn addiction, he is controlling and unloving and selfish.

She has lost all self esteem that she had prior to her marriage to him, has a low self image, and has become depressed.  She has lost all respect or desire for him because of his porn addiction.  She says it makes her sick to her stomach.

He has taken this opportunity to unleash terror on her and everyone around.  He now feels he has the total right and actually duty to inflict his rage at anytime on anyone.  In fact when he tried to burn down the house and she threaten to call the police he was outraged to think she would call the police on him since it was her that cheated.

I too am interested in this up coming show and feedback from the members here.  I have a mess on my hands and don't know where to turn.


You should not have told your daughter's abusive, porn watching. suicidal husband that she cheated on him.  You just gave him more amunition to continue his abusive ways.  I think all you did was add gasoline to an already volatile relationship.  He feels now he has a total right.  Yes you do have a mess on your hands.  I hope she does not have children with this monster.  It will be easier for her to totally separate from him.  I fear for the safety of your daughter.  She needs to get as far away from him as possible.  Is there a place in another state where she can go to live?

 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
October 31, 2006, 9:36 am PST

Wake Up

Quote From: myersmb7

My boyfriend of 5 years came to me and told me he had made a mistake and he had cheated on me.  He begged my forgiveness and asked me to give him a chance to prove himself to me.  Since that time he has asked me to marry him (one plus I think) but on the negative, has done nothing but push me away.  He states that I just need to relax and when am I going to get over this.  If I ask him thing like "what did you do today" he says I am questioning him, he tells me I never give him any space and one time when I checked out his story he told me I was snooping and he hates a snoop.  Everything indicates to me that he is cheating again but he say no.  When I started seeing him he was involved with a married woman, he cheated on me with a married woman, and I found out through all of this that he cheated on his ex-wife with a married woman and I was not quite divorced when he started up with me.  Seems to be a pattern but I want to give him the benefit of the doubt (I don't know why).  I do I get past the affair if he will not talk to me and if I get upset and try to discuss how I am feeling with him he shuts me down and says he is tired of the crap.  Shouldn't he be kissing my ass.  How do I move on and also if I shouldn't....How do I say goodbye?

 

Desperate for help.

If you've watched the Dr. Phil show, you know one of his favorite expressions is that the best predictor of future behavior is past behavior.  If your boyfriend really loves you and want a real marriage, he will be hapy to "kiss your ass" from now until the end of time and be grateful for the chance.  How do you say goodbye?  GOODBYE.  Run, do not walk, away froma marriage that will be a disaster.  Read these other mesages.  You have a chance to get away before marriage complicates things further.  If he won't discuss things that are very important to you now, what do you think the future would hold?  Take it from a guy.  Get out now!  Wake up and smell the bull.
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
October 31, 2006, 9:42 am PST

I Think You Know

Quote From: anniesaints

After 15 years of marriage that has included plenty of verbal and emotional abuse and a workaholic husband, I found myself attracted to a man who is attentive and sweet. We were very good friends who became closer ending up in an emotional affair. Although I feel very guilty and confused, I also feel like I've put up with 15 years of crap.  At least I didn't have sex with the guy. Now my husband wants to make a fresh start.  He tells me I'm the love of his life, he doesn't want to lose me (why all of the sudden?) and he manages to remind me frequently that I cheated on him.  I think my behavior is mild compared to his.  Now what?
Today seems to be my day for responding to people.  I've just been there myself and have very strong feelings about thise subject.  This other guy did meet a need your husband refused to even acknowledge.  You did not have an affair.  You broke it off in time.  That you husband would use that like a club over your head  is inexcusable.  If you want to save this marriage, and if he really does, get counseling.  Remember, you turned to someone for compassion, not passion.
 
User Mood
Weird

Message Emote
blank
October 31, 2006, 9:43 am PST

10/31 Cheating Disasters

Quote From: be_blessed7

I feel terrible for you. I went through the same thing 2 years ago. My husband cheated on me our first year of marriage, while I was pregnant. He lied about it the whole affair and then for a whole year after the affair ended. It drove me CRAZY...I seriously felt like I was losing my mind. I knew something happened but he was such a good liar, he actually turned it around, making me think I was the crazy, jealous person who needed to get a grip. Finally I found out about the affair, as soon as I knew it to be true I couldn't get enough information...I wanted every detail and I drove myself crazy all over again. A year after the affair happened, finding out, was like living it all over again. If you know he cheated on you, there are always going to be things you will not know. We love the men in our lives so much sometimes we are able to believe anything. "What is done in darkness will one day be shouted on the rooftops". All of his ways will be found out...don't drive yourself mad trying to find out every detail, it makes it worse on you. Remember every detail you know is one more detail you have to forget and forgive. I stayed with my husband and we are doing much better. What helped us the most was his attitude to be open and my attitude to let it go. I had to quit trying and just start enjoying and having fun with my husband. I also had to accept that it was NOT ME, it was not my fault. No matter what I did or didn't do or how pretty I was...nothing would have stopped it. He had a problem...GOOD LUCK, I really feel for you and will pray for you. =)

I agree with your message.  i'd just add that women do the same thing.  Men aren't immune.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 31, 2006, 9:48 am PST

You can forgive

My husband cheated on me 10 years ago when I was pregnant with our second child it was with a co-worker.  When I found out I booted his butt out, confronted the co-worker and told her you can have his sorry cheating butt.  About three months later he wanted to try things again...I was not ready for that.....another three months later we decided we would see if it would work.  We have been together since.   He was willing to show he had changed and I was willing to forgive him. I have never thrown it he is face about the affair and I NEVER NEVER said anything to the kids....evan when we where seperated I never said anything bad about my husband to our son...if I needed to vent I had friends to vent to out of earshot of my son.   If you cant forgive and put it behind you and you keep saying things that hurt the kids get out of the marriage. 
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 31, 2006, 10:19 am PST

10/31 Cheating Disasters

Quote From: justlildz

I can't wait to see this show.......was thru the EXACT thing starting in 2000 - still married - but, it's HARD. I always wanted Dr Phil's take on this particular situation.

It seems like Dr. Phil's take is this in a nutshell...the person who cheated is responsible for their actions and must make ammends and become transparent in their future actions.  But the spouse who was cheated on has an equal responsibility to work on getting the marriage back on track.  If a spouse chooses to stay stuck in the angry phase and just wants to give their partner a "life sentence" of misery , then they should just get divorced.  And above all, both parents should work to protect the children from the ugliness of this type situation and not drag them into it.  KIDS SHOULD COME FIRST.

 

 

 

Message Emote
blank
October 31, 2006, 10:20 am PST

hard times

This isn't easy to post but thought I would in case there are women out there, that find themselves in a similar situation. And if anyone would have any advice? I have been unfaithful to my husband for the first time in our 18 yr. marriage.  As I've heard Dr. Phil say many times, "turn towards your spouse"...I did that, so so many times, telling/asking him that I needed him to be apart of our marriage and our family and to not put so many other things ahead of it.  But he did not listen and before I knew it, I found myself talking to another man on the internet and then it turned into a physical relationship.  I'm not saying that I blame my husband for what I did, I don't... no matter how neglectful he was, it gave me NO right to cross that line and I NEVER will again.  I take full responsibility for what I've done.  I want my marriage to be better and for it to be what it should be but I don't know what to do...I find myself wondering if I should tell my husband about the affair or not? I don't want to hurt anyone else and I don't know what to do.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 31, 2006, 10:41 am PST

10/31 Cheating Disasters

Quote From: raeann2003

This isn't easy to post but thought I would in case there are women out there, that find themselves in a similar situation. And if anyone would have any advice? I have been unfaithful to my husband for the first time in our 18 yr. marriage.  As I've heard Dr. Phil say many times, "turn towards your spouse"...I did that, so so many times, telling/asking him that I needed him to be apart of our marriage and our family and to not put so many other things ahead of it.  But he did not listen and before I knew it, I found myself talking to another man on the internet and then it turned into a physical relationship.  I'm not saying that I blame my husband for what I did, I don't... no matter how neglectful he was, it gave me NO right to cross that line and I NEVER will again.  I take full responsibility for what I've done.  I want my marriage to be better and for it to be what it should be but I don't know what to do...I find myself wondering if I should tell my husband about the affair or not? I don't want to hurt anyone else and I don't know what to do.
Raeann, just my opinion, DO NOT tell him.  Since you fully intend to go forward and repair your marriage and know now what a mistake you made, there is no useful purpose in telling him now.  Doing so "to get it off your chest" might make you feel better but would devastate him unnecessarily.  Let this be your burden to bear, not your whole family's burden.  Get some counseling and work through this stuff, but protect your family from the harm that would come with divulging this information.  Obviously, you need some marriage counseling too, but get yourself straightened out first.  Good luck to you!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
frustrated
October 31, 2006, 10:49 am PST

It was SO none of your business

Quote From: debhgn

My daughter recently had a one night stand with a guy  who works with her husband.  They were out at a bar one night, her husband wanted to go home and go to bed, he left her there with his friend and figured she was in good hands.

This is absolutely totally out of character for her to have done this.  Completely opposite of what she believes and stands for.  She lost a baby just a few short weeks prior to this incident and had lost her grandfather just 2 months prior to that.

She told me about it the very next day and I decided that I needed to tell her husband.  Many factors played a part in my deciding to do this, but one was that he has tried to commit suicie on more than once occasion and I felt that he needed to find this out in a "controlled enviorment" so to speak.

They have been separated for 4 weeks now, she is living with me.  For the first couple of weeks he was very upset as expected.  He then started to examine how this could have happened and actually got over it for a few days, long enough for them to take a mini vacation together.

Then suddenly out of the blue he turned into a raging bull.  He has torn their home all to peices, even tried to burn it down.  Holes in the wall, if it was glass it's now broken, and even cutting down some trees that her beloved grandfather had gotten her prior to his death.  He has done several thousand dollars worth of damage to the home.

As for her husband, he is a 30 year old child, she is 25.  He has tried to commit suicide twice, he has a very bad porn addiction, he is controlling and unloving and selfish.

She has lost all self esteem that she had prior to her marriage to him, has a low self image, and has become depressed.  She has lost all respect or desire for him because of his porn addiction.  She says it makes her sick to her stomach.

He has taken this opportunity to unleash terror on her and everyone around.  He now feels he has the total right and actually duty to inflict his rage at anytime on anyone.  In fact when he tried to burn down the house and she threaten to call the police he was outraged to think she would call the police on him since it was her that cheated.

I too am interested in this up coming show and feedback from the members here.  I have a mess on my hands and don't know where to turn.


So you must have a pretty sick relationship with your daughter that you would violate her confidence in you by telling her husband something so devistating. Regardless of the emotional state your daughter was in she was wrong to do what she did but it was her cross to bear, not yours. There are many more productive ways you could have offered support and guidance to her. If you were my mom I'd certainly not be living with you. As for his behaviour why are you passing judgement on him when you are the one that set the wheels in motion? He clearly has emotional issues and maybe their marriage wasn't in the best shape but he is HER husband, it is THEIR marriage to work on or end no yours.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 31, 2006, 10:57 am PST

10/31 Cheating Disasters

Quote From: mkw2004

Do men go through "menopause" too?

 

I was shocked to hear that my own son after being married and loyal for over thirteen years to his wife, suddenly was staying over in town, saying he was working late and was too tired to drive home at 1-2 am. He never stayed over before and his wife got suspicious. One day she went to his car and picked up his cell phone only to find a message on it from a woman...asking are they going to meet again? My DIL calls me all upset and ask's me "what should I do"?

I told you two years ago to go for marriage counseling because your marriage wasn't working but you dismissed my suggestion.

Then I had a talk with my son, alone, " what's going on , I asked him? His reply...well, I have a wife in name only. She gets angry and spiteful and we haven't been intimate in over a year. HMMMM? Well, son, if you have differences, you sould go for marriage counseling to work things out...well, mom, I'm willing but my wife isn't willing to go for help!" You know how hard I work, my family wants for nothing and my wife doesn't have to work, no she stays home with the children. Beside that she complains the house is too much to take care of, I tell her get a housekeeper. She gets a housekeeper but she's still complaining. then she wants me to take a job where I'm home by 6-7 pm at night. I tell her...well, tthis is all I know how to do and I'm good at what I do and I don't want to change jobs.  I don't know what she does with her time but she loves to shop!

 

OK....what about this women on your cell phone....is this serious? He laughs..NO. It's an "escort service". It doesn't mean anything, I love my wife! I ask him..how could you love your wife and go out with other women? Well, what would you do, if your wife hasn't been intimate with you for over a year? You could have gone for therapy for yourself. Yes, he replied, I did and no matter how I approcached my wife with going with me she wouldn't. Mom, this is the out come of her negative behavior. NO son, you made the choice to do what you did.

Several weeks gos by, I get a call from my DIL, she's crying ..help me please, I don't know what to do.

That am, went to their house and did an " intervention", telling them they MUST go for therapy as I'm more concerned about the children and how this effecting them. That their first responsibility was to the children, that no matter what, the children will feel the tension between them. They both started crying.. My DIL blamed herself for situation and her spitefullness. I talked to them seperately to find out just what they thought brought on this problem of infidelity.

My son said...I think I'm going thorugh "male menopause" and I feel unlove, unappreciated, so I want a kind word and  went to an escort service. I wouldn't have done that, if I was getting love, understanding and support from my wife.

Then I talked to my DIL....her reply, I want him home with the family. He works too hard and we can live for less, even if I have to go to work. I asked her..how does that make sense, you going to work? She went on to say, we can get a smaller house, he can get a different job, we don't need a lot of money to be happy. Hmmm? How will his getting a meanial job help him? He's a CEO of a company. What kind of work do you think he should do? she replied...well, he loves fishing when he has the time, so, I told him to open a bait store, then he can keep regular hours and be home for the family. I almost laughed at her reply and said...are you willing to live on $ 50,000 a year, that's with both of you working ? Are you willing to give up your son's golf lessons, your daughters music lessons and your designer clothes? She thought for a moment, looked at me and said....I didn't think about that, how the chidren would not be able continue their lessons. Yes, your life would change drasticly, your too naive' and must think this through intelligently...you MUST go for marriage counseling to work out your differences. She waited a fewf minutes and said...if I have to ,I will go for therapy to save my marriage.

This was soooo sad, to see, two grown adults crying like chidren and their pain could be felt.

Before I left them, made them promise ASAP to find a marriage counselor.

 

They are going for MC. I hope it's not too late!

We live on less then $50,000 a year we both have good jobs we love....and have time to spend with family.....having the best of everything doesnt make you happy.

 

 
First | Prev | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | Next | Last