Message Boards

Topic : 11/01 Is This Normal?

Number of Replies: 532
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 27, 2006, 02:20:08 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
Do you know someone whose behavior is always making you raise an eyebrow? Dr. Phil helps his guests distinguish what's normal and what's not. Kelly says she’s tired of her husband, Scott’s, jokes. She says they’re inappropriate, obnoxious and rude. Scott admits that his jokes can be sexual in nature, but he loves being the life of the party. Will Kelly loosen up, or does Scott need to tone it down? Then, Vicki fears that she’s dying and visits the doctor at least once a week. Her husband, Harvey, says she needs to stop worrying about her health or she’s really going to make herself sick. Is it all in Vicki’s head, or does she really have a reason to be afraid? And, Shelita refuses to celebrate the holidays because she says they’re pagan festivals. Her sister, Akea, says she contradicts herself by accepting presents. Will Akea be able to embrace her sister’s decision, or is Shelita being unreasonable? Plus, Dr. Phil and Robin kick off their participation in the 2006 Toys for Tots holiday campaign! Join the discussion.

Find out what happened on the show.

More November 2006 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
chillin'
November 1, 2006, 12:49 pm PST

believing that a wall is red and its white doesnt change the fact

Quote From: mmomwife

     I dont usually write to discussion boards, but the guest on today's show really upset me. If she doesnt care to celebrate the holidays that's her decision, but she has no right to tell others they are going to be condemed for celebrating their beliefs.  I find it repulsive that people who may or may not have any religious or historical education,  read  "so called" research, and misinterpret and/or misquote it, then launch off on a mission based on their mistaken findings. 
    Christ was not born on Dec.25.   Any informed church-going christian knows that.  No one knows the exact date our Lord was born.   Christmas is a holiday which grew from the mass celebrating Christ's birth.  Whether it be on Dec.25 or June 25, this is the day  we as Christians celebrate God's giving us his only son. 
      Scholars spend their entire lives studying hisory, ancient culture, and the scripture.  If I wish to find reliable information regarding my faith, I will consult one of them, NOT today's guest.  My input to her would be YES!  Your beliefs are wierd... (and obnoxious)!

I beg to agree only partially to what you say.  She is not ashamed of what her religion states and not afraid to not be "politically correct" What she said is true is the sense that the holidays she mentioned are indeed of pagan origin and its easy for all to research it.

I commend her for her stand because it is not easy to do what she just did.  She is sure of her convictions and should not be condemned for that.

What she is emphasizing on is not the actual DOB of Christ but she is emphasizing on the pagan origin.  Let me give you an illustration: if you bake bread and want only half the batch to have leaven in it, you wont put it in the whole batch because a little leaven makes the whole thing rise.  You will separate it because you can't mix both and have what you are looking for.  That what she is saying. She is making a choice and should not be condemned for it.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
November 1, 2006, 12:51 pm PST

Same here

Quote From: bzygurl21

I just finished watching the section on holidays, and  I totally agree with  her. IF you read this, just know that there are a lot of people out here who feel and do the same way. I dont celebrate Halloween at all, in fact, I hate it. At Christmas, so that we didnt miss out growing up, my mom would put up a nativity scene (a BIG ONE) instead of a christmas tree (pagen god) and we would pretend like we were bringing the presents to baby Jesus, instead of putting them under a tree! Hold fast to your beliefs! and I was so glad to hear u say that u wouldnt let ur daughter either, because u will be held responsible for her soul until her age of accountability. You have my prayers!
I totally agree.  The problem is that we are very often so attached to our traditions that we rather offend God than offend men.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 1, 2006, 12:53 pm PST

Agree to some point

   I just watched the show and was appauled this woman referred to Pagans as satanists. If she has done so much research on this, I think she skipped a page about Pagans and Wiccans, This is just the kind of information that gives us a bad reputation and makes people hate us for what we believe in. She needs to spend more time reasearching things before she talks about them. But again this is just my view point. Blessings!
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
November 1, 2006, 12:53 pm PST

The woman not wanting to celebrate holidays

It is obvious to me that the woman who does not want to celebrate holidays, has had some contact with Jehovah's Witnesses. She should have her right to not celebrate these holidays, even if the majority celebrate these. It is her right to worship in the manner that she believes. Everything she brought up about the holidays is totally true. It truly is her sister attempting to impose her beliefs on her sister, when it is obvious that she is attempting to worship her God in her own way. It is not her attempting to deprive her children of fun, it is her way of attempting to worship, and raise her children in her beliefs.

 

I now volunteer at a GED center in my community. If I am teaching the part of the GED that has to do with Essays, around the time of Christmas, I kind of set up the students before I give them an assignment. I ask them how many think it is good to lie to your children? I then ask how many believe it is right to mislead their children in setting up a chance for your children to mistrust your word, just for fun? There are other questions I ask, but to make this long story short, I then give them their assignment, "Should you tell your children there is a Santa Claus? When giving topics I try to make at least one a month a subject to make them think about a topic that actually will make them think about a moral or current event issue going on. Something that will make them think outside their everyday life. They don't always agree with each other on the side of the issues, but they enjoy that part of the Essays.

 

 I am a believer of the Christian faith, and I chose to not tell my children there was a Santa Claus, before I ever knew about any Christian faith that didn't celebrate that holiday. I was so worried that if I told them there was a Santa Claus, and later found out I was lying to them about it, they may question if there really is a Jesus Christ that was truly the son of God. I don't regret that As a matter of fact, I had a woman call me up because she was upset that my son told her son there was not a Santa Claus. My response to her, was I was upset that her son told my son there was a Santa Claus. Who was wrong?

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 1, 2006, 12:55 pm PST

Celebrating the holidays

Quote From: bzygurl21

I just finished watching the section on holidays, and  I totally agree with  her. IF you read this, just know that there are a lot of people out here who feel and do the same way. I dont celebrate Halloween at all, in fact, I hate it. At Christmas, so that we didnt miss out growing up, my mom would put up a nativity scene (a BIG ONE) instead of a christmas tree (pagen god) and we would pretend like we were bringing the presents to baby Jesus, instead of putting them under a tree! Hold fast to your beliefs! and I was so glad to hear u say that u wouldnt let ur daughter either, because u will be held responsible for her soul until her age of accountability. You have my prayers!
 I certainly think everyone has a right to celebrate the holidays, or not, as they see fit.  I would like to point out however that she is being selective in her research.  Christianity itself has pagan roots.  Also American Christmas was actually created as a family holiday, it later evolved into a religious celebration.

All I'm saying is, if she's defending herself with history she needs to read more of it.  If she doesn't want to celebrate the holidays I don't think she really needs to use any defence, it's her choice.
 
User Mood
Silly

Message Emote
blank
November 1, 2006, 12:55 pm PST

My choices

I've had similar probelms (as Shelita) with my family. I have been verbally bashed for not celebrating holidays and birthdays as well.

 

My mom views it this way: It depends on how you celebrate it. People don't look at it that way. I don't celebrate in a pagan way. It's for fellowship, fun, sharing, giving....

 

I try to explain to her my perspective: It's not how people view it, it's how God views it. Just because something is "acceptable" to society doesn't mean it is to God.

 

I am very tolerant of others' views and lifestyles. Just because I "tolerate" it doesn't mean I agree with it. I dont'  judge anyone else since that is not my place. I have some knowledge of what the Bible says and what does and does not  please God. I enjoy sharing what I know, but this doesn't mean I am judging them. I really think this is what Shelita was trying to do. I don't believe she was judging anyone -just stating what SHE believes. I try to avoid this misunderstanding by stating "the Bible says" so that people realize this is from the written Word of God, not my own opinion.

 

As for people thinking that if you don't celebrate holidays you have no fun, that's simply not true. Gift giving is from the heart, not because some say it's that time of year. I give gifts to people whenever the feeling comes. To me, it is more meaningful and sincere. I have had to tell people not to buy me "Christmas" presents, birthday presents, etc. and it is really hard for them to understand. Some call me a scrooge. That's their opinion, they are entitled to it, but my interest is in pleasing God, not "going along" with the crowd just to "keep the peace".

 

I commend Shelita for speaking out. It is really hard to put yourself out there and be that vulnerable. I hope she continues to learn, apply what she learns, and share what she learns. At the very least it opens the door for discussion.

 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
November 1, 2006, 12:56 pm PST

Pagan Christmas is a contradiction in terms.

Pagans may have had a celebration in winter where they danced around a pine tree, but it sure wasn't Christ-mas.  LOL

 

I think it's such a lovely thing for the people who follow Christ to have a big celebration each year in honor of the fact that he was born!  It doesn't matter which day we hold the celebration and it sure doesn't matter whether we have a pine tree in our house or not.,  So pagans liked trees  -- they don't own all trees for all time.  Next you'll be saying we can't have candles in our churches just because Satanists use candles.

 

What matters is that Jesus was born and we are filled with love and goodwill toward each other when we think of it.  Anytime we show love for one another Jesus is happy.

 

As for Santa -- my husband likes to say that he  (Saint Nicholas) was Jesus's chosen representative for the children.  Lighten up girlfriend, think of all the people who go to Christmas Eve service with the family and come home to Jesus.

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
November 1, 2006, 12:58 pm PST

11/01 Is This Normal?

Quote From: jettav

I celebrate Christmas not only as a day to celebrate the birth of Christ (and yes I know it isn't his real birth) and because it is a time of giving and a time set aside to show our love and all. and the reasons why I do or do not celebrate have absolutely nothing to do with whether it is pagen or not, not once have I ever mentioned the word pagen in my postings until now. My children are taught to love, honor and respect Christ as well as others, and this is what Christmas is all about for me and I do not decorate for Halloween, I decorate for fall, won't see witches, and ghosts in my home, sorry if that offends any one, I celebrate according to what I feel is appropaiate for me and my family, not what others do or think.

 Again, sorry if I am offending but pagen or not, it is not what I base my celebrations on. And besides, wht's the big deal if I don't get into Halloween, how is that hurting any one?  As A Christian I choose how I celebrate and what consists in my celebrations and I have made up my own traditions as well during the holidays. My kids decorate the tree themselves wih their ornaments and we sit around the tree reading Bible Stories and reinacting some of those stories, we also pray before we open gifts and eat and of course before Christmas, we have our traditions that involve helping others, Not the traditional ways of celebrating, but our way and that's the way the holidays should be, a family event, celebrating life as it is for us.

My holidays are not based on pagen or not, they are based on how I feel to celebrate and Jesus is a part of every celebration, in fact, we have a bday party for Jesus, might be wrong for the pagen tradition but the holidays are public holidays therfore family's may choose how to celebrate, That is the the good thing about the USA, we get to choose our religions and the way we choose to celebrate, no one can control that  for us. I choose what I like and discard what I don't like as I am sure everyone does. I am sure you don't like the idea of Christ being in Christmas so you don't celebrate Him, I don't like the idea of witches on my window, therefore I don't decorate with witches, tradition or not, pagen or not, has nothing to do with how I celebrate.
I am sure you don't like the idea of Christ being in Christmas so you don't celebrate Him, I don't like the idea of witches on my window, therefore I don't decorate with witches, tradition or not, pagen or not, has nothing to do with how I celebrate.

 

You're right, I don't celebrate Jesus as a God.  I think he was a good person with good intentions, and great knowledge, but no, I do not view him as a God.  And I am fine with Christ being in Christmas, after all, it is Christmas, what I don't understand is, how can someone not accept that there holiday came from Pagan traditions?  And what is so bad about it?  December 25th is not a holiday for us, our Holy day is the Winter Solstice, which just so happens to be around the 25th.  Coincidence?  No.  But people can celebrate what they want, how they want, I just wished that sometimes they knew the truth about it.

 

I don't put witches in my window as well, Jetta. LOL  I think that would offend them. LOL  To me, a witch is a magical person, not an evil person, and I respect them, I would not make a mockery of them as so many do on Halloween.  The church made the witch evil, not Pagans.

 

I'm starting to think that you do not fully understand what I do or why I do it.  I keep with the Old ways, I want to make sure they stay around for a few thousand years more.  That's all. =)

 

Have a great day, Jetta.  Thank you for reading this.

 

Elffie

 


 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
November 1, 2006, 1:04 pm PST

11/01 Is This Normal?

Quote From: elffie

Yes, that is what the church wants you to believe, but NO, it is not true.

 

Samhain (Halloween) was a last harvest festival and it was a day to remember our ancestors.  My ancestors left treats for the visiting spirits (our modern day trick or treating) and dressed up with masks (our modern day costumes) to ward away evil spirits, but to also connect with those souls that have passed that they miss.

 

There are two possible explanations for this Sabbat (holiday), one being the origin of the Aryan God of death, Samana, and the other from the Irish Gaelic word "samhraidhreadth", which literally means "summer's end".  Nothing evil about that. =)  November 1st was the Celtic New Year.  You see, the Celts marked their years in two seasons, summer and winter, light and dark.  Samhain is a harvest festival.

 

The Celts celebrated this for thousands of years before Christianity.  The church began calling it Michaelmas, the feast day of St. Michael, but the Pagan traditions seemed too strong to break away, so it was renamed Eve of all Saints Day, which the next day (nov. 1st) is All saints day.  But again, so much Samhain lore and practise was taking place that the church had no choice but to diabolize this holiday into a night filled with evil and evil spirits.  Again, their way of converting.  They started a successful campaigne of fear among Christians concerning this holiday.  And the witch, well, now she is looked at as an evil person, instead of an elderly, knowledgable women that the towns viewed her as. 

 

So, you see, the church made this into an evil holiday, not Pagans.  Christians did that, and it seems they have had a big following to this day still.

 

You're parents were wrong and I'm sorry that you have had to listen to such a story.  No wonder people get freaked out about this holiday.

 

Thanks for reading.

Elffie

The fact remains that many people who call themselves "devil worshipers" celebrate Halloween as a time to practice very evil things, such as human sacrifices. Furthermore anyone who reads their Bible will see that these practices go against what the Bible teaches even down to the jack o laterns, witches, ghosts.....If you are a God-fearing Christian you read your Bible you do what it says regardless of what others may say. I believe it is our responsibility to tell those who are not saved(accepted Jesus into your heart, asked Him to forgive you of your sins, believe that He is the Son of God and that He died on a cross for your sins, and was raised from the dead) what we believe and why we believe it. After that it is on them as to what they do with the truth. I am not here to cast judgement, only God can judge.

My family and I celebrate Christmas, we know that Jesus was not born on the 25th of December. Do we participate in any pagan practices? No. We do exchange gifts, just like the Wise Men brought gifts to the newborn King, and just as God gave His son Jesus to us) We do not teach our children about Santa Clause because he is not real, God is and He is the one who enables us to give gifts to our loved ones. Now I know other Christians that choose not to celebrate Christmas and we don't think they are wrong, they just choose not to participate.  Like I said we are not here to judge only to spread the truth of God's Word.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
November 1, 2006, 1:14 pm PST

11/01 Is This Normal?

Quote From: bzygurl21

I just finished watching the section on holidays, and  I totally agree with  her. IF you read this, just know that there are a lot of people out here who feel and do the same way. I dont celebrate Halloween at all, in fact, I hate it. At Christmas, so that we didnt miss out growing up, my mom would put up a nativity scene (a BIG ONE) instead of a christmas tree (pagen god) and we would pretend like we were bringing the presents to baby Jesus, instead of putting them under a tree! Hold fast to your beliefs! and I was so glad to hear u say that u wouldnt let ur daughter either, because u will be held responsible for her soul until her age of accountability. You have my prayers!
THANK YOU!!  I TOTALLY agree as well! If people did their research they would realize she knew her stuff and was completely correct on everything she said! I give her congrats as it's not easy to go against the grain in life and stand up for what you believe in. Yes as DrPhil said this came from the 4th century but the point is it came from people that did not worship God and the Bible clearly states not to do as the Pagans do, to keep on doing what is acceptable to the Lord, consider the celebration of anyone's birth to be a pagan custom...
 
First | Prev | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | Next | Last